Facebook Pixel
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
BoxyCharm December 2016 Spoiler #3! | MSA
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

BoxyCharm December 2016 Spoiler #3!

Liz Cadman
ByLiz CadmanDec 6, 2016 | 86 comments

screen-shot-2016-12-02-at-3-17-51-pm

We have the latest December 2016 Boxycharm spoiler! Each subscriber will receive ONE of the following items:

Boxycharm December 2016

And in case you missed the first spoilers, each subscriber will receive:

screen-shot-2016-12-02-at-3-16-52-pm

OFRA Long Lasting Liquid Lipstick - Value $19.90 (In Napa Valley)

AND:

screen-shot-2016-12-02-at-3-17-40-pm

Pure Cosmetics Buff Collection Palette - Value $50

What do you think of the latest December 2016 Boxycharm spoiler? Which item are you hoping for?

If you haven't signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers for future updates!

Liz Cadman
Liz Cadman
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

86 comments

Vicki

Hope I don’t get the bronzer.

Reply ButtonReply

Anna G.

Okay i got my tracking information on the 7th that my box has shipped and that it is supposed to arrive on the 12th, monday! 😊 it weighs .8
i really really want the bronzer.

Reply ButtonReply

Alisonka

I got my tracking info on the 6th. The box was in transit to the post office at 4 am this morning so either today or tomorrow. My box weighs .45. I really really hope that means I’m getting the eyeliner!!!!!!! It’s a pretty good shot that .8 would mean the bronzer, but we don’t know all the items yet.

Reply ButtonReply

Anna Goddard

I hope you’re right! Fingers crossed. But i was thinking the nail polish might be heavy too an on the neqw spoiler Liz posted, it shows two box variations both with nailpolish.

Jeannette C

I have like 10 unused bronzers..I hope I get the nail polish. I’m a nail polish junky and give myself a manicure with a new color every week. But damn, I know I will get that stupid bronzer. I’ll trade anyone if I do!!

Reply ButtonReply

wackyjgal

Woohoo my box is out for shipment! The Palette looks pretty I like the color swatches (it was on someone’s arm)! Not really into the dark lip look but I can just gift it out.
I’m hoping to get the bronzer, but with my luck I’ll get the eyeliner, haha. It’s still worth it though.

Reply ButtonReply

tara lowe

If I get the bronzer, knowing me I will, I will swap you for the liner.

Reply ButtonReply

Dawn L

I got my shipping notification yesterday and I just checked tracking boy they are slow my box should be here by 12/16. Must be using Pony Express lol

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

Lucky!! I want a shipping notification!! Lol.

Reply ButtonReply

Brittany

All righty… well I’m giving the OFRA product to my best friend. If it was another shade I would keep it. I’m excited about the eyeliner/bronze/polish AND palette. I’m so tired of skin care items. Very happy I did not getting any oils/serums last month. I am 25 and have not touched any serums given to me in previous boxes from MONTHS ago because I’m overloaded. Plus I notice that constantly changing my skin routine (adding/subtracting products) causes my skin to break out.

I’m grateful for MORE MAKEUP. LESS SKINCARE always. Thanks Boxycharm! 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Rachel

I love boxy charm this will be my third month, i am hoping for the polish also but would be happy with any of it because i dont have any of them i dont understand all the complaints, because if i was do unhappy with something i would just unsubscribe its that easy

Reply ButtonReply

Denise

I LOVE Boxycharm! What other box gives so much for $21? The value is more than tripled every single month. What I don’t like or know I won’t ever use, I put in a box to give away as gifts. I also get Ipsy and Sephora every month and just ordered Beautybox 5. Can anyone tell me what they think of Beautybox 5?

Reply ButtonReply

SAbrina

I have had BB5 for over a year and love it.

Reply ButtonReply

Anna

I am glad I did not subscribe for this month. The palette looks cute, but I would much rather save for a couple of months and get the real deal and not this knockoff , I have no problem with getting unknown brands, but with original products and not with copies- this being a naked3 dupe. AND I HATE when they tell me it is $50 or whatever. Yeah, right!! Then, I love the ofra formula, but that color is unwearable for me. And it is the 3rd liquid lipstick in a row! And The 3 options: the bronzer, I got in a boxy charm already and it is fine but glittery- OR yet another burgundy nail polish- OR yet another black liner. We will see what comes in january I hope no more dupes with unrealistic prices.

Reply ButtonReply

LindseyMP

Maybe subscription boxes just aren’t the right thing for you! Pure Cosmetics is a high-end brand, so do your research before you go spouting off about what a knockoff it is.
This is a $20 box and no other $20 box gives you products this good. And you do realize that this is a beauty box, right?

