Facebook PixelBoxyCharm February 2019 FULL SPOILERS For Two Variations! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Boxycharm August 2022 Base Spoiler #1, Spoiler #2, Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4

BoxyCharm February 2019 FULL SPOILERS For Two Variations!

MSA
ByMSAFeb 1, 2019 | 123 comments

Boxy-charm-march-2017-0002

BoxyCharm
4.3 overall rating
1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

We have full spoilers for two versions of the February 2019 BoxyCharm box!

One version of the box will include:

Source: Boxycharmsneakpeek

Variation #2 will include:

Source: Boxycharmsneakpeek

And in case you missed it, here’s what every subscriber will receive:

TOUCH IN SOL No Poreblem Primer

Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara

What do you think of the spoilers?

If you sign up now, the February box will be your first box!

If you haven't signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Starting at $30.00
Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

123 comments

NannyNancy

I’m usually satisfied with Boxycharm’s curations. I like and use most of the items every month. What products I don’t like are donated to friends and/or charities. I’m almost 56 yrs old and still get excited to try new products and “play” with them. Am I alone?

Reply ButtonReply

LuluLevar

Based on my personal spoilers, I might be getting variation #2, which is the one I’d prefer! That new coco bumbum cream is gross unless you want to smell like a stale movie theater. Regardless, I can’t imagine ever being disappointed enough to cancel. There’s always at least one item in the box that makes that month’s subscription worth it to me, and I hoard the rest of the stuff to give to my young nieces, friends, etc or hop on a trade board if there’s something in the box I want to get another of. I will say they should at least try to customize it. The profile quiz feels more like data mining than anything to do with customizing. I’m personally okay with all the variations in the boxes. I have to agree with others on the lipstick issue. More often than not, they send something bizarre. I have gotten purple and orange lipsticks and while it’s nice to test out product quality…is that really going to appeal to the majority of subscribers? Probably not. Makes me feel like I’m getting a rejected or poor selling item the vendor needed to dump stock on.

Reply ButtonReply

Regan

My spoilers say I’m getting the PV Bronze Mannikin, does that mean I get SDJ? I saw some people say if you get the highlighter you get either the face wash or face mask.

Reply ButtonReply

Aja

I’m super excited, but it sucks to see a lot of people upset that boxy doesn’t always choose the right items for them hopefully they really do incorporate the beauty quiz (hopefully better than Ipsy). For the most part I’m super happy with everything I’ve gotten from them. I’m getting the Bronzer which I was hoping for, and honestly for the price they’re sending these items I don’t see what the big fuss is about. Getting full sized items for $21 is a great deal even if they don’t all work out for you. Beats going to Ulta and walking out with 5 things that cost me over $80. I usually gift the items I don’t like to a women’s shelter in my area, they are more than happy to receive anything. Not trying to start arguments, as I see a lot of women do here, just giving my opinion.

Reply ButtonReply

Julie B

Just got an email from Boxy revealing that I’m getting the PV highlighter so I guess that means I get the variation with the lip rather than the eye stick? Hopefully the Farmacy cleanser too which is the item I really want.

Reply ButtonReply

nicole

i got the same email. I was really hoping for box 1 with the coco cabana.

Reply ButtonReply

Sharon Paige

Same here! Either box is ok with me, as long as I don’t get the masks! I gave away more than 20 of them as Christmas presents, and still have about 50 left! Fingers crossed!

Reply ButtonReply

Kenley

I just watched an unboxing video and it said that Charmers would either get a Tula Mask, SDJ, or Farmacy cleanser?? I will be livid if I get a mask over the SDJ or cleanser!

Reply ButtonReply

Tabitha

Ugh I’m getting the highlighter so does that mean I get either Tula or Farmacy?? I want SDJ!!

Reply ButtonReply

Katie

Agreed! I really hope I get the cleanser, I have heard great things about Farmacy

Reply ButtonReply

Lorrie

I’m actually kind of glad we’re not getting eye shadow this time. I have more than I will ever use now. I’m OK with the mascara. My last one is drying up. But – the Butter London we got one month was actually better, imo.
I will wear the highlighter – and if I get the bronzer, I have a daughter to give it to. Sometimes the boxes are great – sometimes not so great. What I don’t use – I give away. For the price – it’s the best thing out there, by far, still today (imo, of course).
Glad to see some will be getting the cleanser. I hope to see more like that.
Luxe in March will be very cool, I’m sure. That December “big box” was fun to open. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Dana Zapoticzny

#2 is ugh.. we need to start getting better products or I’ll finally have to end my membership ;-(

Reply ButtonReply

Marie

For the love of everything, can we stop getting this damn mascara? If it’s so beloved, why is it always free? This stuff is terrible and it’s all we get. Also, I am fairly sure we’ve seen the Pretty Vulgar blush before in a Boxycharm? Not impressed 🙁

Reply ButtonReply

TERRI GUILES

I do agree with you. We have received the Pretty Vulgar highlighter as well as a blush before and the better than sex mascara too. I think this is the first month that I haven’t received an eye shadow palette since signing up a year ago!

Reply ButtonReply

Michelle

We didn’t receive a highlighter from PV before, it was however available in the charm room for a time…

Lorrie

I’m actually kind of glad we’re not getting eye shadow this time. I have more than I will ever use now. I’m OK with the mascara. My last one is drying up. But – the Butter London we got one month was actually better, imo.
I will wear the highlighter – and if I get the bronzer, I have a daughter to give it to. Sometimes the boxes are great – sometimes not so great. What I don’t use – I give away. For the price – it’s the best thing out there, by far, still today.
Glad to see some will be getting the cleanser. I hope to see more like that.
Luxe in March will be very cool, I’m sure.

