It's time for our fourth annual Subscription Box Awards!

Each year, MSA asks for YOUR votes across dozens of categories. From big brands to rising stars, we want your picks for the best subscription boxes of the year!

Voting for the 2020 Awards is now closed. Stay tuned: winners will be announced in January!

In the meantime: Check out all of the 2019 award winners in our lists below. Whether you’re looking for a subscription to make your life easier, help you discover new trends, deliver a great value, shop for the perfect gift, or just treat yourself, we’ve got dozens of hand-picked community favorites and MSA Editors' picks to explore.

Browse 2019 Award Winners:

Subscription Boxes for Every Person

Subscription Box For Women: FabFitFun

For Women: FabFitFun

FabFitFun ($49.99) is a quarterly lifestyle box that includes top trendy picks for the season– everything from beauty products, skincare, fun accessories, and new wellness products with a total retail value of at least $200. Members also get great discounts on add-on products through their Edit Sale.

What Readers Are Saying:

The customization and add-on options put this one over the top! Not to mention the amazing variety of products. No more shoeboxes full of red lippies and liquid eyeliner! I’m lookin’ at you, Ipsy!” – Kim W

from 591 Ratings

Buy FabFitFun

Subscription Box For Men: Dollar Shave Club

For Men: Dollar Shave Club

Dollar Shave Club (starting at $5) is a well-known razor subscription service that features high-quality products at affordable prices. In addition to razors, you can stock up on toothpaste, shampoo, and more to keep your bathroom fully stocked on a regular basis. Choose the frequency of your deliveries, the precise items you want to get, and cancel at any time.

What Readers Are Saying:

My husband loves his shaving subscription & it’s not overly complicated for him.” – Gina

from 101 Ratings

Buy Dollar Shave Club

Subscription Box For Teens: OwlCrate

For Teens: OwlCrate

OwlCrate ($29.99) sends literature-loving teens a new release, page-turning YA novel each month, plus 3 to 5 unique book-related goodies.

What Readers Are Saying:

A themed box of fun stuff that uses the senses and isn’t too babyish.” – Sunnymay

from 33 Ratings

Buy OwlCrate

Subscription Box For Kids: KiwiCo

For Kids: KiwiCo

KiwiCo ($19.99) provides hands-on fun activity crates for kids of all ages, from 0 to 16+. Each age range is a different experience customized to your child's interests and capabilities to make every month a fun and educational experience.

What Readers Are Saying:

The projects they come up with are just astonishing. They put incredible thought into carrying out a theme in a really age appropriate way. My kids have discovered how tension works, circuits and gears. The projects are fun to make and turn out as described.” – Kristin

from 17 Ratings

Buy KiwiCo

Clothing & Stylist Subscriptions

Best Overall Personal Stylist Service: Stitch Fix

Best Overall Personal Stylist Service: Stitch Fix

StitchFix ($20 styling fee) is a personal styling service with options for women, men, and kids. Take an in-depth survey on size, style, and pricing, and your stylist will hand-pick 5 items just for you. Keep what you love and return what you don't.

What Readers Are Saying:

I like the pairings and offerings and how they’ve started adding on necessities for a decent price.” – Rowan

from 211 Ratings

Buy Stitch Fix

Women's Clothing: Rachel Zoe Box of Style

Women's Clothing: Rachel Zoe Box of Style

Rachel Zoe Box of Style ($99.99) features $400 worth of Zoe and her team's favorite fashion, beauty and lifestyle items for each season. You can expect gorgeous jewelry and accessories, cosmetics, beauty products, and other luxurious items.

What Readers Are Saying:

Style is on trend and well put together for every box.” – Liabc

from 206 Ratings

Buy Rachel Zoe Box of Style

Men's Clothing: Gentleman's Box

Men's Clothing: Gentleman's Box

Gentleman’s Box ($29) will help get your classic, professional wardrobe up to speed. Boxes typically include stylish accessories like ties, socks, and pocket squares, as well as grooming product samples.

