Box of the Week: VineOh! - $20 Off + Free Shipping!

Posted by on in Beauty Subscription Boxes, Canadian Subscription Box Reviews, Cheap Subscription Boxes, Ipsy Reviews, Makeup Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women | Tags: | 35 comments

Ipsy Review #2 – June 2017

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

Ipsy is a monthly beauty and makeup subscription box. Each month you get full-size or deluxe-sized beauty products, plus a cute makeup bag. I think Ipsy is perfect for anyone who likes to discover and try new beauty items before committing to full-sized products!

(FYI – Just like BirchboxIpsy sends out many different variations of their bag each month – so my review is just one of the bag variations you might receive!)

My Subscription Addiction pays for this subscription. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

The Subscription Box: Ipsy

The Cost: $10 a month (free shipping) or $110 for yearly subscription

The Products: Full-size and samples of makeup and beauty products (including makeup, skincare, hair care, and nail care), plus a makeup bag!

Ships to: U.S. and Canada

Delivered via: USPS

Check out all of our Ipsy reviews and the Beauty Subscription Box List for more makeup boxes!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

Visit the Ipsy Swap Page to swap for any of the items you see in this review!

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

Ipsy’s theme for this month is ‘Volume Up’, and it’s all about being able to express yourself fearlessly. I totally agree that it is now more important than ever to stand by for what we believe in, be it human rights, climate change, or social injustice.

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

This canvas bag’s quirky design is a small reminder for us to speak up our mind. I think it’s adorable! It’s lined on the inside too! 

Now, onto the items!

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

Beauty For Real – I-LINE 24-7 Eyeliner – FULL SIZE! Value $14

Beauty For Real was founded by a celebrity makeup artist, Leslie Munsell. Their products are Cruelty-Free and developed with ‘high-tech formulas and beneficial natural ingredients along with smart innovative packaging’.

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

I received this eyeliner in 24 Karat, which is a warm golden shade. It claims to be a waterproof gel eyeliner with 24-hour wear time. It also contains Vitamin E to condition your skin. This eyeliner is creamy, easy to apply, and very pigmented. The swatch on my arm didn’t smudge or budge at all during the day, and it lasted a long time on my eyelid, too. (I used it in place of eyeshadow since it’s not very visible as an eyeliner on my skin tone)

(Swatched in the lower photo.)

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

Margaret Dabbs London – Treatment-Enriched Nail Polish in Green Daylily – FULL SIZE! Value £14 ($18 USD)

This nail polish came all the way here from England! The founder of this brand, Margaret Dabbs, crafted her products and treatments to be exceptionally effective while ensuring that the scent, look, and feel are luxurious. She uses ‘Emu Oil’ as her key super ingredient as a base for her product lines.

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

This nail polish is enriched with Vitamin E and Wild Rose to strengthen and protect the nails. While the bright teal color is a little out of my comfort zone, I really do love the formula. It was easy to apply and very opaque (only 1 coat needed), plus it didn’t smell like a nail polish AT ALL. In fact, there’s a subtle rose scent that lasted on my nails for days!

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

Here’s how it looks on my medium-warm skin tone. This is one coat of application plus top coat. The color looks greener in real life.

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

Vasanti Cosmetics – Power Oils Lip Gloss in Super Mom – 2.3g Value $6.72 (Full-Size 6.5g Value $19)

**This is my requested item**

I have tried some of Vasanti skincare from GlossyBox and Birchbox, and I have been impressed with their quality. So when Ipsy allowed us to send them a sample request, I didn’t hesitate and picked this beautiful mauvy nude lip gloss. This sample size has almost the same amount of product as Colourpop full-size lip gloss! 

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

This lip gloss is Cruelty-Free, Vegan-Friendly and Paraben Free. It’s enriched by natural oils like Pomegranate Oil and Jojoba Oil, both of which are famous for their anti-aging properties. It lasted about 3 hours on my lips without being sticky. The light citrus scent (I think it smells like lemon tea) is a big plus!

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

The Balm Cosmetics – Balm Spring Blush – 1g Value $3.74 (Full-Size 5.61g Value $21)

Despite knowing this brand for so long, this is actually the first time I’ve tried any products from The Balm Cosmetics! I like their lively packaging and I can’t wait to see if it’ll last 12 hours as it claims.

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

This blush is REALLY pigmented. I almost gave myself a clown face because I wasn’t paying attention while sweeping this blush out of its pan. I think the powder blended easily and the color was not too bright for my skin tone. Unfortunately, on my oily-combination skin, I don’t think it lasted more than a few hours.

