Facebook PixelPlay! By Sephora September 2017 Box #870 FULL Spoilers! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Play! By Sephora April 2020 FULL SPOILERS!

Play! By Sephora September 2017 Box #870 FULL Spoilers!

MSA
ByMSASep 15, 2017 | 117 comments

Screen Shot 2017-02-18 at 9.12.22 AM

Play! by Sephora
3.8 overall rating
564 Ratings | 55 Reviews

We have full spoilers for the September 2017 Play! By Sephora #870!

Play! By Sephora Box #870 will include:

Source: Instagram

Play! By Sephora Box #704 will include:

Source

Play! By Sephora Box #514 will include:

Source: Instagram

Play! By Sephora Box #506 will include:

Source

Play! By Sephora Box #051 will include:

Source: Instagram

Play! By Sephora Box #555 will include:

  • Gimme Brow Volumizing Fiber Gel
  • Laura Mercier Velour Lovers Lip Colour in Happy
  • Belif True Cream Moistrizing Bomb
  • Stella McCartney POP
  • Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner in Black
  • DevaCurl Melt Into Moisture Matcha Butter Conditioning Mask

Play! By Sephora Box #498 will include:

Source

Play! By Sephora Box #912 will include:

In case you missed it, we also have the full reveal of all items sampled in the September Play! By Sephora box!

Makeup:

Each box will include one of these items:

Skincare:

Haircare:

Fragrance:

What do you think of the September Sephora Play spoilers? 

Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

Starting at $10.00
Subscribe Now
PLAY! by Sephora is a monthly beauty and makeup subscription box. Each month, Sephora sends you a mix of six samples (including cosmetics, haircare, skincare, fragrances, and other beauty products) personalized to match your preferences and a PLAY! BOOK of tips and tricks.
MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

117 comments

Casey

Is anyone emailing Sephora to tell them you’re not happy?
I know most emails will get the brush off, but if enough people sent one, they might notice a trend.

Reply ButtonReply

Geena

I called – they really don’t care. Nor is there anything you can do about your profile to get a box you might be happier with they will tell you.

Reply ButtonReply

barbara M

I just got the #September SephoraPlaybox ,mine was #555 and I usually like almost everything, but I have to say I hated everything in this one. The perfume was the same as 100 others I’ve smelled. The deva curl mask would be great if my hair wasn’t stick straight. I never wear eyeliner, let alone liquid black and the red frosted lipstick is horrible. The only decent thing was the belief moisturizer but I already own a full size one. Sorry sephora but this was all work and no play 🙁

Reply ButtonReply

Geena

I got #506 and #555 was one of my box envy boxes!

Reply ButtonReply

Bwitched

I’m 704 I have medium skin, blonde hair, brown eyes with combination skin I have aging, uneven skin tone, dullness, puffy eyes checked and I have fine, straight hair that needs volume but is also dry and damaged from chemical treatment.
How did they throw me in the same box with light skin toned redheads? After reading the profile of the person who received an 870 it seems that box would’ve been more on with my profile. We’re almost twinning except for the some of the hair. I’m now more confused than before 😒

Reply ButtonReply

Toni

I think our only differences are hair color ,hair texture and the color of our eyes

Reply ButtonReply

Bwitched

You’re right! Except for the blonde hair, brown eyes and wavy hair our profile is the same. So how did I get the same box as light skinned redheads? Although it seems like the box isn’t a good choice for them anyway. Sephora, what is up?

Jen

904 pics are posted on Reddit.
Briogeo, the wander lipstick, the green algenist, touch-in-sol, fresh face cream, and sephora liner.

Reply ButtonReply

Maddy

Ugh, I got 904 & both skincare items are the complete opposite of what I need. I have oily skin & I’m 19, why do I need a heavy moisturizer & anti-aging cream?

Reply ButtonReply

andrea

I have fine straight hair and I’m getting a curl product. Geez.

Katie

Hey guys im getting box 870 so if there is a product you want lmk….

Reply ButtonReply

Jamie

I would love the lipstick!

Reply ButtonReply

Lawden

Katie! I’d absolutely love the eyeshadow!!! I’m on the swaps!!!

Reply ButtonReply

Jamie

Here’s what they need to do:

Post all the box variations, and let people pick. Rouge gets first crack, then VIB, then everyone else. They obviously don’t look at profiles, so let us choose. It will give people more incentive to become Rouge/VIB, and at least some people will be happy.

Reply ButtonReply

mberlins

I completely agree with you!! They clearly do not look at profiles. Why would they put something from DevaCurl into most of the boxes? That should be something specific for subscribers with curly hair, and that is not me. I would have been happier with the other box with a different product.

