Facebook PixelPlay! By Sephora September 2017 Box #506 FULL Spoilers! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Play! By Sephora April 2020 FULL SPOILERS!

Play! By Sephora September 2017 Box #506 FULL Spoilers!

MSA
ByMSASep 14, 2017 | 35 comments

Screen Shot 2017-02-18 at 9.12.22 AM

Play! by Sephora
3.8 overall rating
564 Ratings | 55 Reviews

We have full spoilers for the September 2017 Play! By Sephora #506!

Play! By Sephora Box #506 will include:

Source

Play! By Sephora Box #051 will include:

Source: Instagram

Play! By Sephora Box #555 will include:

  • Gimme Brow Volumizing Fiber Gel
  • Laura Mercier Velour Lovers Lip Colour in Happy
  • Belif True Cream Moistrizing Bomb
  • Stella McCartney POP
  • Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner in Black
  • DevaCurl Melt Into Moisture Matcha Butter Conditioning Mask

Play! By Sephora Box #498 will include:

Source

Play! By Sephora Box #912 will include:

In case you missed it, we also have the full reveal of all items sampled in the September Play! By Sephora box!

Makeup:

Each box will include one of these items:

Skincare:

Haircare:

Fragrance:

What do you think of the September Sephora Play spoilers? 

Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

Starting at $10.00
Subscribe Now
PLAY! by Sephora is a monthly beauty and makeup subscription box. Each month, Sephora sends you a mix of six samples (including cosmetics, haircare, skincare, fragrances, and other beauty products) personalized to match your preferences and a PLAY! BOOK of tips and tricks.
MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

35 comments

Julie

I was mad at not getting a fragrance, but happy to try a fancy hair product, however I have crazy long hair (like mid thigh) and skeptical it would be enough – it was plently. BUT. I have not used a product that made my hair this dry in maybe FOREVER. SO. MANY. TANGLES. I know everybody made fun of the Kopari for basically being cooking oil, but honestly it has made my hair so much softer.

Reply ButtonReply

Trisha

Did you get the B&B product? I have really long hair too & I hate when you get tangles!

The Kopari is wonderful. People who complained about it don’t know squat about how good coconut oil (when it’s a superior grade like Kopari is) can do magic to your locks.

I got the IGK Hot Girls sample & will give it away. Not willing to risk a bad hair day- too much work to redo.

I’m asthmatic so no perfume is welcomed!

Reply ButtonReply

Julie

Yeah, it was the B&B. Too bad, because I was interested in trying it, but I felt the moment I started shampooing – my hair tensed up and turned to straw.

Holly

I have #506 and while it’s not a totally heinous box, I’m not totally excited about it. There have been worse boxes before like the April one. It’s worth the $10, but there isn’t anything thrilling in this box. I was hoping to get one of the ciate lip colors over the urban decay as I already have that one and it’s pretty good but don’t need two of them!

Really? Another of those Sephora little eyeliner samples? I guess they are fine but they have sent those little Sephora and MUFE liners so many times and they are so hard to use because they are so short and stubby! Wish I got the Stila but I guess I already have the full size of that one so I guess it’s sort of whatever.

Same thing with that belief moisturizer. I have seen it so many times as a 100 point reward or given away by the boat loads as foil packets. They are filled to the brim in a jar on a counter in Sephora! It’s useable but it isn’t anything I’m excited about. Just another filler they throw in.

The Algenist is the best thing of this whole box. I’m excited for this one. It hasn’t been around forever and just isn’t another moisturizer. Serums are expensive so it’s nice to get one to try out.

Gimme Brow is something I will never use. I don’t use brow products because I already have pretty full brows and like how they look without product in them. I think it’s a good sample but something I will just give away or just try to swap. I’ve also seen this sample a lot of times and was not surprised to see it in a play box.

Lastly the foil hair packets. I would’ve preferred a fragrance or at least an option to pick between the two. I already have a bag full of hair foils and just stick my routine. I’ve also gotten that Bumble and Bumble hair oil sample many times and it doesn’t interest me.

