Facebook Pixel
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Ipsy Reveals Are Up for the December 2016 Glam Bag! | MSA
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Ipsy Glam Bag July 2024 Spoilers

Ipsy Reveals Are Up for the December 2016 Glam Bag!

Liz Cadman
ByLiz CadmanDec 4, 2016 | 200 comments

fileasset

Ipsy Original
4 overall rating
1814 Ratings | 301 Reviews

The December 2016 Ipsy reveals are up!

Here is what I will be getting in one of my Ipsy subscriptions:

screen-shot-2016-12-04-at-11-35-06-pm

What are you getting from Ipsy this month?

If you are new to Ipsy, it is a $10 a month beauty and makeup subscription box. Check out all of our Ipsy reviews to see what’s been in past boxes.

And check out our list of the 15 Beauty Boxes To Try in 2016, and all reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find other subscriptions with similar price points to Ipsy!

Starting at $15.00
Subscribe Now

IPSY Original is one of the most popular and affordable subscriptions around, and our readers have selected it as one of the top beauty boxes for the last 5 years running! IPSY Original connects members with five makeup, skincare, hair care, and other beauty sample... read more.

Liz Cadman
Liz Cadman
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

200 comments

Erica

I cant wait for my bag to come!! Its supposed to come within the next 2 days, and my local post office always gets it here a few days early, so i am so excited!!! I may get it tomorrow which is great. I never look at what I’m getting; i always wait till it comes!!! I am not too excited with the items up, but I’m LOVING the look of that bag itself 😀 I really want eyeliner, and the tarte tartiest lip gloss. Can’t wait!

Reply ButtonReply

Kendall

Got my bag yesterday (and my shipping notice today lol), and tbh I’m pretty disappointed in the bag itself. Definitely leans more pink, and I hate the hair-fuzz! I wonder if I can shave it…

As for the products, I’m decently happy. I really wanted the nyx in bedroom eyes but got the purple instead. I’ll still use it and the formula is awesome, it just wasn’t my first choice. The ciate liquid lip is in a surprisingly wearable color, so I finally have my first matte lipstick I will actually wear. The Jersey shore lip balm is nice, nothing really to say about it. I haven’t tried the Josie maran marajuaca (sp?) oil, but the bottle is so cute! The gold at the top is actually like a little button that draws the oil up into the dropper. So cool!

The only thing I hate is the Ouie salt spray, which I knew already. It might be a good product, I don’t know, but I just can’t stand the old lady perfume smell of it. Ugh. Swap for sure.

Reply ButtonReply

Becca

I’m getting the purple nyx shadow too. Wanted the green.

Reply ButtonReply

Kaitlynn Marie

I think the bag is cute this month but I was expecting something more Christmas-y tbh. I’m getting:
NYX Professional Makeup Prismatic Shadow – yay! I wanted this when I saw the spoilers!
Royal & Langnickel MODA Angle Shader Brush – I don’t know why I didn’t want brushes before, I’m glad to get them now
Symphony Beauty Snow Cream Moisturizer – no aloe, yay!
Hikari Cosmetics Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner in Iris – meh I suck at eyeliner
Smashbox Cosmetics Insta-Matte Lipstick Transformer – meh

I’m not mad at this month. My sisters have cancelled, but I’m holding on. I’m honestly debating switching from this and Birchbox to Boxycharm in the new year. We’ll see.

Reply ButtonReply

Dianne

Only choice the items you want on survey. If you dont want skin care leave it blank. If you want eye-shadow only check eye-shadow. It seems that I have to do this the month prior for it to work.

Reply ButtonReply

Dianne

Got my bag. Like the bag. I posted it on Instagram. Msdthehairdresser. I’m amateur never posted anything thought it would be fun. Why not

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

Is it just me, or is the bag this month pink? I swear its pink.. Lol. And it seems like the samples are getting smaller and smaller…

Reply ButtonReply

Kaitlynn Marie

Ew, it’s pink? Ugh. I hate pink :/

Reply ButtonReply

Renee

It is definitely pink. I had anticipated red.

