Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
The “cake frosting” scent is very heavy and fake. Petal Pusher is darker than I originally thought, but since it is matte, I can’t decide if I like it.
I’ll give it a try in a few days after the weather settles down and I’m not so sensitive to fragrance.
Reply
marjory
i just got mine today and got the laura geller blush in tropic hues and the hank and henry in petal pusher and the wow eyeliner
Reply
Shay
This is my first Boxycharm month. I got an “it’s on the way” email but is there any way I can find out what products I got in advance?
Reply
Brandi
Got my luxe today ! So much stuff ! I wish I could post a picture! I got grande lips in rebel raisin 😔 I have it away already…. and photo finish in serene greens it smells like a green juice .deth valley dry shampoo girlactik highlighter…anyone know about the brand ? The park ave pallet is so pretty . This box makes me so happy !
Reply
lily
I just received my box and got #1A. I didn’t even know they had “letter” variation boxes
Pretty Vulgar Eyeshadow Palette
Laura Geller Baked Blush -n- Brighten: Tropic Hues
Alamar Brush Set
Hank & Henry Liquid Lipstick: Petal Pusher
Butter London Glazen Lustrous Liner
All in all I am happy with this box. And I’m happy to not receive a lip color that looks horrible on 99% of people.
Reply
Pink5
I got variation 2, so LG blush, Hank & Henry Lip, Butter London roller liner.
The LG blush is not as candy pink as the photos show; the texture is a bit crumbly and it’s VERY sparkly.
The Hank & Henry lip is a dark rose, I’ll have to see how it looks on. The scent’s a bit much, but I am not a fan of scented products.
The Butter London is meh. I wouldn’t mind so much if it had shipped in a color other than black. I have enough black eyeliners in various forms to sink the proverbial battleship.
More brushes I’m always happy with as well as color palettes.
Reply
Rhiannon
Looking for the Girlactik highlighter. Who wants to swap?!? 😍🙋🏼♀️
Reply
Amy
I am seriously thinking of canceling boxycharm and it hurts my heart to say it. There are just way too many variation and keep wishing for things they don’t send me. I loved my box for the past year, except when there are variations on pretty much everything. I didn’t mind when it was just one of two or three shades of lipstick or a blush by one of two companies but it’s getting worse.
I get that they are trying to eventually be customized, but that isn’t what made them so populat in the first place! It was the value of the box and getting to try out new things and find products you love. Instead of being excited when my box arrives I’m just dissapointed because I didn’t get what I really wanted.
Reply
Nichole
Does anyone know when they usually ship point purchases?
Reply
Cady
I got box #3 (a dark raspberry red lorac lip & Laura Geller blush) wow this box was sooo good! The eyeshadows are amazing, the brushes are good (the blending one makes a bomb highlighter brush), the lipstick goes on opaque and doesn’t dry out my lips and the blush is sooo pretty! Overall I’m
Pleased and not the least upset over missing the luxe box now.
Reply
Christine G
I got the sneak peak email which says I’m getting the Girlactik duo, which is what I was hoping for. However- after watching some unboxings that were supposed to receive the Girlactik actually received the Laura Geller blush. Now I’m pretty concerned! I have yet to watch an unboxing or read a review by anyone who received the highlighter duo. Really hoping that isn’t the case for everyone!
Reply
melissa
I too have been wondering why no one seems to be getting the highlighter – was thinking about re-subbing just for that but they are in hardly any of the boxes??
Reply
Rochelle
I was sent an email saying that I’m getting the Galatic. I haven’t received my box yet so I don’t know. I’m not a fan of Laura Geller anytime so I’m hoping for theGalatic product which is exactly what I’m hoping for. I’ll let you know.
Mommy
I got the luxe box and it arrives tomorrow. Mine has the girlactik duo
rochellepizza
Hey Christine
I was also told that I’m getting the Girlactik duo. Which I’m very excited about. I noticed that many Charmers have received their box. I’m getting the Boxyluxe box, but I haven’t received mine yet. Have you gotten yours, and which box are you waiting for?
Reply
SP
I signed up for Luxe and got my box today. I was signed in to my account and refreshing the screen where you edit your subscription at 9AM EDT when Luxe launched. I was able to hit the “upgrade” and got an email confirming the additional charge at 9:04 and got an email at 9:06 confirming Luxe. I got the email to upgrade at 9:07.
