Posted by on in Birchbox News, Subscription Box News | Tags: | 138 comments

Birchbox February 2016 Box Reveals Are Up!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2016-02-03 at 12.19.41 AM

The Birchbox reveals for February 2016 are up! (Thanks for the head’s up, Virginia!)

Use this link to see what you’ll get from Birchbox this month. (FYI – the reveal worked for one of my subscriptions, but didn’t load for a different subscription account, so you may need to try back later if it isn’t working for you).

What are you getting from Birchbox this month? Here is what I am getting in one of my accounts:

Screen Shot 2016-02-03 at 12.19.23 AM

If you haven’t signed up yet, get $5 (50 points) to spend in the Birchbox shop when you subscribe with coupon code SUBSCRIBENOW50

Check out my Birchbox reviews to learn more about this subscription!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.

138 Comments

  1. Link is working again and it still shows the same stuff, thank goodness, soooo excited about all my boxs this month! Ipsy seems decent, love my bb, I managed to get the target box and I’m super excited about almost everything in all the boxs. We are super poor this month, so these boxs are kind of like my valentines day presents 😀

  2. So the box that I see (and the one I saw yesterday before they temporarily shut down the link) doesn’t have the item I requested during sample choice. Not sure if I should bother them now since they always say that the items might change up until the 10th. What’s in my box isn’t terrible necessarily but I was looking forward to the REN mask (and I got a confirmation for it).

    Currently my box has:
    * Whish Three Whishes Body Butter (meh)
    * Sahajan Restorative Eye Cream
    * Corioliss Argan Conditioning Mask
    * POP Beauty Matte Velvet Lipstix Trio (super meh, I hate lipstick)
    * ARROW REVIVE Cooling Cheek Tint

  3. The link wasn’t working for me earlier but it is now. Same box, the one that a large amount of us are getting.

  4. I ordered the Date Night box. It’s just in time for a big Police Ball event that I have this weekend. Hopefully the box will arrive in time, it’s set for either Friday or Saturday.
    I worried about what others had said about the illuminator being replaced, but I can finally look at mine and it looks like there’s just the one perfume sample as was intended.
    I am most looking forward to trying the blow out spray and the Lip Tar. I’ve never really been a red lipstick wearer, but maybe this will be my excuse!

  5. I’ve been having trouble with Birchbox’s site lately, especially on Firefox it won’t even open anything. You click and it does nothing. I can’t get any secret link to show either one of my boxes 🙁 I only got to pick a sample for my Ace account before everything was “sold out”.

    • I think they may have done something to remove them. Because I was able to see my box this morning and now I can’t.

      • Yea the link now just goes to a random page on their site. I wonder why they took them down?

        • I hope it’s because the items were wrong because I think I hated whatever I was getting (I can’t even remember what they were besides a dreaded perfume and my sample choice).

          • I hope mine is different too.

          • I’m pretty sure mine is right. Before the link was working I received an email saying it was time to review my January box (I subscribed late in January, but in time to get a box). The products in the email were February’s box instead.

          • The link still works for me and my box is still poo.

    • I’ve been having the same problem on Birchbox.com with Firefox… nothing is clickable. (This is independent of trying to see a box reveal, rather an issue with just using the site at all.) The workaround that has been working is to ctrl + right click (open in new tab) on the link you want to open, and it does successfully open in a new tab. It’s a big pain to not have any of the links on the site working though.

      • I should note that plain right clicking to choose “open in new tab” under the right click menu doesn’t work either… ctrl + right click is the only way I can navigate the site at all.

  6. It doesn’t work when I click the link. Boo!!!!!

  7. that’s weird, I was able to see what was in my box yesterday and now when I try it doesn’t show anything. and a post about the “cheat link” that I responded to on their fb page was deleted. if my box is different then what was shown I’m gonna be so bummed as I loved 4 out of 5 items. anyone else having trouble seeing it today?

