Facebook PixelThe 12 Best Razor Subscriptions for Smooth Shaving - 2023 Winners | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction

The 12 Best Razor Subscriptions for Smooth Shaving in 2023 – Readers’ Choice Awards

Christen Russo
ByChristen RussoJan 13, 2023 | 0 comments

Everyone who shaves has a shared goal: smooth, satiny skin with no nicks or irritation. But there are more roads than one that can lead you there! Decisions range from cartridges vs. safety razors, five blades or just one, aloe strips vs. no aloe strips, and what lotion, oil, or other product you'll use to hydrate your skin afterward. With the variety of individuals, hair types, and needs that exist, we're happy to report that there are a number of shaving systems offered as subscriptions—you're sure to find the razor subscription that works for you.

Every year, we ask our readers to share their top recommended subscriptions of all types. Then we ask our experts to share what they know about each subscription to make it easy for you to know which subscription is right for you. Below, you’ll find our insights for shopping shaving care and razor subscriptions, and see readers’ top choices for disposable razor subscriptions, safety razor subscriptions, women's razor subscriptions as well as the skincare that goes along with the territory.

What To Look For When Shopping Razor Subscriptions

A razor subscription can simplify your routine and take one last item to replenish off your grocery list. Sounds like a great way to simplify life to us! Many shaving clubs offer more than just the goods, too, acting as amazingly helpful resources to help you reduce irritation and own a smooth shave. There's something out there for every budget, and even the most affordable razor subscriptions are an upgrade from what many local convenience stores have on offer.

With that in mind, we’ve collected a list of some of the best razor clubs for both men and women. Before you shop, some thoughts to keep in mind:

  • Decide whether you want a shaving subscription or a one-time shaving kit. If you shave infrequently, monthly razor deliveries might overwhelm you with unnecessary products. In our list, we’ve included both subscription and non-subscription options (and most shave clubs that offer subscriptions also allow one-off orders).
  • Look for the best long-term value. Razor companies often sell their state-of-the-art “systems" for cheap — because customers will buy the replacement cartridges at inflated prices. We’ve focused on companies that provide excellent value over time.
  • Don’t forget the add-ons. If you regularly suffer from razor burn and ingrown hairs, your razor might be the problem — but add-on essentials like moisturizing shave butter might be exactly what you need for smoother shaving.

The Most Popular Razor Subscription Boxes

Read on for our reader’s recommendations for the best razor subscription boxes for men and women that are currently available. If we missed anything, we'd love it if you would let us know in the comments. If you’ve tried one of these services, be sure to leave a quick review (even if you had a poor experience — your review can help other readers avoid subscription remorse).

1. Athena Club

The Best Razor Subscription Overall

What’s In This Razor Subscription Box

Choosing a razor kit that’s right for you can be a daunting task as there are hundreds of brands out there, but you need not look further than the Athena Club razor. Designed with how you really shave in mind, whether you’re in the shower or in a hurry, this razor features five spaced-out blades and a moisturizing serum activated by water for the smoothest, closest shave. You can choose between six different colors, and every order includes a handle, two five-blade cartridges, and a magnetic hook for easy storage. The best part? You’ll never run out of cartridges because you can get them delivered as frequently as you need them!

Who It's For

Everyone who's looking to treat their skin right. Athena Club uses only the most natural and sustainable ingredients, so you can rest easy knowing your self-care essentials are free from harsh chemicals, dyes, and additives.

Other Shaving Products from Athena Club

This shave club offers a wide range of products like shaving cream, body lotion, body wash, tampons, liners, multivitamins and probiotics, wipes, deodorants, and more. Athena Club products are chock-full of all-natural ingredients like avocado oil, chamomile extract, aloe leaf juice, manuka honey, vitamin C, vitamin E, and B5.

Pros

  • You can choose your razor color!
  • Their products use natural, sustainable ingredients with no harsh chemicals. And they're vegan and cruelty-free!
  • Athena Club offers all sorts of products beyond shaving care goods, including vitamins, period care items, and candles.

Cons

  • This isn't as low-waste as other shaving solutions.

What Readers Say:

"Recently switched to Athena Club and I am loving it! The color options are so pretty and the magnetic holder is super useful in the shower." - Jack

Shipping:

Ships to the US for free.