Anyways, in my box:
Headband $4.99
Alamar Ojitos Brushes $18
Juice Beauty Anti-Wrinkle Serum $80
Luxie Airbrush Brush $38
Grande Liquid Lipstick- Rebel Raisin $25
Ipanema Glow Oil $35
Smashbox primer water- Citrus $32
R+Co dry shampoo- travel size $17
Pretty Vulgar Nightingale Palette $35
Girlactick Glow Duo $26
Tarte Park Ave Princess Palette $45
Prices listed are what’s shown on the enclosed card.
Reply
Alex
I just got my box and I got varient #1 and I’m so pleased. My blush is in Tropical Hues and my Lorac lippie is in orchid. I love the pallet and brushes!
Reply
Nichole
Just received my luxe box in the mail today! This is the earliest I have ever gotten my box and it was via fedex which was different.
I received the Laura Geller blush, a violet Voss liquid lip in the color tryst (pink color), coconut smashbox primer, and the juice beauty moisturizer! I’m super happy with all these products
Reply
Sara
My box just appeared today, I never even got a shipping email or anything. I got Laura Geller blush, I was praying for this!! I love their blush, it’s my favorite!! I got the Hank & Henry Liquid Lipstick, it’s a gorgeous shade; but not super matte. I got the Butter roll on eyeliner which I’m a little excited to try. I’m happy with this box, it’s very usable to me.
Reply
Tanya M
Nice! I cancelled on the 31st and now have FOMO.
Reply
momo
im getting the grlactik(wanted!), but that must mean im NOT getting the hank & henry 🙁 my boxes usually arrive saturdays, hope that its here tomorrow and not late next wk… i havent received any tracking info. i figured there was no tracking email bc BC is so backed up from BL promo/release.
Reply
Jacqueline
What shade is the Hank and Henry?
Reply
Jana
The shade is “Petal Pusher” and it is my favorite thing in the box! I have at least 30 different lip products between all my sub boxes and the last MAC Mystery haul, so I don’t usually get too excited about them, but Wow, the color, the lasting power, the smell, and the packaging all blew me away! I have been wearing it since I received it on Thursday. Lasts just as well as my Kat Von D and not quite as matte. It even has a bit of a shimmer. I LOVE it!
Julie B.
Well, that’s funny! FedEx just delivered my Boxycharm! First of all, fedex instead of usps…and I hadn’t gotten a “your box has shipped” email. Plus I always get mine late in the month!
Anyway, I am happy to have variation 2 which is the Laura Geller blush, stroke of Wow roll-on eyeliner, and Hank & Henry lip in Petal Pusher. Amazingly, the variations I was hoping for. And I almost always get box variation 1.
Reply
Jana
My box as well and I am so happy! I needed a replacement blush for my Hourglass and the Laura Geller fits the bill!
Reply
MzBev
What variation number is on your card? I usually get 1, but sometimes will receive #2.
Reply
Julie B
That’s why I mentioned it. I almost always get box 1, but this time it’s 2 according to the card. The only other time I didn’t get 1 was that time with all the colourpop variations.
Victoria Mickle
I’m getting the LG if someone wants to trade for the girlactick
Reply
Alex
I would! Do you know what color. I got the Laura Geller in Tropical Hues. I’m on the swap site
Reply
Victoria Mickle
Hi! I haven’t received my box yet
rochellepizza
I didn’t know that there was anything called a swap site. Can you please tell me about it.
Thanks
Chrissy
I’m a little bummed I’m getting the baked blush— I already have a small one from ispy I never used much of. But, hoping I get that eyeshadow primer because I just ran out and was wondering if I should buy the same stuff or try something new— perfect timing, I hope! As for the lipstick, I saw on IG they swatched this pretty Hank and Henry one and it was kind of a berry color. Fingers crossed for that one. :B
Reply
Gemma
Hey Chrissy 😊 I have never used this eyeshadow primer, and I got it, haven’t touched it because I watched a video on it and it doesn’t seem right for me. Typically I use white concealer.
Anyway, if you get either eyeliner or just about ANY lipstick besides the GRANDE, I’m open to considering one of those instead of the eyeliner, or even something else. Please do let me know at Yahoo, capitals don’t matterit’s my name without spaces:
Gemma Di Marco
Thanks either way!
Reply
Rochelle
I don’t know what kind of eyeshadow primer you’ve been using, but I’ve been using the original Urban Decay ES primer it’s really great. It’s expensive, but you only need a very small amount of product.
Reply
Michelle
Yay, I am getting the blush! Sure I don’t always get what I want, but for $21 a month if I only get one thing I want it’s worth it. I give my family , friends and kids the things I don’t use…I love boxycharm! Can’t please all the people all the time.
