Subscriber Survey: What Box Do You Want to Try in 2018?

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Sunday Subscriber Survey time! This week’s subscription box question is:

What subscription box is #1 on your wishlist for 2018? (Check out some of the boxes we’re watching for 2018 for ideas!)

I’m realizing that I have almost no photos in our house, so Parabo Box is on my list!

What subscription box is at the top of your wishlist this year? 

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.

Posted in Subscription Box News, Subscription Box Questions| Tags: POPSUGAR Must Have Box | 89 comments


  1. Heart & Honey ♥️🍯

    • Same!

  2. Perhaps sadly, I want 2 boxes which don’t exist. At least not at present.

    1) I truly want a Magnolia Market box as I and others have said before now. Joanna Gaines is my personal ” super hero” when she stays out of the rustic decor, : ).

    2) Second wish would be a box of the caliber that Luxor Box used to be for about 3 years.. and Oui Please started out being. Truly luxe and decadent curated bi-monthly, and shipped on time with no excuses, no last minute substitutions and no misleading regarding the true value of the items.

  3. A leggings Subcription like enjoy leggings. Meduces beauty Subcription.

  4. Stitch fix clothing , pop sugar lifestyle, and neon doll jewelry , and of course pusheen!

  5. My favorite box ever is The Nina Garcia Box. But does it skip sometimes? I have to admit the white wrap shirt last time was a miss for me, but it is the box I look forward to the most.

  6. Liz’s recent review reminded me that I’ve been really wanting to try Beauty Heroes. I would have to drop a couple of subs to do that though, so we’ll see how it pans out.

  7. Box of Style and FabFitFun 😊

  8. Breo, I just need some very EXTRA SPECIAL for me money 👍

  9. Tribe beauty box and Boxycharm!!! Maybe 1 popsugar box, but their spoilers come out wayyy too late in the month in my opinion

  10. boxwala beauty

    • Ditto!

  11. Breo Box!

  12. Yummy bazaar full experience – Just waiting for a month where I want everything as it’s too expensive to be an every month thing for me

  13. One of the international snack boxes, but I can’t decide which one! Either Bokksu, Tokyo Treat, or Japan Box. I just need to narrow it down and pick one.

  14. Le Metier de Beaute

  15. Box of Style — but it depends on spring spoilers!

  16. Beekman 1802

  17. Parabo, maybe. Jersey Shore if they do the quarterly box again. I want Magnolia Market to do a box. 🙂

    • Oh, and a drinks box!

    • I would totally do a Magnolia box!!!

  18. I just signed up for Yes Oh Yas, looking forward to the stuff in both February and March! I’m not willing to give up on any of my other subs, FFF, PS, IPSY, boxycharm, and Allure, but I really should lol maybe boxy

  19. Umami subscription.

  20. Seacrate

  21. I want to try Sugarbash this year.

  22. Dying to try Elizabeth and Clarke and Heart & Honey!

  23. Margot Elena.

    Also, February is my last Popsugar box. I just canceled, but am hoping for a promotion.

  24. Margot Elena and 5th Ave.

    • Me too!

  25. 1) Graced box (home decor)
    2) Adidas Avenue A!!!! I MISS YOU!!!

    • I miss Avenue A Adidas – hope it comes back soon

  26. I hope Amazon puts out more sample boxes!

  27. I’m really interested in trying out one of the luxe boxes, but I’m kinda at a loss for which to go for due to mixed opinions. Any suggestions?

    • It depends on what your interested in. If you like luxe accessories and apparel, Luxe Provence is really nice, but also very expensive. Luxor Box sends out a lot of high-end home decor stuff (although they left a bad taste in a lot of subscribers’ mouths when they sent out a travel voucher that was mummified in red tape). Breo Box is good for electronics and is more of a unisex sub. I hesitantly suggest Robb Vices because it’s so hit and miss. Your best bet is just to look out for spoilers for different boxes and decided if you want to take the plunge before you buy. Good luck and have fun!

      • Thank you!

  28. Trunk Club is DEFINITELY on my ‘dying-to-try’ list now that I’m entering the professional world as a social worker.
    I’ve definitely stepped up my game in trying to look presentable (okay, maybe there was a bit of a push there), but I’m totally clueless in figuring out how to put ensembles together so that they don’t look like I created a middle-school Mod-Podge collage.
    I’d love to have a personal stylist that can not only help me figure out how to look more put-together at work, but still value that fashion-forward effort I’m interested in.

