Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
We have a confirmed update from Allure on the alternate item SPOILERS for the August 2016 Allure Beauty Box! In case you missed the original spoilers, here is the video reveal:
UPDATE: Allure has confirmed with MSA the alternative items for the Mally Eye Brightener. Subscribers may receive one of the following instead of the Mally product:
Each month, you'll get 6+ Allure-approved makeup and skincare picks delivered to your door ($100+ value for only $25). 6 or more products (at least 3 FULL-SIZE) valued at $100+ with only expert-approved products, hand-selected by Allure editors. Enjoy a new member gift valued at $15+ free shippin... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Are boxes late? I haven’t even gotten a tracking number yet! I had my box this time last month-
Reply
KC
I typically get mine earlier in the month, too but received it today. I chatted earlier in the week and was told that they had some delays this month.
I am sure yours is right around the corner, too. 🙂
Reply
Jill
FOR ALL WHO GOT THE ELF BRUSH….I used mine today and I am pleasantly surprised. This little brush (it reminds me of a skunk tail LOL) is incredible. I used it for applying my yellow powder. It picks up powder amazingly well and deposits it on the skin so smoothly and flawlessly. And its the perfect size for targeting particular areas on the face. In the box booklet, it states it should only be used for cream and liquid product, not powders. But the brush pouch states that it CAN be used with powder. And it does very well. I imagine it would work wonderfully for contouring, highlighting, and bronzing. So before you toss it aside feeling as though you got ripped off, give it a try. I’m so glad I did. By the way, I ordered a mini glow tonic from pixi (I really wanted to try it!) and came across eyeliner brighteners! I ordered one! ….can’t wait to try it.
Reply
LLR
I got mine today and got the Mally so I’m happy to try some new makeup. The shampoo smells good so that’s something to look forward to just to switch things up.
I like the box this month but is it just me or are they starting to look like every other box? I have always liked that many of the brands and products were new to me so along with the value this was probably my favorite. Maybe I’m getting burnout after 2 years.
Also, if anyone got the Burberry sample-what was it like?
Reply
Toni
It was tiny,but it felt nice on my face
Reply
Karla
My box arrived today. I never received a tracking number. I received the Burberry base, a sample size that I can pick up for free at my local department store. Tiny free sample or $25 Mallywand…that is a fair replacement ?
Reply
Toni
Sometimes I think I just shouldn’t read all the comments on here lol,I also received that sample and was glad it wasn’t the cheep makeup brush but the more I hear the price difference the more cheated I feel.Felling sad now ??
Reply
Alisonka
I got my box today. No shipping info. Nothing even on my account page. I got the ELF brush as well. Does pur-lisse even have a product for oily skin? This is the 3rd time I’ve received this and I can’t use it. If it was for oily skin, I’d be kind of okay with this box, but it is a complete bust for me. I hate sticking around with Allure just hoping they will go back to being this great box everyone said it was, which is what made me subscribe. Nothing about this 4 month experience has been adequate enough to “stick with them”. Goodbye, Allure!
Reply
calilaci
I got the dreaded brush.. Couldn’t wait for the mally. Big disappointment.
Reply
Traci Rhein
Oh YAY! YIPPEE! HOORAY! I GOT MY BOX AND IT’S THE BEST EVER!!!! AN ELF BRUSH!!!!! oh wait……I could a bought that at Walmart…..nevermind…smh…
Reply
Betty
YOou at least got something. I’m missing the extra item completely from my box. 2 boxes in a row where something is missing.
Reply
Kendall
Got the elf brush. Kind of annoyed but resigned to it, since I expected I would. It’s the one thing I can’t use, nor can anyone else I know, so off to GoodWill it goes. I like the rest of the stuff though, so whatever. If I cancel (and I might) it won’t be because of that, however. It will be because of all the issues they have had, and the awful CS. I have yet to have a drama free box. I just don’t know that it’s worth the hassle. If I do cancel though, I’m definitely going to keep an eye on them. Hopefully once they get it together, this will become a great box again, and I’ll resubscribe.
Reply
NinaKC
I got my Allure box today. Never did get shipping info. In my box:
pur-lisse- blue lotus moisturizer
supergoop- setting mist
freeze 24 7- anti age eye serum
garnier – shampoo and conditioner
metalic blue WET brush
cargo swimables in pebble beach
Burberry fresh glow
My book has all my products in it.
I am happy with my box.
Reply
Toni
Ditto to everything including that I never got tracking info either
Reply
Teresa
I got the Burberry, I would have gotten more use out of anything else but of course I got the luminizer. LOL, guess it will be saved for my upcoming cruise to give me a little shimmer on my 1st ever solo. Otherwise I like everything I got, nothing should go to waste which is good.
