Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Can someone please explain how this works. If we order the box do we still get a May box? Or is this like an upgrade? I’m very confused.
Reply
HattiiJ
I had seen a few YouTubers tease some products, one was the Farmacy Honeymoon Glow, which I’ve been dying to try. If that had been/will be a guaranteed item, I’ll get the box. The other products are just MEH.
Reply
Binish
Farmacy Glow is in the June Luxe Box!
Reply
Luna
Yess! If that Honeymoon Glow serum does end up being in the box, then SOLD!!! 😀 (although I am leaning a bit toward getting this box anyways, but we’ll see how I feel when it actually launches)
Reply
MMKinPA
No FOMO here, not sorry I canceled my Boxy. This seems like a good box for someone who is just getting started with higher end skincare.
Reply
Jen
I read a comment on their Instagram… someone asked if these are variations and boxy said to check back 🤦🏽♀️ I would be not be happy if I ordered this box and received variation items
Reply
Binish
I love skincare, I’m a skincare freak and love trying new skincare products. But this…nothing is truly wow i want to try. Besides the Glow mask, I have never used any of these products and yet not at all excited for this. For how much Boxycharm hyped this box up, it is quite disappointing. Ipsy Glam Bag Plus and Allure are sending out more exciting skincare than this. Sorry Boxycharm, but for the first time, I am disappointed.
Reply
Jana
Not even tempted! Nothing here to blow me out of the Park! I have such a backlog of products, I need a WOW product to make me bite!
Reply
Jill
That is exactly what I am thinking!
Reply
Heather Bratten
Looks like a bunch of good products. And a great value. But none of it is anything i need. Now if the grapewater was a guarantee, I’d definitely be in. Looks like it’s a pass for me. But if anybody gets the grapewater and wants to sell/trade let me know!
Reply
Maria
I think I saw in earlier post about this box that the grape water was the $10 one. I’ve been wanting to try it too but that $10 inclusion won’t make paying $50 for it and a few other products I don’t really need or want. I’d rather just pick up a $10 grape water with my next Sephora order.
Reply
Nina
Meh. These are underwhelming considering how much they hyped it up. Not a single hero item in there. I get enough skincare from my BeautyFix, New Beauty Test Tube and Allure subs.. not to mention my 15-20 other subs. No fomo here
Reply
Maria
I’m so torn about this box. I really want to try the serum because I usually love Glamglow products and I have been eyeing that serum and the Saturday Skin peel for a while. I have SO many unused serums right now though. And while I don’t need it, I always love getting a good oil cleanser. Unfortunately I already have those sheet masks, the jade roller, and plenty of night creams. I just don’t know if I can justify $50 after spending the $21 for April’s disastrous box that didn’t have one thing I liked (variation #14 instead of the one I ALWAYS get—variation #1 which looked a little better).
Of course…it probably doesn’t even matter since it will either sell out early or technical glitches will ruin my chances once again. At least it’s not so awesome I would commit to a year sub just to up my chances. 😄
Reply
Christina
In love.
Reply
Joy Jones
I wanted a complete highend box skin care system of cleaner, serum, eye cream, moisturizer day, moisturizer night anti wrinkle, mask, electric cleansing brush, and a Toner. I know i asked for a lot. Im going to pass. I was all set to buy this. Boxyluxe price of $49.99 needed more time and thaught behind some brands and highend must haves.
Reply
Beth
I love the box😍😍😍😍
Reply
Becky
Easy pass. I’ll take GBP at half the price.
Try again Boxy.
Reply
Kelli McDonald
What is GBP?
Reply
Beth
Glam Bag Plus (Ipsy)
MzBev
I wish I could LOVE your comment! So true.
Reply
Badseedgirl
I am on a make-up/skincare no buy at the moment. I was considering ordering this as a Mothers Day gift for my Mom, but got her a 30 minute facial from Ulta instead. I guess this one will have to be a “skip” for me. And my “No Buy” survives another day!
Reply
Courtney
Nothing here reAlly speaks to me. Seems kinda bleh honestly. I was hoping for SR Elemis Tatcha etc… that I would’ve resubscribed for
Reply
T.Marie
Right??!! I mean surely they know the difference between what we have already used or brands that are just eh and thingsu other sub hadn’t already sent us. Do your research!! To make such a big deal and charge $50 is a big joke
Reply
Courtney
I don’t expect them to know what past subs have provided, it would be a great business practice for them to do SOME research, but I just expected something more I guess. I think the amazing deals IPGBP is able to pull off is spoiling me but as it stands that’s where my money is going
Courtney
Other than THAT Elemis that I got in a FFF edit sale and wasn’t impressed with
Reply
Tj
Value is definitely there! But I’ve tried almost all of these products and I wasn’t a fan of any of them. So I’ll be skipping but definitely a deal for someone that these products work well for 🙂
Reply
Yarp
Value-check.
Brands-check.
Boring-check.
Reply
Brittany
I think the value on this is awesome and the brands are great ones that I love! These products specifically are just ones I am SO overstocked on that I can’t justify it. Sad that I will be skipping it, but happy for everyone else who is looking forward to it! I hope they continue with these in the future!
Reply
Jill M
Hmmmmmm, just wasn’t enough to make me resub and take the chance of not even getting this box. It’s a great box, but the only product I haven’t tried is the GG super serum and I’ve heard it’s sticky feeling. Have to use up all my overload of skincare right now anyways, but good luck to everyone that really wants it!!! I hope you all are able to get this! 🙂 I will keep my fingers crossed for you all.
Reply
Lauri
Can non subscribers purchase it?
Reply
tainav
No they can not, first dibs on annual subscribers ,then after 24 hours to other subscribers.
Reply
tainav
I actually have first dibs on this,cant quite believe it.I never have first dibs but this one I ve got! I want this box really bad but I m ordering trough Shipito to Europe so the value is not the same.Postage is a lot and taxes.
Reply
tainav
Value is still there but not as alluring as if I lived in the USA. I love american boxes so much,I just want want want hem so bad.I just have to pay extra to get these fabulous boxes.
This skincare box is what I love so much,skin care:) I love boxycharm too, lots of brands I dont get here in my country.
Reply
Jessie Mendoza
I really love this but I don’t love the April box AT ALL so I’m sure it’s not worth the risk unfortunately
Reply
Maria
If you really really love it you could open a brand new account so you’d get a FOMO box (there’s a post on here about what it may include) instead of the April box. I only stayed subbed to try for the skincare box but I wish I’d just made a new account because the April box (variation #14 btw!!!) was a total bust for me.
Reply
Jessie Mendoza
The April FOMO boxes are for sure better than the April subscriber box. I don’t know what’s going on with boxy now. They were SO good for so long.
Alyse
hmmmmmmm how many jade rollers can one own……
Reply
Angela M DeSilva
Love Elemis!
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.