Update! BoxyCharm December 2016 FULL SPOILERS!!

ByLiz CadmanDec 12, 2016 | 176 comments

screen-shot-2016-12-02-at-3-17-51-pm

UPDATE! We have the FULL SPOILERS for the December 2016 Boxycharm- including new variations!

screen-shot-2016-12-12-at-4-05-46-pm

Source: Instagram

OFRA Long Lasting Liquid Lipstick - Value $19.90 (In Napa Valley)
Pure Cosmetics Buff Collection Palette - Value $50
Butter London Nail Polish - Value $15(Subscribers will receive this or Butter London Eyeliner OR ModelCo Bronzer)
The Original Mini MakeUp Eraser - Value $12
IBY Beauty Lip Liner - Value $14

screen-shot-2016-12-08-at-10-01-37-pm

Source: Instagram user maggiemorge96

OFRA Long Lasting Liquid Lipstick - Value $19.90 (In Napa Valley)
Pure Cosmetics Buff Collection Palette - Value $50
Butter London Nail Polish - Value $15(Subscribers will receive this or Butter London Eyeliner OR ModelCo Bronzer)
Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener - Value $24
Beauty For Real Lip Revitalizer - Value $14

screen-shot-2016-12-08-at-10-04-56-pm

Source: Instagram user apere010

OFRA Long Lasting Liquid Lipstick - Value $19.90 (In Napa Valley)
Pure Cosmetics Buff Collection Palette - Value $50
Butter London Nail Polish - Value $15(Subscribers will receive this or Butter London Eyeliner OR ModelCo Bronzer)
Makeup Geek Full Spectrum Eye Liner Pencil - Value $9
Beauty For Real Lip Revitalizer - Value $14

What do you think of the full December 2016 Boxycharm spoilers?

If you haven't signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. (And if you sign up in the month of December, your first box will be the December box!) Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers for future updates!

Posted in BoxyCharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Read More By Liz Cadman >

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Notify me of follow-up comments by email

176 comments

Roxy D'Agostino

Wow, December is my second month receiving Boxycharm and I loved this month’s box even more than last month’s-and I had a box value of $173! My variation was “kit#32” and included the following:
-Pure Cosmetics Eyeshadow palette
-Model Co. Shimmer Bronzer
-OFRA Metallic Liquid Lipstick
-Purlisse 4in1 Eye Adore Serum
-LBY Beauty lip pencil (light pink)
I don’t wear lip liner but I will wear this one because it’s my favorite lip color-like a light baby pink. Can’t wait to see what January has in store!

Amy

My box weighed .8 lbs and I was REALLY disappointed with my variation. I am redeeming my BoxyCharm Points and I am cancelling before the end of this month. BoxyCharm used to be amazing in the past months, but my news year resolution is to cut my subscription boxes that I am not consistently happy with so bye bye BoxyCharm. Here is what i got if you are curious.

– Pure Cosmetics Buff Palette(“Mirror” was broken, packaging is cheap and is hard to open, but the colors look nice so i’ll give this a shot if the colors suck I am giving this away)
– Butter London Nail Polish (Butter London has some nice polishes)
– IBY Lip Liner in Coral (This is pretty, I will be using this)
– Ofra Purple Liquid Lipstick (Smells nice, but I hate the color and I can’t wear something like this to work in a corporate environment so I will be giving this away)
– Cougar Mineral and Body Shimmering Powder in Diamond Kiss(A leftover dud for sure, but I will give this a shot. Might be a nice highlighter, might end up giving this away too its really glittery)

Gianine

Cosmetics ardent typically heavy, so what difference does that make? I’m not sure I understand.

Gianine

Let me backtrack a bit. My husband and I got this for our daughter (24) as a Christmas gift. She received her first box yesterday, and seemed really happy about it. I did my research and this seemed to be a really good one compared to the others in terms of value for the price. We subscribed for the whole year. What are your opinions?

Jackie

I got the same box except I got the IBY lip liner in the berry shade. The cougar shimmer, I don’t like it, I’ve gotten it in a past box, so I’m not sure why I got it again when I didn’t like it the first time. Its not bad to dust some on your body, but for a face highlight, I was not impressed because its so glittery and its loose so it makes a mess. I was disappointed in this box 🙁

Kellie

I received my box today…my box contained the palette, Ofra lip, Butter London polish (was hoping for their eyeliner as I haven’t polished my nails in nearly a year!), an IBY eyeliner in blue gray (was hoping for the MUG one) and the BFR lip revival scrub. I had hoped for the mini eraser but all in all not a bad box…just won’t use the polish. My box weighed .9 if anyone is trying to figure out things by weight lol.

Irene

I got the same. Happy it wasn’t another black eyeliner.

Shawn

I got the same but a navy blue eyeliner.

Mel

Does anybodies tracking say it was delivered already? Mine says it was delivered yesterday (sunday). I know for a fact that the post office isn’t even open so I’m hoping it’s just an error. Anyone else have this issue?

Toni

Our post office hasn’t been delivering on Sunday

katie

Mine has just started delivering “packages” on Sunday.

Sherry

Post office has been delivering on Sunday due to the holiday season.