    If only I could win the lottery…heh heh…

    • Hello fellow social worker! I’ve also been trying to cultivate a more professional wardrobe 😊

  29. I have not tried Boxycharm or Ricky’s Cult Crushes. I want a new female geek box too. Since Geek Chic monthly took a break.

    • I want a good female geek box, too!

  30. 1. I want to try Fabletics, I just sign up and excited for February 1 to choose my outfit.
    2. Agree, I was Avenue by Adidas to come back, please
    3. From skin care, I want to try Zelens. It is very expensive and I hope MAY BE, so of the boxes will include a little drop of it to try.

    • I want to try Zelens too but way out of my price range!! If any sub box ever has one of their products, that will sell out ASAP!

  31. Zoe Box Of Style will sign up for this Spring box

  32. Seacrate

  33. I definitely want to try Bath Bevy, Bubbles and Bombs, Lavish Bath Box, and any other fun bath boxes. I would also love to try a box for couples, like the Pleasure Pantry or one of those date nights in a box type of things.

  34. Tribe beauty

  35. Box.. yeah right. The boxes I want to try; Pusheen, pretty much all the Loot Crates, Smart Ass & Sass, Teeblox, New Beauty Test tube, Goodbeing, Beauty Vault VIP, Look Fantastic, Petit Vour, Yuzen, and Beauty Fix. I am sure there are many more. Pusheen is on the top of my list.

  36. I want Adidas Avenue A to come back 🙂

    • Yes, please!

    • Yes!

  37. Probably Fortune Cookie soap of the month club.

  38. Margot Elena! I’m resisting, but dang do I wanna sign up for it.

  39. I really wanna try FabFitFun ! I love this subscription and will never unsubscribe. ☺️

  40. LookIncredible my secret box

  41. Margot Elena, Heart+Honey, Takeout Kit, Umai Crate, Rockabilly box, Rosepost, Papergang, The Homesteading box and Go Native are the ones I want the most. I can’t seem to narrow it down to one!

  42. I’d love to try Go Native Hawaiian Beauty box. It looks so interesting and I like the non-beauty products they’ve included.

  43. Sundae home or and bespoke post.. I have so much beauty products it’s time to switch it up.

    • Agree!

  44. Margot Elena box!! I think it’ll have some super cute items in it! Maybe whenever there’s a coupon out..

  45. I really REALLY want to try BoxyCharm. I know I’m a little behind times. I am tired of Play and Ipsy so I’m gonna try something new!

  46. Bomibag. Lengbox. Are Asian beauty boxes that I want to try.

  47. I’m trying the Thredup box 🙃

    Otherwise, Breo Box is something I want to try but don’t know if this is the year.

  48. Any skincare only ones… perhaps a sheet mask one, instead of buying them on Amazon or whatnot…. I am in love with skincare. I have plenty of makeup for eternity, so I’m going to dwindle on spending on makeup this year and spend more on skincare.

  49. I think I’m going to switch from Try the World to Yummy Bazaar. TtW has developed some real problems and I’m over it.

    I’d also like to try Breo Box but it’s just so dang expensive!

  50. Kbeauty and makeup boxes! I would love to try them out and see a post comparing them. I don’t know where to start (and which ones are shady or not)


    • Same here! Would love K beauty products

    • I highly recommend Julep. The sign up bonuses are fantastic. Their skincare is really, really good for the price. The quality of their nail polishes are the best – every person who I have given Julep nail polish to has commented on how their nails improved after using Julep (I was surprised by this). I am not too fond of the colors of their lip product, but the quality is good. Another fabulous thing about Julep is that you can customize your box EVERY MONTH, and skipping a month is easy.

    • Another Kbeauty sub with great skincare is Saranghae. It’s not cheap, but I love it. This is just a skincare sub (not makeup). It is easy to skip a shipment.

      • Thanks for the tip!

      • I googled a big after reading your comment and there seems to be a lot of bad blood about this company, calling it fake and snake oil. The website looks good, but I’m concerned that there are a lot of threads talking abut this being a scam. Have you tried the product yourself? what did you like about it? I am thinking of purchasing, but that scared me. thank you for any input!

      • I googled a big after reading your comment and there seems to be a lot of bad blood about this company, calling it fake and snake oil. The website looks good, but I’m concerned that there are a lot of threads talking abut this being a scam. Have you tried the product yourself? what did you like about it? I am thinking of purchasing, but that scared me. thank you for any input!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!