Gentleman’s Box Subscription Review + Coupon – October 2018


This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Box Review Front

Gentleman’s Box is a monthly subscription box for men “providing the essential elements suited for today’s gentleman.” Every delivery follows their saying – Look Good. Feel Good. Be Good. – and their items will fall into these categories.

This is a review of the Monthly Subscription, $25 a month, box.

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Box Open Zoom Top

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Box Open Top

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Box With All Products

About The Gentleman’s Box

The Subscription Box: The Gentleman’s Box

The Cost: $25.00 a month + free US shipping

COUPON: Save 20% off your first box with coupon code MSA20

The Products: High quality, unique men’s accessories

Shipping: the US for free and International, their FAQ page says that there is an additional charge outside of the U.S.

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 “Mystery Murderer” Review

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Mystery Murderer Booklet Front

The theme this month is ‘Mystery Murderer’. I hoped that would refer to someone who murders mysteries by solving them rather than someone who commits murders mysteriously, as one of those is a gentlemanly aspiration and the other is most assuredly not. However, it actually refers to an undisclosed member of the cast of Clue, whose identity you are encouraged to guess on their website to win a premium box.

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Mystery Murderer Booklet Open

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Mystery Murderer Booklet Back

The booklet is very informative, featuring detailed descriptions and high-quality color photos of each item in the box as well as a personal message from Alleigh, the Gentleman’s Box content creator. There a few other fun things in the booklet too, like a mad-libs page, a member profile and a deal of the month (this month it’s on J. Ciro watches and cufflinks).

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Flyer Front

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Flyer Back

Also included is a flyer for Tastingroom.com which allows you to save $30 on a wine tasting kit.

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Kurt Mayo Tie 1

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Kurt Mayo Tie 2

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Kurt Mayo Tie 3

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Kurt Mayo Tie Model Wear

Kurt Mayo Tie – Listed Value $40

I love a woven tie! It adds extra detail and texture to a formal outfit, which can often be sorely needed when dressing for a swanky party. The mustard color (hint hint!) pops very nicely against blues and neutral greys. I’d say this was a little too fancy and colorful for normal office attire, but it’d be perfect for a special occasion.  

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Circle Socks 2

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Circle Socks 1

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Circle Socks Model Wear

Circle Socks – Listed Value $15

These are great quality (75% Cotton, 22% Polyester, 3% Elastic) socks with the pattern going all the way to the toe. According to the booklet, the design on these is supposed to be a lightning bolt but it looks like lots of little staplers that are bent backward to be refilled. These also feature prominent mustard tones (hint hint) that offset the grey and white making for some nice 60’s style flair.

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Lord of Ties Lapel Pin Pack Front

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Lord of Ties Lapel Pin Pack Back

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Lord of Ties Lapel Pin 1

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Lord of Ties Lapel Pin 2

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Lord of Ties Lapel Pin Model Wear

Lord of Ties Lapel Pin – Listed Value $20

I really like this and it’s not something I would ever think to buy on purpose! It slots neatly into the buttonhole on any suit jacket lapel and would be a great way to signal your identity to a blind date. It both compliments the included tie and can add the intended texture and pop in the tie’s absence if both seems like too much of that color.

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Travelling Gentleman’s Boutique Tie Bar 1

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Travelling Gentleman’s Boutique Tie Bar 3

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Travelling Gentleman’s Boutique Tie Bar 2

Travelling Gentleman’s Boutique Tie Bar – Listed Value $25

A quirky little clip that adds another nice playful detail to a formal outfit. It doesn’t quite reach all the way across the tie but has more than enough grip on the shirt placket to hold it in place.

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Beeyardo Shaving Cream 1

Beeyardo Shaving Cream

Not too strong smelling and not harsh on my skin, this has been a pleasure to shave with! A little goes a long way so this tiny sample size will probably last for weeks.

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Smartypants Gummies Pack

Gentleman’s Box October 2018 - Smartypants Gummies Open

Smartypants Gummies – Buy a 30-day supply for $29.66

Two soft gummy vitamin candies from the ‘Men’s Complete’ collection. They’re chewable and easy to eat, but while they’re supposed to taste of lemon creme, blueberry and blackberry they also have that strong oily taste that everything loaded with omega 3 has. I’m sure they’d be very good for my skin if I was able to take them consistently, a sample size of two doesn’t allow me to test that though.

Verdict: This month’s theme was a little heavy-handed for me (can you guess who all the mustard colored things refer to?) and the associated color a little garish, but the items in this box are all high quality and of a particular style that can just as easily be used in unthemed situations, such as taking your mother for a nice meal, or going to see a friend in a play like a gentleman should.

Not including the samples, this month’s value totals $100. The tie alone is worth more than the $25 monthly fee so this is a very good value box. Great for building up a collection of sharp looking accessories for all occasions!

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Yes. From Gentleman’s Box:

All orders placed on the last day of the month by 11:59 PM Pacific Time will start you with the current month’s box.

Coupon – Use coupon code MSA5 to save $5 off of your first box!

Value Breakdown: This box costs $25.00 + free shipping, which means that each of the 4 items in the box (not including the samples) has an average cost of $6.25.

Check out all our Gentleman’s Box reviews and the Men’s Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What did you think about the October 2018 Gentleman’s Box?

Written by Bob Shields

Bob Shields

Bob is an engineer, photographer and podcaster who’s focuses include technology, food, art and popular culture. He can be heard analyzing the movies and performances of Charlize Theron and Keanu Reeves on two podcasts, Theronathon and The Keanu Review. Among others Bob enjoys Sprezzabox which furnishes him with stylish accessories and interesting little trinkets that he wouldn’t otherwise think to buy for himself.

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.

Posted in Australian Subscription Box Reviews, Canadian Subscription Box Reviews, Gentlemans Box Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Men, UK Subscription Box Reviews| Tags: Gentleman's Box | 0 comments

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!