Mel

Oh boy, now I’ve got a missing box

I got the nail polish (yay!) and the eyeliner in cobalt (anyone want it?) I was shocked at the ofra color. It’s almost black. My husband asked me if I was starting a goth phase.

Jackie

I want the blue eyeliner!!!

Sherry

I am disappointed in the Ofra shade. I love purples but this is too dark almost black. I hope some people really love it but I’m 40 and I can’t pull this off anymore. I will look either silly or creepy not sure which. Lol

If you don’t get it, I’m happy to send you mine!

Toni

I love blue eyeliner I hope I get that

Jeannette

Just got mine! I’m happy I got the nail polish, i also got the eye brightener.

Brittany

Anyone else notice a change in weight with their box on the tracking? Mine started out weighing .9 and now it’s saying .8.

I was all fingers crossed for the top box too! Now…now I dunno. And I have to wait all the way until Friday to find out…and it’ll prob get pushed back thanks to this silly storm.

Mama needs some new makeup to play with!!

Jessica

Mine did the same. I checked it right when I got my confirmation, and then yesterday I noticed it was changed from .9 to .8. So maybe it was .86 and they rounded up, only for it to be rounded down. I dunno. Mine says due Thursday.

Brittany

I’m so glad it wasn’t just me! LOL.

We’ll have to see if we got the same items in our magical weight-changing boxes! Mine’s supposed to be here Friday, but it’s way ahead of where it was last month via tracking…so I’m hoping they’re being safe and over-predicting. That, or FedEx is just on super charge mode…my ipsy bag is making excellent time as well.

Paige

I got the mini make up a racer in mine and the IBY eyeliner in brown

Whitney

How much did your box weigh?

Sherry

Last month mine changed from .9 to .8 so I’m not trusting the weight of my package too much this month. 😭

Jackie

Anyone else’s box taking the scenic route? Every month my box goes from MA to GA to Orlando Fl to Hudson FL. Well I just checked the shipping notification and its in Pennsylvania! Why did it go north just to go south? Doesn’t make sense. Its supposed to be here Tuesday, but I’m def having doubts. Ughh!

Melody

PA is on the way to Florida from MA;)
My packages are taking different routes than typical the last few weeks. I think because they amp up deliveries around this time of year they stick it on whichever truck will get it one step closer to its destination.

Jackie

Ohh lmfao!! Guess I don’t know that part of the US lol!! It updated this morning and is now in NC and its never updated in transit before and its done it twice. Once in PA and now in NC lol. For some reason I always thought PA was further north than MA. Geography was never my strong suit 😉

Kristen

Yes!!! I live in Connecticut and my box was in my city post office and then went back to Massachusetts!

sephrenia300

My .9 lb box arrived yesterday and it was exactly the first box pictured. I’m so thrilled to get the thrive eye brightener, especially since I got that phooey $2 elf brush instead of the mally eye brightener in my Allure box a few boxes ago. Do you hear me Allure? PHOOEY I SAY! I’m excited to try the OFRA since I love dark and wine colored lip products but have never tried a true purple before.

My only complaint is that, because this box shipped so fast, my replacement for the broken vintage highlighter from last month won’t come until my JANUARY box ships :/ I don’t mind waiting, but really hope they don’t run out by then. I would be crushed. (*like my highlighter*)

Tamara d

Got my shipping information today and it weighs .8 …. So I hope it has the mug liner. But we will see

Melody

I got my email today. It weighs .9lb which makes me a little nervous because they are supposed to get a replacement item from my last month’s box. I hope they remember and I don’t have to hound them about it.

Wendy

Same here Melody. My vintage highlighter was smashed and my box weighs .9 lb. Makes me wonder is my replacement in there? Hope you get yours!

Eva

I hope dont have the polish !!!

Melody Ston

I got my email today. It weighs .9lb which makes me a little nervous because it is supposed to include a replacement item from my last month’s box. I hope they remember and that I don’t have to hound them about it.

Sami

Mine weighs the same and I’m also getting a replacement. Although like 2 days after it shipped I got another tracking number (both are different) so I’m assuming it’s in that

mslisa100

Mine came today. I got the Butter polish and the lip scrub. Very happy I got the variations I was hoping for ! 🙂

Barbara

I feel sad because my box is different . I got the stupid Makeup eraser cloth. Won’t use it. I just don’t see how something can take off makeup with just water. No thank you ! Darn, I’m disappointed. Wonder why it isn’t shown in the above variations? Anybody else get it?

mslisa100

and my box shipping weight was 0.9 lbs / 0.41 kgs

Toni

Yayyyyy my box weighs the same ,I would be so happy with these items

[email protected]

Ooh. Ohh my box weighs .9 too…fingers crossed for the polish!!!

Jackie

Who already got their box that weighs .8? If so, what did you get? Mine doesn’t come until Tuesday and the anticipation is killingggggg me!!! 🙂

Ariana

Mine weighed that much and I got the lip liner and make up eraser. I really wanted the lip scrub!

Kimber

There are new photos in the Boxycharm tag on Instagram. Another variation is lip liner from IBY and a mini makeup eraser instead of the eye pen and lip scrub.