    • Yes, the “cheat link” no longer works. Come on BB, you know we want to see what we are getting..

  8. After seeing how many people can see their February box, I’m surprised that neither of mine are up – and one of my accounts is an Ace account. I didn’t choose a curated box for either and chose the Hey Honey peel-off mask as my sample choice for both.

    • Ok, that was weird – I tried a different link (https://www.birchbox.com/me/boxes/women/2016/2) and got to see my boxes on both accounts.

      My Ace account is:

      Hey Honey Take It Off Exfoliating Honey Peel Off Mask (my choice)
      Naobay Oxygenating Cream Moisturizer
      Obliphica Professional Seaberry Serum – Fine to Medium
      Color Club® That’s My Jam
      Eyeko Fat Liquid Eyeliner

      My non-Ace account is:

      Hey Honey Take It Off Exfoliating Honey Peel Off Mask (my choice)
      JUARA Candlenut Body Cream
      Klorane Gentle Dry Shampoo with Oat Milk
      POP Beauty Matte Velvet Lipstix Trio
      ARROW REVIVE Cooling Cheek Tint

      I’m really confused about the cooling cheek tint. I really didn’t need another dry shampoo. I’ve already given a friend two of them, and it’s a good thing we’re having lunch in a couple of weeks so I can give her this one plus one other that I’ve accumulated.

      But Eyeko Fat Liquid Eyeliner? I already have two of these (one came in my other sub, and one came in a Mystery Sample Pack), and I just started using one of them last week. It’s not that I don’t like it, but I can’t imagine I’m going to go them very quickly. I think I’m going to have to give it away because I have a feeling everyone is drowning in these, so no one will want to swap it.

      • If I was on the swap site, I’d swap it VERY happily!! (Been almost 4 months and I’m still wait listed) I LOVE that stuff 🙂 I’m sure you’d get a taker!

        • Hi Victoria,

          We open up the swap waitlist at least once a month, so I’ll look into when you signed up and email you to make sure everything is correct. Thanks!

        • I’m on the swap site but haven’t listed or traded anything yet. I think I need to gather together everything that I have that I’d like to trade (that I haven’t opened) and then try to trade a whole bunch. I’m just afraid of having to spend a lot of money on shipping (which I get – there’s just no way around it, nobody’s fault), which makes me not sure if it’s worthwhile. I guess if you can trade multiple things with one person, that’s the way to go.

  9. • Not Soap, Radio Body Wash (I’ve been tempted by two curated boxes that include this brand, so I’m excited to finally try it now)
    • Obliphica Seaberry Serum (I also received the wrong hair type, but will either swap or give this away)
    • Ren Radiance Renewal Mask (my sample choice)
    • Tocca Emelia (I normally dislike perfume samples, however I love Tocca and am so happy to try this one out! I think it’s a brand new scent to the shop, too)
    • Arrow Boost lip balm (yes!!! I was tempted to pick this for sample choice, and now I get it in addition to my top pick!!!)

  10. Is anyone else having issues contacting BB? You used to be able to call and talk to someone, now you get a message to go online and schedule a call back. I’ve never had an issue with them but they must have just updated this, it’s kind of annoying. I would like to just pick up and call at my convenience but looks like that’s not possible anymore.

    • maybe it’s because they just cut their staff by 15%

      • Not only that, they aren’t going to be offering the 10 additional points for sharing on social media. Seems like there are some serious financial issues at BB.

        • I noticed when I shared this month I didn’t get 10 points but I never saw a notice or anything. Thanks for mentioning!!

  11. I’m getting an Arrow “Cooling” cheek tint…..not sure why I would need or want my cheeks to be cooled by my blush??

    Also getting the Whish Cleansing Oil, ModelCo Lip Liner, Cartier perfume, and some scalp therapy (because my scalp has been through some tough stuff lately and is feeling a bit down).

