Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I still have not received my confirmation email for my June box. Normally I would have gotten that already. Anyone else still waiting for a confirmation/tracking email?
I also tried to email them but for some reason it won’t send it just sends me to FAQ….those aren’t cutting it and I was billed on the 6th.
Reply
Michelle
I’m still waiting for mine too. My credit card was already charged for it too.
Reply
Jennifer Taylor
Me too! I was charged on the 8th, and still haven’t received any kind of email or anything. This was my first box with them, and I’d have to say it will be my last if I ever actually receive it!
Ann
I always get my tracking info on the 13th of the month. Should have it tomorrow.
Reply
christina m
Every single item in my box was different..
Reply
ChereK
By every item, curious about what you got, if you don’t mind my asking?
Thanks!
Reply
Dianne
Its kindof a boring box. Still worth the money. I hope the eyeliner is black. I was hoping for fun colorful eyeshadows or something with a nice clean scent. Pale baby blue nail polish looks ok. I hope next month has color. Ipsy has a nice colorful theme this month with urban decay.
Reply
CT
Just signed up! Happy that they are shipping to Canada now! This box looks amazing and I can’t wait to try everything 🙂
Reply
Mieke
Wasn’t too sad to miss the past two months after I cancelled, but I signed back up for this! I’ll use just about everything.. I’ve been wanting to try a pressed powder, and let’s be honest, I’ll take shimmer and sparkle anything, I’m basically a giant 5 year old. I love masks of all sorts, and Farmacy is something I’ve been wanting to try, and I’ll never complain about a nail polish or eyeliner, especially a new to me brand!
Reply
Patty
Darn you boxycharm I was gonna skip you this month! Then you said shimmer and all my will power flew away never tried anything face from ofra and my current setting powder situation is pretty grim that product alone is the box so if thst liner sucks I’ll get rid of it and not be too worried, the one last month was a disaster for me
Reply
Wanda
I love BoxyCharm. It’s such a greal deal even if you dont like all the products in the box. $21 for over $100 worth of high end products. No other box is doing that . What I don’t like I give away. I am a oily skinned girl in the summer so I am looking forward to the oil absorbing powder
Reply
Marion
This looks like the best BoxyCharm I’ve seen in a while.
Reply
Wendy Sgobbo
If I sign up now is this the first box I would get? I’m obsessed with the Farmacy masks and this one is my favorite. I also really want the free Tarte eyeliner!!
Reply
Liz Cadman
Yes! If you sign up in the month of June, this will be your first box! 🙂
Reply
Halie
The LVX nail polish is the best! I hope everyone gets the light blue color? So excited!!
Reply
Dea
I hope I don’t. Cadaver fingers are this color LOL.
Reply
Lily
Yep, I always associate that shade to a lack of oxygen lol.
Dana
Can’t wait for this box! This will be my third Boxycharm box and it has quickly become a favorite. I can see why some people are tired of getting the same products, BUT you can always give the products that you don’t want as gifts or swap with other people who have other subscriptions. My sister and mother love getting the products that I will not use. I give them a box about once a month because I have other subscriptions and have also put together various products as gifts for birthdays. I highly recommend doing this if you still want to keep the subscription but don’t have any use for all products because the price of the box and the total price of products and brands that you get really make it worth keeping, at least for me 🙂
Reply
L7BG
I’m loving the contents of this box, except for the shimmer powder & the black eyeliner. I wish it were a different color, but I’ll give it to my daughter who uses black. I wonder how shimmery the shimmer powder is? I’ll probably end up giving that to her as well. Good thing we share our boxes. 🙂
Reply
ChereK
I love ORFA, but I don’t know why, but have become shifted from oily/combination to dry skin… I like the box… just wish it was not oil control. … I am in the South and still have been using heavy heavy duty creams! Sooo looking forward to those mask! The first ones! I’m lazy when it comes to those.. lol!
