Posted by on in Cyber Monday Deals | 49 comments

Too Faced Cyber Monday Mystery Box!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Too Faced

UPDATE: Sold out! πŸ™

Thank you Amanda, Brittany, and Brandy for letting us know about this offer! You can get a Too Faced Mystery Makeup Box for $35 – with a guaranteed value of $165! (Plus free standard shipping on all orders!)

UPDATE: Use coupon code OWNIT to get this free set with your order:

Own It

(Thanks Lily!)

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. There will be one for cyber Monday! It’s $39 and will have a value of $137. Sale starts on the site at 12:01pst and 3:01est. Already got my alarm set!

    • Yesss! Thank you, thank you, thank you!!!

  2. Any word on a 2015 mystery box?

    • I really hope so! I want another one more than any other Black Friday/Cyber Monday deal! I posted on the Too Faced FB page and they haven’t commented.

      • I am hoping for another one this year too.

  3. I got my box yesterday and this was probably my favorite black Friday mystery purchase I made ( Bijoux, Mally, Too Faced) The brushes are soooo soft! I I got the lip cream in cinnamon kiss. I LOVE it! I also got a sample gloss in Sex Pot and the black eye liner I just really enjoyed all of the items in this box and I think the pink tin is very cute as well. I will for sure keep my eye out for this type of mystery purchase again.

  4. I got mine two days ago! This is what’s in it….

    Smokey eye palette
    Mini better than sex mascara
    Mini la creme lipstick in believe
    Chocolate Soleil bronzer
    A set of 5 brushes

    I am excited about it! πŸ™‚ it’s a great value!

    • The lipstick color is gorgeous and the brushes are amazing, by the way! The brushes are so soft but hold eyeshadow so well! They’re not the set listed on their website fyi.

    • I have 2 of those mascaras already. Good thing I like it. (But I still have more Benefit “They’re Real” mascara minis.)

      Won’t be using the bronzer (have some of that too, way too dark for me). But I’m excited about everything else.

    • Thank you for posting the box contents! I got the OWNIT code to work so it sounds like I’ve got a couple bronzers in my future!

    • Coorection: *full sized la creme lipstick!

      • *correction haha

  5. Just got this email:

    Thank you for your order. Due to high demand, there will be a delay in shipping the Mystery Box to you. You will receive the package before the Holiday’s. We apologize for the delay. Please let me know if you have any questions.

    I guess that at least means my order isn’t canceled!

    • Follow up about my order being cancelled.

      I’m happy to report that I received the following email from Too Faced:

      “Great News! We are assembling new mystery boxes to fulfill your previous order. If you are still interested in receiving the mystery box, please provide us with the following information. Time is of the essence so please respond to us before December 12th to complete your order.”

      I’m happy they stepped up and corrected their mistake. Hopefully in the future they will have a better system in place so that customers like me don’t have to go through the disappointment and frustration I’ve dealt with for 2 days.

      One positive thing I can say is that the Customer Relations Coordinator that I have been communicating with, Vanessa, has been very professional, courteous and provided excellent customer care.

  6. Too bad this sold out. If it makes anyone feel better, this looks like it’s the “sweet indulgence” tin set from 2012, so some of you may already own it. Sneaky of Too Faced to make it look like a box of goodies when it’s the gift set from 2 years ago. I could be wrong, but I’m betting that’s exactly what it is.

    • I Googled that set and it shows it was $52 with a $381 value. I’d be happy with that.

      • I have almost no Too Faced stuff (maybe one sample lip primer and a small mascara) so I’d be fine with that, too.

    • I looked up that palette – the Amazon link I found the Sweet Indulgence tin had a “value” of 381$ so I’m hopeful we’re not getting antique makeup sent πŸ™‚

    • Oh, don’t get me wrong, it’s an amazing set, and so worth the money. My point is that it may be disappointing for someone like myself who already owns it. Of course, it could be something entirely different! It is a mystery afterall πŸ™‚ Lisa, be sure to post it once you get it so we can see what’s inside!

  7. I just got an e-mail from them. My order is not canceled, but there will be a delay in shipping due to high demand. Oh well, I’ve got a ton of beauty products here now (massive Ulta order where I really piled on the GWPs) to keep me busy until this comes. And the rest of my Black Friday and Cyber Monday spoils are still to come.