Reply ButtonReply

Ann

I’m reading here that people are upset that Sephora doesn’t look at their profiles and/or age when shipping boxes, but I’m also reading here the people with dry skin are getting boxes w moisturizer for dry skin (belief cream moisturizer vs gel, for instance), sometimes 2 skin products for dry skin, lipsticks that were chosen for all skin tones whether you think so or not – who says light complexions can’t wear a bold lip? – and even black eyeliner is now contentious. What I’m getting at is that we are complaining about issues of preference and not profile. The boxes are to encourage you to try new new things, but thank. goodness MSA has a really organized swap section if it’s a miss. Hey, remember when people used to complain about getting perfume samples? Now we’re complaining we aren’t getting them (I’m pro-perfume btw and I’d miss mine, too).

Reply ButtonReply

Jamie

I have straight hair, and this is the third month I’ve gotten products for curly hair. That’s how I know they don’t check my profile.

Toni

Me too I love ❤️ perfume samples,I love my box this month but I’m going to miss my perfume sample . On a good note I got a beautiful smelling one in my Allure (vanilla blackberry)I like it do much I might have to get a full size one. And I read the notes of another(ciao) that sounds heavenly

chris

Nah, some of us are on a limited budget, so I prefer the luck of the draw! The ones that are rouge can probably buy what they want, or at least swap for it. This way it’s fair for everybody to get a chance at a great box.

Reply ButtonReply

Toni

P.s oh yeah I’m really happy 😊 with my box this month

Reply ButtonReply

Toni

This isn’t a rouge box, they do sell one though

Reply ButtonReply

Jamie

I’m aware that this isn’t a rouge box.

Geena

Yes! These unbalanced boxes that ignore profiles are crazy. I cancelled – but if they went to letting people choose from the variations by level I’d go back…

Reply ButtonReply

Julie

I think people would choose more by retail value so they could swap for more.

Amanda

Can someone please tell me all their selections they put in their profile that got the unicorn box #870? Thanks in advance. 😀

Reply ButtonReply

Amanda

Dang I really want the ciate in pin up and the touch in sol. Those were really only the two items i wanted in general. I don’t mind getting the algenist in my #498 box but I am not happy with this month. Would somone who’s getting #870 wanna swap with me? I only want the two items. Thanks in advance. 😀

Reply ButtonReply

Katie

i have the #870 box and i dont think i would ever use the touch in sol

Reply ButtonReply

Jill

I hate box 870… who would wear this eye shadow!? And on top of my lack of interest, my eyeshadow came dried out and almost empty so I can’t even trade it – and the shampoo/conditioner was opened and leaked all over everything else! Things my first disappointing month since subscribing.

Lawden

I’ve been dying to try that and I’m getting box 498😩I’d swap that whole box for it I want it that much! Lol

Amanda

Can someone please tell me what you selected in their profile to get #870 the unicorn box? Thanks in advance. 😀

Reply ButtonReply

Toni

Skin-medium,combination,
Skin concerns-aging,dullness,pores,puffiness,redness,uneven skin tones
Hair-brunette,chemically treated,coarse,curry,wavy
Concerns-anti-aging,curl enhancing,damaged,frizz,shine
Eyes-blue

Trish Bell

Is anyone else waiting for 904 or any other variation not listed yet.
🙁

Reply ButtonReply

Dee

I’m 541

Reply ButtonReply

Kat

I’m waiting on 904 as well. Hope someone shows it today!

Reply ButtonReply

Jen

I should have around 2 or 3 today! I will post as soon as I get it.

Trish Bell

Anybody else have 904? Or any other variation that hasn’t been revealed yet? 🙁

Reply ButtonReply

Vanessa

Yeah, I’m seriously considering cancelling after getting box 912 (THE worst, in my opinion). There’s such a huge difference in values and it really isn’t fair. And WHY do i keep just getting BRIGHT RED OR FUSCHIA LIPSTICKS??! I just wanted the herbivore. With my profile, I should have gotten it, but I don’t think our profiles mean jack. I’ll have to swap for the herbivore and maybe a wearable lip color… which is what I have to do for EVERYTHING I want in these boxes. Might as well cancel, right?!

Reply ButtonReply

Mary

There is a mask set on Birchbox at the moment for $20 and it includes the Herbivore Blue Tansy mask. You could always go into Sephora and get a sample to try it out, and if you like it, Sephora also put a Blue Tansy set with the accompanying Oil on their site too. I believe its $39 a 1 oz mask and .3 oz Lapis facial oil. The set is called True Blue

Reply ButtonReply

Nigh

Since you don’t like what you get for $10, you could always run out and buy full size for full price. Right?!

