Facebook PixelBoxyLuxe March 2019 Spoiler #5! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Boxycharm August 2022 Base Spoiler #1, Spoiler #2, Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4

BoxyLuxe March 2019 Spoiler #5!

MSA
ByMSAJul 9, 2019 | 136 comments

BoxyCharm
4.3 overall rating
1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

We have the latest spoiler for the March BoxyLuxe box! 

Each box will include:

Deborah Lippmann Gel Lab Pro Color in Modern Love and Oh Donna

AND:

Source: beccalynn.75

Lilly Lashes (exact style unknown)

AND:

Iconic London Sculpt & Boost Eyebrow Cushion - Retail Value $39

AND:

IT Cosmetics Confidence in a Cream

In case you missed the previous spoiler, the March box will include one of the following Morphe Palettes:

What do you think of the spoilers?

If you sign up now, the February box will be your first box! (You must be a regular Boxycharm subscriber in order to upgrade to BoxyLuxe.)

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, the regular Boxycharm box is $21 a month. BoxyLuxe is a once-a-quarter upgrade option you can add to your existing $21-a-month Boxycharm subscription. So for an additional $28.99, you’ll get the Luxe items, and be paying a total of $49.99 for that quarterly box. 

Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Starting at $30.00
Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

136 comments

Dee Dee

Who else received this email?

Hey, Charmer!

BoxyCharm here! We are writing to you today with an update on your tracking email.

Because of reasons outside our control we experienced a slight delay with our boxes this month. We are doing everything in our power to get you your box as soon as possible. Stay on the lookout for your tracking email next week!

We hope that you love this month’s box as much as we do!

Thanks for being a Charmer!”

XoXo
Your BoxyCharm Team

Reply ButtonReply

Jessica

I was worried about FOMO cuz I canceled Boxy entirely after the lashes were revealed. I have none so far.

Reply ButtonReply

Emmy Lou

I have a question for my fellow cosmetic addicts: Why are so many of you against receiving items from Nyx and Morphe? Is that because you feel they are inferior brands? Or is it because a luxe box should include more expensive brands? I ask because I think Nyx has some of the best lip products that easily rival Mac and Chanel. Dior is my favorite brand for eye shadows but a very close second is the BH Cosmetics brand, which is incredibly inexpensive for some awesome, long-lasting shadows, at least for me. I’m really interested in hearing your thoughts since so many comments express disappointment with Nyx and Morphe brands. Thanks! 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Misty D Schaedig

Ooh I’m in love with the bh cosmetics carnival palette!!!!! They make some amazing shadows. It just because those are basically drugstore brands and we are supposed to recieve higher end products in the box. I like NYX as a brand it is just that it is drugstore and the Morphe isn’t high end either. Their formulas are usually patchy too. Plus we are seeing the same color scheme over and over. If I decide to go with the luxe box next month I will surely be doing a giveaway with some products. Hope this helps.

Reply ButtonReply

Jules

If you cancel your subscription, but want to subscribe again later, do you then have to go back on the waitlist for Boxyluxe or can you automatically get it again?

Reply ButtonReply

Pink5

So glad I canceled Luxe.

So far the only thing I like is the It cream.

Reply ButtonReply

Bonnie

Wow, I think I’m the only one who got excited about those two nail polish shades. I LOVE nude polish when I’m tan, and warm weather is a-coming! Those look like great pedi shades to me.

Reply ButtonReply

Virginia

I love nude polishes! No complaints here. I’m basically getting the box for the IT cream (which I use already and love). I see everything else as lagniappe.

Reply ButtonReply

Amanda

This is my first time receiving a Boxyluxe. How many items usually come in each box?

Reply ButtonReply

blondie1021

The first box was 11 I believe the second was 9. They promise at least 9.

Reply ButtonReply

Misty

It varies. Usually 5-7. I guess this time it is supposed to be 12.

Reply ButtonReply

Katie McFarland

I’m so glad im not the only one canceling/ready to cancel BoxyCharm! The last few boxes have been crap :/ ipsy has greatly improved and offers a full size upgrade so I’ll probably stick with that!

Reply ButtonReply

Linda

Literally the only thing I want is the it cosmetics cream. I really hope the last items are winners. To people saying “don’t be so negative” I think genuine critique of the box helps the company to understand what we want. If we only offer praise, even when the items are unpopular, then they’ll keep including items that most people can’t use. Critique helps a company grow and improve. If everyone suddenly stopped subscribing to boxy, but all the reviews were fantastic, then they wouldn’t understand what happened or what to do about it.

Reply ButtonReply

Misty

Well said. I agree 100%. The box thus far is crap.

