Facebook PixelBoxyCharm May 2019 FULL Spoilers! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Boxycharm August 2022 Base Spoiler #1, Spoiler #2, Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4

BoxyCharm May 2019 FULL Spoilers!

MSA
ByMSAMay 6, 2019 | 141 comments

Boxycharm

BoxyCharm
4.3 overall rating
1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

We have FULL spoilers for the May 2019 BoxyCharm!

If you aren't familiar, Boxycharm is a beauty + makeup subscription box that sends 5 full-size items each month for $21. It was voted the #1 Makeup Subscription Box by MSA readers, and won places in many categories in the 2019 Subscription Box Awards!

The theme for May is:

This month Make Waves with BoxyCharm 🌊😉#BoxyCharm #BoxyWaves

Variation 1 will include:

Variation 2 will include:

Other variations may include:

PUR PRO Eyelash Curler - Retail Value $18

 

Ciate London Eye Lustre Creme Eyeshadow in Ice OR Cupid

 

Milk Makeup Luminous Blur Stick

OR

Alamar Cosmetics Colorette Blush Trio - Retail Value $22

The Colorette Blush Trio is available in three shades:

Fair/Light

Medium/Tan

Dark/Rich

 

 

GLAMGLOW GENTLEBUBBLE Daily Conditioning Cleanser - Retail Value $28

OR

First Aid Beauty Hello Fab Coconut Water Cream - Retail Value $34


What do you think of the May spoilers? Which item do you want?

If you haven't signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Starting at $30.00
Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

141 comments

RoguesEn3D

I resubscribed after an 8 month hiatus and I’m sorry I did. I received an offer to subscribe to BoxyLuxe, so I took it. Not being in the Boxy world anymore I didn’t realize there is still a waitlist for the Luxe (particularly since seeing so many people unsubscribing). I felt a bit misled at being offered the Luxe subscription – and the offer said nothing about a waitlist – only to be told after signing up that they would let me know when I was taken off the waitlist and charged for Luxe.

Additionally, in times past if someone subscribed this late in the month they would receive the following month’s box, i.e. June. Instead, I was immediately charged and the May box was sent. Not only is there nothing in the May box I like, I will now be charged back-to-back since June 1 is next week. I will stay subscribed for June if for nothing else than to justify being charged for the May box that I am going to have to try to sell on ebay, but Boxycharm has just failed completely in securing my confidence again.

Reply ButtonReply

Jean

I got my first box yesterday – the Milk, the GG, the curler, Ciate in Ice and the Luna Luna lippie in a rather unwearable gold color. Excepting the lip product, I’m pretty happy! I can’t wait to try the Milk blur stick.

Reply ButtonReply

amyr

I got a horrible box!

Milk Blur
Ciate White Glitter eyeshadow (made in China)
Glamglow Cleanser – OK but I would have loved the cream
Eyelash Curler
Poop brown lip gloss that was sticky.

I basically wasted my money and stupidly bought a 6 month sub!

I am on the waitlist for the Boxy Luxe. I sure hope I can get it. It looks pretty good.

I prefer Ipsy Glam Bag Plus and the regular Ipsy. They listen to subscribers.

This box is the worst box I have ever received from any subscription boxes in all the years I have been buying boxes.

Reply ButtonReply

Bunny

The first one to receive Blur Stick! I hope I receive the stick over the highlighter palette!

Reply ButtonReply

Wanda Cardec

I actually got the same box and love it! I didn’t think I would – who wants a curler 😮- but I split it with my daughter and she was asking for one anyway so it worked out. I just got my ipsy and an add on was the pixi peel pads so between that and the glam glow I’m hoping to cut down on the oil slick my face has become 😂 still, I do prefer ipsy gbp hands down!

Reply ButtonReply

Heather

My may box got shipped out the 3rd of may and 2 weeks later I’m still waiting. I had to pay $5 shipping too .