Reply ButtonReply

Not Josie

I think you’re missing the point. Many of our profiles don’t match the samples we are recieving. Sephora is seriously ignoring our profiles. I hate dumping samples because they don’t match my skin tone and it’s fallacy to think shelters are just dying for our discarded cosmetic samples.
It’s a waste of time and money –as this box should be catering to our profiles–in order for us to spend money on new faves. But, hey that’s just My opinion.

Not Josie

I think you’re missing the point. Many of our profiles don’t match the samples we are recieving. Sephora is seriously ignoring our profiles. I hate dumping samples because they don’t match my ski tone and it’s fallacy to think shelters are just dying for our discarded cosmetic samples.

Mikayla

I’m not unhappy with mine, but I’m still SO jealous of this box….

Reply ButtonReply

Kate

904??!?

Reply ButtonReply

Trish Bell

Me too

Reply ButtonReply

Lawden

Nice box!! Lucky girls! I got the 498 box but this was my fav! If anyone would like to swap for the touch in sol shadow let me know!😊

Reply ButtonReply

Annie S.

Will I never get a Fresh sample? I really wanted the Clean perfume (tried to get a sample of it twice and Sephora substituted something else for it). I have “Brooke Shields” eyebrows so I don’t need to fill anything in-please stop sending me brow products. I realize that they maybe popular but since I can’t use them I have no need for them in every box. I’m picky about my hair products and I am unsure about the lipstick color that I received. I’ll swatch it in store in case I want to swap it.

Box 506 – might be my worst box so far.

Reply ButtonReply

Annie S.

Yep- tested it out in the store- that shade of the Urban Decay lipstick barely shows up on me.

It may have to be swapped for something else when my box comes.

Reply ButtonReply

Leslie

#697 is #902 no perfum for me either…. booo 🙁

Reply ButtonReply

Anita

I wonder why I didn’t get a fragrance in my box? It is supposed to always include one fragrance each month. In the video, they said that there were freebies included this month which for me was the Hot Girls shampoo & Conditioner packets. Did they exclude my fragrance because of that?!! Anyone else not happy for not getting a fragrance?

Reply ButtonReply

Sue

Yes! I look forward to the fragrances each month! I received box #498 as well. Hmmmm……..I WANT MY LIL’ PERFUME 😕

Reply ButtonReply

Elena

I’m not happy at all.

Reply ButtonReply

chris

Great box! I am happy for you! FYI- I was on Herbivores sight today and it said not to use the Blue tansy mask with products containing retinol. Could cause a negative reaction.

Reply ButtonReply

Jessica

If anyone with this box wants to swap the touch in sol or herbivore tansy for the Laura Mercier lipstick & deva curl?

Reply ButtonReply

Samantha Lapietra

Omg I just died!! I didn’t think they would out EVERYTHING I wanted in one box but for once I’m so excited! Ipsy hit the spot this month too. I’m so excited!

Reply ButtonReply

chris

I am so happy for you! That is terrific! Hang in there everybody, your perfect box/bag is possible.

Reply ButtonReply

Casey

This is my box! So happy for the blue tansy but I couldn’t care less about the eye shadow.
I’ll be putting it up for swaps if anyone is interested.
Only thing is, I’ll be in Korea until the end of October 😭

Reply ButtonReply

Amanda

I’m following you too. 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Jessica

I’m interested!! In the eye shadow!

Reply ButtonReply

Casey

I’m on the swap site, here! http:// swap.mysubscriptionaddiction. com / user/23421/profile
I have 8 months worth of stuff to list once I come home if you want to just follow me.

del24

where is box 904??? I get mine tuesday it appears I won’t see what’s in it till then :/
story of my life lol

Reply ButtonReply

Trish Bell

It seems like 904 is the only one not sneak peaking. Waaa

Reply ButtonReply

tmi0604

Same question here. Mine comes Wednesday…

Reply ButtonReply

Deanne

Ditto, its driving me crazy! At this point I have no idea what the combo is.

Leslie

Does anyone else has #697? Mine is out for delivery today’s so it will be a true surprise 🙄

Reply ButtonReply

Chrystal

#870 for the win! So much bag envy right now! Especially since I’m getting #912 😩😩😩

Reply ButtonReply

Katie

is there anything you really want from that box?

Reply ButtonReply

Alex

I have box 514 and would swap VERY GENEROUSLY for 870. Or the touch in sol

My email is missyerable @ yahoo . com

http :// swap.mysubscriptionaddiction . com/user/9708/swaps

Reply ButtonReply