MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Galentine’s POPSUGAR Must Have Mystery Boxes! SPOILER UPDATE!

POPSUGAR Must Have has created two exclusive Mystery Boxes for the MSA Galentine’s Day Party!

And we have some additional spoilers for you!

The Box: Girls Night In Box

The Cost: $45

The Products: A cozy night in with your besties can be the perfect cure for the cold-weather blues. Luxuriate in self-care at home with our Girls’ Night In box, which features previous products from recent and past Must Have boxes.

UPDATE: This box will include 12+ items!

Each box will include:

Jack + Lucy Pillow and Blanket Set ($49.99 retail value).

FlashPatch Restoring Night Eye Gels 5-Pack – Value $20

Each box includes $300+ worth of products. Staying in has never been more fun!

*Orders will ship within 7-10 business days via FedEx SmartPost. This is a one-time purchase box and will not autorenew. See FAQs for more details. All Girls’ Night In boxes contain the same assortment of products.

The Box: Girls Night Out Box

The Cost: $95

The Products: The Girls’ Night Out box is the kit you need to sparkle from head to toe. It features previous favorites from recent and past Must Have and Limited Edition boxes, so you can look your best all night long.

UPDATE: This box will include 10+ items!

Each box will include:

Tilo Twilight Scarf – Value $98

And your Girls Night Out mystery box may include:

Sisters of Los Angeles Sweet & Sour Glasses – Value $28

Each box includes $600+ worth of products to help you get ready for your night of glam.

*Orders will ship within 7-10 business days via FedEx SmartPost. This is a one-time purchase box and will not autorenew. See FAQs for more details. Girls’ Night Out boxes may contain different assortment of products. Different assortments are not guaranteed and duplicates will not be refunded.

Check out our Galentine’s Day Deals + Giveaways Page for more great offers!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in Galentines Day 2018, Mystery Boxes, POPSUGAR Must Have Box Coupon, Subscription Boxes & Coupons| Tags: popsugar | popsugar must have | POPSUGAR Must Have Box | 50 comments

Comments (50)

  1. Girls Night In – Inflatable Swan… I’m calling it now.

    • I think the Stella Artois glasses will be the new inflatable swan

      • Oh god. Just NO. I have so much freaking glassware because I lived above a restaurant and would take drinks home from it and return all of them at the end of the month. One month they closed so I was stuck with it all.

        I bet you are right.

      • I hope not. It disappoints me when they basically send advertisements.

  2. I’ve been waiting for a PSMH mistery box FOREVER! Sadly I’ve been busy at work and totally missed it 🙁 I remember the mother’s day collaboration with MSA was amazing. I cant afford a $95 mistery box so I’ll enjoy the reviews and call it a day.

  3. If anyone gets the throw/pillow set and doesn’t want it I would love to purchase it from you. I missed out on girls night in box. I’m VERY new to all of this. Am just getting started with my subscription addiction 😂

  4. Glad I missed this. There’s not one spoiler that I’m interested in. And for $95 things that I know I don’t want – no regrets here.

  5. Was going to get this as a gift for myself today after sleeping on it. Did not think they would sell out so fast. So sad!

    • Me too? I like it when subscription boxes do custom made for MSA. Maybe later they show what was in the box and people can swap with us.

  6. OMG!! I took a big plunge, at least for me, and got the gno box! I absolutely can’t wait to get that big ole pink box in the mail!! I’ve actually been pondering getting it all day and finally convinced myself it would be worth it especially if it’s 600$+ and includes items from the limited edition boxes plus I haven’t ordered anything from popsugar in forever so the items will be new to me! So excited!!

    • Yay! I think those pink boxes are gonna feel so special now that they won’t come around as often.

  7. Was tempted by GNO box until I looked at all of the past boxes. I predict left over make up pallets, fake eye lashes, and one of the two recent sparkly necklaces. Maybe glam glow. I remember the last round of mystery boxes-the most expensive was the worst.

  8. I bit and got the girls night out box, hoping to get the glasses! Ive never gotten any limited edition boxes so here’s no hoping for no repeats!

  9. Really wanted that Girls Night In box and sad to have missed it! Boo!

    • Also sad, I miss it as well…

    • Me too 🙁 The spoilers look awesome

  10. I snagged both and I’m excited! The scarf will be a repeat for me, but my mom’s birthday is coming up and I think she’ll love it. So far, I’m happy with all the spoilers. Mostly, I’m psyched about how many products that is. It’s less than seven dollars per item between the two boxes. If I like most of them, it’ll be a huge win.

