Posted by on in Collective Child Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Kids | Tags: | 13 comments

Collective Child Clothing Box Review – May 2017

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Collective Child is a members-only high-end clothing styling service for children. The Collective Child stylists take your lifestyle, feedback, and seasonal weather into consideration when packing your box.

Collective Child works like some women’s clothing styling boxes. You begin by filling out a style profile for your child. Information about sizing, preferred colors and prints are all taken into account. After completing the style form your box will ship out in about 10 days. You have 7 days to have your child try on all the pieces and then you mail anything back that you decide not to keep with the prepaid mailer. Checking out is now done via an online account. You are billed immediately upon letting them know which items you’ll be keeping and which you’ll be returning. Pricing is comparable to high-end department stores. Collective Child is also charging a membership fee now. The fee is based on how much clothing you keep. The more you keep, the less your fee will be. If you keep over $150 worth of clothing there is no fee.

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

The Subscription Box: Collective Child

The Cost: You are charged for the items you keep. There is no styling fee.

The Products: high-end boutique type clothing for children

Ships to: U.S. for free

Check out all of our Collective Child reviews the Kids Clothing Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Checkout used to be done with a paper form that came in your box. They have now simplified this process and you check out with your online account which is much faster. They ask questions about each piece regarding style, fit and price. This will help your stylist understand why you’ve chosen to keep and return each item.

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Imps&Elfs Chambray Dress – $55.00

This chambray dress by Imps&Elfs is incredibly soft, but also very wrinkly. It was made of 100% Lyocell. It fit my daughter well, but I didn’t feel there was anything especially unique or special about it. I liked the style of the dress, but I have to say spending $55 on a casual dress for a three year old is too steep for me.

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Anthem of the Ants Dress – $68.00

Most of the clothing from Collective Child has been very muted colors. I like that this dress has bolder colors and I thought the tie shoulder straps were very sweet. My daughter liked the colors, pattern and front pockets, but alas $68.00 is simply out of our clothing budget.

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Rylee + Cru Tiger Tank – $37.00

This tank had such a unique print. I loved that it wasn’t the typical girly prints I see when I take her shopping. It’s 100% cotton and the sassy tiger print fits my daughter’s personality well. We will be keeping this tank.

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Imps&Elfs Olive Green Shorts – $46.00

The first thing my daughter said when I pulled these shorts out of the box was, “those are boy shorts, I don’t like them.” The material is so stiff it reminds me of the military-issue duffle bags. They were pretty awful all around.

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Imps&Elfs Cupcake Tee – $26.00

This shirt had the right price, but I found it semi-sheer and semi-boring to boot. I love the fact that this soft shirt is made with 95% organic cotton and has a little stretch from 5% elastane, but the muted colors and tiny abstract desserts didn’t excite my daughter or me.

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Imps&Elfs Chambray Pants – $50.00

These pants were made of the same soft and wrinkly material as the chambray dress. The slouchy fit was cute, but the elastic cinched cuffs were so tight my daughter has a difficult time getting the pants on and off.

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Donsje Panda Bag – $39.00

This nubuck leather panda wallet bag is one of the most precious things I’ve ever seen. My daughter really wanted to keep this item, and I fell in love with it too, until I saw the price tag. Bummer.

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Collective Child Clothing Subscription Box - May 2017

Tiny Cottons Years Tee – $32.00

I liked the pretty pale pink of this pima cotton and elastane tee, but the random years and word “love” printed all over it just didn’t rock me. The fit was nice, but this one will be going back.

Verdict: This was my first month of Collective Child since they changed some of their subscription policies. Their high-priced, quality clothing from little known and hard to source brands were more of a miss than a hit for me this month. We kept one cute tank, but mostly I was disenchanted with the fabrics and patterns in this particular box. I would have loved to have kept the pink, striped Anthem of Ants dress but I felt the price was too high. Now that Collective Child has membership fees and less time to try on and return the clothing (7 days – it used to be 10 days) I feel they may turn off some potential subscribers. I do like their online checkout system though which I found incredibly user-friendly and fast; it’s definitely preferential over their old paper forms you had to fill out by hand and mail back.

What do you think of Collective Child?

Written by Jessica Telesmanich

Jessica Telesmanich

Jessica’s addiction started off slowly enough with Birchbox, but it has grown and grown over the last three years. An elementary school librarian and mom of two she loves boxes that are child-centric. But she’ll never turn down a good fashion, beauty or tasty treat subscription.

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.

13 Comments

  1. That first dress looked like a sack.

  2. Yeah those prices are insane, especially because kids grow out of stuff so quickly. Spending 68$ on a dress for myself is one thing, im not gonna put grow it by next season like my kids will!

    • *Out grow* cause apparenly i cannot hit the right buttons

  3. Is it hard for your daughter to model something she really likes and then have you tell her you’re not buying it? I agree with everyone else, these prices are insane.

    • Good question, Amy! Luckily it’s not been an issue. She’s used to hearing “no” and accepts it quite well. I’m sure if she was a few years older this could become a problem, but at three it hasn’t been. 😊

  4. OMG! Your daughter is sooo adorable I can barely stand it! The clothes were not wowing me at all and the prices are incredibly high, I am more of a clearance rack shopper when it comes to my kids but even when I do slpurge it wouldn’t be at those prices. The panda is adorable and I’m going to do an Amazon nsearch for panda purse. I love her smile even when she dosnt like the clothes, I don’t think my little princess would do that.

    • Thanks so much, Kara! I’m lucky she’s such a sport about “modeling” for my subscription addiction. 😊

  5. Your daughter is a cutie and she looked great in everything, but yeesh on a) the pricing and b) sending pieces that are that wrinkled from just being in the box. Who the heck has time to iron clothing for a 3 year?!

    Cool idea, but seems like a miss!

    • Thanks, Carrie!

  6. Those prices are WAY too high!

  7. Those prices are insane. That’s more than what I spend on things for myself!

  8. Cute kid!

    Love the striped dress but the price tag is way too high.

    • Thanks, Cookie! 😊

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!