Reply ButtonReply

Jody

I got a Mellow eyebrow defining pencil in my box. This is not shown in the spoilers. Interesting.

Reply ButtonReply

Marjory k

i received box 1 with the glam glow cleanser and dose of color in rosebud the eye liner in emerald the blush trio in fair/light and the creme eyeshadow in cupid and im pretty happy with everything

Reply ButtonReply

Deanna Whisman

I absolutely loved everything in this box except the blush palette. Its not even the right shades for my skin tone and I have listed on my profile that blush is the last thing I want. All I wanted was the Milk Blur stick. But im pretty happy with everything else.

Reply ButtonReply

Carlos

I checked the weight and mine package is 0.9 and 7x7x7. Anyone got the same? If so what items did you guys did? I really want the fab cream

Reply ButtonReply

Anne

Loved my box! Sent me all the right colors it was perfect . Should I have gotten a eyelash curler? I have plenty just curious or was
That a variation ?

Reply ButtonReply

Addie

I didn’t think I would like the Boxycharm for May 2019 but after I received the box, I was pretty excited about the products.

Reply ButtonReply

h

Ugh. I’m so fair, so I’m cool-toned, yet got this orange sandwich blush trio. The middle color is pretty, but two nearly identical oranges on me. I’ll look like a big orange Kool-Aid pitcher bursting through a house, saying, “Oh yeah!”

Reply ButtonReply

Bunny

OMG!!! I had tears in my eyes from laughing!

Reply ButtonReply

Kelly

Hands down the best box in a long time, I think they actually looked at my profile. I got the face cleanser. Blush in fair/ light, DOS lip in berry, Cupid eyeshadow stick. I also got the eye brow pencil😍😍😍. I never use eyeliner so this was a wonderful surprise.

Reply ButtonReply

Avery

I loveee boxycharm but I swear I never get what I want lol only box I got what I wanted was in April of 2018. That was the best box.
Hopefully this months box is awesome hoping to get the coconut cream lol

Reply ButtonReply

Vicky H

I got my box! I am so happy!!! I ended up getting variation #2.

*Glam glow cleanser
*Alamar blush palette in light/fair
*Eyeshadow in Cupid
*Dose of colors in bittersweet (red…I don’t like nudes or really dark colors so yay!)
*Mellow brow definer (not for me but I do kind of like the lips in this brand)

Reply ButtonReply

M smith

I just got my May box and the skincare box. In the May box I got the cleanser – the emerald eye pencil which I love because I don’t use basic black much so I really like this. I got the dose of colors in Pinky Promise, the eyeshadow in Cupid and I like it it’s pretty! Finally I also got the Alamar blush trio in fair light. I love this box and I really feel like they listened to my profile this time. Everything was exactly the colors I wanted! 🤗

Reply ButtonReply

Kenley

I received the Dose of Colors lipstick in Merlot, which is a red shade. Would anyone be willing to trade me for a pink or mauve shade?

Reply ButtonReply

Renee'

I got variation 1 and I am not too thrilled. Really wanted the Fab cream as I have dry skin and certainly don’t need another cleanser. The blush palette ugggg they are sending another blush palette in June, takes me a literal decade to pan a blush, so gifting both. Bright red lipstick, to go in the box of dozens of unused reds. Also a blue eyeliner, mailing to my sis back in 1983 lol. But hey, at least the gorgeous Ciate will be great for my daughter, she will squeal for sure. All in all a near total fail for me, but there’s always the next box 😀

Reply ButtonReply

Shannon

If I get the Fab Cream I will trade you ASAP!! 😊 if you’re interested just reply to this comment and it will notify me and we can get each other‘s info. I haven’t got my box yet but I don’t want the fab cream at all, I want is a cleanser LOL

Reply ButtonReply

Carrie

I got the glamglow as well. I was hoping for the fab cream but I think most people are getting the glamglow

Tiina T

Has no one received the FAB creme? All youtube openings have GG cleanser…

Reply ButtonReply

pinkhoo

It will be interesting to see how the blush colors look on, because in the package they are an orange trainwreck. But you can’t judge a cookie by the pan. The fair model on the Alamar webpage wearing the orange blush looks pretty awful in it. But she also looks like she’s got greasy skin and doesn’t wash it (probably too much highlighter.)

