Posted by on in Beauty Subscription Boxes, BeautyCon BFF Box Reviews, Makeup Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Teens, Subscription Boxes for Women | Tags: | 33 comments

BeautyCon Box Fall 2016 Review + Coupon

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.


BeautyCon Box is a quarterly beauty subscription box. They highlight different beauty influencer curators each season and send a mix of beauty and accessory items.


My Subscription Addiction pays for this subscription. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).


This box is curated by MakeupShayla and Angel Merino.


The Subscription Box: BeautyCon Box

The Cost: $35.99 a box (ships once a quarter)

COUPON :Use code ADDICTION20 to save 20% on an annual subscription now until October 31, 2016. And while supplies last, use this link to get a free bonus box with an annual BeautyCon Box subscription, too!

The Products: “Our favorite beauty products and accessories delivered right to your door each season. Plus, members get the chance to win amazing experiences with our influencers!”

Ships to: US Only

Check out all of my BeautyCon Box reviews and all of our Beauty Subscription Box reviews!


Each box comes with an illustrated card of the curators, and on the flip side is the item list;



The Brow Gal Brow Dual-Ended Highlighting Pencil in Gold/Nude – Value $20


This pencil is part shiny highlighter and part matte concealer. Both ends go on smoothly and blend well – I’m really impressed with the formulas and the coverage/pigment. (Both swatched in lower photo.)


DUO Eyelash Adhesive – 2.5 g Value $1.60

I’m completely new to false eyelashes and glue, but Emily let me know that this glue is THE glue all youtube makeup artists use! It’s also free of Parabens, Sulfates, Synthetic Dyes, Petrochemicals, Phthalates, GMOs and Triclosan.

And this is a critical item to include since they also included lashes in this box:


Eyelashes by Flutter lashes by MakeupShayla – Value $10

For years now, I’ve received false lashes in subscription boxes, and kept them saying, “One day I will try these.” Well, in an effort to make sure I try every item I review when possible, it was time to actually try false eyelashes!


They were actually pretty easy to apply once I got over my fear of glue on my lashline. If you haven’t tried false eyelashes before, first, hold the lashes up to your lashline and see if the lashes are too long. Cut any excess, then apply a thin layer of glue to the lashes and let it set for a few seconds. Then apply to your lash line and move into the correct place.

(You can always use makeup remover to take it off if you make any mistakes.)

Here I am with one side on so you can see the before and after (apologies in advance for the closeup):


And these were pretty easy to remove, too. (I used makeup remover solution on a Q-tip on the lash line for a few seconds, then I was able to remove them without pulling out any of my own lashes.)


Jouer Conditioning Lip Treatment (4.5 ml) Value $8

This lip treatment is paraben-free, and non-sticky! It goes on clear and provides a lot of shine and moisture.


Laser Kitten Sweetheart Lipstick Pin – Value $12

There’s usually at least one or two non-beauty items in every BeautyCon box (think accessories like a keychain or necklace). Given how popular enamel pins are right now, I think this is a fun choice. (Though I wonder if this box would it feel like it had a higher value if the accessory item had literally bigger.)


Milani Bella Eyes Gel Powder Eyeshadow in Bella Taupe – Value $5


I really love how smooth this pressed powder felt while applying it! The pigment is pretty good, too. (Swatched in lower photo.)


Ofra Long Lasting Liquid Lipstick in Mocha – (8 g) FULL SIZE! Value $19.50

This liquid lipstick is heavily pigmented, and it has decent staying power, too. I found this Mocha shade to be flattering on my skintone, and I also like that the formula didn’t dry out my lips!

Here it is swatched:


(Lipstick, Eyeshadow, Highlighter, Concealer)


Luxie Rose Gold Large Angled Face Brush – Value $16

I’ve received these Luxie brushes in subscription boxes before, and I’m a fan. The brush is soft, vegan and cruelty-free, and the bristles are coated with an antibacterial solution.


Sugarfina Sugar Lips – (Taster Packet) Value $2.50


These sweet & sour gummy lips are in the flavors of Watermelon, Strawberry, and Bubble Gum. I couldn’t eat these because they are made with Red 40 :(, but Emily and Eric both were happy to sample them!


