Facebook PixelBoxycharm Limited Edition Box - Available Now! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Boxycharm Limited Edition Box

Liz Cadman
ByLiz CadmanNov 9, 2017 | 540 comments

Boxycharm Limited Edition Box

BoxyCharm
4.3 overall rating
1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

UPDATE: This box has sold out, but Boxycharm posted on Facebook that they are looking into restocking and that for future Limited Edition boxes they will make sure there is a limit on how many a customer can buy.

The first ever Boxycharm Limited Edition box is available now for current subscribers. (You'll receive an email with the link.) (FYI - the site is having some loading issues, so if it doesn't work for you immediately, keep trying.)

The box is $44.95 and will feature products from Ofra, Becca, bare minerals, Tarte, Sigma, and Pur, CoverFx, and Makeup Geek! 

(Thanks, Heather, Marla, Barbara, and Alex for the heads up!)

If you haven’t signed up for Boxycharm yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers for future updates!

Starting at $32.00
Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

Liz Cadman
Liz Cadman
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

540 comments

Crystal

ok so first reveal of the limited edition box is Cover FX Custom Enhancer Drops not sure what shade check out IG stories !!!!

Reply ButtonReply

Cp

What is IG stories? Also isn’t everyone going to be getting the blossom color? I just just bought one too 3 weeks ago the same color lol. Am hoping for moonlight

Reply ButtonReply

Ella

I am getting so disappointed with Boxycharm. Great value, amazing products, but while other folks are posting November box reviews I still haven’t even received my tracking email. I want to get the Limited Edition box, but how much longer do I need to wait for the email? And delivery time close to 10 days (after the box being sent around the 10. each month) is really making me drop this subscription. It seems like my box is arriving 2 weeks later than everyone else’s.

Reply ButtonReply

cwesterdale

Didn’t anyone see the owner on FB today? He said they calculated that the boxes would last several weeks. They were shocked the boxes sold out in minutes when they hadn’t even released a teaser yet. He said “Who buys a box when you don’t know what’s in it?”. Guess they had no idea about the leaked details. He has promised several things:
The website will not crash again.
There will be a new box.
It will be released to subscribers only.
There will be a strict limit of one box.
He then apologized profusely and promised updates.
Maybe those of us who haven’t even received the email and got shut out of the website will get a better box. This is why I subscribe. Great products, reasonably priced, and when they make a mistake, the owner addresses the problem personally and fixes it. #Boxycharm

Reply ButtonReply

Melaniehunter711

That’s great of him to say (I hope they do come out with another box!) but we buy a box every month from them with no clue as to what is coming. They have a waitlist that they can’t get to so I just think they should have anticipated this. The big mistake was not limiting people and letting non subscribers in:). I agree with you about the great products. I love my boxes. I think that is why we are all so upset.

Reply ButtonReply

Shay

That’s seriously ridiculous. Im just now kowing the box was available. Why even allow people to purchase up to 10 per order. Its not fare & I’ve been subscribed to Boxycharm for a while
Now. This is just like when BeautyCon had their boxes for like $8 something. Should I even explain that. I just hate checking constantly on the details about this all for nothing.

Reply ButtonReply

Paulette

When I️ first saw the pink / Red Box , but not reading any thing yet I️ thought it was gonna be our ( subscribers only ) Holiday Box for December’s Box . I️ was wrong —- it should have been ‘!!
Feel bad so many wanted it .
I I️wasn’t that interested in it.
They should have made a limit.

Reply ButtonReply

Diana

Why on earth does anyone need multiple boxes? I was unaware it launched this soon so I missed out, but man, the holidays can bring the greed out of people. 😅

Reply ButtonReply

Paulette

They ,probably will sell them on EBay for more money . Greed !!!

Reply ButtonReply

shannan

I never even got the email so never had the chance to even try.

Reply ButtonReply

Korey

So, I tried and tried all night and I couldn’t get it up, tried again today and all sold out. Thanks, BC. What happened to letting your subscribers have a chance at pre-order before opening it up? You couldn’t restrict how many people could order? It would be great if I wasn’t going to see everything that will be in the boxes on ebay as soon as the people who ordered a bunch, selling it for cost.

