Posted by on in Subscription Box News | 30 comments

Julep Cupid’s Mystery Box Available Now!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Cupid Mystery Box!

The Julep Cupid’s Mystery Box is available now! There are 3 different box options to choose from, and there will be no overlap if you pick more than one!

The Box: Julep Cupid’s Mystery Box

The Cost: $24.99 (free shipping if you’re a Maven)

The Products:  You can choose a mani, pedi, or makeup themed Mystery Box. The estimated full retail value is at least $75.00 for each Cupid Mystery box.

I love that they introduced a new color for each box? Are you going to grab one (or more)?

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Couldn’t resist….went back and placed another order….bought the Mani Box and at checkout got a couple polishes and another $9.99 mystery bag (hope it’s not a double from my Pedi Box order!!) Can’t wait to get them………….

  2. I haven’t purchased a mystery box since summer of last year so I am hoping for something good this time! Just placed an order for the Makeup Lover box (I am sucker for flakey glitter polish) and couldn’t resist adding on the mystery add-on.

  3. Forgot to mention in my first reply ~ has anyone seen the ad about a pair of diamond (real ones I wonder?) ear studs will be in one of the Mystery Boxes ?? This is my FIRST Mystery Box with Julep so maybe you all knew about this but…..I DIDN’T and think it’s GREAT!!!! Enjoy ladies ~

  4. I ordered the Pedi Box (loved the nail color) and as I have NEVER had a pedicure I thought I would TREAT MY FEET this month!! Also used the BEMINE code (thank you very much for sharing) and also picked up the $9.99 Mystery Bag at checkout! Love your reviews and have to confess I just signed up for ANOTHER BOX ~ at half off it was an OFFER I COULDN’T REFUSE………I’m now waiting for my first box to arrive from MJ Project DIY, AND……..a FREE STARTER KIT is included ($20 value) who could say no to that?????? I will let you know how I like it . Keep up the good reviewing ~ and I need to try a little restraint ……?

  5. I got the makeup lovers and the add on. SO EXCITED. I can’t wait to see what else is in it!!!!

  6. I ordered the Venus (mani-lovers) Mystery Pack! I also used BEMINE (last night before midnight). I dont think the code was working the way it was supposed to because I was able to get THREE polishes for a total of $5! It didn’t make ANY sense! My card says its good til March 1 but you can only use it once per account. Maybe its not working now because they need to figure out what they did wrong 😀

    Anyway, my box has already shipped and will be here Monday at the latest!

    • I just received my Venus kit! **Warning: Spoilers** I received the Freedom Polymer Kit, Rock Star Hand Creme, a nail file, Mighty Nail and Cuticle Serum and four polishes: Venus, Bette, Madison and America. Since I’m new to Julep, I dont have any of these colors and I luckily like them all!

      • Sounds like a great box! Can’t wait for my box to arrive! 🙂

  7. I LOVED the December mystery box… so I could not resist getting this one! I ended up getting the makeup lovers mystery box, the $9.99 add on mystery bag, and 4 additional sale ($2.99 each) nail polishes for a grand total of $35.74 with the BEMINE discount. So lucky I ordered before they stopped allowing the code to apply!

  8. unfortunately the BEMINE code doesn’t work for the Rosa color – time to browse for a different option! (I LOVE the color in the pedi box and am a big pedicure fan so I know that box will be a big win for me – the coupon code is just a fun bonus)

    • Doesn’t look the BEMINE coupon code is working anymore 🙁

      • Oh no! 🙁 Ok, I’ll remove it from the post. Thanks for letting us know.

        • I tried it again tonight and the BEMINE is back to working!! Glad I decided to wait a bit (maybe my work browser wasn’t working correctly with the website)

  9. Sigh. I wanted Venus for the polish and the mani essentials and then I looked through my collection and discovered that Venus is the same as Clio…..I like Lindy but I haven’t liked any of Julep’s makeup and I’m loyal to it cosmetics so I’ll pass this time on a mystery box.

  10. I will try a mystery box sometime but not this month. All the colors are too glittery for me.

  11. I was debating getting one, but the BEMINE deal convinced me. Of course I couldn’t resist the $9.99 add-on too. I got the makeup box. So about $125-130 of stuff for $35! Not a bad deal!

    • Nice! I think I need to place another order!

  12. This is my first Julep mystery box as well. I opted for the pedi theme, because I am hoping for foot scrubs. I will probably end up sharing the polishes with my mom and sister. With the mystery box and Octavia in my cart, I used the BEMINE code to get Octavia for free! I also added on the 9.99 mystery bag. I love surprises!! Does anyone have the color caddy? If so, how do you like it?

    • Thanks for the tip on the BEMINE coupon working with the mystery box! I’m adding that to the post now. (I already ordered the makeup mystery box, but now I’m thinking of getting another one!)

    • How do you order the $9.99 mystery bag? I didn’t get that option.

      • It was an add-on at checkout when I ordered the mystery box.

  13. I just got the makeup-themed box! I love all of these pretty pink Valentine’s colors (my favorite beauty product time of the year!) so I might grab the mani & pedi boxes later on tonight. I think that Julep has really been upping their Mystery boxes. I remember when I first subscribed they really weren’t all that good, and then they started introducing these same price/different theme boxes (instead of the pricing tiered boxes) and you’ve been getting a much better value per box. I’m so excited to see what will be in the Cupid Boxes!

  14. You can also use the code bemine for a buy one get one free polish

    • OOOO, thanks! I don’t know which to get. I like their makeup products, so I may opt to buy that one.

  15. I bought the mani and pedi ones last night! So excited 🙂

  16. I got the Pedi themed box with the beautiful Aphrodite polish. I have enough makeup and plenty of polish/supplies for a mani. But my poor feet haven’t had enough attention and wearing heavy boots while slushing through this harsh winter has made them feel tired at times. So I think my feet need a treat and a mystery box is a nice surprise.

  17. I just orderd the makeup themed box. Im so excited, never ordered a mystery box before!!

    • Yay! I hope your first mystery box is awesome! 🙂

  18. Never done a Julep mystery box before…so hard to choose!

  19. I was pretty disappointed in the December mystery box, so I will skip this one also. I like that you can choose hands feet or makeup, though. What I really want is the February birthstone nail polish. I may order that eventually. I am waiting to see if Julep has a special Valentine sale-they usually do something for holidays.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.