New Beauty Test Tube Subscription Box Review – March 2014

ByLiz CadmanDec 31, 2014 | 73 comments

New Beauty Test Tube Subscription Box Review - March 2014 Review

New Beauty Test Tube is a bi-monthly beauty and makeup subscription box. Every other month they send you a tube full of deluxe and full size beauty samples, a Beauty To-Go bonus sample pack, and you also get a subscription to New Beauty Magazine. It's a little pricier than other beauty subscriptions, but in general the value is usually incredible. (FYI - this is a different subscription from the QVC New Beauty Test Tube which ships every quarter).

New Beauty Test Tube Subscription Box Review - March 2014 Items

The Subscription Box: New Beauty Test Tube

The Cost: $29.95 a box plus $8.95 shipping (ships every other month)

The Products: Deluxe and full size beauty products. (This subscription also includes a subscription to New Beauty Magazine).

Ships to: US only

Check out all my New Beauty Test Tube reviews, and the Beauty Subscription Box Directory

New Beauty Test Tube Subscription Box Review - March 2014 Samples

In addition to the "tube" of beauty products that each subscriber gets, there's also a New Beauty Beauty To-Go pack that varies by box. My Beauty To-Go Samples included:

Rodial Stemcell Super-Food Facial Oil - 1ml Value $2.50

Phytolisse Perfect Smoothing Shampoo - 1.7 oz Value $4.80

Hydroxatone Instant Wrinkle Filler - 1 oz (FULL SIZE! Value $80!)

Glymed Plus Intense Peptide Skin Recovery Complex - .125 oz Value $10.25

Now on to the main products!

New Beauty Test Tube Subscription Box Review - March 2014 Info

Each New Beauty Test Tube comes with a booklet thoroughly detailing each product included.

New Beauty Test Tube Subscription Box Review - March 2014 Glam Glow

Glam Glow YouthMud Tingle Exfoliate Treatment – .5 oz Value $19

Grandelash MD Grande Mascara - Deluxe Sample Value $10

I just got this Glam Glow YouthMud in my Love Lula Beauty Box and I love it. I'm so happy to have another sample!

New Beauty Test Tube Subscription Box Review - March 2014 Tarte

Tarte Amazonian Clay 12 Hour Blush in Forever Flushed - FULL SIZE! Value $25

YBF Perfect Prep Face Primer - .5 oz Value $10

I absolutely love Tarte products, so I was thrilled to discover this blush in the New Beauty Test Tube! (Their makeup is formulated without parabens, phthalates, etc. and it works great too). Subscribers will either get this shade or Naturally Sunkissed - a bronzer.

New Beauty Test Tube Subscription Box Review - March 2014 Simple

Bioxidea Miracle 48 Mask in Gold - Value $25

Simple Cleansing Facial Wipes - 7 wipes Value $1.50

These Bioxidea Miracle Masks seem to be in every subscription box lately! I guess it's time to finally try one!

New Beauty Test Tube Subscription Box Review - March 2014 Hope in A Jar

Professional Solutions Triple Action Vitamin C Antioxidant - FULL SIZE! Value $40

It's a 10 Miracle Leave In Lite - 2 oz Value $9

Philosophy Hope in A Jar - .4 oz Value $8

This Professional Solutions serum is new to me, but I'm excited to try it, and I love that the sent a full size version! (One of my biggest pet peeves with skincare samples in subscription boxes is when companies send out tiny samples that won't last you long enough to see if the product works for you!)

Verdict: I am so happy with the March New Beauty Test Tube! Based on the last two boxes I was worried this box was turning into a drugstore brand box, but the brands included this month are exactly what I want from New Beauty Test Tube! And the value this month was amazing as well - $150 worth of products in the tube, and I lucked out and got another $100 worth of samples in the Beauty To-Go bag! Definitely worth the $39 I paid - plus I love the magazine that comes with this subscription.

What did you think of the New Beauty Test Tube this month? And which Beauty To-Go samples did you get in your box?

Posted in Beauty Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Read More By Liz Cadman >

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Notify me of follow-up comments by email

73 comments

Judy

I just cancelled my subscription. I’m not going to deal with a company that says one thing in an email and than says another thing when you call them. I also won’t deal with a company that does not replace broken items which is what happened here. I was promised by email a replacement. Now I read that if you call them they say they don’t replace broken items. Which is it Test Tube? Also disappointed that my test tube was not what was pictured above. Not even close.