Reply ButtonReply

Juli

Its a good thing I like the maracuja oil because I am getting 6 of them. I like them for my hair and face. I still have two because I got it last month too. I am getting 6 eyeliners, I am glad they are another color besides black. 3 are iris. I am getting 3 eyeshadows, but don’t know what colors. 2 peppermint balms, that I can’t use because it has coconut oil in it, because of my nut allergy. I will give them to my sister. The two hand creams I am getting because they have coconut oil in them too. I am getting lots of lipglosses. I was hoping that with all my accounts, I would get one of the Josie Moran highlighters, but I didn’t, so I ordered one. I am getting two brushes and a sponge. I have a boat load of sponges already, but I can always use new makeup brushes. I am getting the insta matte lip product. 2 Marc Anthony hair creams, mprincess maple eyeshadow, & 2 mascaras.

Reply ButtonReply

Hailey

I’m getting:
– Ouai wave spray
– Ofra osmetics bliss highlighter/eyeshadow
-Tarte deluxe marajuca oil
-Cake beauty hand repair balm
-Ciaté London matte liquid lipstick in pin-up
I’m really happy with everything I’m getting in my bag this month!

Reply ButtonReply

wackyjgal

I’ve been getting Ipsy for around two years, and my last 2 Glambags were incredibly disappointing. I think that in the last six months I have received one or two bags that I actually was happy with. I’ve been thinking about canceling Ipsy for so long but felt like emotionally attached to it. I know that may seem strange but Ipsy was the first monthly subscription bag I purchased. But then I started watching YouTube videos and also see reviews on this site, I would see all these awesome items everyone else was getting. I started to feel like I was getting the leftover junk that Ipsy didn’t really care for. You would think that loyalty, and having long term members would mean something to these companies, but I’m sad to say that’s not the case with Ipsy, because I seen and read other sites and personal bloggers who also have been long term members having the same complaints.
Anyway, I finally cancelled and have no regrets at all. I know that it’s only $10 a month but most of the stuff I received was honestly nothing but free samples that I could just pick up at any local beauty department store.

Reply ButtonReply

Dawn L

Finally reached the point of total disgust with Ipsy and cancelled after I saw my bag. I’ve had enough of getting crap I can’t use!

My Bag:

Beau Gachis Concealer Brush (Requested no more brushes)

NYX Pris Shadow (Profile has NYX unchecked I don’t like NYX)

Tartiest lip paint in wcw (not my color)

Auora eyeliner blackberry or cinnamon (hopefully cinnamon that’s ok)

Marc Anthony Argon Oil Treatment (I’ll just add this to my draw with all the other hair treatments lol)

I hope I don’t come off as a “B” but it has been like this for the past few months. I’ll get maybe one item I can use and the rest I end up giving away or they just sit in my drawer. I hope you all have a better experience then I have had. If things change maybe I will resubscribe but for now I think it was time to say good bye to Ipsy.

Reply ButtonReply

Winter

I totally forgot to look at all the options this time around so I had no clue what could possibly be in my bag aha. Luckily it turned out alright (without me changing my answers or anything)

1. Royal & Langnickel MODA Angle Shader Brush – I love love love brushes
2. Hanalei Lip Treatment – can never get enough of lip treatments! Mine tend to be chapped if I don’t use anything so this is always a need!
3. OFRA Cosmetics Bliss Eyeshadow/Highlighter – always looking to grow my eyeshadow collection!
4. Ciaté London Liquid Velvet Matte Liquid Lipstick in Pin Up- I love liquid lips! Can’t wait to try!
5. tarte cosmetics deluxe maracuja oil- this is the only thing I’m iffy about, I tend to not put anything on my face at all so this will definitely be something new for me.

Reply ButtonReply

Rosamunde

You will LOVE the Hanalei lip treatment. It’s seriously Amazing!! I’m addicted, lol. 😉

Reply ButtonReply

Jen

I put the oil on the outside of my eyes at night (crows feet prevention) after moisturizer – I think it really works! Not just this oil – any facial oil. But this is one that I use.

