Posted by on in Beauty Subscription Boxes, Birchbox Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women | 64 comments

Birchbox Plus Review + Coupon – April 2015

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Birchbox Plus Review + Coupon - April 2015 Box

Every month Birchbox offers a few different “plus” items you can add to your subscription at a discounted rate. This is the first month I took advantage of their plus offerings – I had to have this Rifle Paper Co. tote!

Birchbox Plus Review + Coupon - April 2015 Florals

My Subscription Addiction pays for this subscription. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

Birchbox Plus Review + Coupon - April 2015 Tote

Rifle Paper Co. Tote – Value $35 (Cost to add to box: $28)

I believe this tote has sold out (or was available exclusively as a plus item, because I can’t find it on their site anymore). I’m happy I added it to my box this month – it is really well made, and so beautiful! It’s also a little larger than your typical tote bag, and it has an additional canvas lining making it extra sturdy.

Birchbox Plus Review + Coupon - April 2015 Box

Birchbox is one of the original beauty subscription boxes, and one of my personal favorites. (I’ve discovered so many new brands through this subscription, and their rewards program is the best!)

This month I decided it was time to have more than one subscription – I wanted the curated box and a sample pick box!

Birchbox Plus Review + Coupon - April 2015 Open

Also I had to get a Rifle Paper Co. designed box – I wished they designed Birchbox boxes every month!

Birchbox Plus Review + Coupon - April 2015 ITems

The Subscription Box: Birchbox

The Cost: $10 a month (get one month free and $10 to spend in the shop with an annual subscription!)

COUPON: Get $10 (100 points) to spend in the Birchbox shop when you subscribe with coupon code JILLIAN

The Products: Beauty and lifestyle samples selected by the Birchbox team.

Ships to: US, FranceSpain and the UK and Canada

Check out all of my Birchbox reviews and the Beauty Subscription Box Directory!

Birchbox Plus Review + Coupon - April 2015 Info

Each box comes with a card detailing the items included and some tips on how to use them.

Birchbox Plus Review + Coupon - April 2015 POP

POP Beauty Portfolio Eye Shadow Palette in Peach Parfait Trio – Value $4?

This was my sample choice for this box. (I just can’t resist a palette in a subscription box!) I’m happy with the amount of pigment in these shades, they blend well together, and the shimmer is subtle so it is great for daytime looks.

Cynthia Rowley Beauty Brightening Illuminator – .04 oz Value $10.20

The Cynthia Rowley beauty line is exclusive to Birchbox, and I’ve liked other products I’ve sampled from her line, so I was excited to try this. It’s a pink pearlescent liquid highlighter, and a little goes a long way. (The coloring reminds me of Benefit’s High Beam).

Birchbox Plus Review + Coupon - April 2015 Wei

WEI Manuka Bee Venom Mask (1 Pod) – Value $7.50

This is an anti-wrinkle mask, and I can’t wait to try it. (I feel like bee venom beauty products have been trending lately as natural Botox alternatives, and I’m curious!)

Birchbox Plus Review + Coupon - April 2015 Beaver

Beaver Professional Hydro Nutritive Moisturizing Shampoo – 2 oz Value $3.50

Beaver Professional Hydro Nutritive Moisturizing Conditioner – 1.35 oz Value $3

Unfortunately for me this shampoo is made with sulfates, and I have to avoid that ingredient in hair care products since my hair is color treated. They will make good swaps/gifts though!

Verdict: This box has a value of about $28. I think the value is great, and I’m happy with the products/brands included, and the sizes of the samples. And I can’t wait to try my bee venom mask!

What do you think of the April 2015 Birchbox? Did you get any Birchbox Plus add-ons this month?

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.

64 Comments

  1. Has anyone noticed that customer service has gone down hill lately. I have yet to receive my April box. I’ve called several times and they either say they will reship or to wait. Finally today May 5th the customer service said I guess we’re out of April sample boxes. She told me she would send me a complimentary June box since I missed the cut off time for May. I had to explain to her over a dozen times it’s technically not complimentary because I’ve already paid for it and have to wait 3 months. After that she still wouldn’t offer me any compensation for the 3 month wait!

