Posted by on in Subscription Box Spoilers | 80 comments

POPSUGAR Must Have September 2014 Spoiler & Coupon!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

New POPSUGAR Must Have $10 Coupon Code

The spoiler for the September 2014 POPSUGAR Must Have box is out!

POPSUGAR Must Have September 2014 Spoiler & Coupon

Each POPSUGAR Must Have box will include the Fall essential scarf by Tilo Scarves. ($125 Value!) Remember, use coupon code MUSTHAVE5 to save $5 off your first box if you haven’t signed up yet.

What do you think of the spoiler? I’m thrilled! AndI have a feeling the September boxes will sell out quickly with this spoiler!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. I have a spoiler pic of whole box, how do I post it?

    • I WANT TO KNOW WHAT IS IN IT!!!! I think you can send the pic to Liz via contact but not sure. Liz if you get the pic PLEASE post it!!!! I so want to know!

      • I don’t know how to post a pic. Google #musthave #tilo its on Instagram you will see it

      • Just posted the spoilers!

    • Just put together a spoiler post – thanks!!

    • Sadly that is the box from 2 years ago. 🙁

    • Wow, that video from two years ago really showcases what I miss about PopSugar, and what it used to be!

      a book AND two movie tickets
      dinner for two coupon
      good looking/sounding snack items
      full Benefit mini kit (not full sizes, but not just a single sample)
      cute notepad
      must haves pouch
      yes to cucumbers towelettes and hair tyes – cute and useful for some
      $25 gc to a website

      Man, if a box was like that again..

    • Wow.. Wish I was signed up 2 years ago. lol

  2. Is there a good $10 off code? Tried MustHaveYT and didn’t work

    • No $10 off coupons right now, but MUSTHAVE5 will work for $5 off.

  3. I love that scarf popsugar is amazing. They get the best deals too. Had to grab this box

  4. Okay, I actually just signed up for my first Popsugar box ever. I was never too interested in it as I seriously dislike being sent random household goods – but I’ve liked the look of the scarves in their previous boxes and I think I will enjoy this scarf too when it gets colder. Here’s hoping the rest of the box is awesome.

  5. For all those (including me) who missed the $10 code I just tried the refer5 coupon code and it took $5 off my order.

  6. Liz the CS of popsugar wrote me that the the coupon expired and the could not do anything about it . That time when I places the order and saw the mistake I checked your post and it still said that the coupon was musthavemom , you only updated the next day . I am so disappointed I their CS . I was looking forward to this subscription as you said it’s one of your favorites .

    • Hi Natalie,

      So sorry. I always try to update coupon codes as soon as I find out they are expired, but unfortunately POPSUGAR doesn’t give me a heads up on when coupons are expiring. Since you didn’t mean to place the order, I would recommend reaching out to POPSUGAR again and letting them know it was an accident and that you would like to have the order cancelled. Then place a new order with the current coupon code.

      Hope that helps!

      • That’s what I tried to write and explain to them . But it doesn’t seem they want to do that .

        • Hi Natalie,

          I would advise not mentioning a promo code when you contact them again . Just write them and say you didn’t mean to place the order an you would like them to cancel it as you do not want it.

          Once they cancel it. Then go and order it using a promo code that works and make sure it goes thru prior to submitting your order. You don’t need to tell them this is what you’re doing.

          Hope that they listen this time!! Good luck

          • Thank you for advice , I didn’t know that and I did mentioned and now they don’t want to do anything about it . I feel so frustrated when some companies do that . For this amount a month that they charge I believe i should get better costumer service .

          • Hi Natalie,

            Some companies can be difficult, especially when they feel like you’re “cheating the system” to them you want their product and you paid for it so your getting what you want. So when you talk about canceling and then re-ordering the same thing they didn’t wanna comply. Your best bet is just to tell them you want a refund and don’t want it. Sometimes it’s best not to tell them what your doing especially if you get a person who doesn’t care to help.
            Did you contact them again and ask for a refund?

    • Same thing happened to me last month. I asked them to cancel so I can use the coupon to get the Turkish towel, and they said no, but they told me I can order another subscription and use the code to get the towel. Well this month I referred myself, so I will get 2 boxes, hopefully 2 different scarves!

      • If you do get duplicate scarves, you can always swap them, I have a feeling you will have no problem swapping them. PopSugar scarves are some of their best items!

      • Thank you blessedmammi , for your comments i greatly appreciated. Only if i would know this before . You are so right , yes they wrote me back saying that the coupon got expired . So i wrote them that there is another coupon that is effective and they didnt respond back till the next day saying that coupon also expired by the time they wrote me back. Oh well i have learned the lesson , that they did not wanted to help.

        • Well there’s always next month to try a code. On the bright side the first spoiler looks amazing and is pricy so it pays for the box. Hopefully everything else will be amazing and you’ll love the box!!