Reply ButtonReply

Dot McDowell

I agree – I was surprised when she said it was a KNOCK OFF brand! WHAT!?! It is a cruelty-free brand but not a knock off for sure! A lot of people don’t know a lot about make – up brands other than the majors though….

Megan

I think you are slightly misinformed. Pure cosmetics is a fairly high end brand. And if you go to their website to purchase this palette, it is $50. I understand what you are saying. It looks very similar to the Naked line and for $50, I’ll buy the a Naked palette, but for 1 of 5 items in a $20 box, this is a good deal. If you’re not interested in trying it, that’s fine. But it costs $50 if purchased individually. Period.

Reply ButtonReply

April

Thank you! Co-sign.

That comment stunk of snobbery privilege. My God!

Lorraine

I really don’t want the nail polish but every month I get the items I don’t want. I contacted customer support asking if I could get the eyeliner or bronzer and they said that they have no control over who gets what because it’s all random (I’m not sure if I believe this). I was upset, since other services like ipsy are very accommodating. I hate that recent boxycharms have varied so much. Some people get great boxes with a high value, and then people like me get boxes with low value and bad items 🙁 probably won’t stay subscribed unless this box really impresses me.

Reply ButtonReply

Cassie

Does anyone know what time of the month this box usually arrives? This is my first month, and I’m wanting to gift the palette to my mom for Christmas, but I wasn’t sure if it would be here in time!

Reply ButtonReply

Anna G.

I got my tracking email on the 7th and it says my box will arrive on the 12th, Monday.

Reply ButtonReply

Sherry

I live in Maryland and usually get mine the 3rd week of the month. I have not gotten a tracking number yet which is not usual for me.

Jackie

It depends on where you live and when you subscribed. The first month I joined (3mo ago), I signed up on Oct 16th and my box didn’t show up until Nov 1st. I live in Florida, and last month, I got my box on Nov 15th or 16th. They start shipping boxes on the 10th of each month and it can take up to 10 business days from the date your box ships until you get it and it can take up to 10 days after your payment was collected, for the box to actually ship. Hope that answers your question

Reply ButtonReply

Cassie

Thank you! I subbed on the 2nd and payment went through that same day. I’m in Arkansas, so hopefully it’ll make it here in time 🙂

Bonnie

Everything looks great and I would be happy with any of it!

Reply ButtonReply

Dominique

Every month, I wait for full spoilers to decide whether or not I want to resub. Then I cancel for the next month and wait again.
The November box was amazing, so I subbed. I considered just keeping the sub going, but decided to cancel before Dec 1st just in case. So glad I did.
~I don’t need anymore palettes. I already have the two studio palettes along with my 6 other palettes. In my opinion, we do not need an eyeshadow palette in every single box.
~The last thing I need is more lipstick. Liquid or otherwise.
~I don’t use nail polish, don’t need anymore eyeliner and I don’t need bronzer.
Absolutely no FOMO 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Bonnie

Sounds like this isn’t the sub for you. It’s really makeup heavy and seems like you aren’t really hoping for makeup in your sub? (since you don’t want eyeshadow, lipstick, nail polish, eye liner, or bronzer). Allure, Look Fantastic, and Birchbox all give far less makeup and more skin and hair. Glossybox too. These might be more up your alley.

Reply ButtonReply

Dominique

Hi Bonnie,
Thanks for your input. Boxycharm is actually my favorite subscription. I think you misunderstand. I LOVE my studio makeup palettes, but I don’t want a palette every month which is why I wait to see the full spoilers. No I don’t like nail polish and I have way too many eyeliners, but I adored the highlighter, eye cream and liquid lipstick from November’s box.
I just prefer more variety ya know? Like we just got a palette and liquid lipstick last month, so I feel comfortable skipping this month.
I’ve tried glossybox and hated it, boxycharm is infinitely better for the same price.

Crystal

I want all of it and none of it at the same time lol,I suffer from the worst case of fomo (fear of missing out).

Reply ButtonReply

Aimee

I do love Boxycharm just not the change. Every month since the changes, I get the products I cannot use like the Marula Oil. I understand but wish it was all the same. Anyone need Marula Oil & the bronzer I’m destined to get this month.

