Posted by on in Ipsy Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 63 comments

Ipsy September 2017 SPOILERS – Sample Selection Options #2!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Ipsy Glam Bag

We have some additional spoilers for the September 2017 Ipsy glam bag! (Thanks, IMSC!)

You can email [email protected] and ask for one of the following:

Or you can ask for:

ipsy September 2017

If you’d like to select a sample for September, I recommend emailing [email protected] with your sample choice from the items listed above. Make sure to email before the end of August!

Are you going to email Ipsy and request a sample? Which one are you picking?

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. I got the I-Line eyeliner in the chocolate fix color 2 months ago. It broke the 1st time I tried to use it & the pencil wouldn’t retract either. Checked out several reviews on their site & saw more than a few similar complaints. I contacted Ipsy, asked for a replacement but also asked if I could get the other color it was offering (can’t remember the name). I received a fairly quick reply saying they would ship a replacement but I couldn’t change the color (thought it didn’t hurt to ask since I have so many black eyeliners.) Several weeks later I get a completely different brand in a goldish slightly bronze colour. I was HAPPY as if it was my birthday. Maybe they had a bad batch & this one will be good, but I hope I don’t get it.
    I love Smashbox but a previous primer sample I got was so small I got 2 uses out of it. Think I’m going for the Neogen truffle oil (never heard of it, never got anything similar in previous Ipsy bags) & I’m hoping to avoid yet another black eyeliner & I have enough lip products to last a year.

  2. Just an FYI: I emailed them asking for the DLS lipgloss, but they replied stating that it is not a part of the sample selection.

  3. I’m leaning towards the mascara, but holding out for something more exciting!

  4. Hate to say it, but I’m pretty fed up with Ipsy – I hardly ever get anything I actually have checked on my profile and constantly get things I’ve never had chosen on it. I emailed them and they did allow me to opt out of two products, but that’s all you’re allowed to opt out of at once, so it didn’t help much. The only way I can for sure get something I like is to see the next month’s spoilers and request something specifically, so I’m really happy you post these.

    • What do you mean you can opt out of two items? Do you mean you can tell them you don’t wa t the items you have in your bag and they will give you different ones?

      • You can opt out of two categories of items. I think I chose self-tanners and dry shampoo when I first subscribed, but I am seeing it mentioned now that these opt-outs are temporary, they are not indefinite. I am guessing you have to email them every few months to let them know which categories of items you don’t want to receive.

        • I felt the same way for several months and did the same thing. I opted out of eyeshadow bc although I love eyeshadow, I have hooded eyes and prefer matte, and I wrote that in every review for 4 years, yet still kept getting shimmering shadows nearly every month. Kinda salty, bc I DO like eyeshadow, just not what they were sending. I also opted out of bronzer. I feel like they said they could opt me out for 3 months at a time ? Idk if I’m just supposed to remind them or ask again, bc my 3 months is up after August. Blahdiggityblah. Anyway, I’ve loved all my bags since then

    • i emailed ipsy and i asked for the tart foundation and to opt of the face masks and face cleansers and my spoilers say they gave me a conceler and face cleanser in my bag 🙁 not happy

      • How do you check which items you’re going to receive in the next month? I just subscribed to Ipsy 3 days ago 🙂

    • Have you changed your age on profile? Say your 18 or something and you’ll start getting better products.

      • Does that really work? My experience with them has been exactly the same as that of the commenter above – they don’t follow my profile, and usually the only good item I receive is the one I request.
        I am this close to canceling in September after I get my tarte mascara, but if it’s as easy as changing my age, I’d be willing to stay.

  5. DLS products need an ingredient list. What in the world!?!

  6. I waited to see the second set of items you can pick and choose the Neogen truffle oil drop. They literally got back to me in 2 minutes to confirm it will be in my bag!

  7. Uhhhh I already asked for the Colourpop but now I really want that dirty little secret lip gloss.Sad I can’t have both

    • How do you request certain products

        • Gracias

          • De nada 🙂

    • If you would rather have the DLS you can email them and tell them that. You won’t get both, but you can at least change your choice.

  8. August bag full spoilers are up!

  9. Are any of these items full size? Or are they all deluxe? I don’t mind, I’m just a like confused cuz of the pictures.

    • Lip products are full size,probably the eyeliner

  10. I asked for the Smashbox foundation. I use foundation more then anything else and would love to try this one. Probably will be a tiny little size, but I hate Colour Pop lippies and have enough mascara and eyeliner to last me a lifetime.

    • Isn’t the smashbox a primer?

    • I was holding out for the Colourpop lippies, because after yet ANOTHER eyeliner and mascara, I’m just about ready to cancel.

      • have you tried emailing them and letting them know you dont want those items?