Starting at $9.00
Active Deal
Use code MSA20 to get 20% off
Use Coupon Code MSA20
Try Athena Club
Not ready to buy? Add it to your Or, if you want to learn more, check out all our Athena Club Razor reviews.

2. Billie

The Best Female-First Shave Brand

Billie Razor Starter Kit including bluue handle, 2 cartridges, and magnetic holder arranged around shipping bag.

Image via our review.

What’s In This Shaving Subscription Box

Billie’s shaving products are designed for women, with sleek designs that easily navigate angles and curves. The 5-blade cartridges handle body hair with ease while cutting down on shave time, and a silky aloe-and-charcoal bar at the top of each razor helps to nurture sensitive skin.

While razor aesthetics aren’t an especially important part of shaving, we dig the fun color options — after all, there’s nothing wrong with matching your accessories to your decor. The best part: Billie’s razors fit into a magnetic holder. Stick the holder to a shower wall or other flat surface, and you’ll keep your razors sharp and rust-free while maintaining easy access.

Who It's For

Billie is designed as a women's razor subscription, but the design is fairly gender-neutral. A great shave is a great shave, and this shaving club delivers.

Other Products from Billie

Body lotion, shave cream, and body wash in fruity botanical scents, as well as a razor travel case. They also just introduced non-shaving beauty items like lip balm, dry shampoo, and facial wipes, all of which are geared toward women (with no “pink tax" included).

Pros

  • Comes with a magnetic holder that sticks to your shower wall.
  • Fun colors to choose from.

Cons

  • The colors aren't very gender-neutral...though we don't believe all colors are for all genders.
  • Language is also very gendered on their site.

What Readers Say:

“Super easy to maintain and adding things to your order when needed is also smooth. Customer service seems very receptive and I have not had any issues. Nice not to have to worry about picking razors up at the store!” – Beth

Shipping:

Ships to the US. Shipping is free for razor & wipe subscriptions, as well as orders over $15. Shipping costs $4 for all other orders.

3. Dollar Shave Club

The Best Shave Club for Extras

Dollar Shave Club starter kit with handle, shave butter, and pack of cartridges on blue backgound

Image via our review.

What’s In This Razor Subscription Box

Dollar Shave Club is one of the few subscriptions to offer more than one cartridge style (subscribers can choose from four blades or six). They’re also one of the most well-known and popular shaving clubs around—for good reason. You’ll find an incredible variety of grooming accessories here, and the auto-ship options provide an easy way to maintain a stock of high-quality products.

As the name implies, Dollar Shave Club is also affordable, and its 30-day money-back guarantee provides some peace of mind. Your first box includes trial-sized products for setting up the perfect routine. Their site allows users to easily adjust shipping frequency, and razor subscriptions can be canceled with a few quick clicks.

Overall, Dollar Shave Club is one of the most versatile shaving subscription services online. If you’re looking for disposable razors and no-frills grooming products, this is a great place to start.

Who It's For

All of Dollar Shave Club’s products are unisex. The site notes that women especially love the Shave Butter, Repair Serum, Hand Cream, and (of course) the Blades.

Other Products from Dollar Shave Club

A full line of shaving, skincare, shower, oral care, hair products, and accessories.

Pros

  • You can choose between four and six blades.
  • Your first box includes trial-size shave products so you can sample their offerings before adding full-size shave butter and other things.

Cons

  • No options for razor color customization.

What Readers Say:

“Love this box. For the value, quality and price it is awesome! I use the 5 blade and let me yell you ladies it gets a very very close shave. The handle is weighted so it feels nice on your hand, adds to the ergonomic shape.” – Kaylee W.

“I use the most blades razor.. i get the best shave on my legs I have ever had in my entire life and I have been shaving my legs for 40 years […] I’m so glade we found y’all..... I’ll never buy a razor in the stores again.” – Alice H.

Shipping:

Ships to the US, Canada, UK, and Australia. Subscriptions ship for free; one-time orders under $18 incur a $4 shipping fee.

4. Harry's

The Best Razor Subscription for Men

Harry's razor starter kit with blue handle, shave gel, and travel case on a blue background

Image via our review.