  7. PopSugar is my FAV box!! And with this spoiler it will continue to be my favorite!!

  8. Thanks for posting this. This scarf has finally convinced me to try popsugar.

  9. Back on the PopSugar bandwagon! I am scarf obsessed & that colour combo is perfect!

    Kim |

  10. I’m still waiting on my August box, ugh, can’t wait to see if I get the necklace or earrings. And I’m driving my apartment building’s concierge nuts checking everyday, even though I get an email when a package arrives. I want that cookie mix! My free range, farm fresh eggs and organic butter have a shorter shelf life, and I bought them just to make those darn cookies! Lol.

    • You are toooo funny lol

  11. Hi Liz , so yesterday I did sign up for this September box, I put the code musthavemom and it was telling me that it’s not valid . Then I pressed again and it said processing . So when I checked the order info on my account it says it is charged $43.15 instead of $32 . Can you please let me know what to do ? I really want the September box but wanted the $10 off as my first box

    • Hi Natalie,

      I would recommend emailing their customer service and letting them know you were applying a coupon code and did not mean to place an order before you could verify the coupon code worked. FYI – the coupon code MUSTHAVEMOM is no longer working, but MUSTHAVEYT is working.

      • Thank you so much Liz for getting back to me so quickly. I did emailed them and hopefully they could do something about it . I can’t cancel the order so I could apply the new code , can I?

    • The code MUSTHAVEMOM didn’t work for me but the code MustHaveYT did take off $10!

  12. Is this the monthly box or thhe Special Edition fall box?

    • This is for the monthly box! 🙂

  13. The scarf alone is worth the price of the box for me! I like the color too. 🙂 Even if that was the only item that I liked in the entire box. I looked at the August box and didn’t care for it.

    September already seems to be an amazing box for subscription boxes. I have liked every spoiler that I’ve seen which is super rare for me. Ah.. It’s going to be a hard month but fun! Are you able to buy the Sep box and cancel?

    • Hi Brandy,
      This is my 3rd popsugar box and I only get the boxes I want because I cancel in between. It’s very easy just go to your account and select cancel subscription.
      From what I’ve experienced their CS is really good. My showered gel from last month exploded in the box and they’re sending a replacement. It’s looking like a good box 🙂

    • Brandy, you can buy it as a gift for yourself. Just check where it says is this a gift. That is how I’ve been getting the boxes every month for myself, no subscription/cancellation needed. And…. I get to use the promo codes every month with no issue. Hope that helps.

  14. I’m super excited about the scarf, in regards to *retail princing* I calculate what I would actually pay for an item and tally up all those costs, i.e. $20 KS necklace or $3o scarf, I always come up with way more value than I pay for the box and justify my subscription : )

  15. I am not a scarf person, but this one looks lovely. I live in So. Cal so not much occasion for a scarf but there are some cold winter mornings where this would be nice to wrap up in. Its beautiful. That is the thing I love about sub boxes, sometimes you get stuff you would never pick out for yourself and then you end up loving it. Popsugar has excellent taste, I just love everything about this subscription!

  16. I’m excited and can’t wait to see it in person.

  17. I wad going to Sogn up last month but saw spoilers and just didn’t like the box. In glad I waited this scarf is so pretty. So excited for the next box!

  18. Looking forward to the scarf, it looks very practical, which I like, and the colors are such a nice fall winter transition, perfect for both seasons – Hope it is not made of wool, if so I have a wool allergy and it will be up for swap.

  19. On the tulip website similar scarfs are selling for $75+ That alone makes the box worth it IMO. I can’t wait to see the rest of the items:)

    • Tilo not tulip. Gurr autocorrect.

  20. Ooh this looks like it might be good. I hope so because I bought a few extras. Te code was too good to pass up. I also bout the LE Fall box I’m waiting to see spoilers for this one.
    Any idea when there might be one?

    • Popsugar has a pinterest inspiration board photo for the LE fall box. No direct spoilers.

  21. September is going to be the month with favorite birthday ever because I totally just caved and bought myself this box! Never had a popsugar before, can anyone recommend? Seems amazing!

  22. While this scarf is pretty and certainly makes the box worth it for me, $125 is a ridiculous price. I feel like Popsugar is getting bad about inflating the retail “value” of their products. August’s necklace seemed like cheap costume jewelry–not at all worth $60, and several times in the past the quality has not matched the proposed retail price (a jewelry roll that feels like imitation leather for $45??). I feel misled a lot of times, and it ruins the experience a bit when the irony is, I’d be more inclined to subscribe if Popsugar’s pricing didn’t seem so padded. Just be honest and say this is a $30 scarf!

    Rant over…

    • I totally agree with you about the inflated retail value of many of the items in Popsugar and other subscription boxes. But, I’m surprised to read that people on here and other forums feel that the Kendra Scott jewelry is cheap looking. I feel like both the necklace and earrings are lovely and well made. Plus the dollar value $52 is actually fairly low compared to other, lower quality, jewelry we’ve gotten from PS in the past. Wasn’t that cheap pink beaded bracelet valued at more than $50? And I think the horseshoe charm on a piece of thread was about $45.

