Facebook PixelBoxyCharm Premium March 2020 Brand Spoiler! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Boxycharm August 2022 Base Spoiler #1, Spoiler #2, Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4

BoxyCharm Premium March 2020 Brand Spoiler!

MSA
ByMSAJan 29, 2020 | 144 comments

Boxycharm Premium

BoxyCharm
4.3 overall rating
1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

We have the brand spoiler for the March 2020 BoxyCharm Premium!

The March box will include 6 products from 1 brand:

Fenty Beauty!

Every product in the March box will be from Fenty Beauty. The box will feature six products (including an eyeshadow palette) with a total value of $143.

We also have spoilers for February.

The choice items for February are:

Sutra Ceramic Flat Iron

OR

Karity Picante Palette

Every February 2020 BoxyCharm Premium will include:

GLOW Recipe Watermelon Glow Ultra-Fine Mist

Hourglass Ambient Lighting Blush

What do you think of the spoilers? 

Here’s everything you need to know about BoxyCharm Premium:

  • It's $35 a month
  • 6-7 beauty items a box
  • $175+ Value
  • You get to pick one of the items
  • The items will be different from BoxyCharm/BoxyLuxe - you can subscribe to both with no product overlap.

Check out our reviews of Boxycharm boxes, and our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more about this subscription.

Starting at $30.00
Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

144 comments

SquirrelyGirl

Here is the 4th premium spoiler for Feb that glamwithsuzan was talking about

Tarte base tape hydrating primer!

Reply ButtonReply

SquirrelyGirl

I re signed up for waitlist [I had previously canceled my spot on it] after watching the Fenty reveal video, not expecting to get off the waitlist in time for March.

Well, its Feb 1st…and I was removed and will be receiving Feb premium. I’m not sure if they are removing everyone like Yosef mentioned, but if I got removed so quickly, maybe others will too?

Reply ButtonReply

Courtney

I signed up for the Premium waitlist on 11/15, and they just pulled me off today (2/1).

Reply ButtonReply

SquirrelyGirl

Yay!!

I wonder if they considered me wait list from the very beginning? I was on it from day 1 but pulled myself off after my two experiences with really horrible customer service. Or maybe it’s just random…

Lesly

I signed up for the waitlist when this was released as well but did not get charged. Glad some people are though! Makes me hopeful for March.

Reply ButtonReply

SquirrelyGirl

I would have been OK not getting off the list at all, but alas, here I am with February too lol. Sending good juju that you are able to get March!

Amo2183

What I am curious about, now that there is a brand takeover with Fenty, will we get to choose a choice item still? Or are we just going to all get whatever they give us?

Reply ButtonReply

Crystal

I’m excited to try Fenty as it will be something new for me,less exciting is box value.

Reply ButtonReply

NM Sanchez

Hi, if I subscribe for Premium now the beginning of February will I get charge for the Feb box? Or will I be in the waitlist until March to get the March box? Can somebody please advise I do want Premium March box. So excited!

Reply ButtonReply

Apricot

I don’t think there’s anyway to know for sure. Reading through this thread it seems some people have been on the waitlist for months while others got off it quickly.

Dawn

That’s what I was thinking too $143???? What happened to at least $175 value???

Reply ButtonReply

SquirrelyGirl

There is a disclaimer on the website [has been there since November] that says during brand takeovers like this the value can be less than $175. It tells me they have been planning this since November. And ruby is correct… You arent going to get overinflated RV like the wooden pencils in the last box. Although, I wouldn’t be surprised if we do get stuff that is currently, or will be soon, on sale. That’s just how sub box models tend to work. I’m still looking forward to it!

RubyWooWhoo

Premium regularly exceeds the $175 minimum because they pad the boxes with low quality fillers like the wooden pencil set for $55 that cost them next to nothing and they can manipulate the values on. There will be no fillers in an all Fenty box and Boxy can’t manipulate the price tags like they normally do either, so that’s why the dollar value is lower. Don’t be fooled by the arbitrary numbers- you’ve never once received a box whose real value approaches what they claim. The Fenty box may have a lower dollar value, but it will be a better quality box.

Xtine

How do I get off the wait list tho? Email them? DM them? Twitter or FB message? Any other suggestions? I really wanted January premium and I want Feb and March too… Any suggestions how to get off waitlist are much appreciated. Thank you!

Reply ButtonReply

Vicky H

This explains why there wasn’t a choice window in February for March Premium… now we can predict when a brand takeover might occur.

🙂🙂🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Pnkl8y

I got an email with Choice dates when they sent me tracking info for my add ons.