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

Here are the swatches of Beauty For Real eyeliner, Vasanti lip gloss, and the Balm Spring Blush.

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

Delectable by Cake Beauty – Coconut & Cream Triple Moisture Body Lotion – 2oz Value $3.50 (Full Size 8oz Value $14)

Cake Beauty is an ingredient-conscious brand from Ontario, Canada. Their formulas are natural ingredient-driven, and the brand itself has a fun and playful touch!

(Good to know for swaps – this product has an inner foil seal.)

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

Not only it’s Cruelty-Free, Vegan, Gluten Free, Paraben Free and Phthalate Free, this body lotion also has a sweet coconut & vanilla scent, which is almost too overwhelming for me. Their main ingredients are coconut oil, shea butter, and aloe vera. The lotion absorbed easily and made my skin feel hydrated for hours. This is a sizable sample size and I will be able to use this for a while.

Ipsy Makeup and Beauty Subscription Box - June 2017

Here is the look I completed using everything from my June Ipsy bag, including the Balm blush, Beauty For Real eyeliner, and Vasanti lip gloss.  

Verdict: This box has a value of about $46, which is great for a $10 subscription. I think the value is on par with my regular Ipsy bags (with the exception of May, which had an even higher value). Even though only 2 products were full-sized, I felt like I received 4 full-sized products because the lip gloss and body lotion sample are quite sizable! I love the eyeliner and lip gloss and enjoyed everything they sent me.

What do you think of the June Ipsy Glam Bag? What items did you get in your bag?

Written by Jira Sai

Jira Sai

Jira discovered the world of subscription boxes when she first moved to New York in 2017 (subscription box is not a thing in her home country!). Thanks to MSA, she’s now subscribed to almost 10 beauty and lifestyle boxes, with FabFitFun, BeautyFIX, and Clean Beauty Box as her favorites. Ps. Her boyfriend thinks that she’s only subscribed to Ipsy, so please keep this a secret between us 😉

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.

35 Comments

  1. HELP anyone PLEASE I need to know the average weight of an Ipsy Bag because I’m ordering internationally. I know that the weight varies every month but can anyone give me an average? Is it more than 1 lb?

  2. I just started in June and am unimpressed with their billing practices. I was taken off the waiting list, withdrawal from my account on 4th and no JUNE bag.
    I received a email welcoming me and my next withdrawal would be AUGUST 1st. I assumed no July billing since no June bag. Then they withdrew $10 on JULY 1st, reminding me another withdrawal on August 1st.

    I actually emailed because there was never a mention of a JULY withdrawal.

    Am I wrong? I believe they owe me a bag? The CSR was rude.

  3. Got everything you did, but the eyeliner (I don’t use eyeliner). I got the PUR Fully Charged mascara I chose instead (LOVE mascara!). Love my bag and last month’s too. Awesome review and look forward to reading these.

  4. I LOVE my Vasanti lipgloss! I was disappointed I got the only nail polish shade that I didn’t want: the Kokie polish in a pretty cobalt blue, but I already have a couple of similar polishes. Anyone interested in swapping for a coral shade? I’m not picky about brand, as long as it’s decent quality.

  5. I’m getting a lot of the same except for the lotion I’m getting a face product I think and I don’t know what color of liner yet. But I’m Happy with it.

  6. The lip gloss and blush suit you for a polished natural look. I wish I’d gotten that eyeliner!!

  7. I tried not looking at my items when the email came in but not self-control took over. I love a surprise but I wanted the extra reward points for sharing. My whole bag is blah blah. I think after being back for 2 months I’m cancelling I don’t need much else for beauty boxes except look fantastic. They rock my world. I wish they added more makeup though… Thats just how I’m feeling.

  8. This is the only make up sub that I have kept. I LOVE Ipsy (even though I really don’t need any more make up).

    • I’m new to Ipsy; this month is my first box. What do you love about them so much specifically? I wanted to try them and Play! both out and see which one I’ll keep.

      • I like that I mostly get full size. And even the few samples I get are pretty big.