Reply ButtonReply

blondie1021

I think to say the box is crap is a bit of a stretch. The cream alone covers the cost of the box. While there are items I dont care for as much a 300$ value for 50$ is not crap. If you dont like items, donate them to your local womens shelter. If the box doesn’t suit your tastes dont subscribe.

Nikki

I hate to jump on the negative band wagon because I’ve really loved almost everything I’ve received from boxy but these spoilers are a huge disappointment. I can’t wear nail polish and even if I could I wish it was a more spring color. I don’t wear lashes and I felt like we’ve received quiet a few lately. The pallet does not seem worthy of an upgraded box. The remaining two items are the only ones that might interest me.

Reply ButtonReply

Misty

I hope we get choice items this month. Variants. I do NOT EVER wear lashes and I do not know anyone who does. So I hope that is up against something else for us to choose from.

Reply ButtonReply

Amanda Spears

i LOVE THE EYESHADOW!! I will trade you if you like any of the other products

Reply ButtonReply

Renee

The IT Cosmetics cream will pay for the box, but I like literally nothing else. May cancel before even receiving my first Luxe box.

Reply ButtonReply

Apricot

Four more items to go? Maybe they will be really good.

Reply ButtonReply

Mrd

We can only hope. Usually the first couple. Spoilers are the best items. The rest is usually small stuff.

Reply ButtonReply

Emmy Lou

Please give me the pink and mauve palette. That’s my hope for this box. Otherwise, I love everything in it!

Reply ButtonReply

Misty Schaedig

I am so damn sick of getting stupid eyelashes in sub boxes along with highlighters and palettes with the same colors over and over!!!!

Reply ButtonReply

Chalet

I love eyelashes, but I completely agree with you on the highlighters and same palettes. I do NOT highlight my face that freaking much (that I would need one every month). I put bronzer as my preference and highlighter as a “rarely” and I have YET to get bronzer and get highlighter every. single. time.

Reply ButtonReply

MMKinPA

I already downgraded my Luxe. For me this is totally not worth the extra $. Most of it would be given away. (Does anyone really need another mostly brown eyeshadow palette – aside from the fact that it’s Morphe ??). I’ll save my $ and buy the It cream with a coupon if I sample it and decide I like it.

Reply ButtonReply

Alisha

I think I might be canceling boxy or at least thr luxe. Between the sudden unfair variations for February and now the not so exciting luxe. The cream and shadow are interesting, but nothing else is for me . Compared to the last two this doesn’t compete.

Reply ButtonReply

pinkhoo

The unfairness of the variations is a bummer. Yes, I got a great value, but my hopes were pretty dashed. I think I’d like the box a lot more if I didn’t know that it could’ve been useable instead of stuff I had to gift to others.

Reply ButtonReply

Nicole

That is exactly how I feel!!!! Plus for me, why did they have a quiz years ago to just NOW start going by them?! I’ve had mine filled out since day one years ago! I just want shades/colors/variations that I can use everyday & feel like im getting my money’s worth out of it! I love to share my products but lately it seems I’m giving them away MORE then I’m keeping them! & that just bugs the crap outta me to get products I’m not going to use & then see others get the products that I wanted but they wanted what I received! I am so grateful for these sub boxes but they have to take into consideration the fact that some of us aren’t able to swap our products like it’s no big deal, I don’t live near a post office & they should consider what products were sent out before! I keep getting repeat items & it’s SO nice of them to send out something after the fact but then I think “is no one really paying attention”?! Some of us cant wear bright makeup ALL the time & don’t want to! I’m just really loving my Glam Bag Plus! I’m getting products that I use all the time! I hope someone can understand where im coming from & I’m NOT being ungrateful but I don’t think it’s too much to ask for to get products that I’ll use & I like!✌✨🌹

DG

That is such an excellent point! So many people get offended when some of us complain about our boxes because no matter what it’s a great value. I agree but like you said, of course it’s frustrating when you see such disparity between the variations. Some are double the value of others and some are so much better in terms of brand, quality, or color. We all pay the same so that’s not really fair.

Now…it would be a different story if the variations were based on our profiles and preferences. I’d be fine with getting a cheaper product if it was a more usable shade or suited to my skin or hair type. Or even just my preferred category of product.

Michelle Diamond

This really sucks I look forward to the luxe box now seeing what half the box looks like I don’t even want it Only thing I like is the moisturizer I like 1 of the pallets but chances are I will get the ones I don’t like all browns don’t use brow stuff I get my nails done and really don’t care for nail polish lashes again don’t where them I would like the cover fx face pallet. Just don’t think this box is good guess it might be time to opt out for awhile and see if it gets any better.

