Posted by on in Subscription Box Spoilers | 34 comments

September BoxyCharm Spoilers!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

September 2014 BoxyCharm Spoilers!

We have three spoilers for the September 2014 Boxycharm box:

September BoxyCharm Spoilers


Each box will include:

1 shade of tarte’s LipSurgence Lip Gloss, 1 Coastal Scents Go Palette, 1 shade of NCLA’s Runway Collection Nail Lacquer, and TWO surprise items!

I don’t know how they do it – this box looks amazing! What do you think of the spoilers?


Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. this one could not be more of a disappointment. Ive tried the tarte glosses and hate them, they arent opaque dont last long smear absolutely everywhere and arent even moisturizing. they look like cheap lipstick that has already faded off right after applying them. the coastal scents palettes are ok, i mean they do produce out of the same factories as morphe so they arent high quality by any means but they are easily workable for a non pro. but they are only 5$ full priced so even if they were amazing quality it doesnt add much to the box value. and the nail polish is only going to be ok for me in one color. like, normally when i dont like things in the box im still hapopy because i have gifts for friends but i’m going to have a REALLY hard time giving away all of these things. and considering what boxycharm has been delivering lately and what theyve teased us with for the future this is a total and complete bust so far. those other two items are going to have to be darn good to make up for things…

  2. Hi I want to subscribe to boxycharm and I would like to know how they personalize each beauty bag ? With a quiz like ipsy? Thanks

    • Comment

    • Hi. Boxycharm is not personalized. They send great items every month though. I really love every box I get from them. Try it out …although they currently have a waiting list.

  3. This month’s ipsy was great but boxycharm never disappoints!!!!!! My favorite sub!

    Btw a few days ago boxycharm had to start a wait list. The last two boxes were total sell outs!

  4. They just posted on their facebook page that they are about to sell out of the September box. So, if you are on the fence I would go for it asap. This box looks awesome and BoxyCharm is my favorite beauty sub. Get one today before they sell out.

  5. I have been trying to resist this subscription for a while but finally gave up. Just subscribed!

  6. *sigh* The spoilers on this were too good! I need an eye shadow palette like one of those and I’ve been wanting to try Tarte products. Those two things alone make this a total win. So many September boxes for me, gah! [Birchbox, Popsugar Must Have, your MSA Quarterly box, and now Boxycharm] I’ll be temporarily broke but have lots of products. 🙂

  7. I watched a YouTube video where they already got their September box and saw the 2 other items. This box does not disappoint!

    • Thanks Hilda. The other 2 items are awesom! I just signed in (it will be my 7th box in September! !!) And I will cancel ipsy in a minute. My first ( and last) 2 bags were disappointment. I wanted to give them 2-3 more months, but too many really good boxes out there to waist money on ipsy)

      • I’m getting ready to cancel my Ipsy and Birchbox and just stick with Boxycharm. I have subscribed since June and they have all been great boxes in my opinion.

    • Thanks Hilda. I have looked online and can’t find the info on the other 2 items. Can you tell me what they are? Thanks!

        • That was a fun video to watch. I may buy this box and be prepared for the fall. I was hoping for a fall palette in the Popsugar LE 🙁

  8. Just cancelled my Ispy and Julep subscriptions and subscribed to this instead. Looks very promising. (MUCH better brands than Ipsy which has been nothing but a disappointment, and Julep was fine but the novelty has worn off and I now have more of those polishes than I could ever possibly use…) Thank you for the heads up!

  9. Does anyone know if Boxycharm personalizes boxes per customer profiles, like Ipsy, Birchbox, etc.? I can’t find anything about that on their site.

    • I don’t think they do honestly. I just signed up yesterday and looked everywhere so I could enter my preferences. You get amazing items from what I have seen from the last years box…but you just never know what colors you will get. I think everyone gets the same items.

    • They do not customize. Everyone gets the same product, with slight color variation.

      • Thanks for the information! Probably not worth the gamble for me, in that case, though the value of this box looks great.

  10. NEED MONEY!!!! lol
    I would need two cause my sister would steal the eyeshadow and lipgloss. If I signed up later in the month would I get this box or October’s?

    • Most of the time as long as you sign up in September you will get the September box. However, they have been known to sell out mid to late month and then you wouldn’t be able to get it. If you follow them or like them on Facebook, you will get more up to date updates on how many boxes are available and when the last day to get them is. They are active on Facebook.

  11. Well, that was a no brainer! I just canceled Birchbox and Graze to get this. I’ve been on the fence w/BB for awhile but was being lazy. This looks so much better. So excited to get this!

  12. These spoilers look amazing! I love the palettes and the lip gloss, the nail polish I’m not wild about but hope I get the red one. I love Boxycharm, it will be my 4th month with it and it’s my favorite subscription.

  13. I have been holding off on BoxyCharm but this sold me. Just signed up for a sub with them. The eye palette looks pretty fabulous and I love Tarte!

    • Me too – Tarte = the best!

  14. Ah man! I have to buy this subscription now too 😉 honestly, I probably spend about $25 a month on cosmetics and things and this box looks like a killer value!!! I’m going to cancel the Julep box (the past two months they have completely messed up my orders) and get this one instead! I was super excited the septmber box was still available!!! Does anyone know how the shipping is of these boxes? Like what date range to expect it?

    • Im on the east coast and I get mine between the 9th and the 11th. I know they ship in few batches and the first one usually goes out around the 5th. I love my Boxycharm. They post everything on their FB page.

    • I know right!! If you look at her past boxes and even on YouTube the boxes usually have between $60-95 dollar value!!

  15. Not so sure about the nail colors, but the other stuff looks great! I’m generally not a fan of lip glosses (too sticky) but love Tarte, so hoping this one will be an exception!

  16. I’m also thrilled about this box. I caught the spoilers on Instagram and each one was better than the last. Fingers crossed I don’t get the red polish since we just got the Lauren B. I was thinking maybe they would only give the red to new subscribers?

  17. Boxycharm never lets me down (with the exception that I get too much nail polish from them)… Such a great box!

  18. Just signed up!! Great value. And considering the lack of palettes in all the fall boxes I was hoping for, this will make up for it!!!

  19. I wish I used makeup, If I did I would be getting this box – I keep hoping they will ad a few beauty / bath products. If they did I would sign up immediately.

  20. I love these spoilers, this box looks as good as last month. I cannot wait to receive this one. I will be happy with any color or shade I get for these items. I wonder what the surprise items are going to be and if they will be full size also……

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!