Benevolent Beauty Mystery Boxes – Available Now!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Benevolent Beauty Box is offering a one-time-purchase mystery box!

The Box: Benevolent Beauty Mystery Box

The Cost: $34.95

The Products: Each mystery box will contain AT LEAST 8 items and valued at over $150. All products are from past boxes; products and colors will vary.

The subscription to Benevolent Beauty Box is $29.95 a month. Check out all of our Benevolent Beauty Box reviews to see what types of items you can expect to see in the mystery box!

How do subscribers rate Benevolent Beauty Box?

16 subscribers rated this subscription
out of 5 stars
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to Benevolent Beauty Box? Add your rating now!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in Benevolent Beauty Box News, Mystery Boxes, Subscription Box News| Tags: benevolent beauty box | 23 comments


  1. Umm, I ordered 2 of these mystery boxes and I’m very concerned now because I checked the tracking number they sent me and it was sent via FIRST CLASS. … The maximum weight for first class mail is 13 oz. Am I missing something? Or will I be getting a second shipment? This seems like quite a low weight of product for what’s supposed to be $300 + value product.

    The reason I bought 2 was because of the good reviews and looking at the previous mystery box. This is my first purchase from this company. I love to try boxes out with mystery box deals to see if they’re a good fit for me. I’m just concerned. Does anybody have insight on this?

    • I just received my Mystery Box today. I never ordered the mystery box before, nor do I subscribe to this one (currently I get LoveGoodly, BeautyCon and BeautyFix) so I don’t know if any of these are repeats from other monthly boxes or the last mystery box. Here are the contents:

      LAW Nail Polish in “A Lot of Spice” a light peachy color

      Au Naturale Creme Shadow in “Bora Bora” a shimmery pale teal color – gonna have to figure out how to play with that one, as I am more of a nude shadow person

      Lauren Brooke Lip Color in “Sangria”

      Orglamix Illume creamy Enlighten Luminizer highlighter

      LARITZY Lip Pencil in “Bare”

      Manna Kadar Lash Extending Primer

      Palmetto Derma Essential Moisturizing Cream

      ColourPop Super Shock Shadow in “School Bus” which is a charcoal gray, almost black, creme shadow. Another one to experiment with.

      • AWWW! I hope I get the au naturale “bora bora” I LOVE that brand AND product (I have it in a mossy green and a shimmery white color) but the Bora Bora color would be AWESOME! Would love a lauren brooke lip item too! Looking at the 2 revealed box contents, it looks like both are right at the $150 retail value mark with little leeway. Oh well. The ingredients look pretty good on these.

      • If that au naturale shadow in bora bora doesn’t work out for you,even if used, I’d swap you for it.

        I just got my boxes today and was actually totally ripped off (one box had only 6 items valued $109 and the other 8 item box had $118 value but the $32 of that was damaged.)

        But here’s what I got that will be up for trade from my mystery boxes:

        1.Ardency Inn Liquid Liner -RV $20 (I have 2 to swap)
        2.ColourPop Hello Kitty Super Shock Shadow (Pink) -RV $8
        3. Jersey Shore My Lash Secret Eyelash Curler – RV $30
        4..Ardency Inn Eye Powder Purple Hearts (NO SEAL so lid came off and good amount of product spilled inside it’s box $32 (but DAMAGED)
        5.LAW nail polish in A Lot of Spice – RV $9
        6. East Falls Mineral Soak Sample Jar -RV $8?
        7. gypsysoulorganics aromatherapy spray SON rain RV $20
        8. Orglamix Luminizer in ILLUME -RV $18

        Let me know if you’d be interested. No pressure though, if you like it, keep it. I just thought if you don’t end up liking it that you might like something I got instead and wanted to put the offer out there. 🙂

    • I just got mine! Pleased with the contents but it is makeup heavy – not skincare. I think I got atleast 8 items – 2 lip, 3 eye, 1 nail, 2 skincare.

      • OOH, I actually way prefer makeup heavy boxes! Would you mind listing the items you got?? 🙂

      • I was gong to ask the same thing, please list contents! Mine comes probably tomorrow. And I love makeup more than skincare so I’m hoping I get the same.

        • Box contents:
          Ardency Inn Modster Easy Ride Liquid Eye Liner $20
          Ardency Inn Light Catching Eye Powder (Purple Hearts) $32
          La Ritzy Lip Pencil (Bare) $18
          ColourPopxHello Kitty (School Bus) $5
          LAW nail polish (Lot of Spice) $9
          BellaPierre Lip Creme (Hibiscus) $20
          Palmetto Derma Antioxidant Mask .34oz $12?
          Palmetto Derma Moisturizing Cream 2oz $48

          All of the colors are completely wearable and don’t feel like “extras” that belong in a mystery box. Looking through IG photos, most look like they have come from recent months. Overall I am very happy!

          • Thank you! That is a terrific box and I hope I get the same. Sometimes a mystery box works out!

          • I like palmetto derma stuff! It does irk me that they would send you the Ardency Inn Liquid Eyeliner which contains parabens. I would really like too see “benevolence” applied to BOTH animals AND humans. I consider parabens a cruelty to humans. I don’t understand why things like parabens, BHT, aluminum in many forms, mineral oil and propylene glycol are still in so many beauty products! And people slather this stuff on their skin, face, eyes and EVEN LIPS. It’s just wrong. I just would like to say, “Dear beauty product companies, Please start caring about the humans.”

            Sorry for the rambling. The other stuff you got looked safe for the most part.

  2. Mine shipped and is on its way! Yippee. I must say it’s fun to have a true mystery coming without spoilers.

    • I am worried when mine going to be shipped. I ordered through my iphone using PayPal but did not log into my account and now have no means to check my order status.
      I agree, last box, when I received I posted here that I did not like it, but I end up using every single item and really enjoy them.

  3. Got it! I wonder when these ship??

  4. I think I really liked the last box so I’ll get another. how sad I saw it that I have so many subs that I can hardly remember what came with them?

    • How sad IS IT* Dang auto correct!

  5. If you ordered more than one mystery box last time, was every item a duplicate between the two boxes, or only some items in each box?

    • I purchased two the last time. Most of my items were different. One or two items were duplicates. Which was a good thing. I loved all of the products I received!

  6. Their past boxes look great. Very curious to see what I’ll get.

  7. Aha, I’ve been waiting all day to buy something fun and new and this was it! I’ve been wanting to try this sub, and you guys have said nice things about their last mystery box, so I was putty in their hands.

  8. I loved this last time that did it, so this time I ordered two.

    • Do you think they’ll have identical items? I loved my last one too. 😍

  9. How come when I check out with PayPal it says “Benevolent Beauty Box Subscription”

    • I asked Rachel the same question. She said this is how PayPal set up charges for her subscription box, but this mystery box is a one-time purchase. I pulled the trigger once I heard that!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!



Ipsy Glam Bag Deal – 2 Free Bonus Items for New Subscribers!
Get This Deal