Reply
Sky
I am getting the Laura Geller blush. Anyone wondering if BL is giving sneak peak, I got in with Boxyluxe and I got the email for the blush. I would love to trade for the girlactik duo if anyone wants to swap I’m on the swap page!
Reply
Toni Marie
Im also getting the laura geller blush. I never tried her products before. Hopefully it works very well. Im excited to try something new.
Reply
Courtney
Same here so I am super excited!!!
Cecilia
I’m getting the girlactik skin-glow-duo hope it will be good
Reply
Misti
me too and it is what I wanted
Reply
Lucy
Me too. I don’t have anything in those colors, I’m excited to try them on.
Reply
NicoleM
don’t think I’m going to like the blush much ( tropic hues) would anyone with the highlighter be willing to trade? And what color are you getting 🙂
Reply
Sheri Wilcox
I’m getting the Laura Geller Baked Blush in Tropic Hues and was hoping for the other. Anyone interested in trading? I’m at grs357 at yahoo dot com.
Reply
Dana
I’m getting the Laura Geller blush and would love to trade for the Girlaktic. I’m active on MSA’s swap site and have 100% feedback. (I can link to my profile when I’m back on my regular computer.)
Reply
Courtney
My response to this mornings spoiler email: ow do you always manage to give me EVERY variant that I DONT want? It’s happened every single time since I subscribed. I mean it defies the odds that EVERY variant would be the one I absolutely have no use for! Shouldn’t I get the one I wAnt 50% of the time or do you guys truly have little elves secretly working to screw me out of the Lux box and ensure I hate every variant item I ever get but tease me with ones I really do want so that I keep spending my money every month on boxes that I mostly give away? If so your business plan is brilliant if not I’ll just take it as proof I’m truly cursed.
Reply
Sandi
Lol same 😂😂😂😂😂 OMGOOOOOODNESSSSSS chica we are cursed!! 🤷♀😩🧟♀👻😉
Reply
KristenKay
That’s funny. I’m okay with the LG but I don’t want more eye liner but I’m guessing I’ll get it. Also didn’t get the luxe box either, I don’t care anymore but still annoyed with the hype and the roll out. I like Boxy for the value but lately it’s been half the box I don’t want. At some point the value will no longer outweigh the disappointment.
Reply
Gemma
Hey Darlin’! I would so LOVE to trade with you for something you may want if you get an eyeliner, either one! I have 2 BoxyCharms, I also get Glossybox, ipsy, Yogi Surprise and a couple others, so I have a treasure of new, untouched makeup!
Let me know please! Yahoo is where you can find me, no spaces and caps don’t matter, it’s my name: Gemma Di Marco
Thanks!💜
Selina
Funny for me too! I got a sneak peek email today for my Boxyluxe and it contained the girlaktic duo BUT I was hoping for that LG blush, cannot win!
Zsuzsana
This is me 100%!! Screwed out of the luxe box, and I always get the one variant I don’t want! This time I am getting the blush in the only shade I already own! Maybe it’s time to call it quits…I renew in December
Reply
Misti
I made the hard choice to quit Boxy Charm have not been to impressed with the lasxt few boxes just subbed to get BoxyLuxe and then didn’t get 1.so I sent them message why.
I also stated in email to Boxy that I personally think that those who got Luxe in Sept shouldn’t get a Dec.1 and it should be rotated until they get their sub together .I get life isn’t fair but I am guessing they had 2,000 boxes for a million people good luck ever getting Boxy Luxe
Maria
I feel the same way, I get 2 boxes. One I tried to upgrade that I have had for over 3 years, and one I created recently so I could still get all the regular items since Luxe wouldn’t have all five. Plus I was desperately hoping to get something other than variation #1 which I have been getting 99% of the time I have been subscribed, Of course I wasn’t able to upgrade and now I have previewed both boxes and they’re likely going to both be exactly the same, both #1. So I am getting 2 LG blushes when I really wanted to try the Girlactik. I feel like I get the worst variations every time. I think variation #1 is the most common one, the one that has the biggest and oldest brands because they can probably get the best deal and the most inventory from them. I get that but why not give everyone to try the newer stuff frim the newer brsnds? Just rotate who gets what variation. So now with a second box I am getting double the products I will get rid of. I know the LG blush is a good product but it’s been around forever and I really wanted to try something new. I’m definitely canceling the 2nd box now, and if I don’t get the Luxe box in December I will cancel completely.
Reply
Heather
Same! 🙁
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.