Reply ButtonReply

Nat

That first sentence threw me completely off!!!!! 😂

Reply ButtonReply

Tj

The tracking email is a joke. I literally just got my box out of the mail…..not one sign of a tracking email, yet there’s the box. I agree with everyone saying non-subscribers shouldn’t have been able to buy it. This was terrible planning by Boxycharm. I also can see how ppl wound up with multiples, not necessarily 10, but more than intended. When I started checking out, the total stopped me because I only added 1, but I had 2 plus a boxycharm sub in my cart. I had to delete the extra box and the sub. I literally added 1, so no clue how the other got in there. I also didn’t refresh at any point, I just let the system do it’s thing…slowly….
Fingers crossed boxy makes some of this right with the subscribers that missed out.

Reply ButtonReply

Punkykiki

The only way Boxy could make it right is to refund money and allow those who bought multiples to receive only a maximum of two. Then they need to SEND A TRACKING EMAIL WITH A CODE. I have yet to get an email with tracking and the code. But after they have done that, they could offer 1 or 2 max IF they had not already purchased one. Allow a suitable time for codes (maybe 24 hours?) before it is once again opened to non-subscribers and subscribers who want to buy multiples.

I received the same stock letter everyone else got in response to my complaint. I was so mad when I was told to have patience as Boxy is going to have more promotions in the next few months. That is simply not good enough. ALL of the boxes should contain the same things and ALL subscribers should have a shot at getting one.

But here is a conundrum….Boxy sent a stock reply to my email. This is the same email address that they couldn’t or wouldn’t use for a code and tracking. Why do some get tracking and others don’t? Last week it was sold out Charm rewards and now this debacle. Boxy, you are really messing up. MSA girls don’t play well when they are wronged. For the love of all that is holy, send everyone a tracking email. Keep the Charm Shop well stocked. Upgrade your awful website. And finally, get a decent customer service team.

Reply ButtonReply

Melaniehunter711

wow. Be glad you got a stock email lol. I emailed last night as soon as it showed sold out. Then when I learned this afternoon about non members and others being able to order multiples while I( as a very loyal customer) who just wanted one couldn’t get one, I emailed again. Guess what?? No response. I said earlier in a post they need to subtract all orders to no more than 2 and cancel non members until all of us get one!! Glad to know they are going to try to make it right with other promotions. What a joke. I wanted this one!!

Jamie

I got tracking and still got screwed. I’m. It sure if that makes you feel better or worse but there it is ❤️

Julie

I don’t think the box is going to be a bunch of repeats from old boxes like other people have said. What would be the point of selling it to charmers if that was the case.
Poorly executed but the way the hyped the box they should have expected this.

I think purposely not revealing what was in it only made it worse. I know I pass on boxes more frequently when I know what’s in it. Like sephora play, I’d probably get that once a year if I knew the contents in advance.

Hopefully they’ll fix it for the people who missed out.

Reply ButtonReply

Jules

Liz shared the link because a lot of subscribers were saying they never get their tracking emails and didn’t want to miss out. Besides the site was crashing before the link was posted on MSA. The only ones at fault are Boxycharm for their poor planning along with the inconsiderate jerks who were buying 10+ boxes to sell at a profit.

Reply ButtonReply

Marisol Reyes

I agree with someone who posted below me that I Love MSA and all it offers us and I, in turn have turned others onto your site Liz BUT I could have seen from a long way off that you posting this was going to send a tremendous amount of traffic to the Boxycharm website AND as subscribers we know the site has its challenges it was a recipe for disaster. It WOULD have been great if you just alerted subscribers to check their emails SO in this way ANY NON SUBSCRIBER WOULD BE FORCED to SUBSCRIBE just like us – JUST a Thought.

Reply ButtonReply

Diana

Are you really trying to suggest to a blog that only talks about subscription boxes to not write a post about a limited edition box? Liz doesn’t need help or advice on how to do her job, she appears to be doing just fine. 😂😂😂

Reply ButtonReply

Marisol Reyes

I never said that – I Said posting a Live Link that was intended for SUBSCRIBERS was unwise – its fine to post about it, MSA is where most of us found out about the box in the first place

JuJu

I am a subscriber and I can’t remember the last time I actually received a tracking email from Boxycharm, certainly not in the last few months. And I know I am far from the only one experiencing this problem. What good would that advice have done, exactly??