What Readers Are Saying:

Great value for young men getting started in business attire.” – Kathy S

from 24 Ratings

Buy Gentleman's Box

Kids Clothing: kidpik

Kids Clothing: kidpik

Kidpik is a clothing box just for girls sizes 4-16. Each box contains 7 high-quality fashion choices of apparel, shoes, and accessories designed to complete beautiful multiple mix and match outfits. Pay only for what you keep, with no styling fee and free shipping and returns.

What Readers Are Saying:

Love everything I get in my daughters Kidpik box – great way to get stylish clothes and shoes for kids!” – slchambers13

from 90 Ratings

Buy kidpik

Beauty Boxes

Best Overall Beauty Box: Ipsy

Best Overall Beauty Box: Ipsy

Ipsy ($10) is one the most popular boxes we review! Readers love the variety (high-end and drugstore products, makeup and skincare, beauty tools and beauty products) and personalization they get from this super affordable subscription.

What Readers Are Saying:

The variety of brands and products ipsy provides can’t be beat. They really try to send products their customers like.” – Jamie G

from 1358 Ratings

Buy ipsy

Best Skincare Products: Allure Beauty Box

Best Skincare Products: Allure Beauty Box

Allure Beauty Box ($15) is a monthly box from the editors of Allure Magazine, featuring a mix of deluxe and full-size samples from mostly high-end beauty brands. Recent boxes have included some of the hottest names in the skincare game—Sunday Riley, Caudalié, Drunk Elephant, La Mer, Glow Recipe, and more!

What Readers Are Saying:

For the latter half of 2018, Allure truly stepped up their game to deliver quality skincare items for you to sample. I’ve since made some amazing discoveries that I made full size purchases of” – JustJese

from 521 Ratings

Buy Allure Beauty Box

Best for Makeup: Boxycharm

Best for Makeup: Boxycharm

Boxycharm ($25) will send you 4-5 full-size beauty products every month, curated from a mix of established and indie brands– and every box has a total retail value of over $100.

What Readers Are Saying:

Boxycharm is every makeup junkie’s holy grail” – GintareT

from 1333 Ratings

Buy Boxycharm

Boxes for All Budgets

Under $15: Birchbox

Under $15: Birchbox

Birchbox ($15) was one of the first beauty subscription boxes, and it continues to be one of our readers’ faves! Get samples of top skin, hair, and makeup products, each month—it’s up to you whether you’d prefer to be surprised by what they pick for you or to see everything you’re getting before the box ships.

What Readers Are Saying:

It’s -hands down- my favorite! Amazing customer service and deals. My favorite hair brands, I’ve find them here! LOVE IT!” – slchambers13

from 593 Ratings

Buy Birchbox

Over $50: POPSUGAR Must Have Box

Over $50: POPSUGAR Must Have Box

POPSUGAR Must-Have Box ($75) is a quarterly assortment of style, wellness, and beauty essentials curated by the editors of With a retail value of over $250 per box, it’s like getting a gift from your most trend-savvy friend every season.

What Readers Are Saying:

I can always find something I like in the quarterly boxes. It is such a good mix of really nice products I didn’t know I might like/need/want.” – Jody

from 510 Ratings

Buy POPSUGAR Must Have Box

Food & Drink Subscriptions

Best Snack Box: Graze

Best Snack Box: Graze

Graze ($13.99) offers over 100 different healthy snacks in super-handy single-serve packages. It’s a fantastic option for families looking to pack lunches or stock up on wholesome treats that are great on the go and customized to your preferences.

What Readers Are Saying:

We have been getting Graze for many years and love the small packs and how easy they are to carry out of the house” – M Williams

from 109 Ratings

Buy Graze

Best Weekly Meal Kit: Hello Fresh

Best Weekly Meal Kit: Hello Fresh

Hello Fresh ($8.74-$9.99 per serving) serves up classic, crowd-pleasing flavors, plus a few fun twists. We love that their ingredients come bundled by recipe, so that you can easily take them from the fridge to the countertop and get started.