All in all I will use the algenist and belief. I guess I can throw the Urban Decay into my purse. The gimme brow will be passed as will the hair foil samples. Hopefully they will do something fun for fall and maybe throw in a burgundy polish for fall! Or possibly an amber shadow.

Reply ButtonReply

SF

UUggghh. Kind of disappointed in this months selection. Yes, you can have too many black eyeliners and no those lipstick colors do not look good on everyone!

None of these samples really perk my interest they are old and boring and how many times are we going to receive the same brand, it maybe different in terms of product but its the same brand every other month!

Come on Sephora, if you are going to add your product please make it worth wild and give us a bigger size to compensate for the lack of diverse products! You’re making great profit off the markup of your brand so hook us up a little! Geeezzz

I’d rather have an ugly bag and better product samples than a nice bag and junk samples.

My box is #704 so i’m holding out hope its better than these shown.

Reply ButtonReply

Leslie

I have not seen anyone receive the Blue Tansy… is this a rare item?!?!

Reply ButtonReply

Kate

It’s official. This will be my last Sephora Play box. I’ve subscribed for about a year and in that time have received THREE liquid lipsticks (none of which were a good color) and TWO plain black eyeliners. I have more foil packets of shampoo that I can ever use, and in this box the skincare brands are not those that interest me. Besides how can you make a decision about buying a full size when samples are so tiny.

If I’d received the Wander lipstick and the Stila eyeliner, I would have been able to look past the rest. Last month, FOUR of the five products went right into the trash.

I’m going to try another beauty box from a different brand.

And no one tell me, hey it’s just ten bucks. $120.00 per year could buy a nice bottle of perfume or three or four good lipsticks. This is nothing but a waste.

Reply ButtonReply

Tracey

This is mine.This is the first month I haven’t been really impressed. Urban Decay lipstick is okay. Annoyed there is apparently no perfume sample in this one. I wanted to smell that Stella McCartney one and every single time I’ve added it as a sample to and order, I’ve gotten some crappy foil sample packets.

Am I alone in being annoyed by that about Sephora? I know its effectively *free stuff*, but if I request samples with an order, that’s what I want. I don’t want you substitute crappy foil packet stuff (that isnt even remotely similar to what I requested) if they’re out of stock. I’d rather not have them at all, if they’re not available. Ugh.

Reply ButtonReply

Jess M

No, you’re not, that’s a HUGE pet peeve of mine with Sephora. I think they need to have a more accurate count of which samples are available and those employees who do the packing in contact with the web employees so they can take them off the site if they’re out, or not put them on the site if they’re not available yet (that happens too). There’s obviously a lack of communication that needs to be fixed. Otherwise, the issue is the packers are not fulfilling the orders correctly and just putting in whatever random samples they feel like, which is not cool. I don’t mind terribly if they need to replace a sample or two occasionally but I think they should at least try to keep it close to the item you selected (like my last order I chose all skincare samples and got all perfume samples instead).

On a similar note, I wish they would swap in deluxe samples you choose with your $25+ purchases. If you used a code to get a freebie you obviously wanted something, so send us something instead of nothing! If they can replace your samples that are not available, why can’t they replace the deluxe freebies that are sold out? I’ve heard their policy is to not do that, but they can with the free samples? It’s the same damn thing, so I think that’s bogus. Sorry for venting! This has been bothering me for a long time!

Reply ButtonReply

Wendy B

It seems to be a common issue with the online orders. I just received an order yesterday and ended up with samples I didn’t choose or want. I get that they’re free but I chose them because I wanted to try them and I definitely won’t use what they sent instead. The kicker is I was browsing the site the following day and those samples were still listed, AFTER my order had already shipped. So they didn’t run out, they just tossed in random samples. Seems like poor marketing because by sending the wrong things they’re keeping me from trying out something I might very well order the full size of next time.

As for the promo samples, in my last order I got an email a few hours later that my promo was cancelled because it was out of stock. I immediately asked if one of the other promos could be added instead since my order was still processing. They said they can’t do that but gave me 100 points to make up for it. I’m not sure why they couldn’t just toss in any one of the ten other promos but I’m happy they did something to make up for it.