  2. I actually used the Beaver shampoo and it just ripped the color out of my hair. The water was actually dark. I was shocked. I have used LOTS of shampoos and that had never happened to me before. That product is total crap. Beware!

  3. This was my first Birchbox and I loved my box. I don’t plan to participate in the chose your sample thing so I can’t comment on that. My box had Cynthia Rowley illuminator wich I’m excited to try,Super Goop eye cream with spf. I’m especially happy about this because most eye cream with spf burns my eyes but Super Goop doesn’t. One of my favorite products. I also got the Wish shave cream in blueberry. Love the scent and how close of a shave it gives. Beauty Protector hair oil. I have really thick hair that is really long-past my butt-and hair oil is always appreciated in sub boxes. Last product was Temple Spa body lotion. Smells amazing,leaves my skin super soft. A fabulous box.

  4. This is my second box. My first box I ordered late in the month and they gave me so-so products, but I thought hey, they are probably giving me left overs. But my second box, I tried MANY MANY MANY times to choose a sample, I wanted the eye shadows because they were so pretty, but the website wouldn’t let me submit my choice for whatever reason. And out of the only 2 boxes I got, I’ve received shampoo and conditioner. I only got one thing I’m really excited to use which is a serum to reduce redness. And I got even a jumbo lip pencil, I’m sort of excited to use. Otherwise I got shampoo, conditioner, and body wash, all that smells bad to me.

  5. I got my Birchbox today – first time with the $30 beta box. I noticed something funny and not sure if this was an error or done on purpose, but my shipping label reads “Ship To: The Bubbly Michelle (insert last name)”… I smiled when I saw this as I’ve not had a good day and whether a mistake or not, I was amused 🙂

    • It’s not a mistake! Mine changes every month.. this month I got “The Shining [x]”

  6. Just got my box today and my eye shadow palette was completely smashed. I emailed customer service. Does anyone know if they replace damaged items?

  7. I got my Box today and the tote add on as well. The tote is beautiful and I’ll start carrying it right away, however I’m disappointed that it doesn’t have any pockets! I would like at least a cell phone pocket, but a zippered pocket would have been nice too. Oh well. I got the Jane ireda,e chosen sample and it’s tiny but very cute. I didn’t try it yet. Also got the eye shadow palette, whish shave cream in blueberry, a hair see rum and a facial peel

  8. Very disappointed with this month’s box. I hate getting shampoo and conditioner! I feel that they bring down the value of the box. There is nothing in the box that I will use this month. Having said that, I love the box and am usually happy with BB.

  9. I just got my April box and liked it, but it’s a little frustrating to get items that I know I’d like but in the wrong shade. For example, I got the Jouer lip/cheek tint and I like the texture and the cute little packaging, but I got the orangey one instead of the pink one. I know that’s the way of subscription boxes, so I’ll just suck it up. 🙂 I will say the gorgeous floral box it came in was almost worth the $10 itself — soooo pretty! I can see why many of you also bought the floral tote. I never get emails from BB offering me options like that or offering the chance to get certain samples or special edition boxes (like Mad Men). They don’t even email to say my box has shipped. I wonder why?

  10. I just received my mad men box (love it) and that adorable tote bag. They shipped both together. The tote is very well made and will last I’m sure. I originally purchased this as a gift but I’m keeping it, it will make a great spring/summer tote for sure.

  11. I’ve been subscribing to BB for 9 months now and I have really been trying to happy or even satisfied with what I recieve, however, for the last 3 months I am not feelin the love =(. Honestly, I never receive anything in the sneak peeks and have received both perfume and body care items in my last few boxes. The only 2 items I don’t use. I have taken my quiz over twice and no changes. Does anyone have suggestions? I appreciate all samples and I don’t wish to complain and bring everyone down.

    • I agree, the last few months have been horrible! And i’m in my 2nd year of subscription. I always get lip product even though I say please no more then 4 a year on my profile. So many hair oils, face oils and perfumes…i’ll give it a few more months but most likely won’t be re subscribing for another year, its just not worth it. And I also never get any of the items in the sneak peak. My friends who monthly subscribe get the roll on mascara, the beauty blender and other cool items that i never got. SO FRUSTRATING as a long time sub.