Reply
Alice
Just so everyone knows, the shampoo and conditioner are “bonus” items, and dont count toward the value. They aren’t even listed in the booklet. Do you like free stuff? Because that’s exactly what those are. I wish people wouldn’t complain about that because it makes me think we are all less likely to receive bonus items when people complain.
I got my box today and it has a $121 value. That’s crazy (yes, I did get the Mally, which I think is fair since I don’t always get the best – ie. I got the horrid $45 glossybox last month). Even without the Mally, your boxes are worth $100. This sub is amazing.
Reply
Crick
Alice I agree with everything you said , we deserve the Mally after the terrible GlossyBox fiasco . I also got :
SuperGoop setting mist spf 50
Cargo (no box )
Eye serum
Purlisse
Mally
Wet brush
Shampoo & conditioner (smells divine !!)
Reply
Jill
Its not about receiving “free stuff”, and it shouldn’t be about receiving expired, left-over items that have been sitting in a warehouse for over a year. This subscription box is to introduce consumers to new and innovative products on the market. Yes, these are only sample products….but it is quite offensive to receive old samples. Samples have a very short shelf life, and they certainly should be fresh and current. Every subscriber deserves nothing less.
Reply
Toni
Well said I agree
Kendall
I think you might be missing the point. There is a big difference between cost and value. For many people, this is just another in a long line of problems in the last few months. They are tired of being misled, treated badly by customer service, and dealing with uncertainty. So yes, many people are fixating on the fact that they got a very low cost item they are unlikely to use (and are very clearly leftovers from previous boxes) when they had been under the assumption that they would get a much higher cost one they were excited about. But that isn’t the only thing they are angry about, it’s just the last straw. And yes, the shampoo and conditioner are very nice, but considering the spoiler about getting them came at the same time they glossed over the variance in products, it can’t be denied that they feel less like “bonuses” and more like consolation prizes. (Also, I highly doubt that what people say here will have any effect, good or bad, on what is put in the box in the future. They are too large of a company, and considering the amount of unanswered BBB complaints lodged against the company, they don’t seem to care too much about subscribers’ grievances. )
Reply
Toni
Got my box today and no I didn’t receive the mally product.I got the Burberry sample and I’m ok with that, would I have liked to try the mally ? yes but I’ll try it at some point I’m sure.I also want to say as tired as I am about black eyeliners I really like this cargo one .And I’m happy they sent us the extra shampoo and conditioner,I’m always happy to try new ones.Cant wait to try the brush ,so all in all I’m happy with my box .ps I also received the cheeper version of the glossy box and canceled my subscription
Reply
Jill
Much to my surprise, I received my box today. No shipping notice at all…and no Mally 🙁
I got the ELF. I am so disappointed. The wet brush is nice. The Cargo liner is just ok b/c its not retractable. The setting mist is nice. The Purlisse is just another moisturizer I will use on my body b/c it breaks out my face. I look forward to trying the eye freeze serum, but it will have to wait considering the tons of eye serums in my stock pile..LOL. And the Whole Blends….no comment. I wanted to try the Pixi face tonic, but oh well. I guess I will experiment with my new Elf brush, and I will get a brightening eye liner elsewhere.
Reply
Latasha
As I expected I got the elf brush. I am done.
Reply
Casey
I got my box today. And I got the ELF brush. I’m not against the brand, I have some ELF products I use. But I did feel like the Mally eye brightener was played up as an item I would be receiving. I’m on the fence about cancelling. I’ve cancelled BB over their point fiasco and picked up Play. Very pleased with that switch. I dropped Ipsy and Boxycharm a year ago and picked this up as my replacement and had been happy. Except I had a broken item in June that took a dozen emails to get sorted out. And CS was so rude. They would state include all previous emails (which I had) and it just got ugly. I guess I will look at September spoilers and go from there. But I’m glad to know I’m in the same boat as others, the switch wasn’t cool.
Reply
Claudia
I picked up my box today. I didn’t get the Mall, just the Burberry which is tiny and I did get it before as a 100 pt sample from Sephora or someplace months ago … maybe in 2014. The brush looks ok but what’s the deal with the shampoo? I feel like the biz has taken a nosedive, I’m still annoyed about that broken Kardashian compact (why the heck does my auto correct recognize Kardashian???). Ewww
Reply
Casey
It took me 6 weeks and dozens of emails to get a replacement for the broken bronzer. They sent me a nice Mally eyeliner but it was a freaking hassle.
Reply
Michelle
Got my box today. I got the Pixie tonic instead of the Mally, which was actually the alternate I wanted if I didn’t get the Mally, but still not happy about getting a substitute period. My biggest problem is how tiny everything is!! Not including the brush(which I don’t care about at all!), I can literally hold everything I received in one hand! So not impressed! I’ve suspended my shipments, we’ll see if they step up their game here. Just going to be happy with my Beauty Fix and Ipsy for now. With the occassional Boxycharm, of course, lol!
