Facebook PixelBoxyCharm March 2018 Box SPOILER #3! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Boxycharm August 2022 Base Spoiler #1, Spoiler #2, Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4

BoxyCharm March 2018 Box SPOILER #3!

MSA
ByMSAFeb 21, 2018 | 168 comments

Boxy-charm-march-2017-0002

BoxyCharm
4.3 overall rating
1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

We have a new spoiler for the March 2018 Boxycharm thanks to Boxycharm Beauties!

The March box will include:

Pretty Vulgar "Make Them Blush" Powder Blush in Hush Blush or Prim Vixen - $26

In case you missed it, Boxycharm sent us one of the March spoiler items early, so we have additional pictures and swatches for you!

All subscribers will receive:

Boxycharm X PUR Cosmetics Palette

The formulas are cruelty-free, gluten-free, talc-free, and vegan-friendly!

The palette includes a mix of mattes and shimmers:

Here they are swatched:

Gorgeous pigment! (Let me know if you have any questions about the palette I can answer!)

This box will also include:

The Vintage Company Smokey Eye Brush Set

What do you think of the March Boxycharm spoilers?

If you haven't signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Starting at $30.00
Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

168 comments

Kristy

Pur just posted a sneak peek of their box. They had Butter London Double Decker Lashes Mascara, And something else I could only see partially. Maybe someone will recognize the packaging.

Reply ButtonReply

Lottie Lorene Riggs

I missed out on February box. I was so disappointed. But I will get Marches so I’m very happy again!!! Can’t wait to see the next two spoilers.

Reply ButtonReply

Crystal

Currently on Boxy’s website they are stating that there is no waitlist. So if you want March go ahead and sign up. (And if you have been on the waitlist and not yet moved off I’d email them about it).

Reply ButtonReply

Aimee

So excited! Went on product overload in November and cancelled the box. Went through all my stuff and gave away, trashed, or donated a TON of stuff and now I’m back. I have missed Boxycharm a lot. Just got my Feb box today and it was really shiny. I really re subbed hoping I would be off the wait list for this. Love the shadows, PUR is awesome and I’m still using that pallet from September 17. Love the blush (either one) and yep I still use blush, but strangely I am excited for the brushes! Like I said I cleaned out the ole make up drawer so I’m ready for some fresh new everything. So happy to be back.

Reply ButtonReply

Yvette

This Boxycharm is fire 🔥I need a good blush and here it is! Thank you babes 😍😍😍😍

Reply ButtonReply

Lucy

The 2017 palette had 8 matte eyeshadows and only 4 shimmery eyeshadows. I wish this one was the same… Even the black eyeshadow has glitter on it. I don’t get it. Why???

Reply ButtonReply

Miranda

I cannot wait for the March box! It looks amazing! Most excited for the eyeshadow pallet, the last one we got from this brand is my fav.. And those colors look great,ecsp.. tyre orange-yellow shade!! Very excited!!!! Would love the next 2 items to be a perfume rollerball and a fun nailpolish❤

Reply ButtonReply

Kiersten

I got off the waitlist about a week or so ago, and i am supposed to have my box by wed. So excited to get my first box! I wonder what i will have in it. Says 0.6 pounds. It seems though that doesnt tell me what box i am getting. Excitedly waiting!! 🤗

Reply ButtonReply

Candace

Bet you’re getting the highlight palette.

Reply ButtonReply

Kim

I’m loving this box. That palette is gorgeous! I can always use brushes, and if I don’t need them now I can save them they don’t go bad. I’ll be happy with either blush. I like to mix it up depending on where I’m going and what I’m wearing. Big thing for me is not all glittery. Loving it!

Reply ButtonReply

Trisha

I signed up on Thursday (yesterday) and got notification today that my cc had been charged and I’m off the waitlist.

That was fast!

Reply ButtonReply

Victoria

I received my February box today and I was so excited I was on the waitlist for roughly 3 weeks and was praying for the February box now I’m so excited to be getting marchs as well! You’ll enjoy it! I also got exactly what I wanted the lip plumper the naked highlight palette and the eye liner plus the brushes and cover fax! It’s well worth the money

Reply ButtonReply

Joyce

I wanted to let everyone know that I am now off the wait list with Boxy Charm. Wow that was fast! I am glad though. I don’t know if I will be getting the Feb or March box. It doesn’t matter just so I get something Anyone know what I am getting?

Reply ButtonReply

Candace

Congrats! Hope you love Boxycharm! This sub is fantastic. I rarely get items I don’t like or can’t use in some way and I really hope it works out that way for you too! Welcome to makeup nirvana!