Simple Cleansing Facial Wipes – 7 wipes Value $1.25

I’ve sampled these before and I’m happy to have more. The wipes are gentle on my skin and remove makeup well.


Mystic Tan Mocha-Kyssed Bronzer Lotion (1 oz) Value $5.85

I was surprised by the scent of this lotion! Most self-tanners I’ve sampled range from not-great to tolerable when it comes to scent, but this one smells like a lovely perfume!

This is a 2-in-1 product. It immediately gives you a bronzer, and then the tanner gradually builds over time. So far, I really like it for the bronzing part – the color looks very natural on my skintone.


And this box also came with some stickers!


Verdict: Based on my estimates, this box has a value of about $101. I think that value is great, but it does feel like this box is missing a stand out hero item or two, or more full-size items like the Summer Box included.

That said, I’m still going to be using almost every item in the box, so I feel like I got my money’s worth.

What do you think of the Fall BeautyCon Box?

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Hello everyone,so I went to my bank account as I always do this time of the month,and I have a 10.00 credit from beautycon .I have no idea what it’s for or why I got it any ideas?

  2. Whats the bonus box that you get ??

  3. I paid for 1 year 4 box’s Now they are telling me I have to pay for shipping every quarter…. What a rip off…. Then you get this messed up fall box…. Please read all about this company …. Shipping is 6.99 so you are not paying 89.00 I have 2 more box’s I am done after that

  4. Does anyone know this sub’s shipping policy? Specifically how long before an order is considered lost and reship-able.

  5. I signed up for the Bunny box, and was happy with that one so I stayed subscribed. I tried to cancel after the Summer box but didn’t realize they have a weird cancellation policy, so I had to get this box too. I was excited at first to see Angel as one of the curators because I have a bunch of his diamond glow powders, so I was hoping for another or at least a sample size (maybe it would come in a shade I don’t already have?)… but this box sucks so bad. I cancelled before mine even made it to me in the mail. I cannot believe how stupid this box is! The value amount promised is a joke!

    My son is allergic to red food dye, so I didn’t pass these gummies on to my kids but they were horrible. So sticky and too sweet.

  6. I got a years subscription for my daughter (15) and this was the last of the 4 boxes. There was no doubt before that I would renew for her because the previous 3 were awesome! This one does absolutely suck and I may look for a different box for next year!

  7. Thanks for reviewing this!

    • I agree with everyone. I was disappointed with this box as well especially after the awesome summer box. I wasn’t so upset at the self tanner after using it. I was losing my tan so it came in handy.

  8. This box sucked! Self Tanner for a Fall box? Really? Candy, stickers and a teeny tiny pin? Was this box curated by 2 10 year olds? Not everyone wears false eyelashes and even if they did, could they spare the lash glue? Not even a full size on that. I really hope the Winter box is worth the price and that an “adult” puts it together or I’m out. Anyone looking for beauty boxes that ARE worth it should check out Boxycharm $21 5 FULL SIZE products and Beauty Fix $24.95 with 5 FULL SIZE products. For that matter Target and Walmart have better beauty boxes than this piece of crap, for less than $10!

    • Yeah…I really enjoyed the last two boxes, but this one was incredibly disappointing. It did not feel particularly well put together at all. I mean, tanner in a fall box? And not even enough tanner to cover my whole body at that. After the care and curation that went into Bunny’s box, I guess I’m a little spoiled but ugh.

  9. This was the most disappointing box ever. I was going to do the yearly subscription this box definitely changed my mind. Gave what little there was in box to my daughter.

  10. I hate to be negative but I feel like this box wasn’t as good as the others maybe because two YouTubers curated it, they each should had gotten their own month I feel.

  11. Liz, can you tell me if the eyeshadow is matte or shimmer?

    • It is a satin matte. Hope that helps! 🙂

      • Yes! Thank you!

  12. The Ofra Mocha I have looks so very different from the one here, and actually from every other one I’ve seen swatched around the internet. I am baffled as to why. Mine is a chocolate brown, but here and every where else it looks like a mauvey brown.

    • Yeesss! I even went to check on the website to see why mine look so different. My ofra mocha doesn’t look like that it looks like a cheer chocolate brown? Smh…

      • I’m glad it is not just me and I’m not crazy. I have the same problem with Americano and Honolulu. They look totally different in person than I’ve seen around the internet. I wonder if it’s because of photo editing.