Reply
Betty
Yeah, Sephora Play is becoming the better value because the sizes are almost as equivalent to Allure sizes sadely.
Reply
Cindy
Haven’t received a shipping confirmation or my box yet. Only my third box. Might have to cancel and spend my money elsewhere.
Reply
Barbie
I received my notice last week, and actually got the box on Friday. Not without some drama.
My P.O. box number was not on the mailing label so it was going to be returned as undeliverable. Luckily, I checked the delivery status and was able to get someone at the post office to pull the box before it was returned! Emailed customer service to make sure my box number is on all future deliveries, but I haven’t heard back yet. (By the way, the full address with p.o. number is listed when I log into my account…) I think it may have gotten removed when I emailed them to let them know that my mailing & billing addresses are different after receiving confirmation for the last Thrills box.
Anyway, to my surprise, I got the Mally highlighter! But honestly, I was ok with receiving one of the substitutes, just because I really love this sub. The only issues I’ve had is whenever I have to contact customer service. Things go all wonky for a while. So, maybe I should stop doing that! 🙂
Reply
KC
I haven’t received my notice yet, either, so I chatted CS to ask for the shipping status.
The rep essentially told me that she won’t have that info. All she could tell me was that I was a paying customer and would receive a box this month. I’ve been a member since late Jan.
Reply
LisaJean2
Same here. You might want to check your account online – I did a chat with them today (my online account only shows my Beauty Thrills presale info) and my box hasn’t even been pulled for shipping yet. ??? They charged my card 8/3. They told me current subscribers always get their boxes before new ones. The whole chat was just frustrating. If I get the ELF brush I am done.
Reply
Cindy
I looked at my account. I don’t see anywhere on there a out the status of my box. My card was charged on 8/3. Last month. I received both Sephora and this box on the same day… so fingers crossed, I guess.
LisaJean2
Update- Mail just came and my box is here. So much for not even being pulled yet. And I did get the ELF brush. Cancelling today.
Dayan
Got my box without receiving the tracking email first, which is odd to me cuz I always get a tracking email ever since I subbed back in May. ?
Anyway, I got the burberry substitute… Not really happy about it since I really wanna try the mally product (looks interesting) and not to mention the value discrepancy. The sample is 5 ml, worth equal to $8. Well, at least I didn’t get the brush, which I totally wouldn’t have any use for.
Really hope Allure won’t ever pull this trick again in the September or any upcoming boxes. It absolutely sucks to get the short straw ?
Reply
cinnamon
I’m going to give them one more box and then I’m cancelling. Ever since they ousted the original managing editor, the magazine (and everything related to them) has gone downhill fast.
Reply
Brittany
Are we being punished for May’s shortage fiasco?
I did receive a complimentary box from Allure in May since they ran out of the Foreo box… but wow! Very disappointed. I did not subscribed to receive travel size Garnier AND an ELF brush. It’s insulting to everyone who was put through problems the last few months!
Does anyone know how to cancel? Can I do it over live chat? I am not looking to speaking to the representatives directly haha.
Thanks!
Reply
Claudia
I’ve been away on vacation so I don’t know if I’ve received my box it not. I’ve been a subscriber since 2014. I’ve give through their assorted chaos over the years but I’m really feeling like this sub has fallen off. I guess we’re all going to have to quit to encourage them to get back on track!
Reply
Michelle
I subscribed back in July, really hoping for That box but missed out. Needless to say I was less than thrilled when I saw what was coming in this month’s box. Now to see the Mally product being substituted, this is a real dud. The worst is that brush, wow. Too bad…I saw such great reviews for this box, I’ll give it one more month then I might have to cancel.
Reply
Aditi
I got the pixi toner which has a $2 target coupon that expired in Nov 2015!!! Seriously, first not everyone got the Mally, and now they are sending old stuff. I just unsubscribed the box, I would rather not pay $15 for old stuff 🙁
Reply
Trish M.
Aditi- I just looked closer at my Pixi and it’s the same – an expired coupon on the back! Not cool 🙁
Reply
Leah
Not surprising. We got those toners a long time ago. I figured they were extras.
Kristina
I received my box today and I did receive the Mally product. I also got everything else in the picture. This is my second box. I’m not posting to brag, only to let others know that there is hope you may get it and you don’t have to be a long term subscriber.
Reply
Theresa
I got mine today, I’m in NH. I’ve been a subscriber since February and I got the Burberry. Initially, I was very excited about the Mally product but Burberry is a favorite brand of mine so a chance to try it is awesome!!!
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.