Reply ButtonReply

Janet villaire

If your credit card was charged in February, you will get the February box. If it’s not charged until March, you will get the March box.

Reply ButtonReply

Lisa Bee

I just got off the waitlist too, mine should be here by Thursday, so excited 😍

Reply ButtonReply

Sherry Michelle Mashburn

I just signed up for the box today. 30 minutes later I was off the waitlist . I’m so excited. And if I don’t want certain colors or things,that is ok. I have nieces who will love it 😊

Reply ButtonReply

Susan

Hi Sherry!
How great for you! That’s the awesome thing about Boxy Charm…. At $21 a month….a deal any day of the month… Anything you don’t like or want… It’s not hard to find someone to take it off your hands and the best part is ….you 100 don’t mind at the price you paid for the entire box!
SO HAPPY FOR YOU SWEETIE❣️

Sherry Michelle Mashburn

I just signed up for the box today. 30 minutes later I was off the waitlist . I’m so excited

Reply ButtonReply

Kenetrice Jones

@Joyce yay so happy for you. Whatever month they bill you in, will be the box you receive. So, if they billed you on any day in February, you will get the Feb box. If they don’t bill you until March 1st or 2nd, then you will get the March box. Hope that helps. 🙂 You are going to love this subscription. I know I do. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

LAURA

I received my 1st Boxycharm box yesterday… <3 it.

Candace

I’ll never understand why people subscribe to subs and then proceed to complain about the items they get. You’re not being forced to subscribe and you know going into it that you get what they send. The whole point of these boxes is product discovery. If you don’t like the color you get but like the formula, go buy it in a color you do like. If you’re giving away most of the items and constantly complaining about them then maybe the box isn’t for you and you should cut it loose and let someone that will appreciate it have your spot. If you’re complaining you have too many of this or that, but you’re also getting multiple beauty subs, maybe you should cut back on subs or go out and actually purchase the items you want instead or hoarding stuff you will probably never use in hopes of getting something you like. Or donate it to a women’s shelter or a church that does community outreach.

Also, just because you don’t personally like a product doesn’t mean it’s a bad product. It means that either it’s just not a good product for you or you may not be applying it in the best way. I see this all the time on these threads. Same thing with colors people receive. Just because it doesn’t work for you doesn’t mean it’s just ugly. It means it’s not right for your skin or skin tone but it will work for the right person. Makeup is not one size fits all. One particular example is the Pur lipscrub from last month. You need to put it on before you start anything else on your face, rub it in to exfoliate, then let it sit on your lips until the very end of your routine then do your lips. I got some decent plumping out of it and nice soft lips. It’s not a crappy product and does what it says. You just need to use it correctly.

I’m sorry but it just drives me crazy. Maybe it’s a sign of the times but just some comments come off as “they should cater to me and my skin tone only and give me what I want” and that’s just not how it works with these boxes. Yes they have you fill out a profile but at the end of the day they are only getting certain amounts of the products. What they get is up to the distributors, not them, so you are getting what the distributor sends. These profiles are more geared towards finding out what kind of products you are interested in rather than colors preferred. I actually like that the distributors send out shades that work better for different skin tones rather than cater to one color. Makeup and sub boxes should be more inclusive. You are not the only person. The world doesn’t revolve around you and neither do sub boxes. If you’re using subs to get all of your makeup and constantly complaining that you don’t like what you get, go buy your own stuff. It’s about product discovery, not relying on these subs to supply everything you need. Like everyone complaining they didn’t get the Naked highlighter palette. I was disappointed I didn’t get it but I ordered it because I wanted to try it out. Just because you didn’t get it in your box doesn’t mean you can’t get it and if you’re spending so much on subs that you can’t afford to go out and buy the products you wanted but didn’t get or the colors you wanted then you are spending too much on subs.

Reply ButtonReply

Niffer

AMEN SISTER! Couldn’t have said it better but think the same.

Reply ButtonReply

Christie

That lip scrub though…. I LOVE it!!!! Y’all don’t want yours, send it my way!!

Reply ButtonReply

Kelly

I agree 100% with Candace! Well said!!!!

Reply ButtonReply

Tasha

Preach! Agree 100%

Reply ButtonReply

blackblondes1992

Preach! A lot of these subscribers are so ungrateful!! We pay very little for all the FULL SIZED products we get. I love Boxy Charm, if you don’t like it go sign up for Ipsy’s baby-sized products and please unsubscribe so someone else can take your spot. This is truly for makeup lovers not make up dablers.

Reply ButtonReply

Kat

Boxycharm should definitely implement preferences. Feburary was a perfect example why.