    • Yep, at least 22 items for $140 comes out to $6.36 an item. Happy I was able to get both. Can’t wait to see what else we get. I’m excited about the glasses, I didn’t get that box and really liked those.

      • Same here! I think they’re really cute. Overpriced, so I wouldn’t get them on their own, but awesome as a part of a box.

      • Unfortunately it says MAY be in the box. Some of us will get them and others won’t. I know how my luck goes so… Hopefully yours is better than mine!!! Good luck!

      • I missed that! Fingers crossed for both of us!

  11. Ordered the night in before it sold out. You know we are getting that Anna Farris book right? Lol

    • I kind of figured that book would be in the box too (which is the reason I hesitated on ordering…donated last one to the library uncracked).

      So, of course now it won’t be in the box because I missed out on ordering! Always the way!

    • I was totally thinking that book would be in there. It seems like it will be the October box with extras to me. Hoping for the scrub, farmacy moisturizer and hand cream from the feb box.

      • Same here Nicole, really want the farmacy and scrub!! Fingers crossed for us all. Just no swans or hats please.

      • the chance at the scrub was how i justified this lol. the scrub is $35 on lalicious’s site, so $45 for the whole box seemed more than fair. now i just need it to be included. ohpleaseohpleaseohplease!

    • Cause when the girls get together they are going to want to read a book 🤣

  12. OMG ! girls night out mystery box ! — really $600+ worth of products? For only $95? Nice!

    I am gonna miss my monthly Box…. 😢

  13. The box was IN MY CART and it wouldn’t let me complete purchase because apparently it sold out in the 15 seconds between adding to my cart and pulling out my credit card. How disappointing.

  14. I guess I don’t think of shot glasses as night out type things. Maybe if you’re pregaming? I kind of see them as night in…as in, stay in and have a drink. But I didn’t order GNO anyway, and am happy for GNI. 😊

    I will now have three sets of pillows/blankets, and really only want one, if that. If someone wants either of my two unneeded sets, I’m happy to send them if you’ll cover shipping (otherwise free) or pickup in a public place if you’re in the Charlotte area. I haven’t priced out USPS shipping on this yet, though.

    • I would definitely pay shipping. I would love to have that set. I tried to purchase the box but was too late. Email coopermargiem at google

      • Messaged you, Margie. My husband will be happy to not have it in the house anymore. 😊 (limited space)

        If Margie is only asking for one, I can send someone else the other set, if interested.

      • Nvm – Kate claimed it below. 😊

      • I would like the other set if you have it still?

      • I’m sorry, Pam! Both the other ladies replied to my email with their addresses, so they’re spoken for. I hope you can find one up for swaps. 🙂

    • I would also love a set…ekatelaw at a.o.l.dotcom

      • Ok messaging you!

    • Just wanted to commend you for that. Such a selfless, thoughtful thing to do!!

      • Aw that’s sweet to say, but we really need the space. The ones I have are just hanging out in my craft closet, and that’s space I can fill with more fabric. 😁

    • They’re rocks glasses, not shot glasses. I would have rather seen this in the GNI box (mostly because that’s the one I got lol) but I do get the idea of why the put them in the “out” box. Sad, I wanted a set of these, they’re so cute

  15. Now that gni is sold out can full spoilers get released? 😉

  16. Night in sold out.

    • Wow! It must have been the spoiler that convinced people to pull trigger. I bought one 5 minutes ago, if that. I guess I got in just under the wire.

      Thanks LIZ!!!

    • Oh good, I was seriously considering caving and grabbing one, so this is good news for my budget!

      • Me too! This site makes it hard to restrain myself haha

    • Dangit, it is! I was out and about this afternoon and didn’t get a chance to buy it. Oh well. My bank account will be happy. 🙂

      • Lillian, I’m gonna follow in Cornflake’s generosity and if you want the eye patches I will gladly mail them to you. I know I won’t use them. wendybrooks77atyahoodotcom.

      • I messaged you! Thanks so much!!!

  17. I’ve been holding out all day, but that did it! I love those flash patches and i’ve been wanting a backup on the pillow/blanket for travel, so there it is! 12+ items for $45 is a smoking deal no matter how yo slice it. Thanks for doing this today, Liz. It was fun! And I love all the illustrations; reminds me of the old-school Stila illustrated packaging. (I’m showing my age).

    • Hope you love the box and glad today was fun! Emily did all the adorable illustrations!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.