I was happy to get a pink lippie until I saw that it is matte. Matte has always been gross (corpse lips!) and now it’s even going out of fashion. It’s not front page new on any prestige beauty brand.

What… why… a green eyeliner. Green.

A new cleanser for my husband. I am faithful to my cleanser and toner.

A brow pencil to stash. It’s not an exciting product, but I will probably never have to buy a brow pencil foreverat this rate.

I’m not quitting anytime soon anyway, because someday they’ll follow the profile I filled out and I won’t get anything from this box. I only got things I hadn’t chosen on my profile.

I will try everything, though. I’ve been surprised about color before.

Reply ButtonReply

Carrie

I don’t know if this will be helpful to anyone trying to determine what box they got based on weight but the FAB cream shipping weight is 4.5oz and The glamglow cleanser shipping weight is 6.4oz

Reply ButtonReply

Natalie

FedEx says my package is 0.9lbs which is 14.4 oz. what variation would that be?

Reply ButtonReply

Carrie

Mine was .9 lbs and I got the glamglow cleanser

MJ

Well I only signed up for regular Boxy this month to get Luxe so I wasn’t super hopeful. I really wanted variation 2 (or 3 or 4 or 5 lol) but received 1. The bright pink lipstick, emerald eye pencil and metallic pink eyeshadow is trash but I have to say the cheek palette was a pleasant surprise! When applied with a light hand the colors were perfect for Summer.

Reply ButtonReply

V

FYI Elemis Pro Collagen Marine Oil is in the charm shop right now for $79 .

Reply ButtonReply

V

My card says box 2 but it has the Glam Glow cleanser, Ciate eyeshadow in Cupid, the blush trio, Dose of Colors lipstick in talk is chic and the brow pencil by mellow. I could not have asked for a better box. 🥰

Reply ButtonReply

Stef

We are box twins! My Dose of Color is Coral Crush and goegeous!!! Such a perfect summery color I’m gonna rock the heck out of. I’m thrilled with my box this month!!

Reply ButtonReply

Jennifer

Just received my box and super happy with the May box. I have to say that the May Boxy boxwas better than my May Ipsy Glam Bag Plus. I got variation number one and my box weighed .9 lb and was 7 x7x7 . I got the Glamglow cleanser, Alamar blush, Ciate london in Cupid, Dose of Color in Pinky Promise (thank you for no nude color!!) and Bodyography eyeliner in Emerald.

Reply ButtonReply

Natalie

Same weight but mine was 9x5x3…

Reply ButtonReply

blondie1021

Those are the specs for my box, I would not mind that variation at all! I get mine tomorrow.

Reply ButtonReply

Shannon

My box weighs .95 lbs, I just hope I got the glam glow!

Reply ButtonReply

liliana

i got lilly lashes in my box. I haven’t seen lilly lashes in any of the spoilers, I feel like I got leftovers.

Reply ButtonReply

Amber

U did they were in a box in a past month I got them in The style Gia or something like that I love them though wish I would of gotten them again tbh

Reply ButtonReply

RosieO

I think I got the same box, Variation #11: GlamGlow cleanser (of course would have preferred the BlurStick but at least I can use this), Alamar blush (I ❤️ the colors), Ciate shadow in Cupid, Oryza gloss, and Lilly lashes. I’m totally thrilled to have gotten the Lilly Lashes and would take them over an eyeliner any day. I wear falsies regularly but always forget to buy them so I’m pretty happy they materialized in my box! I was miffed at having still not gotten my Feb box yet but I love this month’s!

Reply ButtonReply