There seemed to be a pretty even split of people who wanted the Ofra and people who wanted the Naked, but got opposite.
Also, some people really wanted the glitter, while other’s wanted one of the lip scrubs. They should really let us tell them what we like, then send the variations based on that. I’ve also gotten soooo many lipsticks that are the same color as my skin, if there was an option where I could choose the darkest shade, I would.

I’ll continue to voice discontent when I have it. It’s my right as a customer, and a company will never improve when they don’t know how their customers feel.

Reply ButtonReply

charlotte

I completely agree with you! I got the Ofra palette, which was the one I wanted, As well as the lip scrub! Boxycharm is a great company, but every company can improve, and having feedback they can respond to definitely helps.

Allie

Thank you for saying what has needed to be said for a very long time.

Reply ButtonReply

Sherry

Ty. I like everything. If there is something I don’t like my nieces do.

Megan Mcgilbery

Well said, I totally agree

Reply ButtonReply

justmissjamey

Maybe you don’t READ the end of most of these posts…usually (which is what I enjoy about them) the ladies ask …”WHAT DO YOU THINK” or “WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS”

Seriously, everyone has different opinions, likes, dislikes, etc and I for one enjoy reading comments and read what everyone has to say. Not everyone is going to like everything (espically with variations etc)

Reply ButtonReply

Melissa W.

Right? Who cares if someone doesn’t like the contents of a box they got? It’s their right and opinion, just as it is for someone who did like the contents, to be able to express their thoughts on a box. I look forward to reading everyone’s thoughts…. the good and bad, and I don’t think it’s a wise decision to belittle others for doing so. For those who are sick of reading about people not liking what they got… don’t read it and just keep moving!

Rosemary

Everyone…please keep writing your negative comments! If a box is going downhill, changes dramatically, or is a phenomenal disappointment, I want to know.

Also, I want to thank anyone who bothers to comment; good or bad, we read them and then make up our own minds.

Victoria

I’m thinking she meant the ones that are constantly on here complaining and saying they are going to unsub , but never do. Which I have to agree then unsubscribe if your that “unhappy” with the subscription boxes, I don’t think that was directed at the ones who simply don’t like an item in this mo this box, but the ones who are ALWAYS complaining. Just adding my thought I’m neutral

Lexi

I agree with you %100. Very well said.

Rashma

I hope everyone who loves subscription box read this well said.

Reply ButtonReply

Hillary

I just got off the waitlist like 2 weeks ago and I got an email yesterday saying my box shipped. Does that mean this box shipped or is that Februarys box?

Reply ButtonReply

Sara

You get a box for each corresponding month that you get billed. So, if they charged you in February, they just shipped you the February box. Then you will get billed again in the first few days of March and will get March’s box.

Reply ButtonReply

Hillary

Awesome! I wanted February’s box. Thank you!

Joyce

That is cool. Then I will get two boxes. Thanks for letting me know. I do appreciate it

Redhed36

Likely. I was off in January and received January’s box.

Reply ButtonReply

Candace

I already have the entire shade range in this blush. I’ll probably wind up stacking this though. It’s a pretty respectable blush with a lot of pigmentation so I’m happy to get another one at a deep discount.

If you’ve never used PV blush, be warned, it’s pigmented. You need to go in with a light hand and blend well unless you want to look 🤡.

I find their Prim Vixen shade to be flattering on a range of skin tones. The key with it is to blend blend blend with a brush and then then blend some more with a beauty blender. It is just beautiful sheered out. It also doesn’t read ashy on deeper skin tones, which is great for the deeper skin ladies that want a pop of color and I will often reach for this with deeper skinned clients looking for just that. Once you get your makeup on, spray your face with setting spray, pat that in so it’s not just sitting on top, and be amazed. I know it looks wild in the pan, but Prim Vixen can look natural. As with anything, it depends on how it’s applied.