What’s In This Shaving Subscription Box

Harry’s has a wonderfully weighted handle surrounded by a rubbery grip in one of three bold colors. Their products are marketed towards men, but as we've stated before, a great razor can work wonders for anyone.

Harry’s 5-blade German-made cartridges make shaving a breeze, cutting down the time of your shave without sacrificing precision. The travel case included in the starter kit helps keep the razor safe (and looks pretty spiffy, too).

This shaving club cuts out all the extras — though their store has plenty of excellent personal care and aftershave products — so you’ll get exceptional razors without gimmicks or pushy marketing. Every year, Harry’s donates 1% of sales to nonprofits that provide mental health care services to men in need.

Who It's For

Harry’s razors are designed for men. Again, a razor is a razor, but some of the other options we’ve covered (such as Billie) have designs that would be more appropriate for body hair.

Other Products from Harry’s

Shaving products, skincare, shower products, hair products, and accessories. Several sets and bundles are available from $16-$35.

Pros

  • Shave products are free from sulfates and parabens.
  • Harry's donates 1% of our sales to nonprofits that provide mental health care services to men in need every year.

Cons

  • These razors have a facial hair focus and aren't as good of an option for shaving body hair.

What Readers Say:

“Great stuff... I look forward to this box every month. The razors are great quality which is why I went with Harry's.” – Joe C.

“I got this a few months ago for myself! Love it! The quality of Harry's is far better than any female razors I find at target and walmart - and they're even cheaper! I get so much more for less with Harry's and won't be going back to anything else. The razors last a good while too, so I only get razors shipped every 6 months to myself.” – Airs

Shipping:

Ships to the US, Canada, and the UK. Shipping is free for any order over $15.

5. Hanni

The Best Razor for a Waterless Shave

What’s In This Razor Subscription Box

Hanni is a razor brand for women with an emphasis on razors that are stylish, eco-friendly, and perfect for those on the go. Hanni's flagship product, the weighted razor, is an Allure Best of Beauty Winner from 2021 and features an ergonomic design plus proprietary Swedish stainless steel blades.

Choose from four trendy colors–blush, burgundy, midnight, or flame–but don't forget the Shave Pillow, a waterless shave stick that replaces shaving cream and lets you shave whenever, wherever. Change your blades every two weeks, and when you're ready to get rid of them, place them in the blade bin (which can be 100+ bins) and simply recycle them as you normally would. Be sure to check out Hanni's line of chic accessories such as their hero holder, shower scarf, and shower holder.

Who It's For

Hanni is a women's razor subscription. The designs are curated with women in mind and, with blades this sharp, the guy in your life might enjoy it too.

Other Products from Hanni

In addition to the hero holder, shower scarf, and shower holder, you can purchase glass straws, gift cards, razor caps, and blades online.

Pros

  • You're supporting an eco-friendly brand and cutting down on plastic razor waste.
  • You can shave on-the-go with the waterless Shave Pillow.
  • Blades are easy to recycle–just recycle the blade bin like you would any other recyclable item.

Cons

  • Hanni is more expensive than your disposable, plastic razor.

Shipping:

Ships 50 US states, Puerto Rico, Guam, and military bases, but not PO boxes. Orders $45 and above ship free.

6. Gillette Venus

The Best Major Razor Brand Subscription for Women

Image via Gillette Venus

What’s In This Razor Subscription Box

Venus by Gillette is a shave club for women featuring the Venus line of razors. You’ve seen them in the razor aisle — they’re a classic for a good reason, and Gillette continues to add features to make your shaving journey a little more comfortable.

Choose from four handle styles and seven different types of blade cartridges. You can choose the frequency of your deliveries and add products from their new shaving product Venus line to your orders, so this is a one-stop shop for everything you need. Be sure to check out their kits, as the full Gillette lineup has options for targeting specific types of body hair or treating common shave issues.

Who It's For

Venus is designed specifically as a women's razor subscription. Guys could use them (and if you’re living with a man, you might find him borrowing your Venus every once in a while), but the styling is very feminine.

Other Products from Venus by Gillette

Other Gillette-owned grooming products, such as Olay skincare and Secret deodorant, are available as add-ons.