CHOICE
MONDAY, FEBRUARY 10
Early access for the March Base box opens for Premium Subscribers and Waitlisters. BoxyLuxe Choice will open on Monday, February 17.

TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 12
All access opens for the March Base box.
.
MONDAY, FEBRUARY 17
Access for BoxyLuxe Subscribers and Waitlisters opens for March BoxyLuxe.

Reply ButtonReply

Pnkl8y

Oh I see. No premium choice. This is all so confusing.

Christa H.

👍

Reply ButtonReply

Harley

Why am I a premium box subscriber only, but my add on choices were late summersvill? I confirmed with boxycharm that I am a premium subby so I’m a little confused

Reply ButtonReply

Amy

Everyone can choose from add-ons regardless of which tier(s) you have. Most of the add-ons are options for the regular box anyway

Reply ButtonReply

Harley

I’m sorry I didn’t mean add ons. I got an email confirmation saying my choice item was late summersville?

LaylaB

I tried to make a post once, because my first didn’t show up, and I got a notice that it wouldn’t post a duplicate comment. I have no idea, Haha!

Reply ButtonReply

Mari

When do we get to choose if we want the flat iron or palette?

Reply ButtonReply

LaylaB

Choice for Feb was a couple weeks ago. Boxy didn’t send out emails, they just had the dates posted online.

Reply ButtonReply

LaylaB

Choice for Feb was 2 weeks ago. They didn’t send out emails, just posted the dates online. Sorry😐

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

That choice has already passed.

Reply ButtonReply

Sarah

If I sign up to be on the waitlist will I get the Feb premium box because I don’t want it I only want the March premium box. How do I get this?!

Reply ButtonReply

Alice

I signed up for premium at the first offering. Through this month, I never got off the waitlist. I cancelled waitlist. Realized I didn’t want to spend the extra money anyway. Good luck to you. Some people are selected for premium; some are not.

Reply ButtonReply

RubyWooWhoo

I don’t think your chances are great of getting March Premium if you wait to sign up. It’s going to be very popular and people already wait for months for a spot to open for Premium.

Reply ButtonReply

Lisa

Maybe she kept posting because it didn’t show up right away? But 10x is alittle Cray . Most I ever did was 3 repeats.

Reply ButtonReply

Lesly

😂😂

Reply ButtonReply

Angie

So I cancelled premium, but saw the new spoilers and was able to get back on premium the next day which is awesome bc I’m not excited for this months but next months is looking and sounding great!!! So anyways as I was about to cancel they said the other brand that will be in the February premium box is tarte so I can’t wait!! I love it and they said the value is gonna be $310!! Amazing!

Reply ButtonReply

Angela

All the variations are not worth the same amount! Maybe one is worth $319 another one could be something else entirely. For instance they said the Fenty premium box will be worth $143 and their minimum promised value is supposed to be $175!!

Reply ButtonReply

Amy

Same… They actually spoiled on insta that it’s going to be a tarte primer 😁

Reply ButtonReply

Jennifer

Same… I wasn’t crazy about this months Premium, but someone posted the new spoilers on reddit and I went over and reactivated mine as soon as I saw it.

Reply ButtonReply

Amberozia

🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆

Reply ButtonReply

Cady

I hope everyone complaining in the comment section cancels their subscription so I can get mine back hahaha

Reply ButtonReply

Laura

Right! So many people complain about their box. I say just cancel already. Tired of the negative vibes 😉

Reply ButtonReply

Alice

Agree. Don’t read the Macy’s box comments, I’m amazed at the negative responses, lol.

Jessica

Hehe. Me too!

Reply ButtonReply

Cady

I am kicking myself SO hard for cancelling my Premium subscription in January. I really want February and March I hope they will get me off the list again!!

Reply ButtonReply

Ash_Kay

Also, I wanted to cancel my subscription in general which ends I think in February, but now I have to continue it for another four months? Is it really worth it though?

Reply ButtonReply

Ash_Kay

I want this! I’m already a subscriber of the base box, but I do not want the January Premium box. Ugh decisions decisions.

Reply ButtonReply

Jamey

I soooooo want to try Fenty liquid lipstuck!! I just dont want to spend 28 dollars on it to suck!!! Lol. I’ve spent a lot on liquid lipsticks before and been let down so it would be cool if it’s in the box. (I’d love the bright red, but hey, I’m here to try formula and if it works I’ll buy the colors I want , if I dont get it in a box!!!

Wonder if it’s a highliter?!?! Lol. There is that highlighter pallette that has been on sephora for a long time….her pallette is on sale too… but everyone claims fenty eyeshadow are not good.