Also, am I the only one loving the vintage eyeliner? I tested it out in my water lines yesterday and was thrilled. I tend to shy away from pencils because my eyes water constantly due to allergies and even waterproof formulas travel downward, fade out and wear off within a few hours. So I didn’t have high hopes for this. It proved me wrong. The formula just glides like butter, so smooth it’s ridiculous with zero tugging. I wore this for 10 HOURS yesterday and it was still going strong and staying where I put it when I took my makeup off. This was especially great for tight lining my upper waterline. One swipe and it was done. Didn’t even have to go over it! Even high end brands don’t perform like this on me. I’m amazed and quite impressed actually. I know a lot of people don’t like it when they get eyeliner but I’m so glad they sent out the Vintage one. I doubt I would have picked this on my own. I’m so happy to have found a pencil that will work for both me and especially for clients that also suffer from watery eyes and prefer a pencil formula. Because believe me, they ask what they should use, and I give the spiel suggesting liquid or gel liners & sometimes they’re disappointed when I say you need to switch formulas. A lot of women don’t like to hear they need to change their routine or product formulas. Now I can just suggest this bad boy so its a major win. Im going to order 40 of these. 10 for my kits and the other 30 as giveaway products for clients looking for a good pencil formula that will survive itchy, watery eyes & still look fierce af. This eyeliner won me over in a big way. Well done, Vintage, well done. I look forward to discovering other products from this brand and seeing if they capture my heart like this amazing little eyeliner did. That’s what makes Boxycharm so great, I can discover products I’d never pay full price for just to test out. I really hate when I buy something and either I have a limited amount of clients it works for or it’s just a complete flop all around. I’m looking at you, original Subculture palette, Lancome Hypnose mascara, Too Faced Love Light highlighter, most Bobbi Brown eyeshadow palettes, I could keep going. Makeup isn’t cheap. I spend a massive amount of money on product every year (anyone wanna take a stab at how much?) so any way I can save money is just wonderful and Boxy has done this well for me as well as pointed me in the direction of a few products that I didn’t know I needed in my arsenal that are more affordable. Thank you, Boxycharm.

Reply ButtonReply

Kelly

I also really loved the eyeliner! Lasts all day long and looks great!
Thank you for the review on the blush- excited to try either shade 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Maggie

Thanks for this post! I just got my February box yesterday so I’ve not had a chance to try out the products on my face yet. But now I know that I will for sure be trying out the Vintage eyeliner!

Reply ButtonReply

Sara

I never really wore eyeliner (just applied dark shadow with an angled brush) !until trying this pencil- I love it! Like you said, it doesn’t tug at all. Now I’m wearing eyeliner every day. That’s what sub boxes are great for

Reply ButtonReply

Janet villaire

Great post…thanks!

Reply ButtonReply

Tanya

How deep a skin tone Candace? I love it but due to dry eyes no use trying. I tried the vintage liner and use for cat eye since I am waiting for my Lorac pencil to arrive. I did enjoy that the Boxycharm discount covered the shipping for my CoverFx setting spray. I am not much on contour but do work a blush and generally use the deep plums/purple but was shocked how well the Pur blush compact orange worked. I didn’t try the Naked compact but did thrill a friend’s daughter.

Reply ButtonReply

Julie

For everyone that’s complaining about a waitlist while a small portion of it could be for hype they also develop and work with the partners months in advance for these boxes and I love the fact that they don’t over order because unlike certain boxes that will ship old stock boxy seems to have everything fresh and not expired.

Reply ButtonReply

gayle

I got the ofra palette. Looking to trade for the highlighter if anyone is interested.

Reply ButtonReply

Lauren

Did anyone receive the ofra palette in the last box that would like to trade for the highlighter palette if so please email me !

Reply ButtonReply

ashley

YES ME

Reply ButtonReply

Kelly

Me! I want to trade!

Reply ButtonReply

Tina

I have the Naked pallete to swap – ctretinjak at Hotmail dot com

kbsold

Please pm me on fb Kim Abersold (Kim Hunsicker)

Reply ButtonReply

Kim

I would love to. How do I email you?

Reply ButtonReply

Angel

I pulled out just in time! The last box was a total flop and I just knew It wasn’t going to look up anytime soon.

Reply ButtonReply

Tanya

It was looking up for me with the Crown brushes.. Woohoo… and the eyeliner and a birthday gift for a friends daughter. I am still in love with my Crown blush brush and already am mad for the big finishing brush we got this month. And I am getting brushed for a smokey eye.. I’m ready…

Reply ButtonReply

Julie

Yeah, I’m glad I passed the baton to someone on the waitlist. The last 3 boxes have been a miss for me.

I finally started to organize my stash and started by dumping my year of mulitiple beauty box addiction on my bed…needless to say I have an embarrassing amount of makeup and skincare 😲

Reply ButtonReply

annalily5

While ultimately I’ll be happy with either, I’m hoping I get the bright pink. I ave so many things like the other color, and those bright pinks look great on me when I use a light hand. Goes great with my cool toned skin.

Reply ButtonReply

Reyna

Me too! I’ve got dusty rose, and nude/brow everything!!! I am a pasty white, bust out the pinks baby! Lol

Reply ButtonReply

Reyna

Spell check, ugh… ⬆ I meant nude/brown and pastey white, sorry!

