Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Very nice. BTS is one of my faves, haven’t had it from a sub in a while and looking forward to trying this primer.
Reply
Milica
When will we know which products are also included? :/
Reply
TLO
I think Boxy has decided it’s a better business practice for them to show only the ‘good’ spoilers in order to keep people from unsubbing until after they get charged for that month. Also, this way, they don’t have to list the variations that make everybody so crazy. It was bound to happen, but still a bummer; knowing what was coming just added to my anticipation.
Reply
Nicole BW
This primer works very well for me! I’m excited! February must be the month of primers bc for Feb’ s BeautyFix were getting a really expensive primer too!!!!!!!!
Reply
Marjory
What’s IGBP?
Reply
Tammy
Marjory, IGBP is Ipsy Glam Bag Plus
Reply
Vicky H
Boxypreview just posted a few possible spoilers! We may be getting more sol de janerio!!
Reply
Jen
I hope it is Sol De Jenaro! I’ve been hooked ever since I received the small one they sent. My daughter got hooked too. We have two of the body sprays, the giant tub of lotion, the regular size, two of the small, and their bath bombs… I would still be happy if I received more 🤣 I would even resub my daughters acct if it’s not the mini one again… okay we’re a little overboard but I’m hooked.
Reply
Irina
They posted bright blue jar and it smells like popcorn, nothing in common with yellow jar
AG
YES!!! This is amazing! My BTS mascara is running low and I always want/need a primer. Can’t wait to see the rest of this box!! I love Boxycharm!
Reply
T.Marie
Yes!!! I need a new primer for my pores and I love BTS mascara. I need a new one too.. I’m psyched!
Reply
Amanda C
I am so excited about February’s box. Both of those products are great.
Reply
Adriana
I was literally about to run and buy the BTS mascara. Glad I looked at spoilers first!!
Reply
Sam L
I absolutely LOVE this mascara but hate how quickly it dries out! Please Too Faced, figure out a way to keep it from doing that after 2 months of non stop usage and this mascara will forever be my holy grail.
Ahhhh .. these spoilers are making me want to stay a subscriber. I told myself the beginning of this year I was done with subscription boxes until the summer time. No FOMO here because I can just buy this stuff if I want but I mean, who doesn’t like to save money!!
Reply
Virginia
You can buy minis from Sephora. Its better than buying a full tube that dries out. That’s what I do!
Reply
Amanda
I need a couple more spoilers to determine if I’m going to keep my sub. for February or not. I could always use a new primer but I dislike that mascara!!! Any idea if these are variants or will everyone be getting them?
Reply
Renee
Everyone gets both.
Reply
Anne Engebretson
I’m wicked excited for both these spoilers. I need a new primer asap and I wasn’t especially impressed with the It cosmetics mascara we got a few boxes back and I hear great things about this one. I loved this months box. I’m using everything except the liquid lip. I got the dark ofra/Kathleen Lights collaboration. Waaay to dark for me. But I handed it off to a friend with dark skin and she loved it. I got the volume three pallet, I thought I wanted sizzle until I started using vol three. The colors are so easy to work with and are mega compatible with each other or you can mix with another pallet. Either way-magic!!!!!
Reply
Courtney
I haven’t tried this primer although I have several samples of it. Both my Jan boxes were far better than the entire last year of regular boxes even though I got two of the same palettes. A bit tired of all the shimmer eyeshadows but these Tarte ones are actually useable for mature eyes. Finally got two great eyeliner colors and two wearable lip colors that weren’t poop brown. Still don’t care for hair care no matter how many times they send me the same product but the rest of the boxes were a hit and I’m SO happy to see so many new and great brand additions to BC. Elemis, Tatcha, too faced…. IGBP has been the better value for sure but I’ll be hanging onto both for a while yet.
Reply
Jenny
Same
Reply
Marjory
What’s IGBP?
Reply
Bella01
Touch in Sol has awesome reviews. Excited About the spoilers.
Reply
Megan W
Omg so am I. I love Touch in Sol! And who doesn’t love anything from Too Faced? I’m stoked.
Reply
Yosef Martin
No variations on those two items ladies. The BTS and the TIS primer are going to every charmer.
