Posted by on in Food Subscription Boxes, Okie Goodies Box Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews | 5 comments

Okie Goodies Box Subscription Box Review – February 2015

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Okie Goodies Box Subscription Box Review - February 2015 Box

Okie Goodies Box is a monthly subscription that sends foods grown, mixed, or made by small businesses across Oklahoma.

This box was sent to us for review purposes. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Okie Goodies Box Subscription Box Review - February 2015 Inside

The Subscription: Okie Goodies Box

The Cost: $30 per month + $4.95 shipping (less per month with longer subscription plans)

COUPON: Use code GIVEAGIFT15 to save 15% off a gift subscription

The Products: 5-7 goodies (including ready-to-eat snacks, chocolates, candy, jams, sauces, spices, and more) made by small businesses across Oklahoma

Ships to: US

Check out the Food Subscription Box Directory for more food boxes!

Okie Goodies Box Subscription Box Review - February 2015 Extras

Okie Goodies Box Subscription Box Review - February 2015 Card

Okie Goodies Box included a magnet, a coupon code, a card detailing the items in the box, and a map that shows where in Oklahoma the items featured this month were made.

Okie Goodies Box Subscription Box Review - February 2015 Popcorn

Kernels and Kandies Zebra Popcorn– value $5

Unique Confections Truffles– 4 truffles, value $10

This sea salt caramel corn was drizzled with generous amounts of milk and white chocolate. For me, caramel corn is a food I never buy but will happily devour if it’s in the house. Given that it’s described as sea salt caramel corn, I was hoping it might be a little saltier (I couldn’t really pick out the saltiness), but it was still delicious. I did like that it came packaged in a re-sealable bag so I could nibble at it little by little without concern that it would get stale.

Unfortunately, the paper box containing the truffles arrived damaged. It looks like one of the walls came unglued from the rest of the box, and, as a result, the truffles spilled out into the cardboard shipping box during transit. I decided not to eat them (just to be safe), but I really liked the flavors they decided to include. In addition to relatively classic flavors like raspberry and cheesecake, there were also two more unusual flavors: Blackberry Sea Salt and Cayenne White Chocolate. I’m a sucker for an experimental flavor combination, so these were right up my alley! Here’s a photo of the truffles:

Okie Goodies Box Subscription Box Review - February 2015 TrufflesOkie Goodies Box Subscription Box Review - February 2015 Toasted

Sweet Prairie Home Signature Strawberry Fudge– 4oz, value $6

Toasted Strawberry and Sangria Spread– 9oz, value $6.95

Sweet Prairie Home fudge was also included in this month’s O! Fudge Box (The same company runs both O! Fudge Box and Okie Goodies Box). Like the fudge I received in that box, this one did not have an expiration date listed. To be fair, the chocolates didn’t either, but I think there’s a difference between boxed chocolates and fudge sealed in plastic. It seems pretty clear that an unwrapped box of truffles should be eaten soon after it’s received, but I’m not sure about a sealed container of fudge. I reached out to customer service in the hope they could provide an expiration or use by date, but I did not receive a reply.

I really liked the wine fruit spread. It was much thinner than a traditional jam, but the flavor was great. The wine flavor was subtle but definitely present. The Toasted website recommends trying the spread as a marinade for chicken or adding it to sautéed onions and peppers to create a sweet glaze. 

Okie Goodies Box Subscription Box Review - February 2015 Chocolate

CoCoFlow BonBons– 2 bonbons, value $6

As you can probably see from the photo below, this candy box also arrived damaged. Luckily, these bonbons remained in their box. There weren’t any flavors listed on the information card, so I’m not sure exactly what the flavors were. The dark chocolate bonbon was filled with a smooth dark ganache that tasted a little bit fruity, but I couldn’t pinpoint the exact flavor. Raspberry, maybe? The milk chocolate bonbon was filled with a white ganache that might have been flavored with caramel.

Okie Goodies Box Subscription Box Review - February 2015 CocoFlow

Verdict: The value of this box totals $34, which almost exactly equals the cost of the box when you factor in shipping. I enjoyed the variety of products, and I liked the foods I was able to sample. That being said, I think this box will likely have the most appeal to those with some personal tie to Oklahoma. As I mentioned above, I also found their customer service to be unresponsive, which is never a good thing.

What did you think about this month’s Okie Goodies Box?

Update: Since my box of truffles arrived damaged, Okie Goodies kindly sent me a replacement box. I never reached out to them directly about the damaged product, so it was a nice, unexpected surprise to receive another box.

Written by Lindsey Morse

Lindsey Morse

Lindsey is a professional baker by day and a subscription box junkie by night. She first subscribed to Birchbox in 2013 and her addiction grew when she signed up for Graze, PopSugar, and Knoshy. Her favorite part about being a subscription box addict is discovering new products- especially gourmet goodies, beauty products, and kitchen tools!
All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Thank you for the review, Lindsey! I’m so sorry your truffle box didn’t hold up. I’ll get in touch with Andrew at Unique Confections to get you a replacement sent asap!

  2. I would still be all over those truffles. Haha!

  3. I love reading your reviews of food boxes! I’m trying to lose some weight now but I’m definitely going to sign up for one in the future.

    • Thanks so much, Felicia! I really enjoy writing them! 🙂

  4. This box looks really nice! Too bad that you couldn’t try the truffles, the one with the smiley face is especially cute.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.