      • I feel the same way. I’ve been a subscriber for nearly two years now and had really been loving my boxes, but I feel like they’ve taken a turn since I bought a year-long subscription last winter.

        We’re only 4 months into 2015, and for three of those I received a shampoo and conditioner set. I don’t want to turn off the bath and body option because I love the occasional body wash and lotion, but this is silly. 🙁

        • Do you have access to the beta product preferences in you account? You can now limit things like shampoo and conditioner to 4 times a year tops.

  12. I’m so excited I got the tote! It’s more money I didn’t want to spend BUT I really need a nice pretty spring/summer bag. Everything I own right now is dark. It will be perfect for the pool this summer. 🙂 can’t wait to see what I get in my box…I requested the eye shadow pallette too.

  13. Liz or anyone that can help, Do the plus items, and your box come together? Or do they ship separate? Thanks for the help.

    • I think they ship together. My did not because there was an issue.

      • Thanks PA Anna. 🙂

  14. I’m pretty disappointed. Long story short — I used to weigh over 300 lbs, didn’t care what I looked like. Gave up makeup 20 years ago. Recently lost a bunch of weight, started caring again. Figured sample boxes were a good way to “get back into it”. Really want makeup. Birchbox this month was the shaving cream, shampoo, conditioner, a body butter, and LAQA & Co. Sheer Lip Lube Pencil. I’ll use them all, but . . .

  15. I received my tote too! I like it a lot. My box is due to arrive this week. I am receiving:

    1. Beaver Shampoo
    2. Beaver Conditioner
    3. LA Fresh Instant Body Soother
    4. Jane Iredale PYS
    5. Harvey Prince Hello Body Butter

    I feel like I’ve been emailing BirchBox often in the past few weeks. I am unhappy to see a Made in China shampoo and conditioner in my box. Google it. My concerns are the environmental factors. I can’t use it anyway because sulfate agitates my rosacea.

    • I think it’s too big a risk to use any product on your body that is produced in China. There are so many horror stories about production there and no way for the consumer to know whether anything made in China is safe.

      • BB’s take on this is that I should trust them and the product because they are sending it to me. I’m done once my sub runs out. It doesn’t matter what amazing LE or points or specials they have available.

        • I’m going back and forth with BB. They referred me to the product page which lists the shampoo as having avocado and aloe vera extract in it. I googled and read up on every ingredient on the list. Scary reading. I did not find avocado or aloe vera listed.

          My regular shampoo has aloe vera in it. It is the second ingredient and is listed as “Aloe Barbadensis (Leaf Juice)”.

      • Well, the Real Chemistry peel that I got is actually made in China. Too bad ’cause that’s the product I was most wanting to try. I’ll put it out to swap for people who don’t care.

        Without counting it – and I think products form China shouldn’t be counted – my box had a total value of $10.50, which is very disappointing.

        • I forgot about that. I didn’t complain about the peel when I received it. I think Pop and Coastal Scents are made in China too. I don’t know for sure myself, but others have looked into it.

  16. That tote is awesome – I am sooooo jealous right now 🙂

  17. I also got the tote and it surpassed my expectations with the amazing quality of it. It’s cute, but not my style I bought it for a gift for my mom. I think she’ll love it.

  18. I don’t care about the products honestly, I just want that box! It’s sooo cute.

  19. That tote looks really pretty, nicer than it originally looked! I don’t see it anywhere on the website either.
    I got the Jane iredale lip (my choice- I’m so glad it’s in the shop now b/c I’ve wanted it since getting it in a different sub), supergoop eye cream, ojin hair oil vial, Harvey prince lotion, and Not soap Radio body wash. Overall I’m happy with my box.

    • I managed to put another tote in my shopping bag, and went as far as checking out. Maybe a glitch, but I can buy it for sure!

  20. Do you just make another account with a different e-mail if you want multiple boxes?

    • Yep!

      • Why do they make you do it that way when surely they see it’s going to the same physical address, i.e., the same person?