Cheryl Toman

I received Box 514 and would love to trade the Belif True Cream Moisturizing Bomb for either Algenist product or the Fresh product and trade the Stila eyeliner for the Sephora eyeliner. I also would trade the Deva Curl Moisturizing mask.

Reply ButtonReply

Giselle

I would love to trade I got the #506, i want to try the stila eyeliner and the deva curl. Definitely want to give up the aqua bomb, and sephora eye liner

Reply ButtonReply

Stephanie

What is in box 514. I am still not seeing what is in it

Reply ButtonReply

Ashlee

I really wanted the eye shadow, but I looks like no one received it! I don’t wear liquid eyeliner and I don’t do my brows super disappointed also I got box 555.

Reply ButtonReply

Michelle

I have box 514, and it looks like I will be swapping. I really wanted the fresh face cream or the blue tansy. I already have the full size stila eyeliner. I hardly ever wear lipstick. If anyone wants to swap, let me know!

Reply ButtonReply

Emily H

Am I missing something? I’m box #514 and I dont see spoilers here for it yet…

Reply ButtonReply

Pandora

Ehhh I hate everything my box…I want the #912 🙁
Sephora better have an impressive October shipment, or I’ll unsubscribe :\

Reply ButtonReply

Kaitlynn Marie

Honestly, same. This box is a massive miss for me, and lately Sephora has been going further and further downhill. Yeah, it’s only $10 a month, but I still expect better of them.

Reply ButtonReply

Sophalie

Got my box, #912 and yes, is the only one with no perfume. Very disappointed with Play! this month.

Reply ButtonReply

Laura Shadley

I have box #506. I am very happy with it

Reply ButtonReply

Kele

Ugh! This is my box and for the first time in a long time I’m so disappointed with my box. I was so hoping for the blue tansy mask and the divacurl melt into moisture. I don’t have a swap profile but I will swap anything in my box for those two items!

Reply ButtonReply

Brooke

My box says 704 so I’m getting very curious what’s gonna be in mine

Reply ButtonReply

Beccah

Where is #704?! I can only hope it has the tansy! I am mad I won’t be getting the UD lippie! Hopefully someone will swap it!

Reply ButtonReply

Wendy B

Exactly what I was going to ask. I feel so left out and the anticipation is killing me! I haven’t seen the Herbivore mask yet so I’d say we’ll be getting that one, even though my profile stays anti-aging and I should be receiving one of the Algenist products. Not complaining though. I’ll always take a good mask.

Reply ButtonReply

Jacki

I want spoilers for 514!

Reply ButtonReply

Valerie

I want to know what is in 514 too!

Reply ButtonReply

Mariah

I think this is almost identical to box 498 – I think the only differences are the shampoo + conditioner foils. Maybe the Gimme Brow will be a different shade between the boxes.

Reply ButtonReply

Christina

Weird that there is no perfume in box #506.

Reply ButtonReply

Julie

Yay! I’m 506, very happy, my only wish is for a fragrance!

Reply ButtonReply

Kate

Me too! Only wish I didn’t get another black eyeliner, but everything else is pretty great.

Reply ButtonReply

Mandi

I’m box 506 and pretty happy. Would have loved the liquid eyeliner instead of the one I got. The rest I’m excited about.

Reply ButtonReply

Kim

Ugh i’m so disappointed. That is the one color lippie I already have and I already own the gimmie brow, belief cream and I dont wear eye liner. I really wanted the tansy mask. I think they need to stop with so many different versions it just breeds serious box envy and disappointment.

Whoever gets the box with the tansy mask and eyeshadow basically wins the lottery and everyone else is disappointed …sometimes I really wonder why I haven’t cancelled yet.

Reply ButtonReply

chris

Looks like a great box!

Reply ButtonReply

Kori

This is a good box! I so wanted the glitter eyeshadow instead of Gimme Brow (which I know for a fact I do not like) but other than that I’m so happy!

Reply ButtonReply

Brenda

Major box envy again! Much better than the 912 I am getting.

Reply ButtonReply