        • It could also be your own natural lip color or the way your personal chemicals interact with the product as it dries? I know the products look different from when I initially put it on to when it dries.

  13. So the fall box was a huge disappoint BUT, I am in love with the browgal highlighter pencil! It goes on SO smooth, super blendable and the color is perfect!!! So at least I was able to find ONE product in the fall box that is worth using!

  14. The Milani eyeshadow has made regular appearances in Dollar stores, so while the full retail value may be $5, you can usually find it for $1.

    I still want more from this box since it’s quarterly and they have the time to really build an amazing box. Maybe a special collaboration or put together a unique, BeautyCon-exclusive lip color, palette, something special that you can ONLY get through the box. Unfortunately, it looks like they just stuff in things you can find at the drugstore. I’ve been super underwhelmed with this subscription.

    • Yup, that exact shadow is in my local dollar store. So was a skincare product from the summer box. So upset.

  15. Total dud box for me.

  16. I was very disappointed. It’s always to be expected to have both hits and misses in your subscription boxes, and I’m not one to usually complain because I look at subscription boxes as a way to try new brands and products that I wouldn’t normally buy or haven’t heard of, and it does always feels like I’ve gotten my moneys worth, but I expected better of a $35 quarterly box. I am happier with my $10 ipsy bags than I was with this box. I don’t expect products to be all high end or all full size, but when companies like boxycharm can put 5 full size products in a $21 box every month, or my $10 ipsy bags that usually have been having well over $60 value, they make this month’s beautycon box look like a joke.

  17. Nice close up Liz. Your brow game is strong! I really regretted not getting the Summer box after seeing the reviews because with so many full sized products and a value at almost $150 I felt like I missed out on a great deal for a lot of great stuff I would have really enjoyed. So I was all geared up for the Fall box but when I saw the lashes, glue and tanner stuff I said nah, I don’t use those and now looking at the review Im definitely glad I passed. This box is nowhere near as great as Kandee’s or even as good as Bunny’s. Maybe the Winter one will reel me in.

    • Just in case you’re still interested, the box they are giving away with the annual sub right now IS the summer box by Kandee. At least for me, getting both kind of offsets the not-so-great Fall Box.

      • Ohhh that is tempting. And $86 is a good price. Does the annual sub start with this box though? And how do you find out which extra box is included?

        • That’s how much I got it for using the MSA links!

          And yes, unfortunately, it is this box, but you’re getting a full bonus box free so you can pretend you paid for that one instead? 🙂

          And I believe everyone is getting the same box (the Summer Box) as the bonus box. So far every instagram post I’ve seen has shown that one as the bonus. I will say though, that mine was missing one item from the regular box. I don’t know if it was an oversight or if they just ran out of it.

    • I am upset I didn’t wait because I paid for the kandee box and I could have got it for free…5 for the price of 4…I would do it. Just know that the Benzac is already expired from that box. It says 09/16 which is now, and I myself haven’t even touched it. Just found that out.

  18. That’s not a full size ofra liquid lip. the ones you order from ofra for the $20 price point are about double that size – boxy charm did the same thing saying the tiny one was the full size! Definitely agree this box was missing a big ticket/standout item. The wipes easily could’ve been a full size pack, like they had in the box when Bunny curated. And the lipstick could have been an actual full size, but that’s just my opinion!

    • Hm, I saw that the packaging was different than the regular full-size version:

      But the size on the Ofra site is listed as 6 grams, and the one in the box is listed as 8 grams, so I thought it was actually bigger than full-size.

      So in conclusion… I’m officially confused! 🙁

    • It is full sized. It’s just a packaging differentiation. The way ofra explained the difference is the older packaging (looks smaller and fatter) does indeed actually have 2 g MORE than their new (slimmer and longer) packaging. Ofra states the difference as being an inner lining plastic lining. This quote is straight from them on their instagram as it is a common discrepancy that people complain about. I remember it specifically as I was planning on (and did) buy products during a hautelook sale.
      “This packaging actually has 2 grams MORE than our new regular retail packaging as our regular packaging has a plastic inner lining! This packaging is shorter but fatter and has no inner plastic lining and is more travel friendly!💞👍”

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.