Liquid eyeliners don’t work for me… it would have been fun to have had a choice between the gift of the Tarte eyeliner they are giving to new subs and the liquid. .. just a passing thought. ..
Reply
Katherine
I’m loving this month. Idk about everyone else but ofra has been an amazing discovery for me in subscription box world. I absolutely love their matte lipsticks. The staying power is awesome & the colors are very much to my taste. Looks like I’ll be going on an Ofra lipstick swapping spree ?
Reply
Mandy
I agree. I love ofra ever since I received my first liquid lipstick ( in Pasadena) now I am hoooked. I own about 19 now…. But thanks to subscription boxes and coupon codes I have never paid full price ?
Reply
Toni
Why does this site keep saying I.m making a duplicate reply
Toni
Me too about the liquid lipstick in Pasadena
MzBev
I agree! I see many complain about “another Ofra item” but I have discovered I really love everything I’ve tried from them! I have quite of a few of their liquid lipsticks now.
Reply
Carla
4/5 is not bad. I’m a little overloaded on nail polish right now but that’s my fault, not BoxyCharm’s.
Survey question: if BoxyCharm let you opt out of two items so you never received them again, what would you pick? For be it would be perfume and eyeliner (esp black eyeliner).
Reply
Jenn
Bronzer and lipstick, followed closely by mascara
Reply
ChereK
Definitely Black eyeliner in all forms! (I think that might count as 2?)
Reply
Toni
Black eyeliner and b,ack eyeliner
Reply
Lauren
I hate receiving nail polish it ends up turning me off to the entire box. So for me yet another mint green nail polish ugh.
Reply
Jess R
I’d opt out of nail polish and eyeliner for sure. For all of my sub boxes haha.
Reply
MzBev
I’d pick anything brow related and blush.
Reply
Lacey
Not as thrilled about this box. I do want the Ofra powder, but everything else…not really. We just got an eyeliner and nail polish in the last box. Oh, well, not every box can knock it out of the park. 🙂
Reply
Sarah
Someone posted an Unboxing for this box yesterday and I immediately went to cancel my subscription. I’ve been toying with the idea for awhile. They boxes have been less than desirable and for the second month in a row my box mysteriously never made it to my door step.
Reply
Sara
Thank god I didn’t sign up, I don’t want shimmer powder, I wanted just setting powder. Looks like a pretty good box though!
Reply
Ann
Love it!
Reply
Lynn
I love Boxycharm. This is just personal preference, but I feel like I’ve been on nail polish overload with boxes lately! I rarely wear it.
Reply
Barbie
Urrgg! Just yesterday I resolved that when my 3 month sub runs out in Aug, I was gonna cancel. Yea, that’s happening now. Boxycharm, I can’t quit you!
Loving the shimmer powder and the mask (come on, THREE of them?!?!?) Their boxes always rock!
Reply
Liz Cadman
SO excited about the masks! I’ve loved every Farmacy product I’ve tried so far! 🙂
Reply
ChereK
Hey! Positive thing is — it’s still pretty great that they can get all of this for us for $21 per month!!
One of the only beauty boxes I have not dropped! And I think that if we keep giving them our input, they will respond. ..
Cheree
Typically, I am too lazy for them… But I am loving the sound of these!
Sherry
I’m sure a lot of people will like this box, it’s a step up from some of the recent boxes but I am still glad I cancelled. So over Ofra and I won’t use the press powder since I have very dry skin. Already have that polish and eye liner ( not the best liner). I won’t use the face/ shimmer. The only thing I would like would be the face mask but that isn’t worth $21 to me.
Reply
Teresa
I second that. I signed up for Boxycharm and was the recipient of the the couple of crummy boxes. This looks like a better box but with the product being an oil control product and a powder this isn’t a box for us dry skin girls. Not an inspired box I’ve already received a similar color of nail polish from Julep and other box and the eyeliner I don’t know how many times from a number of different boxes.
The mask would great but not as the only product in the box. Never sad that I canceled this subscription.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.