      • I looked up Tilo scarves, they are made of cashmere, wool, and silk. I would not pay that for a scarf but I was so glad I sub another box. My answers to the profile are different from my first sub, so hopefully I get 2 different scarves. Also, I walked right into Nordstrom and saw those Kendra Scott earrings in the case!

        • These scarves do retail for $125. In fact, Saks is selling Tilo scarves for $125 to $195. (See screen shot.) I’m not super surprised that a scarf made with such high quality fabrics (wool, cashmere, and silk) is expensive. I’m just excited I don’t have to spend $125 to get it! September, get here already!

      • I agree, Mary. I think the Kendra Scott jewelry is lovely and the quality is definitely there. The brand uses genuine semi-precious stones and I *think* it’s all USA made — which adds to the price. Last month was my first POPSUGAR box and I was thrilled the brand was included.

    • Eh, it’s like when you go to TJ Maxx or Marshalls and it has the “original retail value”…but it’s nowhere close to what you would ever pay for it. It’s to always make you think you’re getting a “deal”. $125 or $35, this scarf will still be more than I paid for the box, so I’m stoked!

  23. Omg..I’m so excited. I used your code to sign up a few days ago. I think I’m going to be very happy with my first box!

  24. Gray and maroon! Beautiful. Want it now! Lol

    • How do we know the color? I didn’t see that listed anywhere. Thanks!

      • Hi Cindy,

        They’re assuming it’s the scarf in the picture

        • Ok, so I am daft……sorry!

  25. SO excited. I feel like the PopSugar boxes that have had scarves have always been my favorites… March 2014…September 2012…hoping this one is ANOTHER great box!!

  26. I just canceled last week and they just sucked me right back in! I can’t resist a great scarf! But I’m kicking myself because I totally forgot to uncheck the waitlist box. I wish there was a way to correct that after the fact! I sent an email straight away to fix it but the August box is confirmed sold out yes? I hope so! I don’t need more Kendra Scott earrings….and I’m busy swapping away everything in the box but those!

  27. I re-subscribed after seeing this spoiler and coupon! So excited to see what else is in the box!

  28. I love the color! I actually hope I get this particular one, but I don’t have many scarves, so I’m sure I’ll be happy with whichever variation I get. I actually cancelled after the Dial body wash months ago, but here was this $10 off AND this scarf, which is worth the cost alone. You always say how much you love PopSugar, and I just freed up $ cancelling Petit Vour (hard decision!!), so I thought, why not?!

  29. Because of this website, I have signed up for so many subscription boxes! So, thank you, Liz! My husband thanks you too. 😉

    Question, I signed up after seeing the spoiler and on the confirmation email they sent me, it says I ordered a monthly subscription for $29.95, including free shipping. Is just the 1st month $29.95? Or future months as well??

  30. Well, this sucked me in!

    • lol, me too!!!

  31. I found many an Ombré Tilo scarf on Shopstyle by Popsugar for around $75. I love this and I love scarves all 4 seasons! Though I do vary the way I wear and the material it’s made of to go with the temperature. I’m happy they gave us a spoiler and I really look forward to getting this box.

  32. I live in Florida so I’m not excited about the scarf. I was actually planning to cancel before the fall accessories started coming so I’m really surprised they already have one in the September box. Seriously, isn’t it still 80 degrees in most of the country?

    • Well, I would hope to get a scarf BEFORE the cold weather comes…since this box will come around September 15th, it’ll definitely be getting to scarf weather where I live!

    • LOL. Here in Wisconsin we haven’t even had 80 degrees most of the summer and we can get snow even in May…I usually skip all the summer boxes because I’ve been to a beach once in my life and it was on a cold, rainy day on the east coast, not the west…I will gladly take all the cold weather accessories I can get! Don’t feel bad for me though, I love fall & winter. Wisconsin suits me well. 🙂

      • I’m with you 😉 New England girl and HAPPY to have it not be too hot most of the year. I still don’t know how to use all the sunscreen I got in my summer boxes with our short summer, LOL!

  33. I love the idea of a scarf. I will for sure use it. I am on the fence about the value. It is easy to find this brand on Ebay for around $30 for scarves and most sites like have them for around $50. In either case it pays for the box. I hope there is some color variations.

  34. This is a great color for me – I am happy I signed up!
    Love the spoilers 🙂 It’s like unwrapping a gift slowly

    • Cheryl,

      I love your analogy! You are exactly right!


  35. Nice, love a good spoiler!

  36. So excited. Glad that I ordered a second box already.

  37. Ugh I hope this isn’t the only color variation! Brown for fall is booring.

    • I think it’s plum, not brown

      • Yeah, grey and brown isn’t a great color combo… But purple and grey sounds nice 🙂

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.