Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Too Faced 2019 Cyber Monday Mystery Bag Available Now!
The best surprise is one that involves makeup, Lucky for you, the famous Too Faced Mystery Bag is back, but only while supplies last! When they’re gone, they’re gone.
The Products: "This exclusive assortment is valued at $131. If you’re looking for spoilers, we CAN tell you that your Mystery Bag MAY contain products for eyes, lips, and face."
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Is anyone else having an issue checking out? the toofaced site keeps saying that theres something wrong with my payment info. Tried 3 times and still won’t work….ugh
Reply
Carol
I might have considered this, but the Chocolate bar palette is the only one that I already have by them (and I almost never use it lol).
Reply
Caroly
I’m worried white peach pallette may be included. I JUST bought it at TJMaxx so I dont want to risk getting a double. I’m gonna hate myself when it ends up being the chocolate pallet like others are saying!
Reply
Crystal
It shows the items in it when you search. Looks to be the chocolate, bronzer, mascara, lippy and bag.
Reply
Hayley
I posted the same guesses earlier based on the pic that came up when I searched, but then it’s not really a mystery.
Reply
Redhed36
I caved. I was able to get 20% off. Paid $25 after tax.
Reply
Nancy
Where is the 20% off code?
Reply
Redhed36
I signed up for their emails. Use a different email.
Hayley
The 20% off is for 1st time purchasers and it will just pop up on your screen if you’re eligible, if you’ve purchased before you could try clearing your cache, secret browsing mode, or visiting the site from a device tibbe never used to visit the site before and it may give you the 20% pop-up. They may have disabled it because of the 30% off site-wide which is obviously a better deal than 20% off, but the 30% doesn’t workl on the mystery box.
Ara
What code did you usedm
Reply
Hayley
If you’ve purchased before you should be able to clear your cache or go to the website from a different device and get the 20% off first time purchase pop up discount code again.
Cely
How did you get the 20%off?
Reply
Redhed36
It was $35 not $25. It was my first time purchasing something so I took advantage of that popup when you first open the page.
Hayley
Maybe she subscribed to emails? They usually give you a discount when you sign up for their email list. Just a guess?
Hayley
20% off of $42 equals $33.60, not sure how you got to $25 after taxes.
Reply
Redhed36
I meant $35. My bad
Reply
Jennifer
UGH. This and the Tarte mystery bag today, not sure which one to go with!!
Reply
Amy Thompson
I swore to myself yesterday, i was NOT going to buy anything else. Especially makeup. Fail.
Reply
Julie B
I said the same thing to myself, but there I go ordering this. I get it every year and haven’t even used the bonbon palette I got last year in the mystery bag. So far this month I’ll be getting Ipsy, boxy luxe and premium, petit vour regular and plus, Allure and now this. I have not used any of the Tarte bag items yet. I’m so disappointed in myself 🤣
Reply
Hayley
Me too! I was absolutely not going to buy anymore makeup, or anything else AT ALL for myself after Friday & Saturday’s purchases. #MajorFail, I ordered this. And I forgot to cancel Boxyluxe, I thought I would have time to cancel this morning because I was just on the waitlist, but they billed me at 2:30am, so looks like I’ll be getting that, Popsugar Must Have Winter 2019 is already on its way (at the $55 price), and I got one of the $5 Fabfitfun boxes! Now no more shopping for me!!
Lori
I’m not inclined to purchase mystery bags (I buy this one and Beautylish Lycky bags), but after reading all the prior year’s reviews, I went for it last year and was so, so pleased! If you like Too Faced, don’t hesitate to buy this. They don’t give you awful colors and the value is there. I bought one as soon as I saw the headline. THANKS, MSA, I wouldn’t have seen this otherwise!
Reply
Marion
Nope. #eattherich
Reply
Anna
Yup. #donteatpeople
Reply
Rebecca
If someone Could post what they got when they receive it so we know what we can look forward to
Reply
Hayley
This is what I posted about earlier in this same thread as my guesses:
But, it’s not really a mystery if they show pictures of the items, so we’ll see!🤷♀️
Reply
Julie B
It could also be the Chocolate Gold palette
Lori
I hope this is incorrect because even though the chocolate bar palette is my all time favorite palette ever, I already have 2 from buying it 50% off at Ulta. And I don’t use bronzer.
Cassie
Ended up going for this! A little nervous since I typically consider things like this to be unwanted old stock, but I recently tossed a ton of old makeup and can use a bit of a reboot. Fingers crossed it will be nice!
Reply
Phoebe
What am I doing wrong? This is what I get when I try to check out:
Order Summary
Sub Total
$816.00
Shipping
$300.00
Standard: $300.00 (9-13 Bus. Days)
Estimated Total
$1,116.00
Reply
Phoebe
OK, I switched my browser from IE to Firefox and it gave me the right price. Thanks for the suggestion!
Reply
Rebecca
Try making sure you are on the US site. I changed to google browser when that happened to me and the prices were normal
Reply
Liz Cadman
So weird! I had that issue on a version of Safari, but it is fine on my Chrome browser. I would say try a different browser.
Reply
Sherry
Just ordered! Last year I gave to my hairdresser as a christmas gift…this year I might keep for myself 🙂
Reply
damiarassam
Try turning off your computer or phone & rebooting it. Make sure your shipping location is USA. I am going to pass on this. Too faced uses carmine in many of their shadow pallettes (a dye from female bugs). as a feminist, I want to buy only/mostly vegan carmine-free items going forward. June ’19 I got a “clean” mystery bag from bareMinerals for $60, the primer had carmine, broke me out, they pro rated refunded just that amount if I return it by mail, which I never did yet. I like too faced but not surprises. I buy past boxes when I can see what’s in them, read ingredients/reviews. Well keep us posted what you end up getting! I spent too much this black Friday (over $400usd) this week. My fun budget is depleted. In 2020 I’m doing a 40 piece project pan & #lowbuy year. I only want small travel sizes so I can use them up fast before they DOA age out. I drank an expired diet coke & it was noticablely changed for the worse, I don’t want my beauty to be hoarding, lol. All my drawers are full. My small toofaced cosmetics bag has only 7 items, four peach figs, a blush, bronzer, highlight, berry lip powder, a mini mascara, a trial size hangover primer, & foundation samples. I watch Jerrodisms on Youtube, he is awesome. Enjoy!
Reply
Hayley
My guess is the chocolate bar eye palette, a bronzer, BTS mascara, a lip product, and a travel bag with squirrels on it?🤷♀️
We’ll see if I’m right in a few days! What do you guys think?
JackieCupcake
I bet it includes the Clover palette “Lucky for you” seems like a clear hint.
Reply
Katy
I’ve wanted the Clover for awhile now! Oh I wonder, I wonder!
Reply
Emma
That would be surprising as they have that palette flagged as a best seller.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.