What Readers Are Saying:

First (and only) box subscription I use. It is great!” – Sherry

from 33 Ratings

Buy Hello Fresh

Best Wine: Winc

Best Wine: Winc

Winc (Starting at $13/bottle) offers members monthly recommended wines based on their preferences and ratings for past boxes. Use their suggestions or pick anything you want from their catalog, and easily skip months online if needed.

What Readers Are Saying:

Fast shipping is the best and many wines to choose from.” – Mendez

from 18 Ratings

Buy Winc

Boxes For All Interests

Best Ethical Choice: CAUSEBOX

Best Ethical Choice: CAUSEBOX

CAUSEBOX ($54.95) curates at least $150 worth of products each quarter sourced from socially-conscious companies. This lifestyle box includes a broad variety of broads like cosmetics, home decor items, gifts, accessories, jewelry, and other self-care treats.

What Readers Are Saying:

I love how this box contributes to the betterment of the world while spoiling me rotten with high quality items.” – Lauralee M

from 94 Ratings


For Avid Readers: BOTM

For Avid Readers: BOTM

Book of the Month ($14.99) offers a curated monthly selection of 5 new hardcover books for subscribers to choose from. Pick which title you’d like to receive on the first of the month, or let Book of the Month choose for you.

What Readers Are Saying:

It is always so hard to choose between the 5 selections – every month. They do a great job curating.” – Kristin

from 31 Ratings


For Adults-Only: Heart & Honey

For Adults-Only: Heart & Honey

Heart & Honey ($69.99) is an approachable lifestyle box with a sexual health and wellness focus, filled with a variety of items from toys to beauty and gifts.

What Readers Are Saying:

Classy and beautifully curated.” – Shannon S

from 11 Ratings

Buy Heart & Honey

For Dog Owners: BarkBox

For Dog Owners: BarkBox

BarkBox ($29) has unique themes each month, and comes filled with quirky toys, treats, and grooming products picked for your dog based on their size.

What Readers Are Saying:

Customer service was on point, they made it so personable for my pupper.” – Scarey

from 89 Ratings

Buy BarkBox

For Cat Lovers: Cat Lady Box

For Cat Lovers: Cat Lady Box

Cat Lady Box ($39.99) hand picks cat-themed gifts for their subscribers each month. Upgrade to Crazy Cat Lady Box to get surprises for your feline friends, too.

What Readers Are Saying:

This is a splurge at $40 a month but so worth it!” – Esoteric Tartan

from 33 Ratings

Buy Cat Lady Box

Fandom & Pop Culture: Loot Crate

Fandom & Pop Culture: Loot Crate

Loot Crate ($19.99) delivers the perfect box for the geek in your life who loves all things sci-fi, fantasy, and fandom. Collectibles and apparel are typically exclusive and have a $45+ retail value.

What Readers Are Saying:

I gifted this to my husband, and he loves this! Every month he gets a cool shirt, funky socks, and comical underwear.” – Cocoa Gaijin 412

from 180 Ratings

Buy Loot Crate

Community Picks

Best for New Products

Best for New Products

Looking to stay ahead of top trends and discover new beauty and lifestyle products before anyone else? Our readers recommend these 17 boxes for their top notch product curation.


Best for Newbies

Best for Newbies

New to the world of subscription boxes? These brands are a safe bet for those starting out, and promise a reliable value, trustworthy customer service, and excellent overall experience.


Best Loyalty Programs

Best Loyalty Programs

Think outside the box! These subscription boxes have amazing benefits beyond their regular deliveries to your mailbox, in the form of rewards, exclusive sale offers, and more.





  1. There are so many I would like to try but the top ones would be Oui Please, Margot Elena, a Meal Kit, etc, etc etc

    • I would love to win a beauty box!

    • I would love to win any beauty box of anything, I’m a ipsy subscriber at this time im on a fixed income so i can’t afford two, would love to win.