It’s not in any way on Liz that the Boxycharm site allowed non-subscribers to buy the LE boxes, let alone to buy multiples.

Reply ButtonReply

Bella01

yes it is, she placed the site here for everyone to buy before we even received our emails. Didn’t you hear the CEO? They had not posted anything yet and before they could the box was sold out. Liz allowed everyone to buy. I know it might be an accident, i just hope it wasn’t a greedy accident on purpose Liz. I know there’s lots of money to be made by buying thru the links on this site. And you look honest, I really hope it was honest mistake.

Marisol Reyes

Reposting a link meant for subscribers was unwise – LET ME SAY AGAIN I am placing the entire blame on Liz BUT that link allowed people who have NOT supported Boxycharm who are NOT Loyal subscribers the ability to buy a box that was meant for Boxycharmers –

Melaniehunter711

i understand where you are coming from but we need to put the blame fully in boxycharms lap (imo Liz was just doing what boxy asked) AND the people who ordered 10 boxes to sell for a profit. We are loyal customers and they set up a system letting anyone in to order multiple boxes. That is the most idiotic thing I’ve ever heard of. They should have known the response would be huge when they have a waitlist they can’t manage. Great boxes….horrible customer service.

Reply ButtonReply

Marisol

I understand you and I was NOT fully placing it on her
we as subscribers already know their site is NOT “Dynamic” and lacking but that involves a HUGE investment that they may not be ready for which is another reason why they could not block multiple purchases which is crazy BUT posting this link on MSA opened it up to thousands of people who were NOT subscribers – the best option to support boxycharm and their subscribers would be to alert people the emails were up AND SO in that way NON subscribers would have to subscribe just like us. Yes people buying multiple boxes mess it up for everyone which is why clothing collabs lost their shine with retailers from THE SHARKS WHO SHOW UP to buy multiples and leave customers pissed.

Jackie

Thats not fair to Liz to blame her. There are definitely a lot of other spoiler sites that posted about the LE box too. And the site crashed way before Liz even posted on here because it was plastered all over Facebook so if your looking for someone to blame, blame boxycharm for not having enough supply for the demand.

Reply ButtonReply

Marisol

I am not placing the full blame on her lap PLEASE REREAD my comments – that link allowed ANYONE to purchase the box that should have been strictly for subscribers – its an FYI on leveraging the power of your site for the benefit of subscribers – thats it and thats all

Sarah

So I thought “hey…I might get one”. Tried the website off and on for an hour. Forgot about it. Logged in today and there is one in my cart. Went to pay and out of stock. Probably for the best. I have purchased other LE boxes before and always disappointed. There is no FOMO on this one…because I think it won’t live up to the hype and when the spoilers come out I will be “meh” about it anyway. Regardless, poor planning on Boxycharms part all around.

Reply ButtonReply

Jamie

Am I the worst person alive if I hope this box is horrible?

Reply ButtonReply

nancyisshopping

No…the sour grapes was of thinking is just human nature. 🙂 I’m sure I’d be feeling the same way.

Reply ButtonReply

Jamie

Just for that I hope you get the one nice box 😘

Julie

Haha. In the video this morning Yosef said he had planned to issue spoilers about the contents, but never got to, because the box sold out instantly. He didnt expect so many would buy it out without spoilers. Just goes to show the FOMO is very real.

Reply ButtonReply

Anna

Only if I’m the worst person alive for wishing those who bought multiples to sell get stuck with the boxes 😘

Reply ButtonReply

Slynne

I hope they do get it all sorted out. It was a mess. I didn’t get the box I so wanted. Quite annoying to know that some people got multiples … which I’m expecting they’ll try to sell for an insane amount of $.

I usually really like BoxyCharm but I don’t like how this played out.

Jamie

I think that’s mainly where I’m coming from. I don’t want fellow subscribers (with a box or two) to be unhappy, but it would warm my evil little heart if the people with 10+ had to eat that $500! 😈

Svetlana7e

Yes 🙂 LOL

Reply ButtonReply

Jamie

I knew it! 😂 I’m a little salty still.

