Facebook PixelBoxyCharm March 2017 FULL SPOILERS!! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Boxycharm August 2022 Base Spoiler #1, Spoiler #2, Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4

BoxyCharm March 2017 FULL SPOILERS!!

MSA
ByMSAMar 5, 2017 | 137 comments

Screen Shot 2017-01-19 at 4.30.41 PM

BoxyCharm
4.3 overall rating
1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

We have FULL SPOILERS for one of the variations of the March 2017 Boxycharm! (Thanks to larlarlee!)

One version of the March 2017 Boxycharm subscription box will include:

Screen Shot 2017-03-05 at 5.44.22 PM Screen Shot 2017-03-05 at 5.44.33 PM Screen Shot 2017-03-05 at 5.44.46 PM

What do you think of the March 2017 Boxycharm spoilers?

If you haven't signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers for future updates!

FYI – According to Boxycharm, if you sign up before the end of any month, that month’s box will be your first box. 

Starting at $30.00
Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

137 comments

Pam

Hi everyone,

I am brand new to subs (and now addicted). I stumbled across this site by accident looking for reviews for a teen box. This is my first Boxycharm box. I subscribed on March 10, wait listed, but then off the wait list on the 15th. I just received my box today. My box had the standard Naked trio. Crown fan brush, Smashbox primer and lip liner/lip stick. My lip liner and lip stick do match, but wow! they are dark. Mine liner-I am loved, and lipstick-Rockstar. They do not look like they do on REALHER website. Very dark burgundy looking. I have light/pale skin so these will not work for me, but it is fun to get these boxes. My son’s gf loved them, so they will go to her. We are going to experiment with the eye shadow, but they will probably go to her as well. I am coming up on 50, and have worn the same make up for ever. Foundation, powder, blush, eyeliner. Boring. She has inspired me to “step out of my comfort zone.” It should be fun! $20 is good deal!

Reply ButtonReply

Erin

Disappointed. What is up with the TINY Real Her lip liner? It’s just a TIP/sample of liner? For $12.00 supposed value? I’m not in this for samples.
Ridiculous.

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

Its not just a tip or a sample. You sharpen it.

Reply ButtonReply

Julie B.

To those disappointed by the eye palette, give it a try! The colors are beautifully pigmented and silky smooth. I used the red on my lids today, the orange on the inner corners, and added a neutral shadow as transition shade. I know the green will be my favorite since I love greens anyway. Honestly, maybe it has to do with your coloring, but before you dismiss them, check out how they look on your face rather than in the pans.

Reply ButtonReply

kdwaide

I’m really disappointed that I received the bright red dirty little secret lipstick. I really wish I would have received a more neutral lipstick with matching lip liner. The lip liner I received doesn’t even match the lipstick. The naked cosmetics palette is something I will not be able to use, I’ll try to get creative and blend it to see if I can make it work. These colors definitely feel like the creepy Halloween theme. I’m 45 and although I consider myself trendy with my light complexion and blonde hair these colors are just way too out there for me. However, I was thrilled to get the crown brush and the makeup primer. Those two items made this months box a a little over break even for me.

Reply ButtonReply

Christina

A little disappointed… first it took almost two months to get off of the waiting list and then I get charged on the 1st for my box and here we are two weeks later and not even a shipping notice yet. I’ve already reached out to customer service a couple of days ago and all they could say is that the box is being prepared to be shipped soon. How long does it normally take to get your box? Three weeks past the date payment is taken seems a bit excessive to me.

Reply ButtonReply

Christine

The green in the eye palette might work for a holiday appropriate eye look on St. Patrick’s Day actually . . . IF I get my box by then.

I wish they would send out the shipping notifications already.

Reply ButtonReply

Christina

IKR??? I think the wait is a bit ridiculous. They sure don’t wait to take your payment.

Reply ButtonReply

julia

Well this was my first Boxycharm and I’ve got to say I’m really disappointed. I got a fan brush that I don’t need, primer I don’t use anymore, eye shadow that is too shimmery for me and a hot pink lip liner and SCREAMING BRIGHT red lip tint. I really wish they had sent a liner and lip that matched. I could have found someone to gift it to. As it is, I think I’m just going to try to resell the box as a whole and hope for a better outcome next month.

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

Another disappointing variation. As more people get their boxes, I’m getting more bummed. I was so excited after seeing the first round of unboxings that we were getting a lipliner and matching liquid lipstick by the same brand. And then it seems like once all the popular youtubers and bloggers posted their boxes on social medias, the leftover crap got thrown in other boxes for the “regular customers”. I have never had 1 bad thing to say about boxycharm until this month when I’m starting to figure out that this happens more often then not. The 3 variations I’ve seen with the DLS and Japanesque liquid lips and the Ampilash mascara have all been repeats from past boxes and that’s just so disappointing to me. I know I “shouldn’t complain because we only pay $21 for the box” but it’s just not fair in my opinion. Really contemplating switching to Lola Beauty Box and trying that out.

