Posted by on in Mystery Boxes, Subscription Box News | 13 comments

$8 Hollar Stocking Stuffer Mystery Box – Available Now!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Hollar has a new mystery box available now!

The Box: Hollar 8-piece Stocking Stuffer Mystery Box

The Cost: $8

COUPON: Use this referral link to get $5 credit on your first order.

Shipping: Shipping is free on your first order, but you have to spend at least $10 to check out.

The Products: Surprise! Our mystery bags are packed with awesome goodies for SO much less. A $12 value for only $8!

  • Each bag includes 8 randomly selected stocking stuffers from select categories sold at Hollar
  • Items may be overstock or have slightly blemished packaging

Are you going to grab a mystery box? Want to see it reviewed?

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Very unhappy I got the stocking stuffers and the general box. I looked at many unboxings online and they looked great . Mine was Cheap Cheap Cheap stuff. packages of crayons, plain plastic drinking cup and many more let downs. I know blind boxes are a mystery but I will not be ordering from them again.

  2. Thanks Liz, this is a great deal i just placed an order,I also get lipstick.

  3. We just got the $8 beauty box and it was nicer than any box we ever rec from Walmart or Target. I will definitely order another one again. I shared with my 15 year old daughter and we got 4 items each.

  4. How do I get free shipping? I added to the cart but it is showing me shipping charge. I’ve never ordered from here before so?

    • Keep going all the way till the end of the process… you should see shipping charge taken off.

  5. I bought 2 toy mystery boxes & they were EXACTLY the same! The value was in fact there but seriously the same. I have ordered one of the stocking stuffer ones. But just one lol, lesson learned!

    • Lol…. I was afraid of that but I got lucky and got two diff boxes. Email them… they have awesome customer service. They might send you a diff box. 😉

  6. I have gotten some really great stuff that I pick ked off Hollar. They usually have a discount going and you can find some good items if you check regularly. I would say it is more equivalent to the 5below store than the dollar store. Hope that helps.

  7. I bought 3 of the mystery boxes they had recently. I was very impressed! My total was around 25 bucks and I feel if I went to the store I would have spent over $100 to get the same stuff from Walmart or Target. Some of the items were misses for my household, but others were nice surprises. I got a makeup organizer, an E.L.F. eyeliner, spice organizer, a box of crayola crayons, a nice smelling body mist from a brand I never heard of (so was surprised it smelled good), durable cup, a tweezer set (which worked really well, which also surprised me as it worked better than the Sephora tweezer I was using, comparable to Tweeezerman), a light up arrow sign that takes batteries (interesting) it would look cool in a dormroom or kids room, a bamboo fiber (?) plate, a canvas tote bag, a Sally Hansen sparkly nail polish (nice), a drug store brand lipgloss (forget the brand), a truck and track toy for a toddler (gifted to my nephew), some canvas organizers, a slotted serving spoon with a grapevine design, a box of nestle hot cocoa mix with marshmallows, there is other stuff, but this is some things I got off the top of my head it all came in BIG box. Nothing was broken or “blemished” (which we were warned on). The shipping was fast. I feel like I sound like a Rep for Hollar, but nope, I am not. I used to review Subscription Boxes, so it felt like a nice bargain to get this stuff! I would give them a try, especially if you can get the $5 off promo– not much to lose here. Pretty low risk.

    • I received my first beauty mystery box from Hollar as well and contained almost the identical items as yours NYX was the gloss I got plus an Essie polish along with the same you mentioned, mist, organizer, ELF liner, Sally Hanson… etc. I will purchase again!

  8. Has anybody bought stuff from here? What’s the quality vs. The 99 cent store. Thanks for any input.=)

    • I’d describe the quality as being akin to the Target Dollar Spot. Just slightly better than most 99 cent store stuff, but fitting as they have a lot of $2 and $3 items at Hollar. Hope that helps!

      I wouldn’t get this mystery box though, as it’s not much of a discount for random stuff; you’d probably be better off just selecting individual items. The new customer discounts are pretty good!

    • I agree with Melissa, not quite as bad as Dollar Tree/99¢ Store but pretty on par with the Target $1 section. Surprisingly good quality and legit-looking company for what price point they’re selling stuff at.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!