First Impressions is a series that (re)introduces and reviews new brands to My Subscription Addiction, drawing from readers' requests for an insider's first look. Interested in seeing more reviews from this brand, or have another box in mind that you'd like to see reviewed? Let us know in the comments.
Alltrue is back on MSA! We haven't reviewed their box in a while due to their temporary closure, but are excited to review them again.
Alltrue is a quarterly subscription that provides a customizable curation of socially conscious lifestyle products.
The Cost: $69.95 per quarter + free shipping within the contiguous USA ($7.95 shipping Canada, Hawaii, Alaska, and US Territories), or $64.95 per box when you sign up for an annual subscription.
This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the editorial guidelines to learn more about how we review boxes.)
How does Alltrue work?
Each Alltrue box contains 6-8 products. There are different levels of customization available to their Annual and Seasonal subscribers.
From Alltrue:
Spring Box includes a total of six full size products. Annual members get to customize all six tiers, and Seasonal members get to customize tier two and five. Highest combined MSRP is $300.
I did not customize this box and was given an additional item, noted below.
The box came with a nice booklet showcasing all the box choices. It explains a bit more about each item and also shows the other items available in each category. While I did see one or two items that I would have chosen if I had been able to customize my box, the curation was good and I'll be using almost all the items.
Editors Note: Unfortunately, this box sold out between the time it was received and publication! However, due to the high demand, Alltrue is currently offering a Spring Welcome Box, which will be available for any new members. This box will contain a selection of new product and past favorites for them to choose from when they customize.
What's Inside The Alltrue Box?
My first Alltrue box appeared slightly scuffed up, but no more so than any normal box. It may have just been more noticeable on the lovely pattern rather than on a plain boring brown box.
When I opened it, I was happy to see that everything was securely in place and hadn’t shifted at all in transit. The items were displayed nicely and packed securely with minimal packing material needed.
This season's box had 6 categories.
Category 6
Evio Beauty - Tear Catchers Eye Patches (6 Pack) - Retail Value $19
This was the first item that I tried out. When I opened the box, I was happy to see that there were 6 individually packaged pairs of hydrogels - that makes it so easy to pop one in my toiletry kit when I travel.
These seem to be pretty standard hydrogel eye patches. With my sensitive skin, I love that they are fragrance free! They stayed on well while I went about getting ready in the morning. Other brands that I have tried have a tendency to slide off when upright/walking around.
Category 5
Willow Collective - Cryo Glam Pink Cooling Globes - Retail Value $30
In this little box I found this pair of pink, water and glitter-filled, glass-handled globes for facial rolling. The back of the box had very clear directions and benefits. Once I unwrapped them they were quite secure nested in a tray within the box, but it seemed a bit clunky for ongoing storage for regular use. I think that a padded storage pouch or lidded box would be most practical.
This is the only item that I didn't love - it's just something that I know I won't use because they aren't very practical for my lifestyle. They should be placed in the freezer for 20 minutes before use, but cannot be stored in the fridge or freezer. Which means I'd have to sit around with a timer and hope not to get interrupted by a kid or a dog. Which is not very likely.
However, I know some pre-teen girls who would love them!
Category 4
Foxy Originals Gold Teardrop Earrings - Retail Value $32
This is the item I didn’t know I needed. I’ve been wearing diamond studs almost exclusively for the last 20+ years, but have recently wanted a few other pairs of earrings to put in rotation. So this is a beautiful and classic addition, and something Ill wear regularly.
They are also sustainably produced, per the included booklet:
Like all Foxy jewelry, these 14k gold teardrop earrings were handmade locally in Toronto, Canada by a small production team of skilled craftspeople, reducing the brand’s carbon footprint and creating local jobs.
These are a great weight; sturdy, but not heavy. The smooth gold tone is classic, but the curved teardrop shape has a bit of interest. They would go well with just about anything!
Category 3
MYTAGALONGS - Beauty Travel Tube Set, set of 4, 2.7 oz each - Retail Value $24
I don't know what it says about me, but I was super excited for these. I've tried multiple travel bottles over the years that all have just been fine, but not great. These check all the boxes: they are slim, but they have a wide mouth that makes filling and cleaning them a breeze. The colors are distinct - no more having to use a Sharpie to write what is in each container. The almost 3 ounce size is enough for a longer trip while still being TSA compatible. I probably could do without the pouch (which can be repurposed), but only because they fit so well in my travel bag.
Category 2
UpCircle Eye Roller and Eye Cream - Retail Value $35
This category choice is actually two items. The packaging was intuitive and inviting - I could immediately see they paired together. I have never used an eye roller before, but loved trying it out. The roller itself was compact without feeling too small. It was comfortable in my hand and the metal stayed naturally cool.
The eye cream had a nice scent and beautiful light golden color. The ingredient list was very clear and had no red flags for someone like me with sensitive skin. I will definitely make this part of my daily routine.
Category 1
Talianna Ombre Glass Wine Tumblers, set of 2 - Retail Value $49
These glasses are beautiful. They are nice and weighty, but not heavy. The blue ombre is both bold and subtle at the same time.
I was unfamiliar with the brand, but the booklet states:
A set of two created by another set of two. Talianna is a collaboration between mother-daughter duo Talia and Anna, who started her first business in 2002 with her mother and grandmother. We love a long line of female founders.
I understand why they sent 2, but I'm not a big fan of that quantity - I always prefer a set of four. Fortunately there was a card in the box with a QR code directly to the website if I wanted to buy another matching or coordinating set. Which leads me to wonder if this color was made exclusively for Alltrue - on public websites I was only able to find them in Plum.
I like these glasses, and they are gorgeous, but I don’t know if I would have picked them knowing I have plenty of wine glasses. But they’ll get used - I'm thinking for sangria in the summer.
Bonus Item
SiiZU - Cozy Poncho Wrap (Gray Stripe) - Retail Value $110
This is so cozy!!! It is a long, fringed, split front poncho style wrap sweater. The fabric was so soft and absolutely gorgeous neutral shades of cream and light/medium grey. I love that the box could include a clothing item, by picking something that is truly one size fits most.
For me, this would be an ideal travel item. It easily dresses up jeans or leggings, and can double as a blanket. It’s the perfect cross between a sweater and a scarf. I'm 5’-6", and I had everyone in the family try it on, and it really works well for any height. They all commented on how soft it is. However, I have not shown it to my mom yet because I have a feeling she might try to keep it for herself!
Value - Was This Box Worth It?
The Cost: $69.95 per quarter + free shipping within the contiguous USA ($7.95 shipping Canada, Hawaii, Alaska, and US Territories), or $64.95 per box when you sign up for an annual subscription.
The Alltrue Spring 2024 Box contains 6 items (I'm not including the bonus item). This subscription states a value up to $250+ in value per box, and for this season up to $300. My items added up to a total of $189 (once again, not including the bonus item), which is still over 2.5 times the cost of the box!
Math aside, IT'S SO WORTH IT. This subscription is a great value. It is a well-balanced mix of beauty, home decor, and practical items, as well as wearables. Everything is of high quality, and I like knowing that I can feel good about supporting all the brands represented in the box, most of which I hadn’t heard of before.
To Wrap Up:
Can you still get this box if you sign up today? No, this box sold out while it was in transit. However, due to the high demand, Alltrue is currently offering a Spring Welcome Box, which will be available for any new members. This box will contain a selection of new product and past favorites for them to choose from when they customize.
What do you think of the Spring 2024 Box? Click below to write a review!
Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.