Reply ButtonReply

Dianne

I noticed a survey on Boxycharm. I never saw it before. Just completed it. It asks what I would prefer and my age skin color and eyes and hair color.

Reply ButtonReply

Nan

I saw that a couple days ago, too.

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

I did the survey too but it doesn’t save the preferences like ipsy does. I clicked on it again and had to redo it. Not sure if they are going to start doing more personalized boxes but I sure hope so.

Reply ButtonReply

Dianne

I hope so to

Julie B.

I got a Japonesque lipstick instead of the Real Her liquid lip. I was disappointed because the Japonesque, though valued at $20 I think, is a screaming bright Red. Second month in a row now to get unwearable clown red lipstick. Love you Boxycharm but please send nude or pink lipstick!

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

Wow that is extremely disappointing. Did you get the RealHer lipliner? I don’t understand why the popular YouTuber’s and bloggers get the matching variation and us “regular customers” get leftover crap because I know a few months ago they sent out Japanesque sp? liquid lipsticks and the other variation I’ve seen was the Ampilash or whatever the brand is, mascara and I know that’s been sent out previously as well. Its not fair that everyone is getting leftover junk.

Reply ButtonReply

Julie B.

Yes I did get the Real Her liner in I Am Unique which is really pretty, wish I could have gotten the matching lipstick. I wouldn’t mind the Japonesque lipstick in any other color, it seems excellent quality! But two red lipsticks in two months is too many!

Marie

Yeah, not cool. I got the red Dirty Little Secret liquid lipstick from the August 2016 box.

Svetlana7e

Got my box today. Very happy. The brush was much much thicker then we got a month ago. I will use it for powder. The eye shadow was much pretties in person then on the picture, the colors are intense but i have an idea how i would use it. The lip liner beautiful burgundy. The liquid lipstick is like a gloss but not that was pictured, different company and it is light red. Another successful months with Boxycharm.

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

That’s disappointing that it wasn’t the RealHer liquid lipstick. I really wanted to try it. I hope I get it :/

Reply ButtonReply

Svetlana7e

I was ok with it because I have it coming in FFF box, but I can see how it feels disappointed. I rather to get other lipstick.

Cheyenne

I just got my box (no shipping notice) and got a variation.
Instead of a lip liner, I got Ampilash Mascara Serum.

Reply ButtonReply

Virginia

I have amplilash from a previous box. I absolutley love it for when you want long, defined eyelashes, but not super caked on.

Reply ButtonReply

Marie

I also got a variation. I got the Realher lip liner but got a red Dirty Little Secret liquid lipstick instead of Realher lipstick. Now I have a lipliner with nothing to match it. 😐

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

Omg that’s crazy!! I haven’t gotten a shipping notification either yet! That makes me worry because id much rather have the lip liner vs mascara 😭😭

Reply ButtonReply

Virginia

The mascara is a good one, so dont be too disappointed

Genevieve Mullis

All the pictures I see being posted on IG have lipliner ‘I am loved’.
I cannot see the liquid lip color names.

Reply ButtonReply

Genevieve Mullis

Wait, I can see some. All the ones I can see are ‘I am a rock star’.
So far I don’t see any variations.

Reply ButtonReply

Marianne

FINALLY got my February box today! Absolutely awesome and worth the wait! Can’t wait to get the March box!!

Reply ButtonReply

Julie B.

Hey looking for advice from boxycharmers. I have a lot of charm points due to an item that was damaged and they could not replace so gave me points So total amount of points amounts to about $50 plus free shipping but I literally don’t like anything in the charm shop, which seems to have boring nail polish and leftover makeup. So how often do they put me stuff in the charm shop? I don’t know whether to wait for new merchandise.

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

Sometimes it takes a while to find decent items in the shop. I think they put a few new items in there monthly but not sure exactly what part of the month. Maybe you can email them and ask. Their email is help.boxycharm.com

Reply ButtonReply

Caitlin

anyone else’s box ship? mine weighs .6 – I wonder if the only variation this month will be in lip color. It seems like sometimes they run out of the item that most people get and sub in something similar, so i could see getting a different brand of liner/lip color. Like how last month it seemed most people were getting the royal & Langnickel brushes and then I got a repeat of luxie brushes.

Reply ButtonReply

Marianne

Have you gotten your box yet? I just got my shipping notification today and it says mine also weighs .6. Just curious to see what everyone is getting! I saw a box variation on IG that included a L’oreal product that I would not be thrilled to get! The anticipation is killing me!!! 😂😂😂

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

I’m dying to know too!! Just got my shipping info this morning and mine also says .6. I have a feeling getting my box this late in the month is going to be super disappointing because all the good stuff already went out. If I get a Loreal product I will be really mad because I could buy that at Wal-Mart and the whole point of sub boxes is to get to try new and different brands.

Dawn

My box is .6 also I wonder what the variation is I hope it is not something that isn’t shown. I just cancelled my subscription anyway because it was due to renew and after this months box I don’t think I can handle another 6 months of Boxy Charm. They need to step up their game a little and get back to what they use to be lately the boxes have been not so great in my opinion.