Excited to find out!! I love they put name brand items from brands I know and want to try things from instead of obscure brands with unknown quality or origins.

Reply ButtonReply

amarante

It’s not false advertising and promotion because it clearly states that brand takeovers are the exception in terms of value.

I would imagine it’s because the actual cost of the products from a brand like Fenty is more for a fewer number of items since they can’t throw in crap fillers or brands that are manufactured solely for beauty boxes which are cheap.

I’m not sure why people are complaining. Why would anyone want a box with inflated retail values for crap products like the $55 trio of wood eyeliners in last month’s Premium Box. That $55 worth of pencils was worth $0 to me and at most $10 or $15 if someone actually used cheap eyeliner wood pencils.

Reply ButtonReply

Amo2183

I agree totally. And by the way this box is being hyped up by Josef and the boxycrew themselves (and him saying this surprise will *change our life*(lol), we can most likely assume that this box will definitely be worth it. I dont think they will pump us up like this just to disappoint us. Theres just too many of us to lose. And from the base box disappointments lately, this is a huge step up. So no complaints here! 😊

Reply ButtonReply

Brittney

My only complaint is premium touts 6-7 full sized items valued at $175. Yes, I know about the brand takeover disclaimer, BUT if the box is really not going to be over the $175 mark, the least that could be done is actually throw in that seventh item that we’ve never actually received in premium yet.

To be fair, I’m pretty excited about the Fenty box regardless, but don’t think it would’ve killed them to actually include a seventh item for once to help stick to or at least be closer to the $175 value. As long as there’s decent variety in the box, I’m sure I’ll be happy with it anyways.

Ruth

My thoughts exactly. I’m willing to give up
a little total value for having everything in the box come from a brand that’s a known quantity and already has a lot of fans.

I’m on the older and more conservative side, and if something doesn’t work for me, I give it to my daughter or nieces or a friend’s daughter. If I have something from a nice brand, I feel like I can just offer it to someone by itself. If I have items from unknown brands, I feel compelled to offer them with something of known quality so it doesn’t look like I blew all my Kmart rewards dollars on impulse buys from their cosmetics clearance.

Reply ButtonReply

Rugby

Lol, you have a point. I don’t Manda Kandar valued at $30 vs something I want to try.

Reply ButtonReply

cdnlass1

So if I am understanding correctly, the Fenty items will equal $143 and then you add on our choice item and Glow Recipe spray and Hourglass blush. I think that equals more than $175 so its within the correct parameters.

Reply ButtonReply

carol ann.

Fenty is March. everything else you listed is February.

Reply ButtonReply

Sherri

Just FYI, BC has the following disclaimer in fine print on their website in a couple of locations, including on the Premium page and at the bottom of the box comparison chart: “Minimum value of $175 unless during a brand takeover promotion.” It’s also noted in the FAQs. So I don’t know that I’d classify this instance as false advertising.

Reply ButtonReply

Sherri

Oh, and I meant to add that the FAQ that says that shows that it was last updated in November 2019. So if that is indeed the case, it’s not something they just added.

Reply ButtonReply

Robyn

Ooh I’m so excited!!! I have the same given name as Rihanna so consider myself kindred 😂😂😂.

Seriously though, I really hope to try her new mascara, and hope it’s not the galaxy palette, I have that and it is super sparkles. Anything though I’ll take for $35 even if $143 not $175. It’s all fun 😊

Reply ButtonReply

Jane

I would rather have quality products at their actual price vs three wood pencil liners they value at $55. Maybe that’s just me, but I have to raise an eyebrow at some of these valuations. 🤔

Reply ButtonReply

daniellek

this will just encourage them to continue with crappy filler items to drive up the cost of the box. my January box was with a value of more than 200$ but i was really disappointed in it and only like 2 items there- got the sad eye pencil set with the crazy made up value.

i’d rather receive great well known items from a poplar brand that has very fair prices to begin with with a lower value total than get a box for of unknown brands with “an amazing value”.

Reply ButtonReply

Graziella Salgado

TOTALLY agree! I’d much rather have more desirable items at actual reasonable prices as opposed to items with ridiculously and obviously inflated price tags!

Robyn

Right, please no more QMS and Avanti.

Apricot

Agree.

Lauren

I’d like to get on the waitlist for this box without having to subscribe to the base boxy charm…. they are going to send me Jan & Feb when I’ll like to simply get on the list for the premium box…

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

You will need to do the base box sadly, that’s the only way to do it. Maybe wait until 2/1 so you won’t have to get the January box as well?

Reply ButtonReply

Melissa

God, this is such a spot.on analogy

Reply ButtonReply