Posted by on in Subscription Box News | 186 comments

Too Faced Mystery Bag Countdown Party – Giveaway #2

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.


The countdownΒ party continues! The Too Faced Mystery Bag launches at 3 AM ET, and we’re doing a Flash Giveaway every half hour to keep things fun while we wait!

This prize is a $100 Sephora Gift Card! (And congrats to our winner from the last giveaway, Helen W.)

(Winner will be contacted by email – make sure to enter with an email account you check frequently).

If you do the refer-a-friend entry option in this giveaway, you’ll get the entries for that once the friend has entered the giveaway. Giveaway is open only to US residents 18 and over.

(Also – any suggestions for a fun question to ask for the next giveaway?)

a Rafflecopter giveaway

If the giveaway isn’t loading for you, click here.

Too Faced Mystery BagΒ IS NOW LIVE!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. I’ve tried about 10 subscription boxes, but I think my favorites are PopSugar (on a good month :)) and BoxyCharm!

  2. birchbox, love with food, and some one time buys.

  3. I’ve tried Birchbox and Play, and thanks to the Black Friday deals, I’ll be adding Popsugar to the mix!

  4. I have tried a whopping 35 different boxes (oh boy…)

    Favorite is PopSugar followed by Allure.

    • Yikes, girl! Where do you store all that stuff?

      • @Lisa, I give away some as gifts, some as donations, ebay some, and one day plan to participate in the Swaps. The rest? Organized in boxes under my vanity table.

        • Good ideas, all. I’ve donated a lot of things from mine like the personal care items (shampoos, lotions, etc.) to local shelters. I finally cancelled both, though, since there were a lot of repeats and the Target boxes seemed like they were targeting (no pun intended) much younger buyers (that like dark purple or pink florescent lips).

    • I feel compelled to add that I’ve cancelled about 25 of those boxes and have “only” 10 now. πŸ˜€ πŸ˜€

      • Which 10 do you have now?

    • I agree some boxes repeat items

  5. I have tried 20+ and fab fit fun is my fave.

  6. I’ve only tried Target and Walmart boxes, but I just signed up for the Allure one through this site. I’m excited to get it! I’d do more but haven’t yet and am trying hard to stay on a budget (of sorts). I’m interested in Ipsy next.

  7. I think I’ve tried 15-20 but I’ve cancelled about 5 of them and some were one-off boxes. I’m shocked by the ones I have liked so much (Julep!) and by the ones that were not so impressive (I won’t give examples because that’s kind of rude).

  8. I think I’ve tried about 8. Most of them being beauty boxes but a few clothing ones!

    • Have you tried Gwynnie Bee by any chance? I’d like to but yikes, the cost! Clothes look cute, though.

  9. I’ve tried Naturebox, Sephora Play!, and the Beautycon box. I liked the idea of Naturebox, but I didn’t care for the foods, just not my favorite flavors. I really liked the Play! box as I’m a makeup newbie and I didn’t have a lot of these products and it allowed me to try brands I had heard of before, but hadn’t had a chance to check out yet. I also liked the bonus perfume sample in every bag. It might be my favorite, but it was such a hassle to sign up for.

    I only got one Beautycon box, but I loved it. I got the Spring 2016 one, curated by grav3yardgirl, because she’s one of my favorite youtubers. I love the concept behind the box and you get a good variety of items. If I had more money, I’d definitely be getting this box.

  10. Oh my favorite favorite value on makeup is boxycharm, but I love ipsy for the price, cute bags, products, and great app.

  11. I have tried 1UP Box, Nerd Block Jr., Loot Crate, Ipsy, Sephora Play, and Boxycharm! My favorite is definitely Boxycharm!!!

  12. You said above to use an email that we check frequently. Are you referring to the email we use to subscribe to the MSA newsletter?

    • I hope so, because I see nowhere to enter an actual email, so I’m assuming if we are regular newsletter subscribers, our user names here on the blog will match up to our emails. Is that right, Liz?

      • If the rafflecopter widget doesn’t request your email, that means you’re already logged in from a previous giveaway. (so, you should be good!)

  13. I’ve tried too many to count. Popsugar is one of my favorites price/value wise however curation is not always my favorite. Box of Style is another good one.

  14. I’ve tried Ipsy, Birchbox and Boxycharm and Ipsy is my favorite so far!

  15. Also, random question….how are giveaway winners chosen? Obvi randomly, but how? I really wanna win something, anything! <3

    • We use rafflecopter which select a random winner for us for each giveaway. Hope that helps πŸ™‚

      • Oh cool, thanks! Now….off to pray to the rafflecopter gods to pick my name hahaha! πŸ™‚

  16. i’ve tried…idk man, a lot. i really, really enjoyed degustabox.