Mel

It’s not a blush it’s either going to be a Pretty Vulgar bronzer or hilighter.

Reply ButtonReply

Deloris Warren-Preast

Boxy Charmy, I used to like your box.but I’ve started to not like you so much.you couldn’t look at my profile.ever lipstick,gloss,that you have sent me I’ve have not liked.
one reason I sign with your box everyone was bragging
about how good it was.its was for few months.now now I’ve not liking as much.every moth I give few things away because I either don’t like it.ive hate product.

Reply ButtonReply

Courtney

Variation Box # 1 PLEASEEE!!! I normally get the 1st one soooo hopefully it will be the same!!! And no more dang highlighters please!!!! 😊

Reply ButtonReply

Susan

I hope to get variation nbr 1 tooo,,,,,,,I already have two products the same already in variation nbr 2 from another subscription box,,,,,,,,,,,,,this is my first time signing up,I actually didnt know anything about variations,,,,,
Susan

Reply ButtonReply

Shelley

How do they determine what box number we get? I was 4th for 3 boxes and have been getting 1st box ever since.

Reply ButtonReply

Patty

Hope I Get Variation No.1,This Time I would Like it, I have given my Daughter About Every Lip Item I Have received

Reply ButtonReply

MimiR

Ugh!!! Showing lots of items I’m not interested in. I hope they finally go by profiles. Beginning to become less and less engaged….

Reply ButtonReply

Ela Avar

I always get at least a couple things I love and use, so the boxes are always worth it for me (I get two). With all the variations, tho, it’s too early to start thinking about what will actually be in the boxes.

Reply ButtonReply

Vicky H

Hoping for #2 except with a lighter or medium toned bronzer. 🙂

I like the trestique lip products like the lip crayons…just haven’t used the glaze yet. I have a sample so either way I guess I’ll get to try it soon!

I do think both boxes are pretty darn good this month and I am hopeful for Luxe next month.

Reply ButtonReply

Beth

I really hope that Yosef is reading here! We are sick and tired of all the variations! I agree with Gina. Limit it to two or three variations and allow subscribers to choose. PLEASE Boxycharm!!!

Reply ButtonReply

Em

Amen. 100% AGREE

Reply ButtonReply

Michelle Diamond

Yes not 14 plus variations.

Reply ButtonReply

Gina

I would love to see Boxy move to a ZERO VARIATION set up, or a subscriber choice for 1 or 2 variants per month, or even a non choice variation between shades of the same product from the same brand.
Boxy used to be my favorite, but the fourteen or more monthly box versions are getting out of hand. Especially when the “variants” are completelty different products, from multiple brands, and have significantly different price points.
I’m sure Boxy wants all subscribers to be happy. I hope they do read these comments.

Reply ButtonReply

Michelle Diamond

I agree I’m so tired of these variant items I never get a product that I like or want and the color I get are the worse I have given u on ever getting a color I will wear.

Reply ButtonReply

Jean

Hoping for variation #1. I want that coco cabana cream!!

Reply ButtonReply

Shelly McLaughlin

Please please please box #1

Reply ButtonReply

Cranky Aunt P

If fortune fails me, I’m going to have to get in on swapping somewhere because I hate highlighters. I don’t think almost anyone else should be wearing them, either, chances are you probably look terrible in them. If you have some on the tip of your nose right now you look bizarre and no one has had the nerve to tell you before. Go wash it off, everyone had a bad makeup phase, that was yours, it can be over now.

I’m looking forward to trying the mascara, it’s one of the few premium ones at that price range I haven’t tried. I hope by now whomever named it has had enough couples counseling that mascara is no longer better than intimacy with their significant other, and I hope it’s good mascara.

Reply ButtonReply

Angel

I think the silver case is their Highlighter. I think both variations are getting a highlighter, not bronzer.

Reply ButtonReply

Rachel

I want box #2. I’m pale and the bronzers come in light, medium and dark. There’s no way to match them to our skin tones. I also have very sensitive skin and I’m highly allergic to perfume like smells. I really like the pretty vulgar highlighter colors and I love Farmacy.

Reply ButtonReply

Koreen

I really want # 2 because i’m as pale as a ghost so bronzers are horrible on me and I want the Pharmacy cleanser. fingers crossed. I’ve given up on the lip colors because they are always too brown or just plain red, both of which also look horrible on a ghost.

Reply ButtonReply

Irene

I pray for box #1 with the coco cream nudestix and pretty vulgar

Reply ButtonReply

Jess

Meeee tooooo!!!!

Reply ButtonReply

Lisa Krewer

I really hope I get box number 1 too! That Coco Cabana cream!!! 😍

Tera Cherie McNeil

I’m so sick of variations because I never get what I’m hoping and wishing for and one or two once in a while isn’t bad but three or more each time…meh. already the primer and mascara are a sure thing!!!

Reply ButtonReply

Tera Cherie McNeil

I’m so sick of variations because I never get what I’m hoping and wishing for and one or two once in a while isn’t bad but three or more each time…meh. already the primer and mascara are a sure thing!!! Now that I look closer, of be happy with either but think I’m hoping for#2👌💖

Reply ButtonReply