Pros

  • You can choose your handle style and your blade cartridge style.
  • They're working to reduce stigma about body hair by using direct language like "pubic hair."
  • Blades are surrounded by Olay moisturizer.

Cons

  • Some folks prefer to support small businesses, and this is a big brand.

Shipping:

Ships to the US. All orders over $15 ship for free.

7. Flamingo

The Best Razor Subscription for Body Hair

Flamingo starter kit including taro handle, 2 cartridges, body lotion, shave foam, suction cup holder, and a purple carry pouch on a blue background

Image via our review.

What’s In This Shaving Subscription

Flamingo starts you off with a short quiz to understand your body hair removal needs. They offer both shaving and waxing solutions, as well as moisturizing options for your specific needs and preferences. Flamingo blades are surrounded by a generous aloe bar that helps the razor glide across your skin. It also has a perfectly weighted handle fully surrounded by a rubbery grip that comes in four colors, each with a different vibe.

Rather than signing up for one specific subscription, Flamingo uses your quiz answers to suggest products that might enhance or improve your shaving and/or waxing routine. Each suggested product has a note indicating why it was selected for you, and they also suggest a refill frequency (every 2, 4, or 6 months) they think might work well for your lifestyle.

Who It's For

While Flamingo is dedicated to women-positive causes, their products feature gender-neutral styling. Several male reviewers have noted that the company’s products provide a smoother look and less irritation than other disposables on the market — throw in their excellent shave gel and body lotion, and you’re on your way to a worry-free shave.

Other Products from Flamingo

Foaming shave gel and body lotion with a floral scent, ingrown spot treatment, hydrating spray, and wax strips for your body and face. Several bundles are available.

Pros

  • Offers not only options for your shaving needs, but wax strips as well. They'll send one, the other, or both.
  • Awesomely gender-inclusive brand.
  • Choose your refill frequency.

Cons

  • The razor cartridge isn't fully surrounded by a moisturizing strip.

Shipping:

Ships to the contiguous US. Shipping is free for orders over $15 and costs $3 for orders under $15.

8. All Girl Shave Club

The Best Shaving Subscription for Young Girls

All Girl Shave Club razor screen shot

Image via All Girl Shave Club.

What’s In This Razor Subscription Box

The All Girl Shave Club is a shaving subscription box with a feminine focus. The first box arrives with a full Starter Kit, containing a rose gold, weighted metal handle, a 4-pack of 6-blade, diamond-coated razor cartridges, a safety cover, and a glittery shaving tote. The razor head is flexible so as to follow the contours of its user's body smoothly, and the cartridge is affixed with a moisturizing Vitamin E and aloe strip. For those thinking they'd like to add more shave-related products into their box, you can customize your subscription with one-time additions at a discount. All Girl Shave Club lets you choose to have your shave box delivered every 2, 3, or 4 months based on your needs.

Who It's For

All Girl Shave Club doesn't shy away from being a female-focused razor subscription. Beyond just the name, their weighted metal handles are offered only in rose gold, and where you do have a choice—with the rubber grip—it's between pale pink and purple. This shaving subscription also offers a one-time box ($39.99) called Shine, Girl!, which is an essential box catered to girls who are preparing for their first shaving experience.

Other Products from All Girl Shave Club

The All Girl Shave Club store carries whipped shave butter with cutesy scent names like "Pink Champagne" and "Flirty Mermaid," as well as other shaving accessories like a razor travel bag and shower razor holder. They also carry fun beauty extras like lip gloss, shower caps, nail polish, hair clips, and assorted beauty samples. The vibe is very flirty and feminine.

Pros

  • First box comes with a safety cover and travel tote.
  • One of the only shaving subscriptions targeted to a younger audience.

Cons

  • There's only one handle color option: rose gold.

Shipping:

Ships to the US and Canada. Free US shipping on subscriptions over $18 and one-time orders over $39; otherwise shipping costs $5.95. All shipping to Canada costs $15.

9. Women's Shave Club

The Best Simple, Affordable Razor Subscription for Women

Women's Shave CLub razors splashing in water screen shot

Image via issuewire.com

What’s In This Razor Subscription Box

Women’s Shave Club was started to provide a quality razors at an affordable price. Made with high-quality Swedish steel, their razor cartridges include moisture strips that soothe your skin with each pass.