  12. I got the whish oil cleanser
    The not soap body wash
    Arrow lip balm
    The red nail polish
    And the hair serum for medium-coarse hair.
    I picked the oil cleanser but had a very hard time choosing it over the lip balm so VERY excited I’m getting both to try. The body wash looks amazing, blackberry and vanilla cream??!! Yes plz.
    The nail polish looks like a beautiful color, not sure about the brand.
    The hair serum stuff us the only thing Im bummed about, I have it on my profile that I have fine, wavy, oily hair. There is no way I am going to be able to use this stuff, will just weigh my hair down. I thought maybe if it had some nice ingredients that maybe I could use it almost like a mask, and just rinse it out after letting it sit on my hair, but the ingredients are just chemicals and 1 oil, I’ll stick to my pure coconut oil.

    • I got the exact same! 🙂 I actually picked the Arrow Lip Balm as my choice though.

      I also have fine wavy/curly hair on my profile and, for some reason, will also be receiving the serum for medium to coarse hair.

      As for the red nail polish, ugh, I can’t pull of red nails or lips…just does not work with my skin tone. However, I’m accruing quite a pile of red, red, red…I never luck out to get pink or neutral. I’m hoping once I get into the swap page, I’ll be able to find a lady who loves red but only ever gets pink, neutral, nude and we can swap those products regularly!! Lol

  13. This is so weird…my sample choice is not in my box, even though it shows up under “My Box”. I’m a longtime Ace and placed my choice first thing the morning it came out, even before it was advertised. Has this ever happened to anyone before? How did you handle it – contact BB?

    • Same thing for me – I’ve been an ACE since 2014 and my sample choice item is not showing in my box for Feb. (I picked the REN mask.)

      They always say that the boxes aren’t final until the 10th so I’m not sure if I should wait until then to contact them…?

  14. Hope the perfume by Harvey will at least be a rollerball. Love Rollerballs, hate those other tiny perfume samples. <3

    • Birchbox never sends rollerballs in the monthly boxes.

      • Yeah… I think I got them confused with my Ipsy. I have a few Rollerballs from them.

    • I just think they should only include the free perfume samples only as a bonus, not counted as one of our items. Just my thoughts… <3

      • Agree 100%!

      • TOTALLY agree!

        When they’re a bonus, I’m happy to get them because it’s an extra 10 pts.

  15. I bought the “date night” box separate and received it today already!

  16. I will be getting…

    Harvey Prince Ageless pink grapefruit
    12 benefits instant healthy hair treatment (received another leave in last month too, but it smells like men’s aftershave)
    Supergoop cc cream
    Whish cleansing oil ( my choice )
    Pop beauty velvet matte lipstix trio

    This is my second box and I’m pretty impressed. I like fragrance samples though. I thought this would be my first box, but I must have subscribed in time for Jan. I received the ciate polish in play date, the tint water in strawberry juice, the derme serum, the 3 minute peel, and the number 4 leave in conditioner.

    • Oops! Didn’t mean to post twice. I couldn’t find my earlier comment.

    • I’m getting the same as you. I’m guessing we’re getting a sample of one of the lipsricks. Hope I get the rose one. I don’t want red…I need another red lipstick like I need a third eye lol.?

      • Same here lol. I don’t think we’ll be getting all the either. I’m hoping for a color other than red. I find myself always buying red. I need to be forced to choose another color.

  17. I’m getting:
    -Arrow lip balm (sample choice..yay!)
    -L’Artisan perfume sample (blah..I don’t wear perfume)
    -COOLA classic spf 30 cucumber moisturizer (yay!)
    -Malin + Goetz clarifying clay mask (super excited to try this)
    -Oiudad Vitacurl Define & Shine gel-creme (curly hair products are always welcomed here!)
    Pretty excited about this one..if I can get 4 out of 5 that are decent, I consider it a good month!

  18. getting the exact same box as Liz… i do not like that honey peel stuff and i have the juara body creme which is just OK, oh well.

