Posted by on in Subscription Box Spoilers | 16 comments

Beauty Box 5 September Spoilers & Free Box Coupon!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Beauty Box 5 September Spoiler

The spoilers for the September Beauty Box 5 box are out! Each box will include:

Beauty Box 5 September Spoilers & Free Box Coupon

Nicka K Eye Light Crayon (Full Size, in one of 6 shades)

Beauty Box 5 September Spoilers & Free Box Coupon! Nail Polish

And a My Beauty Spot Nail Polish (Full Size, in one of 18 shades).

What do you think of the spoilers for the September Beauty Box 5 box? And if you haven’t signed up for the September box yet, when you sign up make sure to use coupon code AUGUSTFREE to get the August box free. (You’ll pay for the upcoming September box).

(Check out my Beauty Box 5 reviews to learn more about this subscription).

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Okay guys! I received my box and cancelled. I received 2 foil packets that are conditioner you can get for free. Toe seperators. Nail polish, tiny 0.5 acne treatment and nicka k eye crayon. The nail polish I found online $1.99 eye crayon $2-3 and the other items. It is really valued at $8-10 box but I wouldn’t pay $5 for this dollar store junk.

    Now I really do not like to complain but was terribly disaapointed. I will sign back up when I see a good sample or full size item.

  2. This month will be my first box, and I am so far really excited! I am obsessed with nail polish (i paint my nail four times a week at minimum) and while I’m not really an eyeshadow person, when I do use it I prefer a crayon. Also it looks like you could use it as a funky eyeliner, which I am all about! But between the yearly subscription plus the free August box, my grand total is like 7.80 per box. They could send me nothing but drugstore brands and I wouldn’t be able to complain! And I like the variation of colors, since a lot of boxes seem to cater more towards the snow white types, with strictly light skintone friendly colors or products. For me, gold is a neutral, and will be most welcome amongst my greens and purples.

    • I *am* one of the snow white types, but I like to use color. (On the other hand, the highlighters from Sample Society and Glossybox have been the same color as or else too dark for my skin.)

      How do you keep your nails in good shape, painting them 4x a week? I was doing twice a week and they started splitting from acetone-based removers, so if there is a product you use that helps, I would love to know.

      • I’ve found that drugstore brand nail polish removers work best for me. I’ve tried the fancy ones that promise no smell or taste or weird white residue, but I always go back to my generic nourishing remover. It still smells awful, and it’s not the most powerful remover, but it gets the job done, is super cheap, and doesn’t leave my fingers all funky looking. Between that and my julep cuticle oil my nails stay pretty healthy!

  3. I like that BB5 carries full size items but there hasn’t been many products I liked in 3 months. I can’t even remember what all I’ve received but I don’t think more then one item has been used. Both spoilers as I have researched online is about $1.99. It’s not terrible and I think the shadow stick may be useful if I got a decent shade but I’m doubting the fingernail polish will since I have a ton. I did get about $50 in items with my last box. The best box to date but didn’t like but maybe one item.

    Plus it’s too much product to accumulate that I won’t ever use. It least with the samples, I’m not getting a ton of stuff and I usually find an item I love. With the full size boxes Blush Beauty Mystery Box and Boxycharm it’s more but I usually find a few items I love and the value is amazing.

    They do have good customer service so it’s good to give them a good 3 months and see if it’s right for you. I have received a fingernail polish in every box from them and I know that they will all never get used. I doubt next month they will have fingernail polish as they usually don’t every month and if the spoilers are good I’ll rejoin.

  4. Of all six shades of eye crayon, I’ll end up with the gold – aka the ONE I really don’t want. Fingers crossed to the BB5 gods that I’ll get the purple though :]

  5. I have like BB5 so fa r. I have a 3 month membership & they sent me the wrong month. They caught it before I did, emailed me, let me know that they would not charge me, & also sent me the correct month’s box. True, I was a bit weirded out this month w/ the hair conditioning product in another language, but I was able to find some info elsewhere. Overall, I like BB5. Hopefully, I don’t get yellow or gold! Then its ging up for swaps!

  6. This is going to be my first box so I am excited and by far I like what is coming 🙂 I just love this site, I have discover a whole new world 🙂

  7. I couldn’t find the ingredient list for the eye crayon, so not sure if I feel comfortable using it on my sensitive skin…not really excited about either of the spoilers, will likely cancel after this month and stick to the more ingredient-conscious boxes.

  8. I like the eye crayons, I have enough nail polish and pray I don’t get the yellow one. Did anyone else get an email for a special edition box for $200 valued over $400 worth of products? And did anyone get it?

    • I got the email and think they’re crazy! For $200 I need a list of products ahead of time like Allure does. BB5 is just so iffy every month that I’m terrified to go for this one.

      • Totally agree. I want everything listed for $200, and it would also have to include a pony.

        • As a former sucker who bought one of their “limited edition” boxes, I feel confident in saying don’t do it. That’s an insane price for what I’m sure will be nothing but cheap drugstore products (and no name, “prestige” brands from China). And when I got my box of Walgreens goodies (which are fine if that’s what I’m choosing to buy but not in a “special” box), they charged me twice and sent 2 identical boxes a few days apart and it took me weeks to get them to refund me. They wanted me to lay to ship it back! Talk about a scam! Save your $$$ ladies!

          • $200 is enough to buy you 2 Popsugar LE Boxes….how could you top that?

          • My dealings with this company were all so unprofessional, I honestly thought they were a brand new company just figuring things out. When I found out they’d been around a long time, I was furious.

  9. Naturally, I will end up with the yellow nail polish…

    Actually, my chances are pretty good that I’ll get something I like if there are 18 different shades. I got some black and white confetti stuff in the last box and I really liked it (and much preferred it to some of the others I saw online).

    I like most of the eye crayon shades, too. Not sure the gold one will look good on me, but I’d be happy with any of the others.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.