Reply ButtonReply

Gina

Hi Aimee.
I would love to swap the Marula Oil ! I received the Vintage Illuminating face Highlighter.
I not even open the Box, since i knew what it was .LOL

Reply ButtonReply

Toni

Isn’t funny I wanted the highlighter just like the month before with the ofra highlighter instead I got the oil

Candice

I would definitely prefer the Marula Oil & Bronzer over what I got in my November box. I received the Vanity Illuminator and the Makeup Geek Blush but they are pink and I am African American with a yellow undertone. In other words you can’t even see them on my skin, I was super disappointed. I would be happy to trade with you since I only swatched the other two items to see if they would actually work.

Reply ButtonReply

Dominique

Candice,
Have you tried the products? I am also African American with yellow undertones and the vintage highlighter shows up beautifully. And anyone can wear blush.

Sherry

I wanted the oil so bad so that’s why I didn’t get it. Lol
I do agree it was easier to except the items when everyone got the same.

Shayna

I would loveeee the oil (I feel like I posted a million times on other posts trying to get sometime to swap with me lol!) https://swap.mysubscriptionaddiction.com/user/19970/profile

Reply ButtonReply

Shayna

Just let me know and if you don’t see anything I might have something you’re looking for not posted!

Dorian

What would you want to swap the oil for? I was really hoping for it and didn’t get it!

Reply ButtonReply

Leandra Jimenez

What was the old boxy charm like?

Reply ButtonReply

Kay

Everyone got the same products. I liked it way better that way. It does seem a good bit of people get screwed each month. The get low budget items while others get the more expensive box and it happens like that every month it’s not one month low box next month higher end items. Quit trying to be like ipsy and other sub boxes everyone has joined because they love Boxycharm if they wanted you to be like others they would sub them.

Jackie

Omg I would love the marula oil and/or the bronzer!! I wanted the oil so bad and didn’t get it, and I want the bronzer, so I know I won’t get it :'(

Reply ButtonReply

Dianne

I hope they have different colors of the ofra lipstick. I’d use the Nail polish or eyeliner or another bronzer. I’ve gotten the ofra lipstick in a dark black red in a past box. I look like a zombie in dark lipsticks. I love purple lipstick but not that dark. Love the eyeshadows. If I get the lipstick in that color I’ll give it to my niece.

Reply ButtonReply

Tris

Sadly the shade of the Ofra will not vary. Everyone will receive the purple shade, Napa Valley.

Reply ButtonReply

Mel

I really dont want the bronzer. Ive only used brozer once in my life and never agian. It’s just not for me. However I love butter london nailpolish and eyeliner so either would be very welcome

Reply ButtonReply

Sherry

Personally I would be happy with any of the three. I would pick the eyeliner if I had a choice since I have never tried it. Second I would take the bronzer and save it for summer. This is my favorite and go to bronzer so I would be happy to get another.

Reply ButtonReply

Marigia_St

The Ofra lipstick in Napa Valley for each subscriber… Oh, no! I don’t wear this awful shade ;( I hope to receive something nude/pink/red but no any dark violet for my lips

Reply ButtonReply

Brittnee

Me too 🙁

Reply ButtonReply

NinaKC

I have this palette and really, really like it. Quartz, Dune and Clay are not matte like a Tarte matte would be but a fine sheen. Mirage(at the very end) is glittery. The rest are shimmery. The brush is nice too. They stay on pretty good without primer.

Reply ButtonReply

Raquel

I Love Boxycharm I have gotten 4 palletes so far and I hope they keep on coming!

Reply ButtonReply

Rachel

Me too

Reply ButtonReply

Debbie

I think that polish is La Moss, or maybe if it’s a dark photograph, saucy jack. Both are great colors, but I especially love La Moss. Since I have both those colors , my best friend will be thrilled if I get the polish 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Dawn L

So far looks like a great box. I hope I get the polish cause I don’t use Bronzers and I have enough eyeliners to last me a few years!!!

Reply ButtonReply

Kim

I already got that same bronzer from Boxycharm. I will be ticked if they send me another one. I’d prefer the polish out of all 3 but I will be very upset with a duplicate of the same exact product.

Reply ButtonReply

Claudia

I just wanted to share my fantastic service from Boxycharm. I am at college and so a few months ago, when leaving for summer, I changed my address to have it shipped home. Boxycharm seemed to have a glitch and it changed the address back to my school address, and I didn’t notice until it had shipped. Boxycharm however, sent me a replacement box for my home address so I could get the box I paid for! Also, my November order had a shipping issue, so I had contacted them when I did not receive my box in the appropriate time, and they were quick to find and ship out my box and give me 1000 charms in the shop! I absolutely love Boxycharm, and even though it may take them time to respond, they are always quick to fix the issues!

Reply ButtonReply