  17. I’ve tried 5 different subs, mostly beauty subs, but Adidas Avenue A is my favorite!

  18. I have tried … too many?! The box I am most excited about right now is Elementary Box – I haven’t gotten one yet, but I am excited to get my first one!

  19. I have tried 8 different subscription boxes. My favorite is a tie between Sephora and Ipsy. They both have such great items every month!!!

  20. I have tried 8 subs, currently still have 7. The only one I let go was Pop Sugar, even though my all time favorite box was their February box this year.

  21. I’ve tried several over the past four years & I’m happy with Degustabox & Walmart subscriptions atm.

  22. Only 2 boxes so far but love them both!

  23. After finding this site, I decided to do all my Christmas shopping via subscription boxes. Somehow I have managed to try 20ish? And my shopping list nowhere near justifies that. Will have to whittle down in the new year!

    • I can’t pick a favorite yet as they have not all arrived.

      The most impressive isn’t a subscription — it’s the Look Fantastic Advent Calendar. I haven’t seen what is inside it yet, but the presentation is beautiful.

  24. Currently have ipsy and just subscribed to boxy. Used to have allure but cancelling. My fave is ipsy, can’t beat it for $10

  25. I have tried about 25-30 subscriptions. I love fabfitfun, sephora play, ipsy, boxycharm…. too many hahaha and my all time favorite pet one is BarkBox! Not sure I have just one I love more than the others. Changes month to month.

  26. I’ve tried at least half a dozen boxes. I think my favorite has been yarnbox!

  27. I’ve tried 3. It started with ipsy, then Birchbox, and I was on the wait list for Play by Sephora. I have cancelled ipsy and Birchbox because I kept getting the same products. Play by Sephora is definitely my favorite out of the three πŸ™‚

  28. I’ve probably tried 30 plus subscription boxes…to choose a favorite? Boxycharm and bling is the new black. Ipsy and glossybox and allure and play are also in my faves…but I have so many (all beauty but the bling) test tube beauty is pretty awesome tooπŸ’„πŸ’‹πŸ’žπŸ™‹! Ugh….I can’t choose just one anything!

  29. I have tried more than 20 boxes God help me lol my favorite one would have to be boxycharm!! It is consistently great value & I’m always satisfied with everything I get!

  30. Oh man I don’t even know how many I’ve tried…so many one off boxes, mystery bags, etc. I’ve probably tried at least 25 different ones though. My favorites at the moment are Bookish Box and BPure box!

  31. Hi Liz,
    I love doing subscription boxes and Ive done ipsy and sephora! Theyre my favorite and im hoping to try birchbox next. Thanks so much for doing this giveaway πŸ™‚

  32. I’ve tried at least 50 boxes over the last 5 years. My favorite is still Popsugar.

  33. Sephora gift card? I can get some Xmas shopping done with that!

  34. I’ve only tried a handful and my favorite so far is Ipsy.

  35. I have tried maybe 6 and my favorite is Boxycharm.

  36. I’ve probably tried 8 already and still can’t decide on a favorite.

  37. I’ve tried 8 I think and I could no sooner choose a favorite child.

    • Haha! Love this πŸ™‚

  38. I’ve tried a bunch, but I think the food ones are my favorite. I just resubscribed to Love With Food.

  39. I’be tried 5-6 subscription boxes. Birchbox was my strong favorite because of the points for YEARS until they changed their system 😒 Now it’s PSMH!

  40. I’m afraid to try to add them all up. Most I’ve only tried briefly, and I’ve managed to get down to only a few now, but I’d say I’ve probably tried 30-40.

  41. I have tried 5 subscription boxes so far. My favorites are a tie between FabFitFun and Popsugar!

  42. How many have I tried? I think I’m up to 10 or maybe 15 now and I haven’t canceled any yet.

  43. I have tried 17 different boxes (OMG, what?) I think my favorite is BeautyFix or PopSugar!

  44. I’ve tried at least a dozen boxes if not more! My favorite was Rachel Zoe, but I think Avenue A by Adidas and Happy Rebel Box are my newest faves. I don’t have too much from those boxes that are “repeats” or I feel the need to try to make work.

  45. I have only tried the October Target Beauty Box and the November Lookfantastic box. I cancelled Lookfantastic due to their customer service. I just signed up for Popsugar and am looking for something else. I do not have a favorite yet!

  46. I’m new to the beauty sub world–only tried 3 so far. Ipsy is my fave (Sephora is a close 2nd)

  47. i have tried about 7 boxes. I love my Sephora box!!!

  48. I’ve tried a lot, but my favorite is the Sephora subscription.

  49. My favorite box right now is Ipsy!

  50. I just found this site and now I just know I’m going to get hooked on subscription boxes!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!