        Also, what is the difference between a “sample pick” box and a regular one? Do you always get 5 different products in each?

  21. I am not sure if this works for everyone, but I saw the Rifle paper tote in the shop on the app. I ordered it on April 1 and got it last week itself. The picture says Sold Out,but you will be able to add it to the cart.

  22. I received both of my curated boxes last week and just now got shipping for my upgraded account. Also I couldn’t even see what I was getting till yesterday, & I’m not sure if what I’m getting is really worth the extra money or time it takes to get to me. I think everyone with the upgraded accounts are getting the same thing which include the Beaver shampoo and conditioner, a nail polish, two of the sample choices, and a set with a mascara and eyeliner I believe. I guess I’ll wait till I have it to see if I actually think its worth it. Also I love that Cynthia Rowley highlighter, it’s beautiful!

  23. This coupon code doesn’t seem to work either.

    • Yes, I tried the coupon code yesterday–it doesn’t work. Bummer.

  24. I have two subscriptions because I always like getting one special box and one regular currated box. My regular box had the beaver conditioner and shampoo (which quite frankly I’m tired of getting shampoo and conditioner samples), the bee venom mask which I am stoked to try, the blueberry whish shaving cream (super nice for traveling) and the jouer tint in petal (which is cute but not something ill use much). Between both boxes, i feel like i got a pretty good deal this month. Loved the madmen box though!

  25. I haven’t received mine yet, but of course I peaked online to check what I am getting. I am getting another Whish shaving cream (I’ve received one before) and also the Bee Venom that I’m pretty upset about. I’m allergic to bees and will not be able to use it. I am going to wear gloves when I open my box in case it has opened up during shipping. I’ve received leaking products in 3 out of 9 Birchboxes. Two have been minor leaks but last month I got a lipstick that the cap came off of and got all over everything and the detangler leaked all over. Their customer service was awesome and sent me a new box though. I’ll probably contact them again about the Bee venom but I feel bad about doing it two months in a row.

    • Sara,

      I’m also allergic to bees (and yes, really allergic with the epi-pen and the whole bit), but never considered avoiding products with bee venom. Perhaps I’m just particularly dumb. Have you been advised by a doctor to avoid bee venom products, or are you making an assumption? I apologize if that sounds critical, I’m honestly just curious as I have never considered the possibility before.

      • I got the bee venom mask last month and it came with a note that said not to use it if you are allergic to bees.

      • If you are allergic to bee stings – or insect bites you should avoid this product. I am basing this on my own Doctor’s advice when I asked her if it would be safe for me to use. Yes, I talk “product” with my Doctor. She is cool like that! But, take that with a grain of salt.

      • When I saw I was getting it in my box I googled it to see if it caused reactions and found out that they advised against it for people with allergies. If you google it, there are actually a lot of people who react to the product that aren’t even allergic. It just seems like an unnecessarily dangerous thing to put in a subscription box.

  26. I haven’t gotten my box yet, but this is what I’m getting:

    – Jane iredale cheek/lip stain
    – harvey prince yogini perfume
    – supergoop cc cream
    – real luminous peel
    – temple spa face & body balm.

    I think I’ll use all the products. I’m so glad I didn’t get anything for the hair, in particular any hair voluminizers or hair sprays! Come to think of it, I should put the ones I have for swapping.

    • I got almost the same box except I have Number 4 Hydrating Shampoo instead of the peel.

  27. This is only my 2nd month getting Birchbox (or any sub box for that matter!) and mine is completely different than yours.

    I got:
    – Real Chemistry Luminous 3-minute peel (sounds interesting!)
    – Whish Shaving Cream in Coconut (I don’t really like coconut but I’ll try it)
    – Jouer Tint (my choice, really small but I like it! esp. as a cream blush)
    – Number 4 Super Comb Prep & Protect (sounds good to try)
    – Atelier Cologne, Orange Sanguine (I’m not a citrus person but I put it on my wrists the other day and waited a while as is generally suggested and the citrus smell went away and what was left, I actually liked! I almost never wear perfume so I chose the option to get perfume samples as little as possible but this isn’t bad.)