Reply
Kimberly
Mr.Martin You are an entire snack 😂😂
Reply
Nicole BW
Thank you Joe for personally answering! These are great products & I can’t wait to enjoy them! God bless
Reply
Lexie
Thank you!!! I was scared the Primer wasn’t🙏🏻
Reply
Lawden
Oooh helllloooo Yosef!!!! You are one beautiful man😘💞💘
Reply
Melanie
Wow. Thanks for the reply! Wanna give us a third spoiler? 😀 Also, the January 2019 box is spectacular!
Reply
JoannaNYC
Thanks for confirming. I was just asking myself this question! Great spoilers so far for Feb!
Reply
Angie H
Thank you Yosef! I am so happy those are not variations. That primer has amazing reviews, I’m excited to try it.
Reply
Dawn
Thank you Yosef. Boxy is killing it. So excited for these 2 products. My birthday month’s box is going to be Awesome. Thank you.
Reply
Cassie Lawrence
My bday is February 7th!
BELINDA FREDD
Concerning the birthday box: Do we get a special box for our birthdays??
Mine is Feb 1o and I was jus wondering wandering what do you have to he a birthday special box . I would like one.
Pamela Woodfield
Will they both be in all the Luxe boxes as well!?
Reply
Dehlila
Luxe is every 3 months (so not until march) these spoilers are for Feb!
Snowhitetwin
Wow a comment from Yosef himself!!
Reply
Pink5
Not excited about either. I don’t use primer and have tried the BTS and been underwhelmed.
Looks like it’s time to cancel.
Reply
Nenia Haven
I am not interested in either spoiler. May skip out on the Feb box.
Reply
Madasen
I have not yet subscribed to BoxyCharm but I plan to. I would like the February box to be my first because the January one doesn”t really interest me that much. When should I subscribe to ensure that my first box will be the February one?
Reply
Reidy
February. You get the box the month you sub providing they have some left. So if you sub end of Jan and they still have boxes- you get the Jan box.
Reply
J L
That primer didn’t do much for me and I returned it.
Reply
Tammy
Ive tried this primer and it also did nothing for my large pores. It actually made them more obvious.
Reply
Alisha
Like the spoilers so far ,but have learned to not get to excited until the box comes . So many variants pop up once boxes start arriving .
Reply
Whitney Earl
Yosef just commented above saying all charmers will get the 2 spoilers thus far. So you can count on getting the TIS primer and the BTS mascara. =)
Reply
Tera McNeil
Boxycharm, I love you and have been with you over a year but PLEASE stop all of the variations. It is such a let down when you really want what may or may not be in your box (usually what I want is not in there). I could never let my Boxy go, I did the Boxy Lux but I just have too much product to use that I opted out of that one for a bit, but listen to the feedback…. people are not happy with so many variations, some here and there ok, but it is too many lately and I am not one to complain. I complain about the people who complain, lol.
Reply
Ryan
I wholeheartedly agree with this! and I’ve said this so many times myself (here & on diff forums)
Reply
Tera McNeil
I am currently using Too Faced BTS Mascara and an extra never hurts! I LOVE to try new primers & this one has been on my list so I am excited to try the No Poreblem Primer!! No matter what I let go of, what I cancel, current No Buy…. I can’t let go of my Boxycharm.
Reply
June
Yeah! I need a new primer and this one looks interesting. Really hope we all get to try it!! I think this is the type of product we all should receive. Variations in lip and eye colors don’t really bother me, because it’s sometimes nice to try something out of my comfort zone in lipsticks, liners, shadows, etc.
Reply
Whitney Earl
Yosef commented above saying all chamers will get both the primer and the mascara. =)
Reply
Jen
Is this a variation??
Reply
Gina
This primer is great, if it’s FULL SIZE & not a sample size. If everyone gets it. January was such a disappointment for me – first time in a year of subbing that Boxy was a let down.
Reply
Tera
Awe, that is a bummer. I thought there have been worse boxes over the past year. What was it that made it so bad for you? I am really excited about this primer too!! It says 1 fl oz, and that is the full size at Sephora for $18.
Reply
Gina
I don’t care for the BTS mascara at all. For January – only 2 products are something I needed or would use (masks & brow pencil), compared to past boxes where there might be only be one or two I wouldn’t use & loved the rest. The travel size conditioning spray is unimpressive when compared to the full size received in IGBP. I also received the Ofra lip color that’s a muddy rust color. It’s just not for me anymore. I may try to only sub months that are Luxe, as those continue to be impressive. Boxy was so awesome for the past year, but it seems the regular monthly sub boxes have gone downhill. Too many variations on quality, color & value… plus they are definitely not concerned with individual profiles.
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.