  19. I’m getting:

    *Naobay Oxygenating Cream Moisturizer
    *Hey Honey exfoliating mask
    *Obliphica Seaberry Serum in Fine to Medium.
    *Color Club That’s My Jam Nail Polish
    * Eyeko Fat Liquid Eyeliner.

    I didn’t get the Eyeko liner last month (chose the K beauty box), so I guess they really are slowly giving them out to everyone.

    • I’m so annoyed to see that hair serum comes in a “fine to medium” option when I have “fine” listed as my hair choice and am receiving the “medium and coarse” serum. (of course none of this has anything to do with the previous poster)

      Just shows me that my profile has little impact on your selections.

      • me too. they real don’t loo at your profile.

    • I got one in my non-curated box last month (I have two subs). I also got one back in November or December as part of a Mystery Sample Pack. I will be getting one this month in my other sub (not the one I got it in last month). I think they also had it as a gift with purchase for a while, too, if I recall correctly. It seems like they have a lot of these on hand.

      It’s a good eyeliner, but I don’t really need three. I have an order arriving on Friday or Saturday and am not sure if I’ll laugh or cry if it comes in the Mystery Sample Pack again. I have gotten repeats of box items in MSPs before (though one of them was one of my favorite products, plus it’s a bonus, so it’s hard to complain).

      • Sorry, that was about the Eyeko liner. I didn’t realize there had already been replies and that my reply wouldn’t be clear (mobile site doesn’t doesn’t distinguish).

  20. *Whish Revitalizing Cleansing Oil
    *FHI Daily Beauty For Wildlife Healing Argan Oil
    *Sahajan Restorative Eye Cream
    *Body Shop Fuji Green Tea Body Butter
    *Arrow Boost Color Enhancing Lip Balm

    I’ve gotten way into cleansing oils, so I’m super excited! Another great Birchbox month for me! 🙂

    • Mine is the same as yours. I think I’ll actually like everything this month!

    • Ohhhh, nice box. Looks very moisturizing, I would love to get this one.

  21. Mine is ok. I like the Naobay and the Lip Balm.

    *Not Soap, Radio Body Wash
    *Naobay Oxegenating Cream Moisturizer
    *Terax Hair Care Original Crema
    *Tocca Parfum Emelia
    *ARROW BOOST Color Enchancing Lip Balm (sample choice)

  22. I picked the curated box, but this link tells me that instead of the Cynthia Rowley highlighter, I’ll get a Cartier perfume sample. Oh well.

    • Um. Wut? That’s not okay! The curated box isn’t supposed to have any variations! Substituting a fragrance vial for a makeup product is particularly bad.

      Maybe it’s just listed wrong in your reveal and you’ll actually get the highlighter. If not, I’d suggest writing to them.

    • That’s super weird and not cool. I hope that’s a mistake. One of the reasons I didn’t pick that box is bc I already had that Cynthia Rowley sample from a previous box. Today I got an order with a MSP – and guess what’s in it? Cynthia Rowley Brightening Illuminator. So they can’t say they ran out.

  23. I’m getting two of the exact same scrappy box!! How does that even happen? I’m not sure whether I should be upset or mad now…

  24. Yay, thanks Liz. I will be receiving:

    *Not Soap, Radio Body Wash
    *Whish Cleansing Oil
    *Obliphica Professional Seaberry Serum
    *Color Club Nail Polish in ‘That’s My Jam’
    *ARROW BOOST Color Enchancing Lip Balm (sample choice)

    Never tried/heard of any of these, so I’m super excited to get my box.

    • I got the EXACT SAME box!!!! I’m pretty excited

    • I also have the exact same box!

    • Exact same contents in my box. I’m very happy because at sample choice time it was hard to decide between the Whish oil and the lip balm. And now I’m getting both. Yay!

    • I am getting that same box..hope its not all foil ..my last box was..so upset

    • I’m also getting the exact same box! I have no nail polish on my profile because I don’t paint my fingernails, so kind of disappointed in that. It is a pretty red, though.