    I would mind trying that Bee Venom mask… let us know how it works!

    • If anyone want to trade the bee mask for the Jane iredale lipstain, please let me know!

  28. I looked at my spoilers online and almost called them out of anger – but then decided to wait for my box as last month they posted the wrong box online (actually I think they sent me the wrong box). My sample choice was missing and it contained a shampoo and conditioner for dry/damaged hair – my account clearly states that I have color treated hair so I can’t use the sulfate and I did not mark dry or damaged. I do have BB Beta so if the box they posted online is really my box then that would be my all time worse one as it’s just a bunch of items that I haven’t marked to receive no more than 4 times a year and no sample choice!!

  29. I added the tote as well, it looks really nice, although I so didn’t need another bag (sigh). My box won’t be here until Thursday and I am extra impatient for it this month, I don’t know why. The app says I’m getting the highlighter too, and I think that’s a fun product to try for spring, and I want to try the mask!

  30. You seem to have gotten a really nice box, and I’m a little jealous. This month I got another Number 4 product, and this is the 3rd month in a row getting their brand. I also got the Whish shave cream, which I’d received in another box before. I was a little annoyed by that, but even more annoyed when I went to review my items and it told my I could not review the Whish shave cream since I already had done it before. I e-mailed Birchbox and am waiting a response, but I really don’t feel like I should miss out on a point because they wouldn’t give me a new and different sample.

    I’ve been noticing my boxes really have no value and no thought put into them lately, and they arrive later and later. Does anyone else notice this happening? I’m really annoyed and thinking of cancelling, repeat products are just no fun!

    • I got a repeat Whish product that I could review. I called them and they gave me 10 points. They couldn’t have been nicer 🙂

    • Let them know your frustration! I emailed and got 50 points, and an apology.

      • Thanks for the advice! I did e-mail them and I’m just waiting on a response. I hope they’re as nice to me as they were with other subscribers and give me some points to make up for it.

  31. My Birchbox was a little bit of a bust this month, except I love the Jane Iredele Lip & Cheek Stain (the one I picked for this month). The sample size is pretty small, but I was just really excited to try it and have already ordered the full size version.

    I will try the other items I received, but nothing I’m really excited about. Last month and the month before were really great for me though, so I don’t mind a slight dud every now and then.

  32. I am getting that Beaver shampoo and conditioner on BOTH of my accounts this month. I use shampoo with sulfates so I don’t care about that (even though my hair is color-treated, it doesn’t seem to make a difference for me). But I did contact Birchbox and asked them what I could do to make my boxes a little more different from one another and they set me up for the Beta preferences thing where I can opt to reduce the number of certain types of samples I get.

    • Have never heard about a Beta preferences thing! What’s that all about please?

      • Something that is apparently not active on everyone’s account. I think they only activated it for me because I asked how to differentiate my two boxes. (I said I didn’t mind the types of things they were sending, I just didn’t want the SAME samples in each box.) So they gave both my accounts access to a more in-depth preferences quiz. You can limit types of samples to 4 times per year (similar to the perfume question on the profile but for more categories like shampoo and conditioner).

        I don’t know how well it works yet because it won’t go into effect until my May box. But I have been getting a lot of sample overlap so I hope this stops that.

      • I’ve been a subscriber for 9 months and I’ve had the Beta preferences set up since November, I think. There are 5 main categories: body, hair, makeup, nails, skincare. Each of these main categories is then further divided into smaller subtopics. You get to choose between “Max 4 per year” or “Keep them coming” for each subtopic.

        The problem with that is there are so many subtopics under each main category that you can still end up with a ton of products that you’re not interested in. For instance, there are 7 different hair subtopics. I don’t want any hair products, but with each one set to “Max 4 per year” I could potentially still get 28 of them. I realize that they did that for logistical reasons, they can’t perfectly curate every single box they send out to each subscriber! I just hope the Birchbox team looks at the preferences as a whole and uses it as guideline to get me more of what I want and less of what I don’t.

        • I’ve been a subscriber for almost two years and my account doesnt have this option!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.