Select from a trial (one-time purchase) or jump in with a monthly/bi-monthly subscription. Cancel your membership at any time without penalty; shipping is free for all orders, and with prices starting under $7 per month, this shave club offers everyday luxury without the hefty price tag (or hassle).

Who It's For

This shave club is marketed towards women, but many of their styles are fairly unisex. With that said, we’ll put this squarely in the “for gals" category.

Other Products from Women’s Shave Club

They also have a compact travel razor coming soon for $6.99/month.

Pros

  • You can choose between a disposable or system razor.
  • All their razors have 3-5 blades.
  • They offer a one-time trial so you don't have to commit to the subscription right away.

Cons

  • Each razor type only comes in one color option.

Shipping:

Ships to the US for free.

10. Happy Legs Club

The Best Body Hair Razors for a Closer Shave

Open Happy Legs Club Box with razor inside and three blade packs in front

Image via Happy Legs Club Cratejoy.

What’s In This Shaving Subscription Box

Happy Legs Club is a razor subscription for — you guessed it — shaving without succumbing to razor burn and irritation. They have “hers” and “his” options, both of which feature ergonomically designed razors and refill cartridges. You’ll also receive organic shave soap for a closer, more luxurious shave.

Their cartridges feature a vitamin E & aloe vera lubricating strip, and reviewers say that the razors are suitably sharp. The real draw here is the price; for less than $20 every two months, you’ll never worry about running out of cartridges.

This razor subscription ships in simple packaging, and it doesn’t have the bells and whistles of the other shave clubs we’ve covered. That’s the point: you need razors and shave soap. Happy Legs Club has razors and shave soap. Hey, whoever said that personal care had to be complicated?

Who It's For

Happy Legs Club is marketed toward women, and the razors are designed to target body hair.

Other Products from Happy Legs Club

Organic shave soap in lavender, oatmeal spice, and citrus scents.

Pros

  • This is a really straightforward subscription for those who want no fuss.
  • Their shave soap comes in bar form, creating less waste.

Cons

  • The moisturizing strip isn't as generous as with some other razors.

What Readers Say:

"I like the high quality razor and I just used it. My legs are smooth like never before.I enjoy it!" - Ewa S.

"My daughter LOVES these razors, she is hard to please so they must be great!" - Allison G.

Shipping:

Ships to the US.

11. OUI the People

Best Safety Razor Subscription for Women

Oui Shave rose gold razor, pack of blades, and shave cream group on blue background.

Image via our review.

What’s In This Shaving Subscription Box

We can appreciate a touch of luxury, and OUI the People has the luxury to spare. Their razors feature a gorgeous metal surface in your choice of matte black or rose gold, which isn’t just beautiful; the material is built to last without rusting, and the heavy feel of the metal makes precision shaving easier.

Single double-edge blades create less waste than plastic cartridges, and while there’s a learning curve, you can get an incredibly close shave with classic-style razors. The weight of the razor guides the shaving process, trimming hair without pulling it away from your skin. That means a better shave for people with skin sensitivities—and OUI the People offers online resources to help you learn how to optimize your routine.

While this shaving club requires a fairly expensive initial purchase, it’s affordable over time; new blades are cheap, and both men and women can benefit from the single-blade revolution.

Who It's For

OUI the People’s razors use single double-edged blades, so any shaver could use them. Their styling is slightly more feminine than masculine (but that’s our subjective opinion).

Other Products from OUI the People

SUGARCOAT Shave Gel-to-Milk, FEATHERWEIGHT Hydrating Body Gloss, DEEP V Bikini Line Sheet Mask, and more. Several different sets are available too.

Pros

  • This brand is radically gender-inclusive of all on the gender spectrum.
  • Safety razors are the most eco-friendly shaving solution out there!

Cons

  • More expensive upfront.
  • Single-blade razors require a little finesse and have a learning curve.

Shipping:

Ships to the US and Canada. US shipping is free for over $75; costs $5 for US orders under $75, and $15 for Canada-bound orders.