        • I emailed them 2 months after I changed my profile and still kept getting them. I’ll see how September goes and might just edit down to Boxycharm only.

    • That’s not a foundation, the Smashbox is a primer. I’ve never seen any beauty box subscription include a foundation – how would they know your precise shade?

      • I’m getting a Josie Maran foundation in August’s bag. Pretty sure you provide that info when you sign up and fill out a profile. I also am getting a shade-specific concealer. I’ve also gotten foundation from LookFantastic.

        • Well, even saying “light-skinned” (which was what I checked in my profile) doesn’t really mean anything – a lot of brands have like 4-6 different shades of ivory.

          Anyway, I am upset that I checked all the shades of eyeliner in my profile except black, and guess what I am receiving this month? A black eyeliner. 🙁

          There were plenty of items this month that would have fit my checked preferences, I don’t understand why they are sending me that one.

          In other words, I am just saying whatever you state in your profile might not really mean much. 🙁

          • I continue to tell them I don’t use liquid liner and I don’t use black. It’s in my profile and I’ve emailed them. What did I get this month? What did I get last month? Black liquid liner. I’m frustrated.

        • I got foundation from Look Fantastic too. It was way too light for me.

      • I get foundation all the time in sub boxes. Especially from ones that have a profile. I select medium for my skin tone and always get medium foundation, concealer, BB or cc cream. I have never gotten foundation or concealer that didn’t match my skin tone choice in my profiles.

        • Okay, good (although I’ve still never seen one, and I have ordered many-many beauty boxes 🙂 ), but still, the Smashbox here is a primer. 🙂

  11. I requested the Colourpop lippie stick. I’m a sucker for ‘exclusive’ colors and collabs 😍

  12. Not a fan of that lipgloss packaging. It reminds me of glosses from that $1 website.🙊

  13. I asked for the Skinfood Cleansing Foam. I’m using the Skinfood pineapple gommage mask these days and it’s the cheapest one I’ve found that isn’t tested on animals. Works great, huge bottle, and I’m a big fan!

  14. Yay! I just requested the Truffle Oil! 🙂

  15. I just asked for the colourpop lip gloss, they glosses are probably the only thing i havnt tried from colourpop

  16. I’m on a journey to discover the perfect mascara for me so naturally I chose the tarte lights, camera, lashes 4 in 1 mascara.

  17. I requested the Tarte mascara. I can always use a new one….

  18. I requested the Coloupop Lippie Stix the other day and got a reply saying that it would be in my bag 😀 I love that ipsy has started doing this.

  19. Nothing new and exciting, I’m super tired of Smashbox primers, I don’t like them. And the Tarte mascara, people love it, does nothing for me.

  20. Really hoping I don’t receive the Beauty For Real eyeliner since I just got one in my Boxycharm last month. The Dirty Little Secret lip gloss looks interesting. Ipsy sent me one of their baked highlighters last year and I still use it regularly.

    • Amanda, did you like the eyeliner? I’ve got a bag full of black eyeliners but there’s always room for one more.

      • I haven’t tried it because I have it available to swap on my page. I can’t keep up with all the eyeliners Ipsy sends me! Haha

    • Also wondering if it’s as good as I e heard -being a gel liner w staying power-supposedly.. pls answer -Thank you!!!

      • I haven’t tried it because I have it available to swap on my page. I can’t keep up with all the eyeliners Ipsy sends me! Haha

  21. I wish there was a way to just have them fill my whole bag with these lip products!

    • Have you looked into the Lip Monthly subscription box, I just canselled mine due to financial issues. It’s around $12.95 a month, but you can get your first month for $5. THey send you 4-5 products, and out of that only one is not a lip product, I loved it so much.

  22. That lip gloss seems interesting. Has anybody tried it?

    • I love Colourpop’s lip glosses. They have more than a hint of color, which I love, and don’t feel sticky.

    • I got it in my ipsy bag a few months ago. It doesn’t stay on. Even after using a lip prime

  23. Meh, nothing is jumping put at me, hopefully they put a decent bag together for me. Unless there is another round of spoilers.

  24. I’m still leaning toward the Tarte mascara, but waiting to see what spoilers are next.

    • The Tarte mascara is really nice! I got it in a sample set from Sephora and I absolutely love it.

      • Good to hear!

    • Yeah, that was what I requested. Didn’t want to take a chance on that one.

  25. Are any of these full size..? Or the teeny tiny samples?

    • I know right i wanna ask for the smashboc primer but am scared ill get one of those little samples they always send of size.

      • I want the primer as well but I don’t want Barbie doll size.

    • I would think that both the eyeliner and the lip gloss are full size, I just really hope I don’t get them. 😐

    • I think all the lip products are. The Colour Pop ones certainly will be, and I think the DLS products are always are as well.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!