What Subscription Boxes Do You Want to See Us Review in 2016?

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.


I’d love your help! Please let me know in the comments what subscription boxes you’d like to see reviewed on My Subscription Addiction! This can include boxes we haven’t reviewed yet, boxes we haven’t reviewed in awhile, or even just a genre of boxes you’d like to see more reviews for!

Thanks for your help!!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in Subscription Box News| 149 comments


  1. more votes for 5 Wacky Women and Beekman!

  2. Faithbox, Little Lace Box/Serendipity, and My Ireland Box. I also like the idea someone mentioned of just having people who get certain boxes that aren’t reviewed send in pictures and list of items. Oh, and the Beekman 1802 boxes would be good to see what is in them, too. I really like the products I’ve tried but not sure if a box of only their products would be good or not.

  3. I’ll add my voice to the chorus wanting more kbeauty box reviews. Big time!!! I’ve been wanting to learn more about kbeauty for years, but the closest I ever came was looking at Memebox and being confused/overwhelmed by all of the unknown brands and products. :-/ But MaryJane and Mandy made good points about the special knowledge required to properly review those products.

    If there are any more home decor boxes out there, that’d be great.

  4. Retro Pop Box, I have a 3 month sub on the 70’s version. I’d like some feedback /advice on keeping it beyond the 3 months. It’s a new box & I’m an old hippy at heart so I may be biased in my opinions about the boxes. Thanks for the great job you’re doing to keep us all informed!

  5. I haven’t seen a review for Hammock Pack lately (or maybe I just missed it!). I’d also like to see reviews for FanMail, Fandom of the Month, Gamer Girl Monthly, and Box of Dread.

    • I like ALL of Carrie’s suggestions. These are all boxes I am interested in as well. I miss your Hammock Pack reviews!

  6. I would like to see LLB get another chance here. I understand sone people had issues but there are other major boxes where people have any just as many if not more issues as well. Just my thought.. Also, would LOVE reviews of k-beauty but I agree it would take some extra investigating and maybe recruiting someone with more k-beauty experience. I’m just intrigued with all of it! Also, I would love more reviews of cheaper beauty boxes like lip monthly or beauty box 5 once in awhile. Sometimes I get emails and they seem so cheap that I wonder if it’s worth it or if it’s a total waste of time. Thanks for everything though Liz, happy with all your reviews!

  7. The Kinder Box!

  8. I think a review on Faithbox would be awesome! I’ve really enjoy this box and I’m sure many others would too.

  9. Erin Mcdermott jewelry the luxe box.

  10. Tokidoki blind boxes (i.e., Barbie especially, Hello Kitty), Memebox, Kawaii box, K-beauty boxes.?

    • I could help you out with the Kawaii-ish boxes if you need a reviewer. I’ve been starting to get these for my daughter. 🙂 I used to be part of two large group blogs where I produced a lot of content and reviews and I miss it.

      • I just signed up for the Pusheen box. Do you know of any other subs that are authorized and licensed dealers? Looking for Sanrio products. Some of the Kawaii boxes looks like low quality knock off products.

  11. I love learning about new boxes from you! I’ve signed up for Mighty Fix and Elizabeth and Clarke because of your reviews. I don’t have a specific one I’d like to see, but if you try it and like it…I wanna know about it!

  12. I would love to be a reviewer. I used to work for a tech magazine and did monthly reviews for them for a few years. Let me know if you need some help. I also have a husband that used to be a chef, fancy chef school, fancy restaurant ( whose specialties are French and Italian ) and is now a personal trainer / amateur gardener. I would love to help review something along those lines, fitness, cooking / snacking ( I love to eat ) or gardening.

  13. the iPenBox and Ink Drop (Goulet Pens). Anything pen or ink related.

  14. I’d love to see Lindsey review the Beekman 1802 Specialty Food Box and you review their Beauty Box.

    And I’d really really LOVE to see you review another MSA box… (hoping that you’ll do another box or collaboration this year – I discovered MSA too late to get one for myself).