Reply ButtonReply

Genevieve

Mine weighs .6

Reply ButtonReply

Terri Cooley

I’m concerned because I have not received my March box. I paid a 1 year subscription upfront. I have emailed them and gotten no response. I’m extremely disappointed as this is my favorite box I receive. Any advice??

Reply ButtonReply

jasmine jones

boxes dont ship out until at least the 10th of each month.

Mira Aguirre

Uh… No one has. You will get it by the end of March.

Jackie

I don’t think anyone received their March box yet.

Marie

Mine shipped and it weighs .5 lbs. Hmmm. Wonder if there are other variations.

Reply ButtonReply

Paula G

Hi all😃 Is there a way to see if your boxed shipped from their website?

Jackie

Dang I would have loved to get that Luxie set again. I got a Sedona lace trio with a blending brush, angled eyeliner brush, and a spooley/angled eyebrow brush. I think the lip products are the only variations because if I remember right, in the first 3 spoilers on boxys IG, it says every charmer will receive those products.

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

I meant a bent eyeliner brush not angled lol

Shelly

It’s nice to see some different color eye shadows for a change. I love Boxycharm! Even if I don’t like a particular color, it’s always nice to try out, and if all else fails I throw any unwanteds in my Halloween costume box. You never know when you’ll need one of those off colors.

Reply ButtonReply

ariana

How long does it take to get off the waitlist? I’ve always been able to unsubscribe whenever I didn’t really care for a month’s box but ever since boxy has gotten more popular, there’s a waitlist now and I don’t know when I’m ever getting off it!

Reply ButtonReply

Paula G

I just got off the waitlist March 2nd and I went on it Feb 11. So around 3 weeks. 😃

Reply ButtonReply

Chrissy

I’m definitely contacting them asap because I signed up in January (around the 18th) and I’m still on the wait list 😞super disappointed…..

Belinda

Is this the same crown fan brush I received in the February box? I love it but I don’t need two.

Reply ButtonReply

Jackie

Its def not the same brush. This one is bigger and denser. You can use it for almost any powder. I have a similar one and I use it to set my face or contour or blush. Some people use it for highlight, but the brush is too big for my liking for highlight. There are no rules to makeup so use it for whatever you’d like 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

missy

I’m hoping if I get a lip color, it is something like this one. Last month I got a terrible lip color but I do like this one. I do agree that these are more fall type colors, but I’m not mad at them.

Reply ButtonReply

Andrea

Last month’s lip color was awful. Mine was orangey-pink, and definitely not attractive!

Reply ButtonReply

Idzie

I am so pleased with this!! Those eyeshadows are 100% my coloursso I know I’ll get tons of use out of them, that fan brush is unlike anything in my brush collection so I’m pleased with that, happy to try the Smashbox primer, and I always like lip products… 🙂

Reply ButtonReply

Geena

I love it! Definitely having box envy – bad enough to see if anyone who gets this variation would consider selling it to me to be honest…

Reply ButtonReply

Aimee

This is the 1st time in all my BoxyCharm boxes that the value has been below $100. If I get items above, it will be about $75. I still LOVE them but after last months whopping $155, I must say even I (Miss Positive) was a little surprised. Love the products just a bit baffled. I
loved last months Real Her lipstick. Where else can you spend $19 & get $75? Love to all you beauties out there!

Reply ButtonReply

Marie

I’m coming up with $102 value. The eyeshadow palette is on pre sale for $39.99 + $16 primer + $18.99 brush + $15 lipstick + $12.50 lip liner.

Reply ButtonReply

Aimee

The eyeshadow has been on sale for I believe $24.99 until after the 2nd spoiler. My addition may be wrong but that palette was less until second spoiler. Don’t get me wrong, I’m still happy. I may have forgot to add the lip liner but my post was positive. I was just surprised by the difference & I’m the first to admit I makes tons of mistakes.

Hazey

The box this month looks good! Not gonna lie, it isn’t as exciting as when I saw February’s reveal, however, I am very much looking forward to receiving that fan brush. The bristles are full and lush, not skimpy like some other fan brushes i’ve seen before. The lipkit however, looks like a repeat from what FabFitFun suscribers will be getting in their spring box, so that’s kind of a bummer. I do hope though, that I get different colors at least! Love that we’re getting a smashbox item though!

Reply ButtonReply

Tiffany

I hope I get different shades from FabFitFun also! I don’t mind getting the same formula as long as I don’t get repeat shades. Hopefully RealHer will keep in mind that many people likely subscribe to both boxes and send different variations for each?

Reply ButtonReply

Maria

I wonder why they didn’t save that palette for October. It seems more appropriate at that time. Not sad that I cancelled.

Reply ButtonReply

Debbie

I don’t own a fan brush so I’m looking forward to that! Love the shade of the lip stuff in the above photo, but those eyeshadows, IDK….
I’m super pale and I don’t think I can pull off orange yellow and red

Reply ButtonReply