Renee

I thought I was the only one dealing with this problem. I used to love this test tube and was so excited to open but now its boring and not what it used to be. I think we are getting next to nothing before we would get lot’s of stuff full size things and now its junk. Also, I did not receive my full size lotion value $40 on the last tube and I called and talked to a “live” person she was very friendly and said I should receive in about 3 to 4 weeks, well guess what? Nothing ever came. I am not renewing my subscription. I have now been getting “POP Sugar Must Have” and love it.

Jess

My tube was similar, except I got the Tarte oil roller, which was totally shattered and had leaked all over the contents of the tube. (I’m pretty sure the heavy nail polish bottle in the tube collided with it during transit – the oil was in a little piece of bubble wrap but the polish was loose.) New Beauty’s customer support leaves something to be desired, they were somewhat rude and a replacement item still hasn’t arrived.

These tubes used to be awesome, not sure if they’re worth the money (and hassle) anymore.

Judy

Well after waiting over a month for the Tarte pure maracuja oil replacement it did finally arrive. So if customer service told you they would not replace broken items they are wrong. I emailed shortly after I received the March test tube about this and they said they would send a replacement. I had given up on them and canceled my subscription but I’m happy to say that although it took over a month they did send a replacement as they said they would. I will see what the April test tube looks like and than I am sign up again. Although what one person gets is not always what another will get. I found that out with the March test tube.

Trish

Do you have any recommendations on the best way to contact them about this? My oil arrived totally shattered also. The glass didn’t stay contained in the bubble wrap, so all of my items were covered in oil and shards of glass. Needless to say, that was not a very fun unboxing! It also said that I should have a mascara in there, but there wasn’t one. I e-mailed them about this and I still haven’t heard anything back.

Jess

I called them, thinking it would be better to speak to someone in person. The woman I spoke with made it very clear they would not replace any of the other items, even if they were covered in oil (the oil had soaked all the way under the cap of the nail polish bottle, which they refused to replace.) They did agree to replace the mascara, but only after I made a big production about feeling unsafe using contaminated eye makeup. It’s been almost 3 weeks and the replacements haven’t arrived, I’m starting to think they just blew me off. The level of customer service is seriously lacking considering the price of this subscription. I’m canceling as soon as I get this resolved.

That really sucks about the broken glass, I guess I was lucky mine stayed in the bubble wrap. I would call them (especially if they haven’t responded to email) I hope you get better service than I did.

Brandy

This is the 1st Test Tube I’ve signed up for and so far haven’t received it. I signed up on March 5th. This past weekend I contacted New Beauty and they located my tracking. My New Beauty Test Tube was shipped out on 3/12 and is still in the hands of FedEx as of this afternoon on 3/18. They are using FedEx SmartPost. It’s been 12 hours since it departed Chicago to either go to another FedEx sort center or hopefully the Post Office in my town that’s less than 2 hours from Chicago. The tracking doesn’t even say where it’s headed.

For the $10 shipping fee, they could have sent it straight through the Post Office. We should not have to pay shipping and due to this experience, I don’t think I’ll keep this subscription.

Michelle

I just received mine today but I had different samples in the to go bag except for the Rodial foil which had leaked all over the other contents. Mine included a Philosophy love sweet love shower gel bottle (1oz.) a phytomist instant hydrating conditioner (50ml) and a NeoStrata Skin Active Cellular restoration sample (.5 oz tube). My blush arrived with a broken mirror too. I reached out to them but last time I got a damaged item they offered me a $5 credit rather than replacing it so we’ll see. I just resubbed so I don’t know if I will keep it or not.

laurel

Use the coupon on the mask, and you can get another mask free–just pay shipping and handling!

Jennifer

I am also a little disappointed with my box which is different than your review. It is the same as some of the reviewers here (like the one Judy posted); I got the one with the Tarte oil. While I found the box okay in general but I am disappointed in the beauty-to-go samples, I got one Boost it complexion enhancer, 2 Nip+Fab serum packets and one jar of “beat- up” looking lipgloss. The worst part is that it took 3 weeks to get to my house. If they charge almost $9 for shipping, I expect better service than Fedex Smartpost!