  15. The baby guy box

    • Lil pnuts box (from New Orleans)

  16. Luxor petite !!! I never know what’s in that one but always want to know?

    • I so agree! I did suck it up and get the full size box but would love to know what is in the petite version!

      • Lucky you!!! I would love to get the normal box! Their boxes always look so amazing!

  17. Kawaii box, Doki Doki crate, cute things, gamer or nerd related.

  18. Yes on planner and stationary subscriptions. As with Kbeauty subs, no offense Liz, but I would rather read reviews from someone who does their research on the ingredients. This is because Kbeauty has a lot of unusual products and I know Liz does not have the time to thoroughly investigate the ingredients and/or translate it into English as most of the packaging is written in Korean. Also, most of the time the info card (if any) does not list the full ingredient list. This is why I subscribe to blogs who devote their blog entirely on Kbeauty.

    • Oh, I agree on the Korean beauty boxes and products. There are just so many brands and products and when I lived there for a few years it was fun to try a lot of them out. However, some of my coworkers would warn me about certain brands(especially the lesser known ones) that were either made with much lower quality products or made with fake ingredients all together. So someone pretty knowledgeable and with a better grasp of Hangul (Korean writing) would be a great resource.

    • Could you give me the name of a Korean beauty blog site? Love Korean beauty products but would like to get them reviewed before purchase!

        • Yup, Fiddy Snails is my number one pick.

      • You can try Fanserviced-B or Beautyfindsforme – both ladies are current on the K beauty trends and do thorough research on ingredients and brands.

      • Why are my comments with links deleted? None of them are affiliate links – just blogs!! Thanks.

        • Not deleted. Any comment with a link has to be approved first by admin for spam reasons. Everything should be appearing now. Thanks and sorry for any confusion! 🙂

  19. Love + Blessed (loved it when you did those), Messy Box, Planner Addict, fitness boxes!!!

  20. I would love to see you review that Disney box that came out not so long ago.

    • Are you talking about the Tsum Tsums? If so, if you check my profile pic it is the image of their most recent (3rd box).

      Each of their boxes come packaged like that. If you curious about what has already been sent out: Spoilers ahead for rest of post

      1st box – Mickey with mini old school Mickey
      2nd box – Minnie with a mini Minnie

  21. I wish that for pet boxes, you would show the big dog options (like are already reviewed for Nyx) but also for smaller dogs. It’s really frustrating to have all these dog boxes reviewed but only know of what the content would be for my small dog in one box – BarkBox, because that’s the one you get for Buckles. I understand the initial need was to have boxes shown for bigger dogs also but now it seems to have gone the complete opposite way.

    How about giving Social Bliss Style Box another shot? I’m also intrigued by all of these sock boxes, more of the crafty ones, and some of the indie nail polish boxes!

  22. K beauty is something I would love to see! So many unusual products that other people would not know about without your help! 3b, memebox, mishibox, beauteque, meikoko BCDATION box. There’s quite a bunch <3

  23. I would love to see reviews for home decor them boxes (if there are any.)

  24. I gifted my tea-loving girlfriend The Cozy Mug subscription box and she LOVES it! I’d like to see reviews of this cool box ~

  25. Lookfantastic Beauty Box! Ive been getting it for over a year now and I’m absolutely shocked you don’t review it! They consistently send out quality and higher end brands in their boxes and the sizes are always generous, often full size items! Not to mention, they do free worldwide shipping! It’s definitely my favorite beauty box.

  26. Rent the Runway unlimited because I just joined! Also, outdoor themed boxes. I’ve seen a couple on here and they looked great but it was only 1 or 2 boxes and I like to see a couple months before joining. Shoe subscriptions haven’t been reviewed much either. It would be nice to know of different companies than JustFab and Shoedazzle.

  27. All those sound great, but I would love to try k-beauty boxes ?

  28. There’s a box called Out of The Box that’s a bunch (and I do mean a lot!) of samples from Etsy sellers. The value is more a matter of introducing you to new Etsy stores than anything else, but I’d love your opinion on it at least a few times, if not monthly. I also second the vote for more K-beauty boxes like Beauteque and 3B.