    • Exact same box here too.

    • Exact same box lol wonder if that was intentional on their part. This variation seems VERY popular. But hey, I’m not complaining 😀

    • Getting the same box, yeah! So excited to try the Whish cleansing oil and Arrow lip balm. This is a great box for me and I can’t wait to get it!

    • My box too! I am pretty happy as I like that body wash and wanted to try the cleansing oil, but went with the balm for a sample choice. I like Color Club polish and felt this was a great Valentines themed box!

    • Add me to the long list of people getting this same box. I’m excited for everything but the nail polish, which I don’t wear. I’m sure I’ll find someone to gift it to.

    • Same box here… only my 2nd Birchbox (well 3rd, I purchased the Strong Start box as well), so everything but the balm is new to me. And I can’t wait to get the lip balm, my daughter “borrowed” the one I got in the Strong Start box and refuses to return it 🙂

      • This is the same box I’m getting as well… also my second monthly and I purchased the strong start box!! Lol

    • Another one getting this box. I was most excited for the nail polish. I don’t paint my nails often but I will when I get a sample.

    • Same box here.

    • Same box for me. I did not want nail polish.

    • Wow! Seems like many of us are getting the exact same box! Im excited about mine but it seems like there used to be more variation.

    • Count me amongst those getting these same five items. The Whish cleansing oil was my choice but the lip balm was my second choice, so I’m happy on that front. And I happen to have medium-to-coarse hair so that product is okay by me too. I’m just thrilled to not be getting my two banes-of-the-box world, eyeliner and perfume!

    • Seems like too many girls getting the same box. Might be an.error

      • I was thinking the same thing…

  25. I’m getting
    Harvey Prince Ageless pink grapefruit
    12 benefits instant healthy hair treatment
    Whish cleansing oil (my choice)
    Supergoop dailycorrect cc cream 35+ spf
    Pop beauty velvet matte lipstix trio

    This is my second box and I have to say that I’m impressed so far.

    • Mine too! Not super excited as I won’t use perfume and lipstick.

  26. L’Oréal Professionnel Mythic Oil Nourishing Masque – Desperate need of a hair masque right now; so SUPER excited about this.

    Oscar de la Renta Flor Eau de Parfum – womp womp

    REN Glycol Lactic Radiance Renewal Mask – My Sample Choice 🙂

    POP Beauty Matte Velvet Lipstix Trio – Wome womp again… i just dont wear lipstick in super bright colors… but who knows; i may like it

    Marcelle New·Age 8 in 1 Power Serum – This gets really good reviews; so I am excited to try it.

    all in all 3/5 i’m excited to get. so; it’s an ok box.

  27. I was late for sample choice. I really wanted the arrow lip balm but it was out so I got the whish cleansing oil. So…I’m so excited the lip balm is actually in my box! That arrow cheek tint that some are getting sounds interesting too.
    I’m very happy with this month’s box!
    Whish cleansing oil
    Arrow lip balm
    Obliphica professional seaberry serum
    Color club nail polish (love getting nail polish)
    Not soap body wash

  28. I’m getting:
    ARROW BOOST Color Enhancing Lip Balm (my choice, yay!)
    Color Club® That’s My Jam (I’m a Julep snob and I have colors similar to this, although there was a time when all I wanted from sub boxes was nailpolish and never got it so despite me probably not using it, it is nice to see)
    Obliphica Professional Seaberry Serum – Medium to Coarse (I do not have medium or coarse hair, I have fine hair with some bends…this, like most serums and conditioners that I’ve gotten from BB will probably weigh my hair down)
    Whish Revitalizing Cleansing Oil (I’ve tried several Whish products thanks to BB and am never impressed)
    Not Soap, Radio Body Wash (I’ll throw it in my toiletries box with the rest of the body washes that I get monthly and use it when I camp or travel)

    This will be my last BB after being a subscriber for almost two years. I just have lost my excitement for BB – I haven’t discovered anything new that I loved in about a year and I just feel like the stuff I’m getting keeps being put in a drawer and not used. After this month I’ll have $20 in points which I can use towards my most favorite BB discovery, Paula’s Choice BHA exfoliate!