Reply ButtonReply

Rebecca

I really want the blush palette! I wanted it, snow cream. and the maracuja (which i got) I wish I was part of the swap, but I can’t find it.

Reply ButtonReply

Mo

I’m pretty pleased with my December bag!

– REN mask
– Snow Cream Moisturizer
– POREfessional face primer
– Tarte glossy lip paint in wcw
– Be Matte Blush in Fresh Melon, Blackberry, and Guava

Reply ButtonReply

Ashlee

I haven’t seen my bag twin yet. I’m getting:

1. Hanalei lip treatment (excited to try, perfect time of year for it!)

2. Beau Gachis concealer brush (I have a blender brush from this brand I love and use every day, but I use my beauty blender for concealer, maybe I could use to touch up under my outer eye with concealer after finishing my eye make-up?)

3. NYX prismatic eyeshadow (always up to try something new, hopefully it’s in bedroom eyes or maybe fireball, not sure I’d use the rest…I already have greens from Colourpop and Loreal infallible, and that purple is really purple

4. Tarte Tarteist glossy lip paint in wcw (the berry look really pretty, excited to try)

5. Aurora intensively precise eyeliner (I have SO many eyeliners, but I guess I’ll try it)

Reply ButtonReply

Dianne

I’m getting,
Mintpear- beauty blending sponge
Benefit- face primer
NYX-prismatic shadow
Ciate’ London-n pin up
Nip+Fab-glycolic fix serum

Reply ButtonReply

Dawn

-Hikari Cosmetics Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner in Iris
-Marc Anthony True Professional Nourishing Argan Oil of Morocco Deep Hydrating Treatment
-Ciaté London Liquid Velvet Matte Liquid Lipstick in Pin Up
-tarte cosmetics deluxe maracuja oil
-theBalm Cosmetics Mad Lash® Mascara

I originally wasn’t crazy I was getting ANOTHER eyeliner but this one is purple! So I’m okay with that. I’m kind of over matte lipsticks. They dry out my lips and make them look like painted buttholes. But it looks like a nice color so I’ll try it again.

Reply ButtonReply

Mo

Painted buttholes lmao…

dab a little of the maracuja oil before applying the lipgloss

Reply ButtonReply

April

I am super irritated with ipsy’s site. It let me check the contents of my bag but not for my 2 daughter’s bags. When I click to “viewing bag,” it shoots me to the bottom and reveals NOTHING. Grr…i want to know what they’re getting too!
I am getting:

Smashbox insta-matte lipstick

OFRA bliss eyeshadow/highlighter

INSPR duo brow

Jersey Shore Consmetics Peppermint chap

City Colour blush

Reply ButtonReply

April

Ugh. Somehow the last words of the 3 last items got cut off. Weird.
They were: brow highlighter, chap stick, blush trio.

Reply ButtonReply

Jenn

Hey – does anyone feel their new color/other preferences helped or improved their bag this month? I see some folks are psyched to get non-black eyeliner! With mine, I’m not sure I can tell yet. My lip color, I chose.

I tried to set my preferences to always receive nail polish, and I was excited about the color prefrences — so I was sad I didn’t get one. Then I realized they aren’t even offering one this month. LOL. That will make some people very happy 🙂

My bag contains:
Moda Angle Shader Brush (I got an angled shader brush just last month!)
Hanalei Lip Treatment
OFRA Bliss Eyeshadow/Highlighter
Ciate Liquid Velvet Matte Lipstick (that was my choice)
Tarte Maracuja Oil

I wasn’t thrilled at first but… actually I like this bag. It made a bad first impression by repeating last month — but I will probably use, or at least enjoy trying, everything. I have never used matte liquid lipstick (at least one that actually dries down, which I think this one does?) It may not be my thing — but I will still enjoy trying it! And not having to buy it if I don’t like it. Right?? And, depending on the quality of the bag, I could potentially even use it as a wristlet. Also – this bag is awesome for not including liner or mascara. Points for that.

