Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Subscriber Survey: What Subscription Are You Gifting This Holiday Season?
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I am re-gifting lots of sub box items I’ve received this past year and won’t use. I am also thinking about Nest candles for my son’s girlfriend/almost fiancé. I had planned to gift Robb Vices to my son but I haven’t been that impressed with ours lately.
I’d like to hear about great CS experiences. We seem to hear a lot about bad CS but it would be nice to hear some outstanding experiences. CS is essential to me in choosing which businesses to use.
Reply
Gerogiann
Have gifted Ipsy to my sister which she really seemed to enjoy. My MIL was mixed feelings on the kcup sub I gave her. My daughters liked the Boxycharm they received from their aunt. I would give ipsy or Boxycharm.
Reply
Elizabeth
I gifted my sister with an enjoy leggings 3 month subscription for her birthday in May, and she has since run out and requested another subscription for Christmas! She says they’re just like Lula and super cute and comfy.
Reply
Jessvii
Previously tried gifting my partner with MightyFix, Birchbox Man (before it went downhill), and Loot Crate (not all at the same time). Only the Birchbox Man was a hit, so I’m pretty clueless about what to get this year.
Reply
Nancy
Pop Sugar for my step daughter and daughter in law. Maybe Vine Oh for my other son’s GF.
Reply
michy
I’ve gifted graze to my sister and love with food (she loves both). I want to gift her PSMH if they do another BF deal. I gift my friends usually birchbox or sephora play. I give my nerdy friends (like me) loot crate or loot tees/socks. I want to gift my aunt an essential oil or candle type box. Cousins I was looking at gifting love with food or another box that would offer a good BF deal. I’m pretty open with also making gift boxes with all of the stuff I have. Also, my glossyboxes make for great gifting boxes. I might gift glossybox to my mom, because I’ve never had issues with them and I think she would enjoy that it’s more skin products and not makeup heavy. I also would gift her loot tees or lootwear. It’s really open when it comes to her…
Reply
Drminniecooper
Birchbox for a friend and Bokksu for hubby.
Reply
Em
FFF all the way – for my nanny, my mother in law, my mother and a friend. It’s just the best all arounder.
Reply
MinnePuffin
Oh, I would have loved that when I was a nanny. Nice gifting!
Reply
Mallorie
Mommy Mailbox for my mom! Gave it to her last year and she absolutely loved it all year! Thinking about doing a fandom box for my sister this year too!
Reply
Jeannette
Gifting my hubby Loot Crate Star Trek Edition. 1 full year, 4 boxes.
Reply
Melody
I am giving Boxycharm to my friend for her b-day. She will be ecstatic!!!
I am hoping someone will gift me Letters From Dead People:)
Reply
melissa
Just finished 3-month Birchbox to a friend. Thinking of gifting her 3 month good being next.
Might gift another friend Pusheen box depending on what the winter box looks like. Boxwalla is supposed to do a one off box with a movie, book and food/drink item. Waiting for more info on that to gift to my mother.
Haven’t found anything my father would like. And trying NOT to gift myself Just the Right Book. HA HA!
Reply
Erin
IPSY to my best girlfriends cuz it’s affordable to do a whole year for each and they get to fill in their profile. Plus it’s a gift every month for a year! 🙂
Reply
Marion
CatLady for my aunt, Go Native for my cousin. Looking for a good one for my uncle.
Reply
Jody
A food box for my daughter(maybe Degusta)? Beauty boxes and lifestyle ones. Waiting to see what Sugarbash comes out with. It’s getting hard to pick the right ones.
Reply
carol
I’m probably going to continue Gentleman’s Box for my brother; and Birchbox for my sister-in-law. Maybe tea subscription for daughter; have just subbed to Pusheen for her. Maybe Mighty Fix for granddaughter this year; she’s taking home economics, with cooking, this year in school. Tried her on Ipsy, but she wasnt into it. Might not continue the food boxes for grandson; he’s been getting Love with Food, and Yummy Bazaar, and Music Box. He’s such a teen, at 12! Maybe Birchbox Man, for him!
Box subs have been a wonderful discovery for me. I spend a lot of time reading about them, and I find it a lot more enjoyable than going through a store would be. For me.
Reply
michy
I agree. I hate shopping most times I can never find what I want to gift. And boxes are like instant gifts!
Reply
Artemis
I’m gifting Sprezzabox to my brothers. I’m still looking for other subscription boxes for other male family members.
I’m also gifting unused beauty products from my subscriptions to my female family members.
Reply
JulieS
I am gifting Boxycharm to my sisters. My husband gifts me Emma & Chloe. He said that way each month when I receive a piece of jewelry it reminds me how much he loves me. I think it’s really sweet.
Reply
Maggie
Aww!! That is so sweet. I love that so much
Reply
Julie
I will be gifting Globe in to my parent’s.
Reply
Shara
I’m ordering the mine chest from loot crate for my 8 year old
Reply
'Rie
I’m making custom boxes from items I’ve received but won’t use.
(Translation: Swans for everyone!)
Reply
Jeanette
hahahahaha
Reply
wordsone
not buying subscriptions but i am also creating gift boxes from some subscription finds a..have things set aside from the thrills box… have 10 bottles of WEN 😉 😉
some Fabfitfun, Allure and Birchbox things that i saved for others….
Reply
Bethany
I gifted PS last year, hard not to with that epic BF deal!! Holding out to see what deals come this year before deciding 🙂
Reply
Marie-Claire
I think Popsugar makes a great gift; especially if they have a good Black Friday/cyber Monday special. Plus I have tucked away some goodies from boxes that I received earlier this year that will be added to gifts.
Reply
Jt
Popsugar every year for my mom!
Reply
Liz Cadman
I get POPSUGAR every year for my mom, too! 🙂
Reply
Ashlea
Won’t be gifting any boxes, but will be gifting lots of tidbits I saved from boxes. 🙂
I’d like to see the answers to the question “what has made you drop a sub?”
Reply
Jeanette
great question!!!!!!!!!
Reply
Elly
That’s a great question. I’d definitely like to see answers to that. Recently I had to choose between several subs and all things equal—price, quality, value— I chose which ones to drop based on the misspellings (sometimes multiple) on the letters or item lists. Maybe that will sound petty to some people, but spellcheck is everywhere. It speaks to lack of attention to detail, and if a sub owner can’t be bothered to run spellcheck or proofread, I don’t have a lot of faith in their professionalism as a whole.
Reply
KW
Great question suggestion — seconded!
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.