  29. I would love to see more reviews of scented candle boxes (Flicker and Flame, Frosted Candle Company Etsy Tart Box, etc.) and Mommy Mailbox.

  30. I would love to see you review the Rainbow Honey mystery bags. 🙂 They’ve added a few different kinds!

  31. I would love to see an Enclothe Boutique review and of course Golden Tote!!

  32. Th luxe box and the grapevine box!

    • Also Norsebox

  33. I love reviews of craft boxes, but they’re tough because a good review shows a finished project! Or at least the items in use.

    • I agree, it would be nice to see someone who gets craft boxes and completes the projects.

      Also Norsebox, Kairos, the Beekman box and Bonjour Jolie. And whatever Lindsey feels like reviewing, because she’s awesome.

      • Seconded for Bonjour Jolie or other TOM boxes!

  34. I would love to see trunk club!

  35. Mommy Mailbox and the Fashion Able Monthly Maker’s box!

  36. Recent subs for me that I would like to see reviewed are White Willow, 5 Wacky Women (what I have seen/received of these two I’ve really liked so far), and Adult Color Box. I believe that all 3 of these are pretty new. Crate Joy has a TON of new boxes. And whatever happened to BabeBox??

  37. Simon Says Stamp Card Kit, other scrapbook/card kits. I really like the cat box reviews.

  38. Planner Addict Box! Also some more of the outdoor themed ones along the lines of Cairn, which is one of my favorites. 🙂

  39. I love the PopSugar reviews, Ipsy, Birchbox, but I would love to see more food oriented boxes. Specifically Love with Food and Munchpak!

  40. Personally, I would like the kbeauty boxes, like Beautiquebox, Mishibox or Memebox or 3bbox reviewed. Also, I like geeky boxes like Fanmail box, fanspirations, fan empire and fandom of the month club. On the same note, why not the jewelry box, flitwicks box.

  41. i only saw one review on the candle boxes =( so there is nothing to compare it to =)

    Box of Radiance

    Flicker and Flame

    Frosted Candle Company Etsy Tart Box

    • My Ireland Box =)

  42. Often times you get spoiler pics to post from the first person to get a highly sought after box. It would be nice if people who get obscure boxes or just ones you don’t review could send in a pic of the contents to you and you could post. So not really a review but hey readers FYI this is what’s comes in this lesser known box. So it would just be the picture and a list of the items. That way you don’t have to do a million reviews but we may hear about some cool other box. Does this even make sense?!?!?!

    • Love it. Great idea! And it totally made sense ?

    • Yes, made complete sense. It’s like what she did with the Winter Pusheen Box (seeing the spring spoiler reminded me of it) – no one reviewed it, but she posted pics.

    • Yes, I love this idea too!

    • I really like this idea!

  43. Natural and organic beauty. Boxes that feature small batch products and products from smaller retailers.

  44. Ooh I second the fitness boxes!

    • Looks like we need a fitness box reviewer! 🙂

      • How does someone become a reviewer?

  45. I would LOVE workout/fitness boxes. I’m a weightlifter and I’ve come across some boxes that would be great for goodies with healthy and fueling snacks and to help before/after workouts, but I haven’t committed because I don’t know what to expect. Just would love reviews on a broader range of the fitness/health boxes out there!

  46. I would love to see Front Door Fashion reviewed!

    More vegan boxes would be great as well, especially if there’s a meal delivery option (like Plated). The only one I know of is Purple Carrot.

    Thanks for all the amazing work you do with this site and consideration you show to your audience!

  47. I was wondering what happened to the LLB reviews.

    • The LLB owners are….special.

      • Intriguing response.

    • Yes! I love LLB and their Serendipity box! I’ve been looking for the review for this month but can’t find it!

      • MSA stopped reviewing LLB after some issues came up. You can read about it in the comments section of the last box review (March? April?).

  48. Earths healing box

  49. More self help and healthy living. Also boxes like goddess provisions, sapphire soul, weevolve etc.

    • Agree!! These listed and any more spiritually based boxes – not religious- spiritual!

  50. I’d love to see more fitness boxes reviewed. I know there are more out there.. would like some insight into more options..

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!