Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
So far I’m delighted with Boxy Charm, I started in December. It is a good way to treat myself and upgrade my make up and beauty regime for a reasonable price. It is a fun way to treat myself.
Now is everything a keeper in a box? Well no, I don’t need nail stuff and some of the shades are a bit to edgy for me. I might use that purple lip stick for Mardi Gras though…But if I can use most of the things I feel it is worth it. The products that I can’t use I’m going to donate to a local women’s shelter in my area
Reply
Kendra
I swear I saw a sneak peak of another z palette coming in Feb! If not Sephora sells cheap ones…
Reply
Toni
I saw it too ,it was either on Instagram or Twitter .It was for a small z palette and it was the girl with the red hair
Reply
Kathy
I got a sample size body butter in my Jan box I thought it was all full size we surpose to get it says $14 for it I looked it up it was not full size at all! Its a 1.3 oz size glow for a cause body butter a tiny sample to me. Anybody else get one?
Reply
Jessica
Yes I got the sample size also!? This is my first box so I wasn’t sure if that was ok but I thought it should be all full size products?!
Reply
Jess Balliet
I’ve been getting Boxycharm for some time now. Most items are full size, but from time to time we do get some deluxe size samples. Still the best beauty box on the market, and I think I’ve tried them all.
Sharon
I LOVE MUG eyeshadows! I just got some foils and duochromes this week. Can’t wait!!
Reply
Ann Ricci
BOXYCHARM is my most favorite beauty box…..I wish there were more skin care products in the box……..do not like receiving nail polishes////as most peeps have their favorite color and go to salon to get their nails done…..I do have a stock pile of products ….. will be considering skipping a box here and there…..
Reply
Dianne
When I was going to cancel it showed me the:
“Dr. Brandt product” “Makeup Geek” “drawing of 2 brushes”.
Plus their was a waitlist if I did cancel!
I have way to much skin care and makeup!
I want the Makeup Geek and the makeup brush or brush’s. But I’m cancelling this box soon.
Reply
Amanda
It says the wait list thing if you cancel but it doesn’t do it. I’ve cancelled and resubbed after seeing spoilers and I never have to wait. It’s a way to keep you signed up.
Reply
Lauren
I really love make up geek cosmetics and hope I get at least one of the burnt colors. With that said I feel like I’m on eyeshadow overload from this box, not complaining just have so many lately.
Reply
Mel
I’m excited about the shadow, but the skincare, I feel like the skincare will be a variation which I won’t get. Either way the eyeshadow is the showstopper for me. Skincare is important I know, but doesn’t make me that excited.
Reply
Heather
I just started getting Boxycharm in December and I’m so glad I discovered it! I have a few pan shadows already from Ofra and Urban Decay but no Z palette so I ordered one off ebay. I am currently using everything I got this month in my box everyday and a few things from last month .. I looooooove Boxycharm!!!
Reply
Courtney
I’m really excited about this box!!
Reply
Lindsey
I love getting single shadows instead of palletts! Plus, I love makeup geek; their eyeshadows are always great
Reply
Toni
Love makeup geek as long as I get color’s I don’t have I’m happy.Ive cancelled quite a few boxes myself,so far I’ve cancelled Glossybox,beauty joy box,lip monthly,and beautyfix box .Im on skin and haircare overload .Birchbox could be next! Also had julep and leggings monthly on hold last time and they could get cancelled too lol
Reply
Dianne
I’m trying to cut back. But I’m keeping Boxycharm and Ipsy for now. I canceled Play by Sephora and Birchbox and Glamour Doll Eyes and Allure. I’m also canceling Beauty Box 5 before it renews in March. I’ll cancel Boxycharm soon. Just getting to much. I want to try Teeblox.
Reply
Linda
Hope skim care isn’t a face peel. Have a few now, don’t really want another one.
Reply
Alisonka
Oooo… hope to get at least 1 matte color. This is a nice switch up from a palette! I love my palettes, but am on overload. These will be a nice addition to my custom zpalette. I just can’t pull off blue or grey.
Dr. Brant would be a very nice addition to the box! Anything other than moisturizer for me will be welcome.
Reply
Whitshay
Sucks for ppl who just joined bciz we didn’t get a zplette😣
Reply
Heather
Same here and I already have 3 pan shadows now getting 2 more so I ordered a Z palette off ebay!
Alisonka
Oh, I bought my first one on amazon for like $7. Empty, of course, but I like it way better than the ofra one.
Monica
I totally agree! January was my first box so I was really hoping Feb would be a palette. Just found out about these amazing boxes but made it late to the game for a palette. Hope there’s one in my near future! 🙏🏼
Tamara Deneweth
Yay I’m soooooo excited live mug shadows!! All the colors are so pretty but I hope I get some warm toned colors😀
Reply
Theresa
Skincare is dr brandt age defying microdemabrasion
Reply
Mikayla
Yo if it is the full size dr Brandt microdermabrasion (That’s insane!!!) I’m signing up!!! I’m obsessed with that stuff and almost out of my deluxe sample
Reply
Whitshay
How do you know 😀
Reply
Valerie
Someone tried to cancel their sub and it teased them with Make up Geek, the Dr Brandt and a drawing of brushes. They took a screenshot and posted it on Facebook.
Laurie
January was my third boxycharm. I have a hard time imagining ever cancelling this box. I just love it.
Reply
Becky
So so so bummed! My january box was finally supposed to be delivered today. It was delivered all right — but not to my address! Does this happen to anyone else???
Reply
Nan
Oh no!
Allie
This happened once with my ipsy bag. Someone hacked my account and switched my address to theirs. Some people are pathetic.
Nikki
It happened to me! I contacted customer service, and they were amazing. They sent out a new box right away, which actually came to my correct address!
Julie B.
So if I want to start with this box instead of with the Jan box, I have to wait till Feb to join up, is that right?
Reply
Jezzy
Yes!
Reply
Jay
Are these single eye shadows something you could put in a Z palette?
Reply
Sabrina
Yes they are. I have several in my Z pallet.
Reply
Christine
Yes! This is more like it! Ive been dying to try them!
Reply
MaryJane
Yasss, MUG. So glad no crazy blue or green colors. 😀
Reply
Kenya
The skin care item is a Dr. Brandt item.
Reply
Nan
How do you know that?
Reply
Kenya
When you go to cancel your account for boxycharm it asks you are you sure and tries to get you to stay subscribed by showing you a sneak peek of February. It shows makeup geek, Dr. brandt, and an unknown makeup brush.
Nicole A
Someone on Facebook mentioned the Dr. Brandt microdermabrasion for the February box-that’s $79!!!
Reply
Nan
I hope so. I’d love to try that.
Reply
svetlana7e
love Boxycharm. Received January box yesterday. Loved everything (except shampoo, but it will be send as a gift to one of MSA user), Cheek stain was amazing. Put this morning, it looked so natural and gave my face such a healthy color
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.