Reply ButtonReply

Kizzie

I agree! besides the cream they could keep EVERYTHING else uggh

Reply ButtonReply

Maria

That’s how I feel. To me the first Luxe box (the one most of us got cheated out of) was definitely the best so far. December was ok but not great for me personally. Last night after seeing this 5th spoiler I canceled Luxe for March. And if I don’t see at least one fantastic spoiler for the regular box I’ll cancel that too. I’m not excited about the Cover FX palette at all, but at least (hopefully) we’ll get the one that’s best suited to our skin color.

Reply ButtonReply

Patty Bledsoe

I canceled The Luxe Box

Reply ButtonReply

Miranda

Extremely disappointed with these spoilers. So far there is only 1 item I really want and 1 that’s OK. The test I won’t even use. Hate lashes, won’t use the nail gel, the brow stuff is alright, I’ll try it at least. But when we are spending this much extra money for the box I want to be wowed… This is not a wow box at all. I’ve gotten regular boxy charm boxes I’ve liked better than these spoilers. May have to unsub finally unless the last items are amazing. I’ve been happy with the other luxe boxes I’ve received so far but this one is the worst. I just don’t see what’s luxe about this box, these seem like they belong in regular boxy.

Reply ButtonReply

Val

I really like DL’s nail polish. The Modern Love color is shown on the DL site. I found Oh Dona on HSN in the Just My Imagination set.

Reply ButtonReply

Katherine

Want that cream so bad but not any of this other crap. I think I will pass on lux for March :/

Reply ButtonReply

Regina

I hate to say it but boxy is headed down the same road as Rickys Cult Crushes

Reply ButtonReply

Dani

I think you’re right! I hadn’t even thought of that but it definitely seems that way. I’m not too upset though. I spend way too much money on sub boxes and beauty products in general as it is. I have a huge stash of unused products and now that I get the Ipsy Glam Bag Plus, it’s going to be much much easier to end my 3+ year relationship with Boxy. That sub is seriously putting Boxy to shame. Especially for those of us that like skincare as much or more than makeup. Plus they don’t have many variations and they use your profile when choosing them.

Reply ButtonReply

Jessica

At first I thought the polishes were brown, but upon looking up pictures, they appear to have a good deal of pink to them. Like…pinkie brownie nude. The pictures Boxycharm provided make them look hideous, but they’re actually nice looking.

Reply ButtonReply

Allie

I have no use for nail polish. I can’t wear it at work. So they only time I could wear it is on the weekend or time off. I don’t want to paint my nails and two days later take it off.

Reply ButtonReply

Cady

How about your toes ?! That’s what I do ! I’m washing dishes and cleaning all day so nail polish doesn’t last more than a few hours on me but at least I can have nice painted toes lol

Reply ButtonReply

Chanise

I get gel nails and toes so I can’t even use it on my toes lol I don’t even know anyone who doesn’t have gel nails that I can give these to.

Karol

I say go for it. Really, it only lasts two days, anyway. (For me, at least. I type a lot. 🙂 )

Reply ButtonReply

Angie

I’m hoping the rest of the spoilers are gonna be a lot better than this stuff. But this is just not gonna work for me just on these ones alone. They got me with the cream but lost me with the useless eyelashes, nail polish, and the eyebrow cream. Nvr thought I would have an issue with them not having a awesome box or not. The palettes ok but nothing to where if the next spoilers come out I’ll decide what to do

Reply ButtonReply

Jill M

If the other spoilers don’t do it for me, I’m just gonna opt out. I dont use nail polish or lashes. The only thing I’m actually interested in is the moisturizer. I’m hoping the box is going to include the Cover FX palette.

Reply ButtonReply

cher

Me too…..about to cancel luxe Ipsy plus is kicking BC butt!

Reply ButtonReply

Sarah

Same. I’m excited about the cream, and I’d be happy with the Morphe palette, but the others aren’t even intriguing. I hate to be negative, but with the extra money for Luxe, I’d like to at least be happy with the box, if not wowed.

Reply ButtonReply

Angie

Exactly! That’s exactly how I feel. They’ve killed it for boxyluxe for now but yeah I feel that way too! If I’m gonna spend that much I want it to be amazing! Not mediocre and maybe I’ll use this and maybe I won’t. I love them a lot but if the spoilers are gonna keep at it like this then I will unsubscribe as soon as I know everything included

Joy Britton

Oh wow. Anyone know if I cancel the Luxe part of I can add it back later, or is it back of the waitlist line? I don’t usually like to complain about Boxy, as it’s still normally a good deal for the few things I do like. But if these are the top 5 items in the Luxe box I might skip. I don’t want any of it. That nail polish is super ugly. I’d rather have 2 Ipsy Plus boxes – 10 items for $50 that are actually personalized to me. I don’t pay $50 to give stuff away or try stuff that hardly anybody wants.

Reply ButtonReply