    • I’m getting this exact box as well and nothing is exciting at all to me. I just cancelled. I’m all sampled out anyway. Birchbox is great for newbies but I think I’m done unless something pops up I’m excited about.

  29. In one box I’m getting not soap, radio body wash, whish cleansing oil, arrow balm (my choice), Obliphica hair serum, and color club nail polish in that’s my jam. Not overly exciting, but I’m happy.

    I chose the featured box for my other subscription, but on my preview it shows two perfume samples and no Cynthia Rowley highlighter. Anyone else seeing this? Hopefully it’s just a glitch on the site and I’ll actually get the right stuff….

  30. I am getting:

    * Arrow lip balm (my choice)
    * Not Soap
    * Dasein Winter perfume (I think this is my fourth or fifth one since July)
    * Malin+Goetz clarifying mask (yeah)
    * Parlor leave in conditioner

    I wil have to look at my profile because I would like to get more makeup stuff.

    • Ooh, Birchbox has Dasein Winter now? I love that. Was going to buy it from Olfactif but it was over $80 even with January’s code so I didn’t. But with Birchbox points and an anniversary code? I totally can!

      • I have liked all the perfume samples I have gotten I just feel like I get them a lot.

  31. I’m getting the Hey Honey peel off mask (my sample choice), Juara body creme, Klorane dry shampoo, POP Beauty lipstick, and Arrow Revive cheek tint. All in all, a solid box with a great mix of skincare, makeup, and haircare. Now if ipsy would just open early access… 😉

  32. I’ve been pretty luck with BB. This is the first dud in a while. I got:
    – Not Soap, Radio Body Wash – I use bar soap so this will be given away
    – Whish Cleansing Oil – I will use this one
    – Obliphica Professional Seaberry Serum – Medium to Coarse – I have fine hair so not sure if I can use this.
    – Color Club That’s My Jam nail polish – I rarely wear nail polish and when I do it isn’t red.
    – Arrow Boost lip balm – My choice
    I guess it is the body wash and nail polish that killed it for me. I would probably have loved the hair serum if it was for my hair type. I can’t complain too much as I have never gotten a Harvey Prince item or a perfume sample from BB 🙂

  33. Yay! Aside from the red nail polish, I really like what I’m getting: Arrow lip balm, Whish Cleansing Oil, Obliphica Seaberry Extract hair serum, Not Soap, Radio body wash.

  34. I’m getting:

    Whish Three Whishes Body Butter – Got this in my first box over a year ago.. wasn’t impressed
    Hey Honey Take It Off Exfoliating Honey Peel Off Mask – my sample choice
    Klorane Gentle Dry Shampoo with Oat Milk – tried it before, not a dry shampoo fan (I know some people swear by it)
    POP Beauty Matte Velvet Lipstix Trio – the colors are not for me at all
    ARROW REVIVE Cooling Cheek Tint – this might be interesting

    I’m only interested in trying 2 of the 5 products and one was my choice anyway :-/

    • I’ve got the same box coming and, like you, I’m only excited about the cheek tint and hey honey mask. I don’t like dry shampoo and keep getting it from various boxes and birchbox has sent me whish body butter twice before and I didn’t like it either time. I find the scents plasticy and the lotion not moisturizing enough. And I don’t use lipstick, I’m a gloss girl all the way.

    • I’m getting the same box too. Agreed, not a fan of Whish but I’m excited for everything else in this box!