Bella01

Oh i just received my email. I will try and get the LE box now. Yayyy

Reply ButtonReply

Melanie712

Boxycharm should Subtract all the orders over 2 boxes down and delete non members orders until members gets a chance to get one box. I’m a loyal customer. I tried to order 5 hours after I received the email( I didn’t see until then) and they were sold out. So irritated they let people and non members order so many.

Reply ButtonReply

Marisol Reyes

I agree – people who are NOT subscribers should be entitled to a box before the subscriber who supports the brand – ijs

Reply ButtonReply

Renee

Liz just wanted to say I absolutely love your site! I’m a beauty box addict lol and I love all the spoilers u do! Awesome website! I know this whole Boxycharm bs was in no way ur fault (u were doing exactly what Boxycharm said to do) and I actually got a box because of you! I’m a subscriber have been for 2 years and haven’t received a tracking email in like 4 months! I’m so sorry for anyone who is a actual subscriber that didn’t get one! 😢 I wish I could buy all you wonderful ladies one! Well hopefully BC will make it right and get in more! As for the lady on here bragging about getting 7 and going to sell them for 2x more all I can say is karma is a b*tch and so are you 🙃 Have a nice day

Reply ButtonReply

melaniehunter711

Awesome response!! She tried to justify. There is no justification for being selfish. I guess some people just weren’t raised right. Congrats to you on getting one. I received a tracking email. Got on their site as soon as I saw email and they were sold out. So bummed out. I sent them a fiery email. I’ve been a loyal customer. I’m happy for you sweetie!!!

Reply ButtonReply

melaniehunter711

Are you serious people ordered 10 boxes. I got on 5 hours after receiving my email and they were sold out. That is ridiculous. I’m upset. I’m a loyal long time customer

Reply ButtonReply

Bella01

I just went to get my LE box and their sold out. I am a loyal Charmer and pay for my daughters box too. And I couldn’t even get a LE box. I’m very sad. This just ruined my night.
So disappointed in you Boxycharm. Why did you do this to us loyal customers?

Reply ButtonReply

Bella01

I feel like it greed.

melaniehunter711

Oh and I signed up for alerts and never got one just my normal tracking email.

Reply ButtonReply

Sarah

I am also very upset with how this was executed. Charmers should have had first dibs on getting the LE box. I got my email around 6:45 pm yesterday and around 7 i went to get the box, it let me sign into my account then told me there was an error and crashed. I tried until 10:30 to try and get it but no luck. Mean while non members had several boxes when the people who are supporting boxycharm cant even get one.
So upset over this.

Reply ButtonReply

Melissa W.

Yep.. sold out! Boxy said that they are trying to restock this box, and that they didn’t think it was going to sell out so quick. They said next time, it will only be for subscribers only and will have a limit of one per person..

Reply ButtonReply

Brittany

I never even got an email about it and im subscribed 🙁 i seen someone say they got it so i went on their site an sold out! I feel like this was a completely unfair opportunity. I hate when companies hype a product up but dont make enough for their customers.

Reply ButtonReply

Michelle

These alerts that we sign up for at the bottom of the reviews…how do they work? I was signed up for all 4 and got no alert at all , I saw the post on facebook.

Reply ButtonReply

Lisa Prather

I am beyond irritated. I tried from second i got my email, (site crashed). Finally it was in my inbox but would not take payment. I waited everyday watching for my email. How disappointing. Some people are getting 20 boxes, all I wanted was one. All lifer subscribers should of been emailed ticket for one with more at later time up for grabs. So upset at how this was handled.

Reply ButtonReply

Mary Davis

I’ve been a subscriber forever and I didn’t even get a link or notice that the sale had begun, like I was told to expect. And it’s already sold out? What a disappointment!

Reply ButtonReply

h

I have been a subscriber for a while. I waited for the link in the email, and then I tried a thousand times and finally was able to buy ONE BOX.

While I guess I could have bought as many boxes as I would have wanted to buy, I BOUGHT ONE, as I have ONE subscription.

Each subscriber should have received one link to their subscription to accept or pass. After all those emails were sent, then it should have been a free for all. Their website probably would not have gone down and every subscriber would have been given a chance to buy one.

Reply ButtonReply