  8. This looked interesting, It’s a shame that it was out of stock before I even saw that it was a thing! I own many TooFaced pallets and I adore them. That being said I always buy them from a third party like Ulta or Sephora, so I have not experienced the crappy customer service. They must have had a tiny stock of these if they sold out by 7am! woah! I still don’t know if I would have bought it either way, I couldn’t really tell how big it was and the fact that it was a “mystery box” means that I can’t see what sort of shades it had in it. Since I own so many of their pallets already I wouldn’t want to have a bunch of repeat colors, So I’m not too put out that they sold out. I just hope someone does a review of it so I can get a peek at the inside. πŸ™‚

  9. I didn’t realize shipping was free and that the cost would disappear. It wasn’t showing that when I bought it (3:44 EST) but I found a free shipping code online. And at least I was able to get it. I guess that’s one perk of working night shift. I come home early.

    • LOL! I mean I come home in the early morning. So I’m awake to browse websites that launch things after midnight.

  10. I had ordered around 7am CST and it went through fine, or at least I have not seen a Cancelled email.

    However, that is terrible customer service. I was able to add something to my cart for Black Friday but on Thursday night, from Ulta, and later got this email which is IMO great customer service.

    “Due to extremely high demand for our popular Black Friday deals, we are out of stock on one or more of the items that you ordered. Unfortunately, we discovered this situation only after we had confirmed your order. Currently, we are processing the in-stock portion of your order for shipment. When your order ships, we will send you an email notification that includes the contents of the order and a delivery tracking number. Please note that you will not be charged for any out of stock item.

    We apologize for the inconvenience. Because we appreciate your business, please accept this $20 e-gift card valid on any online or in-store purchase at ULTA. “

    • I ordered at about 9AM Eastern and my order has not been canceled. (Same with Mally. And Beauty Bar. I was BAD yesterday.) I keep checking just to be sure, after reading all the comments here. I think I’ll go check again…

    • Wow, that’s awesome that they gave you a gift card for your trouble!

  11. Placed mine this morning too. And just got an email they oversold. I was so excited this is a huge disappointment and really bad customer service. They could have at least offered a coupon or discount or something!

    • REALLY BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE/CARE!! For such a large company to not have a better handle on their website and then punish the customer for their mistake is really…crappy!

  12. I placed my order before 9am & payment was taken almost immediately. Just got an email that they oversold and are canceling my order! EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED!!! I picked this sale over others just to have it cancelled. This would have been my first time trying TOO FACED, not a very good first impression.

    • 9AM what time zone?

      • Eastern. They said it sold out by 7am PST. So my order should be good since it went thru by 6am PST.


        First and Last order!

  13. I was so excited to get one this morning, but sad I missed out on the ownit code. I’m still glad I was able to get it as half of what I was trying to get lately was out of stock after I ordered it.

  14. I missed out on the own it code, but I am really excited about this bag. I am glad I was able to snag one early this morning.

  15. I ordered mine last night and missed all these codes but am still excited to get the box. Last year’s was fabulous. Hope this one is great too!

  16. Thanks for the tip and the code! I got one!

  17. Sold out πŸ™

  18. Nooooooo it’s sold outttt. So sad. πŸ™

  19. Already out of stock :(((((

  20. I just ordered and received free shipping, 2 samples and the Glow to Go. Thank you all for the ordering tips!

  21. I can’t seem to order. Anyone else having problems? Help!

    • Ugh, same thing happened to me. So not cool!

  22. Entered PayPal info and hit submit and they took it out of my bag πŸ™

    • Same thing just happened to me!

  23. sold out πŸ™

  24. I am upset because I had one in my cart and was still looking around…went to check out and it is gone! And now they are sold out!

  25. Code worked, thank you! It gave me a free Sunbunny bronzed with brush! Once I also selected my two free samples, I suddenly got free shipping! It’s a great deal!

    • Hi, I ordered around the same time as you and they canceled my order this afternoon. Did they cancel yours?

      Thanks, Lisa

  26. Code CANTRESIST works for free shipping!

  27. Code ” ownit ” can be used with this beauty bag for more freebies! GLOW TO GO

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!