Chrystal

All of the .8 boxes I’ve seen posted on IG have the variation with Butter polish, IBY lip liner & the makeup eraser. I have yet to see any post with the bronzer or Butter eyeliner. Was hoping to receive the lip scrub 😩

Jackie

Thanks, girl. I looked on the BoxyCharm IG but didn’t see any photos. I will look at their tagged stuff and “liked” lol. I was really hoping for that eye pen

Dianne

Still waiting for mine. I hope we get the KL polish next month.

Luna

Oooh! Did you see a spoiler that a KL polish could be in next month’s box? I just bought all of her new polishes during the pre-sale. 🙂

Kimber

It’s possible because Kathleen Lights’ sister is one of the main Boxycharm girls (Ylette)

Jackie

Where did you see that??? I normally don’t get excited over nail polish, but I love KathleenLights and I’ve seen a few of her polish swatches that look beautiful!

SarahC

Same especially Zoey❤️❤️

Alisonka

I just got mine out of the mailbox. Shipping get weight was 1 lb/ 45kg. I got the box pictured first above. Ofra lip, lips scrub, palette, eye brightener (yay!) And butter london nail in a burgundy color.

Alisonka

The palette colors are gorgeous. The picture above is bad light. I was going to gift this as I have a ton of palettes, but now I don’t think I can!

Courtney

How is their customer service? Do they respond pretty quickly or do you have to keep trying to get ahold of them? I ask because I messaged them Monday through Facebook and haven’t heard back so I was wondering if email was the best way to communicate with them.

KrAyZeBuTeY

Email them and they get right back and they have great customer service,

MzBev

Anytime I’ve had to contact them, via email, it takes the full 72 hours to get a response. they are super slow, imo. Then if you respond, you’ll wait another 3 days before your next response. that’s been my experience.

Laurabeth

I have always gotten same day or next day responses on the multiple times I have emailed them- definitely the way to go!

Courtney

Thank you 😊 I will try them that way!

Mayra

I’ll get mine on Tuesday! I hope to get any of these variations!! Until know I’ve been getting the variation I like.. hope this one is a good one.. any of these boxes for me are winners!!

Halie

Are the variations being sorted by subscription sign up dates? I’m hoping for the eye brightener! I won’t use the dark/Halloween lipstick or the grandma colored nail polish! I have yet to use the palette from fabfitfun so this one will most likely go untouched. The lip scrub yes please!

Stefanie

Red, is a “grandma” color nail polish? 😕

Sherry

That’s one spicy and sassy grandma with her beautiful red nails. Lol 😉

Tamara Deneweth

I would def use the mug liner so I hope I get that but I’ll be happy with
Any of the variations BC imo they are all great!!!

Stephanie

How does everybody seem to know what their box will weigh? My November box never had tracking info. I haven’t received anything for December’s box either, though of course I haven’t received my December box, so they may not have sent it out. I’ve tried to look for this info on their page, but any info eludes me.

Sherry

We know from the tracking info emailed to us. If you don’t get tracking info this month you might want to email boxy just let them know so hopefully they can fix that issue for you. I just got tracking email this morning but this is early for me to get it.

Mine said 1 pound. I got the first variation with nail polish! Love the pallet so much I just ordered another box! I have two girls and several nieces that I share with is something isn’t what I like, like the napa valley lip stuff, one of my nieces will. E getting it for Christmas!

Sherry

Mine says .90 but it said the same last month and then when it got to my area it changed to .84. So I’m not sure if I can trust that.

Liz G

Oooh mine is 1 lb too. Hope I get the same!

Genevieve Mullis

Mine says .08 😭
What color polish did you get?

nika

Genevieve Mullis – .8 box has mini makeup eraser cloth, lip liner (sorta nude looking), ofra halloween-ish lippie, Butter polish & buff palette. Just saw it on IG

No lip scrub 🙁

Ruby Murray, it’s a deep red

Genevieve Mullis

Does anyone know what the color possibilities are for the nail polish? I’m hoping for this item as well as hoping the colors are good.

nika

Genevieve Mullis only deep red so far (might be the only option)

Melody

I haven’t received shipping email yet:(
I would prefer the Thrive cosmetics product but would be happy with the eyeliner too especially if it’s an I,interesting color.
Is that bronzer matte or shimmer? Anyone know? I wouldnt mind it if it is matte. Evry bronzer I have received in a box is shimmer:/.

Sherry

The model Co bronzer is a shimmer. It has a gold shimmer in it. It is my favorite bronzer ever. I use it as a blush.

Anna

So glad to know you can use it as blush! Now I’m happy with whatever variation I get 😝

AprilJK

I read it is glittery :/

Sherry

The model Co bronzer has a gold shimmer in it which is very flattering. Its not a high shine or glittery bronzer. It quite beautiful and natural looking. I use it daily as a blush.

kate

I got the temptu liquid bronzer a couple of months ago in a boxycharm box, it was matte, and awesome.

AprilJK

I got that too, if it’s the one I’m thinking of. It has a bit of shimmer to it.

Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Update! BoxyCharm December 2016 FULL SPOILERS!!

Submit A Brand

Information

Company