  2. Would love to try FabFitFun! 🙂

  3. Rachel Zoe has been my #1 would-love-to-try-but-could-never-justify box for so long. The box clutch that was featured in it a while back was by far the item I’ve coveted most from any subscription box ever. I’ve subscribed to Popsugar back when it was monthly and not quarterly, though, and lately it has seemed more and more appealing.

  4. I would love the Book of the Month Club or the Winc sub box! Awesome prizes, as always. Happy to know I already get some of the other “best” boxes!

  5. I am LOVING Ipsy lately!

  6. I’m most impressed with New Beauty TestTube I’ve received three tubes so far and I have yet to be disappointed. I love the number of full size items and the impressive range of high end and K-beauty brands included. I see myself sticking with this one for a while. If I won, I’d probably choose PopSugar. I’ve been tempted by this sub, but I’ve only ever gotten one box.

  7. Birchbox, Glossybox or PopSugar Must Have subscriptions rank up there for me, as well as any of the Kbeauty boxes.

  8. I would love to try PSMH or Causebox

  9. I think I’d pick Popsugar! I got the last two quarterly boxes, but it’s out of my budget now, so I’d really like to continue it. Otherwise, I think I’d like to try Coastal Co.

  10. I love Margot Elena

  11. Would love to try fabfitfun!

  12. I would like to try BOS

  13. I love my fabfitfun box! But I would love to try Popsugar!

  14. Popsugar!
    But coastal co. seems interesting!

  15. Popsugar Must Have or Fabfitfun 🙂

  16. Oui Please would be my choice. I had some recent problem with FedEx, so I cancelled my sub, but I’d love to get OP again soon.

  17. I really like Boxycharm. I also get FFF and will recieve my first Glam Bag Plus! Super Excited.

  18. I would love the Heart and Honey, PopSugar would be my second choice

  19. I’d like to try Margot Elena. It’s full of luxurious products that I know I would love, and use all of.

  20. I would love to try new beauty test tube or fff box.

  21. My favorites are Breo Box and Popsugar. I think I’d like to try Coastal Co.

  22. My favourite is FabFitFun, but second is Causebox. Have also tried PoshBox and loved it also.

  23. Margot Elena amd IGBP

  24. If I won, I’d try Coastal!

  25. I enjoy too many subs to have a fav but I would love to try Margot Elena or Robb Vices.

  26. Causebox is my favorite, and Fabfitfun is a close second!

  27. Ipsy Glam Bag Plus

  28. Popsugar or fabfitfun are definitely my favorite on the list and I should try them out.

  29. I love Ipsy Glam Bag Plus with all the add ons and the customization. Plus, I love SkinCare!

  30. FabFitFun is probably my favorite

  31. My fave is either popsugar or fff

  32. Popsugar and globein

  33. My favorite subscription box is Rachel Zoe Box of Style.

  34. So many great ones! I’d love to try PopSugar !!! Would be so awesome thanks my subscription addiction

  35. FabFitFun, PopSugar, sometimes Causebox and Rachel Zoe Box of Style. Mostly I just really LOVE sub boxes.

  36. hearts and honey 🙂

  37. BoxyCharm and IGBP

  38. I would like to try the Pop Sugar box…have heard great things about it.

  39. Box of Style because it suits my style and Popsugar because of its curation and high quality products!

  40. Margot Elena is the best – I’d love to try Rachel Zoe’s Box of Style

  41. Pusheen for how happy it makes its recipient; Margot Elena, for how much I enjoy it myself!

  42. I would love to try PopSugar, Box of Style, or Margot Elena!

  43. My fav so far is Fabfitfun!!!

  44. Fabfitfun

  45. Causebox! I would want to try Popsugar

  46. Popsugar, FFF are favs. Would love to try Globein!!

  47. I love lots of boxes but would enjoy Popsugar to win because it always has a nice variety of products.

  48. The pop sugar one is also one of the boxes I would love to try 🤞💕

    • I’d love to get free boxes, so guess I need to start a blog. Please email me all the details on how to start. I’d love to try pop sugar and allure, and a lot of other boxes

  49. I would love to try the fab fit fun box!!!!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!