  35. I am getting bored with BB. The only thing that is great is there boxes.

    This is my secondI yearly subscription to BB and I have yet to get many “makeup” items. I’m finding my boxes are repetitive, This is my box:

    Jura body cream – another body product
    Whish Cleansing Oil – this is ok, but another skin care
    Honey take it off mask – I am collection masks, enough
    ModelCo lip liner (I don’t have a lip liner so I will use this)
    Palor leave in conditioner – this is new to me and I do use conditioners

  36. I got:

    1. Not Soap, Radio Body Wash
    2. Naobay Oxygenating Cream Moisturizer
    3. Terax Hair Care Original Crema
    4. TOCCA Eau de Parfum, Emelia
    5. ARROW BOOST Color Enhancing Lip Balm (my choice)

    Not too excited about this box at all… I really don’t like getting perfume samples in my boxes and there was one in my last box. What is a Hair Crema?? I’m picky about the styling products I use on my hair and this one has no reviews. I don’t need a basic moisturizer either. *sigh* If anyone wants to swap items, you know where to find me!

    • I got the exact same thing as you. It just seems like I’ve gotten many products like this within the last couple months. I’m not super excited, but sometimes I’ve been surprised by boxes that don’t ‘awe’ me right away. Hopefully, it’s not too bad! (I’m with you on the perfume though…ugh.)

  37. I am unsure how I feel about my box. I got the date night box and they are giving me 2 perfume samples. Ugggg, I asked for 6 or less on their questionnaire. I read the reviews of the Catherine Malandrino perfume and some are saying it smells like grandma. This is my second box from them (3rd if you count the lip sync) , and while January was great, I have a feeling this is gonna be a miss.

  38. I opted for the Date Night Box for the Cynthia Rowley Illuminator and it is not included in my box, but is instead replaced with a Cartier Goutte de Rose Eau de Toilette sample, making 2 frangrance samples for this curated box. Not at all what I signed up for. Seems like they are always replacing items in my boxes with subpar samples. Kinda disappointed, again.

    • I am getting the same. I was hoping for the Cynthia Rowley illuminator and was replaced with perfume. Disappointed as well.

  39. Loving my box?Not soap radio body waswash, Moringa lavender face oil, Living proof hair mask, pop lip trio, Cool a face matte tint.Rockin Birchbox

    • Same box as Lisa. I am very excited to try everything in my box. I did not get on the site in time to choose anything in advance so I am very pleased at the selection I am getting!!

    • That’s a great box!

  40. I haven’t been this excited about my box in a while!! I’m getting the Body Shop Fuji Green Tea Body Butter (I love anything green tea flavored so I’m curious what this will smell like), Terax Hair Care Crema (will use), Tocca Emelia perfume (meh about perfume, but love Tocca), Arrow lip balm (PYS), Hey Honey mask (debated forever about choosing this for PYS so yay). Can’t wait to try everything 🙂

  41. OMG I love my surprise picks: my pick the Honey Peel plus Arrow cheek tint, Whish body butter, POP mask and even Klorane dry shampoo (my 1st dry shampoo dupe!). ?

  42. Did anyone else who chose the Date Night box NOT get the Cynthia Rowley brightening illuminator? My reveal is showing that I got a perfume instead. The box already came with one perfume, so that’s a huge disappointment. I would have preferred ANYTHING but another perfume as a replacement.

    • I did as well. Kinda bummed about it. I think I would of been happy with anything but another perfume.

  43. I didn’t get the chance to choose the lip balm, which I wanted, so I got the Hey Honey Peel off Mask, along with Argan Conditioning Mask, Naobay Hydroplus Face Cream, Color Club That’s My Jam nail polish, and Pop Beauty Matte Velvet LIpstix. I’m not excited about the nail polish, but it seems like a pretty solid box.

  44. My first sub has the same products in your screen shot, but my second has the not soap, radio gel, marcelle new age 8 in 1 power serum, coola matte tint, pop beauty matte velvet lipstix trio, and beauty protect spray. I’m guessing it will just be one of the three lipsticks. I’m not sure I can get on board with a brand that spells it lipstix with an x, though. 😉

  45. I’m getting Dasein Winter fragrance (ugh), Harvey Prince Hello Body Cream (ok), Beauty Protector Protect & Detangle (ok), Super Goop Anti-Aging Eye Cream (I’m 22 and look about 16, so I don’t need this :P), and the Arrow lip balm, which was my choice for the month. This box looks kind of meh to me, but the lip balm and the $5 I’ll get in points make it worth it!