Joyce

So how many months will I be on this wait list? I am confused about that. I thought it would be like all the other subscription boxes where you just order it. I don’t understand why they do not buy enough stock to service new customers as well. It really isn’t giving me a very good impression of Boxy Charm. You know when you see a new service you really like you want to start it right away.

Reply ButtonReply

annalily5

I doubt they’d be able to make such great boxes if they didn’t have a waitlist. Something that just throws in a bunch of small samples that can be thrown into the next box/bag if they accidentally order doesn’t have much risk if they over order. Boxy has such high valued, uniquely curated boxes that if they accidentally over order they have a bunch of expensive palettes or such lying around that they can no longer sell. They wouldn’t be able to afford to keep that behavior up for long without starting to only order lower value products, having repeat items, or raising their price, all of which would then make them far less desirable a box.

Reply ButtonReply

Beth

I subscribed on November to boxycharm and got off the waitlist on January and received January’s box. Because they have limited supplies, they mostly wait until someone unsubscribes. this month has been very quick because so many girls were disappointed by the last 2 or 3 boxes. Being in a waitlist is not a bad thing, theres almost better stuff in the future. waitlist won’t take more than 2 months. don’t get impatient because we’ve all been there. and calling out boxycharm won’t help. again, its really not that bad

Reply ButtonReply

shari

I actually think that is a marketing tactic. It makes it look like 1. They are so much in demand there is a waitlist 2. Keeps you from canceling if you know you have to wait to get pur back on, you may miss something good. 3. When you come off the waitlist they ask you to share it on Social Media that you are off the waitlist, so therefore it shows other’s how great Boxycharm must be to have a waitlist. Clever marketing, yet may put some off also or they may get tired of waiting and cancel. Especially if they miss a really Fab box.

Reply ButtonReply

MzBev

Boxycharm has been in waitlist mode for over a year now, probably a year and a half. This isn’t a new thing for them. They have, however, been getting people OFF the waitlist much quicker this month.

Reply ButtonReply

Redhed36

As far as I know MSA is not affiliated with Boxycharm. If you were waitlisted by Boxycharm I don’t think MSA can do much. I was waitlisted in early December and was off in time for my January box. Hope you aren’t on it long. In your case you need to be kind of hopeful for a bad box so people cancel. LOL.

Reply ButtonReply

Joyce

This service is a Rip Off. The reviews should be removed from this site. I tried to join today and they put me on some kind of a wait list so I guess I wont get the March Box. I am unhappy because I really liked it.

Reply ButtonReply

AnnieS.

Why should the reviews be removed because you are wait listed for a subscription box? MSA does not control how BoxyCharm runs their service. You may not be added right away due to the popularity of this particular subscription. As with any subscription service, there is no guarantee that you will receive the current box when you sign up.

The March spoilers are for people who already have a subscription to BoxyCharm and people who might want to see what types of products are sent out before signing up.

Reply ButtonReply

Joyce

You are right this service has nothing to do with Boxy Charm. I actually really enjoy this site and the administrator and those that write the reviews and model the products. They are very nice and kind. I realize it is not their fault.

I was just upset because I tried to sign up and was immediately waitlisted. I have tried many subscription boxes and have never been waitlisted on any of the others. I don’t understand why they do not stock enough product to service new customers as well as their existing customers. This makes a bad impression when someone opts to try their service for the first time.

Diana

Omg, it’s been an eyeshadow palette and brushes for the 3 boxes now. This adds great value to the box but I’m starting to get overwhelmed with brushes and “meh” palettes! I do really like the PUR palettes that have been in previous boxycharms, though.

Reply ButtonReply

Snowhitetwin

How the heck can someone use sooooo much make up every month? I’m starting to learn that quality over quantity is the way to go in the end.

Reply ButtonReply

Samantha T

I’m always so impressed by Pur palettes though! And the blue looks so promising!

Reply ButtonReply

Anna

It’s called hoarding.

Reply ButtonReply

Caitlin

yeah, i tried to do the order the day they restocked and then they were having “issues” so it wasn’t working, and then when they finally email me back that it’s resolved, everything is sold out. So now i’m wondering if I wait for the next restock, but i’m assuming if I cancel I lose the charms, and I was kinda thinking of canceling this month.

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

I am so PUMPED for this box!!! Liz, I know this has probably been asked 100 times, but I haven’t read all the comments yet, is this PÜR palette the same formula as the previous one we got? It looks amazingly pigmented. Have you applied it to the eyes yet? How does it blend? Im so excited!

Reply ButtonReply