12. Bevel

Best Safety Razor Subscription for Men

Bevel Safety Razor and mini shave cream, restoring balm, and grooming oil on blue background

Image via My Subscription Addiction

What’s In This Shaving Subscription Box

Bevel is a safety razor brand founded by Tristan Walker of Walker and Company. His purpose: “to make health and beauty simple for people of color.” Their flagship product is a meticulously crafted safety razor that minimizes irritation and razor bumps. If nothing else works for you, safety razors are well worth your time; while there’s a bit of a learning curve to using them, these classic shaving tools can save your skin (literally). Bevel offers tutorials to help you establish proper techniques, so if you’re not sure how to use your razor, mix your lather, or care for your skin when you’re finished, head to their site to learn.

We love that Bevel is dedicated to addressing the needs of POC, and anyone can use their products to get a better shave. Start with one of their bundles, then set up recurring orders to re-up at a discount.

Who It's For

Bevel’s razors are unisex. Their marketing targets men, but ladies, don’t worry; safety razors work for anyone, and there’s nothing especially masculine about the design.

Other Products from Bevel

Shaving, hair, and skincare products, as well as an electric razor.

Pros

  • Safety razors are the most eco-friendly shaving solution out there!
  • Their shaving products have really tasteful designs.

Cons

  • More expensive upfront.
  • Single-blade razors require a little finesse and have a learning curve.

Shipping:

Ships to the US and Canada.

How to Get The Most Out of Your Razor Subscription Once You’ve Picked

Once you’ve picked out the right box for you, here's what you can do to help make sure you make the most of your new subscription.

  • Check for a coupon before you place your order. If you know MSA, you know we love a deal. In addition to the coupons listed throughout this article, watch our feed to catch deals that can save you a few bucks, and don't forget to check in with our reviews and subscription box directory for the best coupons before buying.
  • Be honest with yourself as you answer quiz questions. Auto-refills and replenishment subscriptions are most awesome if you can nail your needs. Take a week or two to pay attention to your routine and shaving habits so you don't find yourself with too few or too many razor cartridges and shaving products.
  • Change your razor blade regularly. The best way to get a close shave is to use a sharp, clean blade or cartridge. Razor subscription boxes are a fantastic way to make sure you're fully supplied so you can rotate dull blades out regularly without having to make a run to the drugstore.
  • Dispose of razor cartridges properly. Be a good citizen of the earth! When your razor blade gets dull and you're ready for a new one, wrap the old one in tape or paper before tossing it in the garbage. Or, if you have a sharps collection location near you, you could take it there.

 

Factors We Considered When Reviewing These Razor Subscriptions

This list features our fellow subscription fanatics’ top choices, and we can confidently recommend the subscriptions above since we’ve researched and reviewed them all. Factors we considered when reviewing these subscriptions include:

  • Overall Value - If you’re purchasing razors online, you’re looking for the best possible deal. With that in mind, we avoided services with expensive refill kits — while a great shave is worth the money, we limited our selection to services that provide high-quality blades with budget-friendly pricing.
  • Brand Reputation - We thoroughly researched each company’s reputation; every brand makes occasional mistakes, but we prioritized razor clubs that provide responsive customer support. We also included a few reviews from MSA readers to help you understand what you’re getting for your money.
  • Shaving Subscription Options - Some people shave every day — others shave less than once per month. We looked for shaving subscriptions with easy online management options, which should help you order refills that fit your lifestyle. We also included services that specialize in one-off orders.
  • Add-On Products - The right shaving accessories can make a difference. While this was a minor factor, we tried to find shaving clubs that offered a variety of optional products for different skin types.

 

We hope we’ve helped you find a razor club that works for you. Remember, if you’ve had an experience with any of the brands listed above — positive or negative — let us know by leaving a comment or by writing a review on the company’s My Subscription Addiction page.

Christen Russo
Christen Russo

Hi there, I'm Christen! I've been writing with MSA since 2017. I am all sorts of things: a writer, a mother, an outdoors-lover, a low-maintenance self-carer, and general hungry person.

You'll find me collecting stationery and squirreling away stickers, riding bikes and swimming with my family, creating outfits in earth tones and flowy silhouettes that make me feel amazing, wearing big earrings, drinking beer and asking my husband to feed me harmonies to sing, taking my vitamins, living for live music, roping everyone into a craft, being human and vulnerable, and celebrating the phenomenon of being alive.


Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.