    • That’s the exact same box I’m getting. I’m kind of bummed there’s no actual cosmetics in it.

      • I agree!

    • Start the eye creams now. Your older self will thank you!

      • I agree about starting eye care early. I’m 47. I was like you, always looked at least ten years younger than my age. Alas, I never took care of my skin till 45, and now nobody says “what? you’re how old? I can’t believe it!” 🙁

      • Hmm, thanks for the advice 🙂

      • I also looked young for my age and my grandmother showed me now important skin creams are and I started young. I am 45 now and I get people thinking I am 10 or more years younger. I think it may be a large part genetics but since I am a sun worshiper, my skin could and probably should look much worse than my years.

  46. Not gonna lie, I’m really digging the box design. I always hang on to the boxes themselves because they make cute storage options. 🙂

    Anyways, I chose the Hey Honey mask. I had a hard time picking either that or the Arrow lip balm. Turns out, I’m also getting the balm! Win for me! I’m also getting a sample of a Tocca perfume. Usually I don’t like perfume samples (that aren’t miniatures), but I love Tocca and wouldn’t mind trying out another one of their fragrances.

  47. Mine looks unexciting but could turn out to be great once I use the products.

    1. Arrow lip balm (my sample choice)
    2. a Color Club nail polish (I almost never wear nail polish)
    3. BORGHESE Fango Purificante Clay Cleanser (I’m intrigued! But I haven’t been impressed with Borghese so far)
    4. Corioliss Argan Conditioning Mask (stuff with Argan oil is cool)
    5. a perfume that I’ve never heard of (Ugh. I don’t mind perfume as an extra, but not when it’s one of the five. 😛 Oh well.)

    Meh. We’ll see.

    • I’m getting this same box and couldn’t be more disappointed. I hate nail polish and perfume and have fine, thin hair that looks like a dirty mop when I use deep conditioners. I’ll try the face cleanser, but I’ve already found my holy grail cleanser, so it’s not exciting for me. The only thing I want is the lip balm I picked and it looks like a lot of people that picked something else got it anyway and a much better box! Boo.

      • Oh no!

        I don’t mind getting one or two products I don’t like (it’s unrealistic to love everything), but when every single product is a bust?? Oof. Maybe you can swap them?

  48. The one that says “this link” did not work for me but then I tried the one that says “Birchbox” and it worked!!! I’m super excited! I saw your box and saw the Juara creme and I was like oh my god i hope I get it aaannnd I am going to get it. Super happy, I know is sample size but still. ????

  49. I am THRILLED with my box – my favorite ever from Birchbox. I selected the Honey mask and am getting a Not Soap, Radio shower gel (which I’ve been dying to try ever since seeing it on the swap site), Obliphica hair serum, a Modelco universal lip liner, and an Arrow cheek tint. Can’t wait to get it!

    • Your box sounds like a great one! 🙂

    • I’m getting the same box! ? I’m excited for everything except the lip liner. I don’t really use lip products except for balms, but I’m sure I can find a friend to give it to. ?

  50. Ahaha, 5 months in, & I am ~finally~ getting a coveted Harvey Prince item!!! I also had managed to avoid Supergoop in any sub boxes… until now.

    • Hahaha I am also getting “dat harvey prince” that everybody is talking about;) sadly. hate perfume samples. Btw, why are you avoiding Supergoop? Looks like I am getting CC cream and I love foundation-like items in by boxes and was excited about it. Is it bad??

    • Supergoop is a fantastic brand as long as you’re not getting a sunblock *snooze*. Their CC cream was a life changer for me and I first received it as a BB sample but not before getting another dang sunblock, of course ?

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.