Judy

I just got my March beauty test tube. A few of the things were the same but many were not and I am disappointed. Not only were they not the same but one of them the “tarte pure maracuja oil rollerball came brken in pieces. So people should be aware that you may not get what others get. I received the following –
It’s a 10 miracle leave in lite
Glamglow youthmud tinglexfoliate treatment
Lumene night cream
It cosmetics powder brush
Mally liquid lipstick
Orly nail lacquer
Bioxidea miracle 48 diamond
Grandelash -MD Grande mascara
Tarte pure maracuja oil rollerball (broken in pieces)
plus bonus small samples of Boost it complexion enhancer,Perricone MD hi potency eye lift and nip + fab no needle fix serum

While I always look forward to this tube of goodies I am disappointed in the selection and may not continue. I will see what they say about the broken Tarte.

Jess

Any luck getting a replacement on the broken Tarte oil? Mine was smashed to bits as well, still haven’t received a replacement.

Judy

They sent me an email saying they would send a replacement but I’m still waiting. Will let you know when I get it. Let me know if you get yours.
Thanks.

Chris

I got the same as Judy as well—–almost completely different than Liz’s, and my to-go bag was completely different from both of yours. I’m a little disappointed as well, at least at the value factor. Lots of items I’d like to try in mine though, so maybe I’ll try another month?

Oksana

I got the same tube as Judy. Except different bonus samples and all 4 very tiny: single use Sothys mask, Rodial facial oil, Memorie Liquide perfume sample and 0.017 oz Perlace primer

Breanna

I noticed the same thing!! I signed up specifically to get the tube shown above because I was told everyone receives the same tube, just different bonus items. Im going to be really bummed if I get the tube your received. No offense of course, I was just under the assumption I would get the one I had seen. I really wanted that Tarte Blush and the Vitamin E.

jessica

Can I get an invite as well! This box looks amazing, I love everything in it. I might drop ipsy and sub to this instead.

Haley Chenot

Hello! Could you please send me an invite? Thank you!! 🙂

Patricia

Would love to get an invite for this tube.
I have been wanting to try it and I have been wanting to try the GlamGlow!!

Sarah

You can find a lot of what’s in these boxes on eBay for pretty cheap so if you get something you love then check out eBay for another for usually under $5!

susie

need an invite!

jenjohn521

Could you please send me a referral as well? I must have! Ipsy, BB, and Julep just aren’t enough boxes! ; )

Rachel

This looks great, could I get an invite? Thanks!

Barbara

What is the Beauty-to-Go Bag and how does one subscribe?

[email protected]

could I please get a referral …I belong to blush and ipsy but would like to try this box!

Summer

Hi ladies! This is by far one of my favorite subs. Unfortunaly due to their lack of organization, their double billing, and poor customer service I have to cancel. FYI I refered my sister in July, just got my free tube in feb. and that was a huge huge hassle!

kathryn

let me jump on this band wagon- Can I have a referral too!?

LEX UPTO

Can you send me a referral? I’d love to try this subscription box!
This page rocks!

Liz Cadman

Invite sent!

Stacey

Could you please send me an invite as well? Thank you!

Liz Cadman

Invite sent!

Melinda

Could I get a referral link, please? Thanks.

Liz Cadman

Invite sent!

KdL

I enjoyed TT when they first came out back in the early 2000’s. I lost the feeling for them and the products that they started sending me back in 2011ish. Whenever it was that birchbox came on the scene. But, this box is amazing and I resigned up yesterday. Liz, did you get the magazine yet? Or have they stopped sending that out with the tubes???

Liz Cadman

I just got my first magazine from them a few weeks ago. (At that point I had given up on ever getting the magazine!) So it will show up eventually 🙂

KdL

Thankyou, for all you do!!!:)

Jamie

Liz, please send me an email as well! Thankb

Liz Cadman

Invite sent!

Jennifer Ivey

Hi Liz! Would you please e-mail me an invite? I’d like for you to get the referral credit 🙂

Liz Cadman

Invite sent!

Jennifer Ivey

Thanks Liz! I just signed up using the link you sent me 🙂

Sarah

I am so excited to get this box! My tracking says it should be here on Saturday Mar. 8th! woohoo! This looks like an awesome test tube.

Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

New Beauty Test Tube Subscription Box Review – March 2014

Advertise With MSA

Information

Company