Reply ButtonReply

Samantha

I had removed nudes from my color preferences because I hate mauve on my skin tone. I emailed them and asked if I could never get mauve lipstick again, and they said their algorithm doesn’t sort by color (I think especially for their products that come in more than one color per month), which seems to defeat the point of the color preferences. But maybe they are working up to it, or at least I hope.

Reply ButtonReply

Glitterfly

My favorite bag so far in three months!

Hikari cosmetics felt tip liquid eyeliner in iris (dark purple) my favorite color.

Marc Anthony true professional nourishing argon oil deep hydrating treatment

NYX professional makeup prismatic shadow (hoping for any shade but the green)

Ciate liquid velvet matte lipstick in pin up (love the color)

Tarte cosmetics deluxe maracja oil

Reply ButtonReply

Rebecca

Finally found a bag sister! Yay!

Reply ButtonReply

Meg

I’m getting…

Briogeo Curl Charisma gel – I don’t use hair gel but I have curly hair listed in my profile so I can’t complain

Snow Cream Moisturizer – always excited to try new moisturizers

Hikari Felt Tip Eyeliner in Iris – I was initially not that excited about this because it looked black, but I’m excited now that I know it’s plum

Smashbox Insta-Matte – Excited to try!

NYX Prismatic Shadow – all of these colors look beautiful so I’m excited for this

All in all I’m really excited about most of the products in this bag!

Reply ButtonReply

Amy

I am really excited about this month’s bag, the only thing I would have liked to have had is the Tarte Oil but they picked some good ones out for me!

– Ren Glycol Lactic Renewal Radiance Mask( I got this in a Birchbox once and I loved it, super excited to get it again!)
– Symphony Beauty Snow Cream Moisturizer (I have dry skin, so I need all the hydration I can get! I go through these quickly)
– Benefit Porefessional Primer (I actually bought the sample at Ulta a while back and I love it!)
– Josie Maran Argan Enlightment Illuminizer (This was also on my wish list!)
– Ciate London Liquid Velvet Lipstick in Pin-Up (This looks like a wearable color)

They nailed last month too, and I have been a member since January, so it seems like they are finally getting my preferences down.

Reply ButtonReply

Mel P

Just curious about the porefessional primer…I also have really dry skin so I was worried this might exasperate the problem? But you mentioned that you liked it so much that you bought more, so you didn’t find that it dried out your skin even more?

Reply ButtonReply

Amy

I haven’t had any problems with the porefessional drying out my skin, as long as I use a moisturizer underneath. If I don’t use a moisturizer, everything starts bothering my skin.

Steohanie

My bag is:

The Professional Primer (I already have this, but I can always use travel sizes)
MicaBeauty Angled Eye Shadow Brush (I love getting brushes, I haven’t bought them in ages)
NYX Prismatic Eyeshadow (I’m hoping for Bedroom Eyes, don’t know how much use I’ll get out of the other colors)
Ciate Liquid Lipstick in Pin Up (I LOVE liquid lipsticks so hopefully this is good)
Nip + Fab Glycolic Fix Serum (Meh)

Reply ButtonReply

Rebecca

I want anything but bedroom eyes! lol

Reply ButtonReply

Casey

I can’t see mine! Is anyone else having issues still?

Reply ButtonReply

Sara

Anyone want to swap for the Quai wave spray? I got it in a Sephora play! box previously and salt sprays do nothing but make my hair sticky!

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

I haven’t seen my bag twin yet. I’m getting

-Symphony Beauty
Snow Cream Moisturizer

-Hikari felt tip liner in Iris

-Tarte Maracuja Oil

-The Balm Mad Lash mascara

-mPrincess
Mineral Eyeshadow in Melting Maple

The only thing I’m excited for is the oil since I requested it. Considering swapping the rest. I was really hoping for a highlight/illuminate or a primer (not the benefit one) or something other than what I got lol.

Reply ButtonReply

Becca

I really wanted the Snow Cream

Reply ButtonReply