      • Ipsy is definitely the best about sending big sample sizes, mostly makeup, and keeping subscribers engaged throughout the month by staggering updates. I feel like I get an ipsy email I’m excited about once a week! Play, on the other hand, is a lot more no frills. The samples are high end but TINY (I’d say nothing bigger than my little finger, and often more the size of a quarter) and a mix of makeup and skincare, and they really don’t engage through other offers etc. Personally, I feel that I’d get better value from Sephora if I just spent the $10/month on products I wanted and used my points from those purchases for the occasional extra sample I wanted, but to each herown! 🙂

        • Hi Beth,

          Not sure which Play boxes you got, but I have mostly gotten boxes with travel size product, and some full size, and some that are a little smaller. Overall, with the exception of the perfume samples, they select for me, I have been very happy with Play. I am finding myself on this site to see if there are any other subs that I might be interested in that offer brands outside of what Sephora offers. I do agree with you on their lack of engagement, we don’t know what we are getting, but we do fill out a questionnaire so the color and product type matches for me have been spot on for my tone (colors). Whether or not they are my cup of tea (cosmetic colors) is another matter altogether.

          Jiri,

          Thanks for your review and sharing the products. Good insight for someone looking to add another sub.

          Thanks,

  9. Nice review Jira! I’m not getting any of the same items, but it’s interesting reading about them. I would love to try the lotion.

  10. I love the lip gloss which was also my pick. It’s a beautiful WEARABLE color, its hydrating, & it smells amazing. Definitely not something you can apply without a mirror though.

    • I’m glad you like the lipgloss, it’s my favorite item in the bag too!

  11. It’s weird to me that so many Ipsy products are cruelty-free and vegan, then they throw in a brand that uses emu oil as its base for its products. Not only are birds killed for the oil, the oil has been falsely marketed as a cure for cancer, arthritis, etc. It’s the new snake oil.

    • Thanks for letting us know. I was wondering about that and was going to research it. Had never even heard of it.

    • Yeah, ew not cool. Would not have wanted to get that product.

    • Oh no. The polish was the only item I liked but I can’t support animal cruelty. Why would polish ever ever need oil? Especially emu oil? I’m sure a lot of people are put off by this. It seems unnecessary and cruel.

    • Oh my, thank you for letting us know. 🙁

    • Emu oil and snail slime!!! Crushed beetles to make products red. Come on, people….we live in a world where beauty products can be just as beneficial and amazing WITHOUT using animals and their secretions (and we use ALOT more than just the three mentioned). Are we truly that vain??? Beauty products are fun and transforming and make us feel good about ourselves. But we should all remember that beauty on the inside is worth a million times more than a face full of makeup made with bug and animal parts. Yuck!!!! P.S. Yes, I received the nail polish from Ipsy. Not too sure what to do with it now…..it looks beautiful and expensive, but I will not be wearing it. 😿

      • If you don’t approve of animal products in cosmetics, you probably won’t like an ipsy subscription. Unfortunately they don’t currently have any cruelty free subscription options, and I think until they see clear proof that this is losing them subscribers, they are pretty unlikely to start offering one. 🙁

    • Which brand and item had the emu oil in it??! Is it by chance the red trust fund polish?? If so, that’s what is supposed to be in my bag (per the website ).. I’ve been a vegetarian for 25 years out of respect for animals (I do not mind or care if someone else eats meat, and I don’t judge ) but personally I don’t want to use known products that are produced by hurting animals…
      Thanks

      • Whoops, I see it now…my mistake for not reading…I thought I had already read the ipsy review.. hopefully I don’t get the blue one shown

  12. Try using that gold eyeliner right on top of the black. Unless it’s really low pigment, it should pop and give you a nice gold line. I’m hoping I get that, but the brown is ok too. I’m getting one of them…

    • Thanks Bonnie! Will definitely try that!

  13. Hi Jira, do you remember if the eyeliner came sealed? I might try to swap for it. Thanks!

    • I got this exact bag, eyeliner does not come sealed.

    • Hi Michelle, unfortunately, as Kikikenzie said, it did not come sealed. I’m sure you can still swap it though 🙂

  14. So fat from emus is blended into the nail polish. Got it.

  15. Every time I think about resubbing to ipsy i see a review with lipstick, eyeliner and nail polish, all items I don’t use! When I get unusable items with Sephora they are gold on the swap site but ipsy items never go. I just can’t decide! Are they giving the option of eliminating 3 categories to everyone?

    • Yes the opt-out categories are for everyone. You have to email them which ones you want out of, and they are only letting some people opt-out of two. They will opt you out of that certain product for a period of time. It’s also good to know that if you want to opt-out of a certain formula of product such as liquid eyeliner, you have to opt-out of eyeliner altogether.

  16. Oh, I wanted that gold eyeliner so bad. They keep giving me black. 🙁

    • same 🙁 .. hopefully next time!

  17. That 2oz cake lotion actually sells for $6 on their website.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!